This N&O article caught my attention, for it is chock full of inaccuracies and question-begging statements.
The article begins:
North Carolina will receive $159 million as part of a federal aid package designed to fight foreclosures in states plagued by high unemployment.
The $600 million package announced Monday by the Obama administration is the latest sign that the nation’s foreclosure problem has spread from subprime borrowers to the growing number of people who can’t find work.
No mention, naturally, of where that money will come from and what economic consequences there will be from diverting money from productive taxpayers to folks who likely should not continue living in their current home anyway.
Next comes this statement:
“The first wave of foreclosures had more to do with subprime loans, but right now many of the foreclosures in North Carolina are because of the surge in unemployment,” said Charlene Crowell, communications manager for state policy and outreach at the Center for Responsible Lending in Durham.
This sentiment represents the commonly accepted script, that the “first wave” of foreclosures was almost exclusively contained to “subprime loans.” But according to an analysis of foreclosure data conducted by economist Stan Liebowitz, that’s not the case:
Prime foreclosures began their increase at the same moment (third quarter of 2006) as subprime foreclosures, as can be seen in figure 5. Further, the prime foreclosure rate went into territory that was far above where it had been in the prior ten years, much more so than was the case for subprime loans. In percentage terms, the increase in foreclosures started from the second quarter of 2006 until the end of 2007 was 39 percent for subprime loans and 69 percent for prime loans. There is no evidence to support a claim that somehow the subprime market had this unprecedented increase in foreclosures and that later the prime loans accidentally caught the contagion. Both markets were hit at the same time, and the force was at least as strong in the prime market.
Advocates of such foreclosure-prevention measures often like to say that stemming the tide of foreclosure rates will help keep housing prices from dipping even further, as foreclosed homes can cause downward pressure on other homes in the neighborhood. Curiously, however, these same advocates include groups like “the N.C. Housing Finance Agency, whose mission is to provide affordable housing options to residents,” the group set to receive the federal government money. But if they want to see affordable housing options, why do they want to prop up housing prices?
Finally, the article doesn’t mention broader economic consequences of further government meddling in foreclosure proceedings. In the current phase of our economic recession, most are familiar with the “credit crunch” in which banks are not lending out much of their money, particularly to businesses. A major reason for this is because banks’ balance sheets are in bad shape, and need to be cleaned up. Their balance sheets are in trouble in large part because their home loan assets are in great question.
Typically, mortgage payments to banks represent a predictable income flow, but in the current housing meltdown, those income flows are difficult to value. What needs to happen to thaw the credit freeze is for banks to be able to accurately asses the values on their balance sheets. To do this, homes in which the owner can no longer afford to make the payments need to be foreclosed upon as quickly as possible so that banks can re-value their capital assets. Once banks can be confident again in the value of their assets, they will be much more willing to begin lending again. But with government meddling prolonging this process, banks still face a high level of uncertainty as to what will happen with their home loans assets. It is this uncertainty that is making them less willing to extend loans and thus ease the credit crunch.
In short, these foreclosure-prevention measures are prolonging the recession, causing more people to lose their jobs, thus causing more foreclosures.