If a handful of state legislators get their way, all products manufactured from 100-percent recycled content, like yesterday’s News & Observer, a campaign flyer, and scrap pieces of cardboard boxes, will soon be exempted from state sales tax. Because these items are made with the “environment in mind,” they now are being looked at as “special.”
House Bill 1668, “An Act to Exempt From Sales and Use Tax the Purchase of Products Entirely Composed of Recycled Materials” is set to be introduced during the current legislative session of the General Assembly. Sponsored primarily by Rep. Marvin Lewis (D-Cumberland) and co-sponsored by Reps. Martha Alexander (D-Mecklenburg), Lorene Coates (D-Rowan), Jerry Dockham (R-Davidson), Sandra Hughes (D-New Hanover), and Diane Parfitt (D-Cumberland), this bill does exactly as its title suggests. All products manufactured from 100-percent recycled items would, in effect, be exempt from sales taxes.
Just before the start of this year’s legislative session, Senate and House Democrats estimated that between $800 million and $1 billion in additional revenue or spending cuts would be needed to balance the budget for the start of the fiscal year in July. Considering this news, one would probably expect the state to not be as charitable this year in offering North Carolinians tax credits or other programs that would further reduce the amount of generated revenue. When it comes to legislative politics, however, one must throw all semblance of common sense out the window.
For more than two years, the General Assembly has been in talks to broaden the sales tax base to include more items. There has been a study committee working on it. This bill would actually narrow the sales-tax base by exempting more products, making it counterproductive to a stable source of revenue, and winner of the Civitas Institute “Bad Bill of the Week.”
The question members of the General Assembly need to ask themselves is whether or not a tax credit program that encourages the use of recycled materials— in the form of H.B. 1668—is worth the additional loss of revenue when it will already be difficult enough to balance the budget.