The state unemployment rate dropped in November from 10.4 percent to 10 percent according to the Division of Employment Security. That is still above the national unemployment rate. The rate stood at 9.8 percent at this time last year. There was a small gain of 3,800 in the number jobs. That is still a far cry from recovering over 306,000 jobs lost since the recession began. Over the course of the last year private sector jobs have grown by 30,800. The number of people unemployed since November 2010 increased by over 12,000.
Economics
State Unemployment Rate Drops Slightly but Still at Double Digits
Crony Capitalism: Local Style
Courtesy of the Cape Fear Patriot blog comes this report of Wilmington City Council engaging in a classic case of crony capitalism.
Do you have a piece of property outside of the city limits and the county is refusing to meet your zoning demands? No worries. The Wilmington City Council is apparently for sale, happy to help you circumvent the New Hanover County Commissioners and grant your special zoning request, for a price.
The current example is a 27 acre parcel 2.5 miles from the borders of the city. Flournoy Development Company, a property developer out of Columbus GA, is planning to build luxury apartments off of Market Street in the northern part of the county. When the county denied Flournoy’s rezoning request, Flournoy turned to the city for help.
Seems the Wilmington City Council is now eager to annex the property to enable the devloper to skirt county zoning laws. In exchange, the city will collect the taxes generated by the new development. A nice quid pro quo among the political class and the politically connected.
Making matters worse, is that the City is embarking on a public relations campaign to convince residents that the annexation would bring public services to the area being annexed. Problem is, that claim is untrue, as public service are already being provided to the area. There will be no net benefit for the residents in the area under consideration of being annexed to benefit the developer.
County Commissioner Jason Thompson agrees. In a telephone interview he stated that the move by the city was nothing more than an attempt by the city to usurp the counties zoning authority for the developer in exchange for the ability to tax future property owners in the development.
Perdue’s Cronies Put Project on Hold
In new news pertaining to the proposed wind farm in Elizabeth City, the Charlotte Business Journal reports that the developer has decided not to begin construction on the boondoggle project.
Iberdrola Renewables has decided not to start construction on a proposed $600 million N.C. wind project this year. The company says it has been unable to negotiate a power-purchase agreement with a regional power company for the electricity the operation would generate.
And without an extension of an expiring federal program that would offer a grant of up to $200 million for the 300-megawatt project, it is unlikely to be built in the near term.
“The federal incentives are a critical piece of the project,” says Iberdrola spokesman Paul Copelman. “I wouldn’t want to say we definitely couldn’t find a way to build it. But if the incentives expire, it’s very challenging for the industry.”
Translation: our wind energy is so terribly inefficient and expensive that we need $200 million in taxpayer dollars, plus an agreement from a utility company to purchase and then pass along the higher costs to ratepayers in order to make it work. Our industry is such a politically-manufactured scam that it will virtually disappear without massive government bailouts.
A few days ago, I wrote about Gov. Perdue’s role in this latest “greed energy” shakedown. Perdue issued letters to the heads of major NC utility providers in an attempt to pressure one of them to purchase this horribly expensive source of energy. In essence, Perdue wanted to ensure that a multi-billion dollar Spanish company could line its pockets at the expense of taxpayers (via the $200 million federal subsidy) and energy consumers (via higher energy costs).
Thankfully, energy consumers in NE North Carolina and taxpayers across the U.S. dodged this crony capitalism bullet – for now.
N&O Parrots Obama’s Economic Fallacies
In response to a recent editorial in the N&O, I submitted the following letter:
The N&O editors claim that President Obama “plainly is correct” in his warning that a higher payroll tax would depress the economy because “consumer spending is key to the recovery.”
But the President and N&O editors are plainly wrong. The fact is, consumer spending is now higher than it was during the height of the pre-recession boom. Data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) shows that inflation-adjusted personal consumption expenditures (PCE) had already climbed back above the pre-recession heights by fourth quarter of 2010, and is currently running 1.4 percent higher than that previous high. Indeed, PCE only dipped by a mere 3.4 percent at its lowest point in the recession.
The true cause of the recession is a lack of investment spending by businesses. Nonresidential, private fixed investment dropped by a dramatic 22 percent from its pre-recession peak to its lowest point. It is still running 8 percent below its pre-recession high point.
The data clearly shows that consumer spending is not the problem. Obama and the N&O editors unfortunately insist on ignoring the facts and instead thoughtlessly propagate a dangerous myth.
In so doing, they advocate for policies that damage our economy and prolong the pain.
