These bills – Senate Bills (SB) 1113 and 1114 – Carrboro Energy Efficiency/Renewable and Chapel Hill Energy Efficiency/Renewable sponsored by Sen. Ellie Kinnaird (D-Orange, Person) grant the city council’s of Carrboro and Chapel Hill, respectively, the ability to engage in “no-bid” contracts.
S.B. 1113 and S.B. 1114, if passed, would make the towns of Carrboro and Chapel Hill exempt from General Statutes, 143-129, 143-131, and 143-132; which compel local governments to accept a minimum number of bids for contracts on municipal projects over $500,000 and supplies exceeding $30,000. The bills provide little guidance as to what projects could be included in these exceptions, save for the extremely vague phrase “aimed at increasing energy efficiency.”
The primary problem with these bills is that they encourage patronage and cronyism to take place with the municipal contracts of Carrboro and Chapel Hill. If the city council does not need to accept a minimum number of bids for a contract, what regulations would be in place to stop the council from contracting the first familiar face to make an offer for the project? What is there to prevent city council members from tailoring a project for a specific contractor? If this bill were to pass, the answer is ‘nothing.’
Another worry with this bill is the obscurity of what it means to be “aimed at increasing energy efficiency.” This could be applied to virtually any project in which there would be even the slightest predicted increase in energy efficiency. This could include anything as simple as painting the walls of a municipal office building white to absorb less sunlight and lower energy costs or as complex as creating an entirely ‘green’ wastewater treatment plant, with energy efficient heating, cooling, lighting, plumbing, and just about any other aspect of a building that has an ‘energy efficient’ alternative.
What these bills would do is encourage city councils to invent projects that could be termed “aimed at energy efficiency” in order to line the pockets of any contractor they favor with the money of Carrboro and Chapel Hill taxpayers. These bills would create blatant system of patronage in Carrboro and Chapel Hill and that is what earns S.B. 1113 and 1114 the title of “Bad Bill of the Week.”