Legislation which allows for concealed carry in restaurants that serve alcohol as well as in State Parks was passed by the Senate Judiciary II Committee. The bill, HB111, is a major legislative focus for gun right activists this session. The bill also clarifies where local governments can and cannot prohibit concealed carry. The bill will now move on to the Senate Finance Committee.
Crime
Bill Expanding Gun Rights Moves Forward
Racial Justice Act Amendment Headed for House Floor
A House judiciary panel passed an amendment to the Racial Justice Act narrowing what evidence could be used in an inmate’s appeal of a death sentence. A death row inmate could no longer use statistics in a hearing to argue racial bias is ingrained in North Carolina’s judicial system. The inmate would have to prove a prosecutor was actually racially biased in pursuing a death penalty. Democrats argued against the amendment saying racism still existed in the system and that led to a heated discussion between Rep. Mickey Michaux (D-Durham) the presiding chair Rep. Sarah Stevens (R-Surry). Stevens told Michaux she told him she wanted him to stick to the merits of the bill instead of motives of the majority:
It may be on the House floor this afternoon.
The NC Medicaid Fraud Debacle Costs Taxpayers Millions
We all know that millions of dollars are wasted in state government every year (don’t get me started on waste at the federal level). This is a frustrating fact mainly because it is our tax dollars that are being misused. So much waste and fraud have come to exist that when news of a new story involving government waste and fraud arises, it usually doesn’t faze us.
Well, a recent revelation in North Carolina’s Medicaid program should cause indignation in all citizens of North Carolina, not just conservatives.
Thanks to IBM, $191 million dollars of potential fraudulent Medicaid claims have been exposed. That’s a lot of money; money, it should be remembered, that comes from taxpayers. I am sure that $191 million could have been put to use in the government, or, better yet, used by individuals to purchase goods and services or to create jobs. But, no, that money went down the drain, funneled to greedy and deceptive individuals.
Medicaid is not going anywhere anytime soon; therefore, it makes absolute sense that we use the tools created by IBM and other companies to crack down on the fraud that exists in government.
It has been reported that 206 outpatient behavioral health providers in North Carolina were the perpetrators of the $191 million dollars’ worth of fraud. Fraud was committed in a few ways: when providers billed for more than 24 hours of service rendered per day, when providers intentionally overbilled for a service rendered, and when they double-billed (billed for a patient enrolled in group therapy and then billed for that same patient in individual therapy sessions). This obviously was a lucrative business for many duplicitous schemers. Fortunately, the software created by IBM was designed to identify the suspicious claims submitted to Medicaid. Hopefully, justice will soon be served to those who defrauded taxpayers of millions of dollars.
This event should be a wake-up call for North Carolinians. Medicaid is a billion dollar industry, and it appeared to be far too easy for some shady characters to funnel millions of taxpayer dollars to their own greedy pockets.
If fraud of this magnitude exists in Medicaid, I am sure it exists elsewhere in state government. North Carolina is struggling right now. It is time for the state to increase its efforts in finding and exposing fraud wherever it exists. The tools exist; it is simply a matter of mustering inner fortitude to utilize them for the sake of taxpayers across the state.
Eugenics Compensation Program: Observations and Comments
The participation of North Carolina in a “Eugenics Program” from 1929-1974 was a horrific chapter in our state history. The effort of some legislators to establish a Eugenics Compensation Program is an acknowledgement that the program was wrong and that individuals were harmed. There are two bills, House Bill 947 and Senate Bill 800, that have been introduced to establish a compensation program for victims. While the sentiment and purpose are right and noble, there are problems in the bills that are rightly causing conservatives problems.
The money allocated in the bills, $10,000,000, is to compensate victims in the amount of $50,000 each. To me there is no amount of adequate compensation for those who had this done to them against their will. But since a number has to be set we will use what is in the bills. The source of the money is one of the problems. The taxpayers of North Carolina are being taxed to compensate for a program approved and run by past members of the political class, none of which ever seem to be publicly named. Names should be named!
More than half of today’s residents were not here when this program ended in 1974. A more appropriate source of funds would be to intercept some of the millions of dollars which go to the Golden Leaf Foundation. These funds were part of an agreement by tobacco companies to compensate the states for higher health care spending. This change would result in more general fund money available for state needs and would relieve current taxpayers from funding the remedy for something they had no part in authorizing, allowing or even tolerating.
Another problem is the amount of “administrative overhead” funded. The total spending allocated to state agencies in the bills is $960,000. If that spending is not new spending that will be okay, but I have a suspicion that the amounts allocated to agencies will go up to cover this spending. Again, a good move would be to take the money out of Tobacco Settlement Funds. Here is the list of new state offices and projected spending for this program from HB 947:
- There is created in the Department of Administration the Office of Justice for Sterilization Victims
- Industrial Commission, the sum of one hundred eighty-four thousand dollars ($184,000) shall be used for the administration of Section 1 of this act
- Department of Administration, the sum of six hundred fifty-four thousand dollars ($654,000) shall be used for the expenses of the Office of Justice for Sterilization Victims as set forth in Section 1 of this act
- Department of Cultural Resources, the sum of fifty-seven thousand dollars ($57,000) shall be used for the electronic scanning and indexing of documents
- Department of Administration, the sum of one hundred fifty-five thousand dollars ($155,000) shall be used for the creation and maintenance of the database established under this section
The other problem with this bill is the effective date of the payments. Unlike most bills that are effective upon passage or at a date certain in the future, this bill is retroactive. Section one reads in part: “§ 143B-426.52. Claims for compensation for asexualization or sterilization. Lines 10-13 reads A claim may be submitted on behalf of a claimant by a person lawfully authorized to act on the individual’s behalf. A claim may be submitted by the personal representative of an individual who dies on or after March 1, 2010. This appears to “compensate” dead people. While I am sure the lawyers can explain this part in pretty language, if this is to compensate living victims it should not be retroactive. This sets a troubling precedent for future remedies of this type.