Economics Professor Responds to N&O’s Endorsement of Cary Stadium Deal
The News and Observer’s editorial page on Sunday produced a wrong-headed endorsement of Cary’s $6 million soccer stadium expansion:
It’s a lot of money to put into a soccer stadium, but Cary seems to have the right, “if you build it, they will come” attitude. The municipality of 140,000 people figures that its soccer park could draw national collegiate championship playoffs back to town with the 3,000 additional seats that are being added.
In recent years, Cary has lost out to other communities with new stadiums and more space. But Cary, in terms of additional amenities such as hotels and restaurants and shopping, takes a back seat to no one and isn’t shirking from the competition. It wants the 2012 men’s collegiate championship and the men’s and women’s finals in 2013.
Soccer is an international sport whose popularity will only grow in the decades to come. And in terms of facilities, it is not on the super-expensive scale of major college football or basketball. For Cary this adds up to smart sport, and smart business.
The N&O’s endorsement echoes the rosy numbers politicians always give when promoting these taxpayer funded developments. Dr. Mark Steckbeck, an economics professor at my very own Campbell University, gave a short indictment of the faulty economic thinking at work in this editorial, and points to the massive losses Roanoke Rapids has sustained from its publicly-funded Randy Parton Theatre at his blog.
For many like me, it’s not that I regard government spending on things like this misguided, and therefore inappropriate, because markets are infallible and if things like a soccer stadium were truly socially efficient markets would have already supplied it. No, it’s that because of the incentive structures in place, individuals acting in private markets and spending their own money are far less likely to err relative to politicians and bureaucrats spending other people’s money in deciding how to allocate scarce resources
Dr. Steckbeck’s public choice arguments ring true to me – local politicians are ill-equipped to make economic development decisions, and when those decisions go badly, they can sink the finances of an entire town. It is much easier to make risky bets with taxpayer money than to invest your own private capital into a project.
How Much Does Your County Lose in the NC Lottery?
Nash County is a poor rural county Northeast of Raleigh. Its median income is below the state average, yet has the highest per capita sales in the state for the North Carolina Education Lottery (NCEL): two and a half times the average last year.
In 2010 alone, the amount of money spent by Nash County residents on the lottery resulted in over $22 million pouring out of the county. During this same time, Nash County experienced over 12 percent unemployment.
Bradley Morgan, former Nash County Commission Chair, lamented the net loss of wealth from his county.
“We should at least be getting a fair share of how much we put in,” Morgan said, referring to lottery proceeds that don’t fall proportionately according to the amount each county puts in.
Morgan regrets that so many people in his county are, “looking for the pie in the sky,” and use the lottery to reach out for a nearly impossible hope of hitting the jackpot. Morgan states the he personally has only played the lottery once in his life.
Despite Morgan’s concern, the Nash County website’s homepage proudly advertises the NCEL and the money its programs have put into the community.
In 2010 Nash County spent nearly $38 million on the lottery, and received only 40 percent of that back. The money comes back through the revenue created by local lottery vendors, prize money, and the state budget disbursements of lottery proceeds.
On the other hand, counties in the far West of the state put little into the lottery and have net dollar gains from state lottery proceeds. Buncombe County received $68 million more than it put into the lottery in 2010.
The lottery is draining millions of dollars from many counties in the state. Other counties get a nice influx of dollars from the lottery proceeds. Is your county a winner or loser of the North Carolina Education Lottery (NCEL)?
Next week, Civitas will release statewide data on total county dollars gained or lost in recent years through the North Carolina Education Lottery.
Lottery prize winners vary widely by year, so it is difficult to get a long term picture of how much money is leaving the county, so a one-year snapshot is the only tool available to evaluate a county net gain or loss. The calculation of gain/loss is a combination of total count lottery sales, minus vendor retail, prizes, and subsequent year NCEL education funds received by the county. These figures combined give an approximation of the net gain or loss in total lottery dollars experienced by counties across the state.
New Law Gives NC Breweries a Boost
In a piece of welcome news, Governor Perdue signed into law a piece of legislation that gives breweries in the state increased access to customers.
HB 796, which passed the legislature in the late November special session, allows all licensed breweries in North Carolina to sell beer and offer on-site tastings. Previous law restricted these events and sales to breweries producing less than 25,000 barrels per year. There is speculation that the legislative action is designed to attract beer producers Sierra Nevada and New Belgium to the state.
The bill is expected to boost the state’s already thriving craft brew industry. There are currently dozens of small breweries in the state, and Asheville, NC was named “Beer City USA” in 2010.
The deregulation provisions were included in a bill that also altered funding for Cherokee County Schools and allows high school students to take non-credit courses at community colleges. The law takes effect immediately with Perdue’s signature.
Let us hope that legislators continue to create jobs this way: deregulation, not corporate welfare deals. This quote from a recent News and Observer article on the issue gave an interesting perspective from a North Carolina entrepreneur on how increased competition will increase benefits for consumers and improve his industry in the state:
Oscar Wong is the founder of Asheville’s Highland Brewing Co., the state’s largest brewery, producing 23,000 barrels a year. He acknowledges the new midsize breweries would cut into his market share.
“As far as competition for us, it may kick our (butt) a little bit, but it’s the American way,” he said.
But Wong, a member of the local Chamber of Commerce, felt conflicted because it would benefit his community.
“As they say, pioneers get shot at more,” he said. “We’ll just have to keep up and do our thing.”
North Carolina falls flat in new small business ranking
North Carolina has been named a state with one of the “most anti-entrepreneur policy environments” in a new report released by the Small Business and Entrepreneurship Council. Out of the 50 states and the District of Columbia, North Carolina ranked an abysmal 37th, behind all of her neighbors and the entire southeastern United States except for Maryland. The report compiled the state’s positives and considerable negatives for small business owners and entrepreneurs:
• No corporate or individual alternative minimum tax
• Relatively low property taxes
• Fairly low level of state and local government spending and debt
• High personal income and individual capital gains taxes
• Imposition of a state death tax
• High unemployment taxes
• High number of health insurance mandates
• Fairly high crime rate
• High gas and diesel taxes
For those paying attention to big-business focused rankings such as Forbes and Site Selection, North Carolina’s low score may come as a shock. As Civitas’ Brian Balfour has written, the reports highlighting North Carolina’s problems seems to correlate much more closely with our economic conditions than the rosier rankings often touted by Governor Perdue. As the recent Chiquita and failed Continental Tire corporate welfare deals have shown, our state’s policymakers seem to be more focused on securing high profile deals to help themselves secure re-election than in creating an atmosphere where entrepreneurs can thrive and grow.
The General Assembly and Governor could immediately take several steps to improve this ranking: Repeal the unpopular death tax, cap the gas tax, and stop implementing onerous health insurance requirements (instead of going forward with Obamacare’s mandated healthcare exchange).
Legislative Committee to Subpoena Director of Employment Security Division
Frustrated members of the Joint Revenue Laws Study Committee unanimously voted to issue a subpoena to force the new head of the Division of Employment Security, Lynn Holmes, to appear before them. Holmes was the director of the Employment Security Commission before it merged with the state Commerce Department in November. The Perdue Administration then appointed her to lead the new division. The committee has been trying for months to have her brief them on what she was doing about the $2.5 billion debt to the federal government for loans to pay unemployment benefits. The state had to make a $78 million interest payment on the debt in September and will face other such payments unless a solution to the debt is found. Committee co-chair Sen. Bob Rucho (R-Mecklenburg) said Holmes was asked to appear at the December 7 meeting but she chose to decline. He told members at that meeting Holmes would be subpoenaed.
In a written statement the Commerce Department claimed it was a scheduling problem.
Assistant Secretary Holmes notified Department of Commerce
leadership of a personal conflict and that she would not be able to attend
today’s meeting. The Department of Commerce and Assistant Secretary
Holmes notified General Assembly staff of the conflict. It’s my understanding
that a meeting has been set up next week with Senator Rucho, Secretary Crisco,
and Assistant Secretary Holmes. It is her intention to attend the January
meeting, and that no subpoena is necessary. The Department of Commerce is
committed to working with the General Assembly and providing information and
updates as requested.
Rucho said after the meeting the unemployment debt is the most important issue Holmes has to address and the committee needs her cooperation.
New Analysis Shows NC Losing Jobs Faster Than National Trend
Posted today at newgeography.com is an interesting state-by-state analysis of job growth (or loss) over the last four years. What sets this analysis apart is that it measures job changes relative to national trends. In other words, for North Carolina (and all the other states) it measures how many jobs the state should have if it followed national job trends and then compares that to actual jobs in the state. The time frame examined is 2007-2011, so the study essentially examines how states have fared during the recession.
According to this methodology, North Carolina has not fared very well. NC ranks 19th worst, meaning that it has lost ground in terms of its share of the nation’s jobs. The study’s authors offer the following cloudy conclusion for states (like NC) that lost ground:
If a state is hemorrhaging jobs faster than the national economy, there should be cause for concern. There are likely toxic conditions within industry sectors and economic policies that make it very difficult for employment and economic activity to flourish. As the nation recovers these states will likely recover much slower, and other states might just keep pulling more jobs away from them.