The new Republican legislature is to be commended for tackling a difficult issue that past legislatures have avoided, even when state budgets were flush. While righting this horrible wrong they should continue to be conservative in spending the hardworking taxpayers money. A final thought, while not knowing the details around the programs end, it should be noted that it ended under the administration of the first Republican Governor in recent history, Jim Holshouser.
Task Force Issues Proposals for Fighting Unemployment Fraud
The House of Representatives Unemployment Fraud Task Force approved proposed legislation giving the state more measures to go after fraudulent over payments of unemployment benefits.
For one thing, the proposal would eliminate any statute of limitations on recovering over payments. Currently the State Division of Employment Security has ten years to recover benefits received through fraud. If the over payments are not the fraudulent then the state has three years to go after reimbursements.
The bill would also increase the penalty for unemployment fraud from a misdemeanor to a felony for benefits exceeding $400.
It would impose a 15 percent penalty on fraudulent over payments as required by the federal government beginning October 1, 2013
The legislation also adds the federal mandate to charge employers accounts for over payments due to the failure of the employer to respond to the division in a timely and adequate manner.
Members of the task force want employers to report new hires more quickly so the state can match unemployment recipients with a Directory of New Hires. The proposal would require employers to report new hires within 60 days.
The task force is also considering amending the proposal to allow the state to garnish wages to recover over payments.
NC Democratic Party Scandal Takes Sad Turn
Jay Parmley’s former girlfriend believes that he infected her with HIV. Parmley, former Executive Director of the NC Democratic Party, resigned on April 15 amid allegations of sexual harassment from a young male employee. According to the Daily Caller article, Rebecca Burgin was 20 when she met Parmley (32) who was her American Government professor. Parmley was teaching at a community college while serving as executive director and chairman of the Oklahoma Democratic Party.
David Parker, chairman of the NC Democratic Party, evidently didn’t talk to Burgin when he vetted Parmley for the NCDP’s Executive Director job, although he was adamant in a recent press conference when he said; “In four different states where he has been on staff, no one — and I mean no one — and I don’t know who in this room has tried to track down people in other states, but if you heard something bad about Jay Parmley, frankly I would be shocked because I vetted him as thoroughly as I could.”
The DC article revealed that “Parmley’s lawyer offered her (Ms. Burgin) health coverage, paid for by the Democratic National Committee, to manage her illness. She ultimately declined that offer, fearing it would constitute insurance fraud. Parmley, she said, abandoned her a few months later.”
In light of this revelation, it is even more important for the State Board of Elections (SBOE) to investigate the source of funds used by the NCDP to arrange for a reported financial settlement with the former staff member. In a letter dated April 19, 2012, the Civitas Institute asked the SBOE to investigate NCDP. As of this blog post the State Board has not responded to the Civitas Institute’s formal request.
While Civitas’ interest focuses on the source of funds used by the NCDP for the settlement, we should learn more details about the expenditures in general, in the NCDP’s campaign finance report due this Friday (April 27) ‑ that is, if the payments were made to the alleged victim in this reporting.
The North Carolina Campaign Finance Manual states, “There are very few restrictions on how a party committee may spend its money. However, all expenditures must be reported, along with the specific purpose of the expenditure.” It goes on to say, “All expenditures that are over $50 may not be paid with cash and must be disclosed with the name of the payee, the address of the payee, the date of the expenditure, and the specific purpose of the expenditure. Election sum-to-date totals for the payee must also be included.
The sordid details of this sad story leave me with two questions: (1) Is it commonplace for the Democratic Party (State and National) to pay off injured parties with insurance plans? and (2) Are we now waiting for another shoe to drop?
Racial Justice Act & News and Observer Exposed
State Senate President pro tem Phil Berger (R – Rockingham) has a great letter in today’s N&O. In it he takes the paper’s editorial page to task for misrepresenting the Racial Justice Act and for misrepresenting a Twitter statement from his office. The RJA is a bad piece of legislation and every District Attorney in NC agrees that Governor Perdue’s veto of Senate Bill 9 No Discriminatory Purpose in Death Penalty should be overridden! That includes Democratic, Republican, white and back DA’s alike, every last one of them!
From the beginning of his letter:
Here’s why both were ill-conceived: The Racial Justice Act does not, as the editorial claims, require an inmate to “show a pattern of racial bias in prosecutors’ handling of his case.” If only it did.
Regardless of the inmate’s race, or the race of jury members, the RJA allows convicted murderers to successfully claim bias using statewide data unconnected to their case. It makes the case’s evidence, and even statistics from the case’s surrounding area, irrelevant.
Further on he adds:
The RJA, unfortunately, has little to do with race or justice – it’s a backhanded attempt to end the death penalty. (emphasis added)
Interestingly, the editorial opines that the state’s Legislative Building is a “hot-air factory where opponents of the Racial Justice Act seemingly will say anything …” Clearly, it is death penalty opponents, including those who write The N&O’s knee-jerk editorials, who say anything to help North Carolina’s most heinous criminals leave death row.
Go read this excellent letter yourself, than call your state house member, and other state house members and ask them to override the veto. The Senate has already overridden the veto, it is in the state house for action.
By the way 75% of North Carolina voters think the death penalty is an appropriate punishment in certain cases.