…according to this post from Michael Strong.
-Max Borders
Education
School Choice is a Civil Rights Issue
Quieting DPI Bragadoccio on Test Scores
The NC Department of Public Instruction (DPI) is patting itself on the back for improving test scores. But a pretty scathing critique had already been leveled here in September. A sliver:
State assessment tests tell us that North Carolina students are performing well and improving each year. Yet national standardized tests are more rigorous and paint a picture of much poorer achievement and slower progress. Much of the difference comes down to the fact that our state tests compare today’s students to a curve based on students 15 years ago, and a lot has changed in since then.
The bottom line?
The information provided by North Carolina standardized tests is limited and can be misleading. At best, it gives only an overall picture of how student knowledge has improved over time. At worst, it contributes to a false sense of complacency. The student proficiency benchmark is not tied to the demands of today’s society or workforce. Other states have made tough decisions to sacrifice good marks for a more rigorous (and accurate) measure of student proficiency. Without such a measure, we cannot tell whether we have truly done the job we set out to do 15 years ago. Our job is not to prepare citizens for standards of the past, but for challenges of the future.
People interested in education should read the whole critique. It points to a state education bureaucracy engaged in circuitous self-justification with metrics at odds with national standards.
–Max Borders
Public School Growth: Tempered Hysteria
First the schools – especially Wake Co. – colluded with the papers – especially the N&O – to scare everyone into thinking the schools would be spilling over. (Never mind that the teachers’ interests have created a protectionist racket around the "smaller class size" mythology.) Now new numbers indicate Wake County is 2000 pupils short of predictions (read: scare tactics made while the General Assembly was in session, designed to justify raiding your pockets, were inaccurate.)
Of course, couple the hysteria over new pupils with the idea that there aren’t enough resources to pay for new schools to house them. And yet – apart from illegal immigrants – Wake County isn’t being overrun by poor people. These newcomers (mostly professionals) pay taxes. If schools and growth don’t pay for themselves, someone is squandering school resources, somewhere.
-Max Borders
Bring the FIRE back to Chapel Hill
The University of Delaware dismantles its indoctrination program due to the work of students and the FIRE. We need to get the FIRE (Foundation for Individual Rights in Education)working in Chapel Hill again.
In the spirit of that defunkt program, I’d like to remind my white readers that they are both ‘racist’ and ‘unsustainable’. (HT: Sister Toldjah)
-Max Borders
George Will on the Utah Vouchers Vote
A must read from George Will on the vote next Tuesday in Utah on the school voucher program. A sliver:
In today’s political taxonomy, "progressives" are rebranded liberals dodging the damage they did to their old label. Perhaps their most injurious idea — injurious to themselves and public schools — was the forced busing of (mostly other people’s) children to engineer "racial balance" in public schools. Soon, liberals will need a third label if people notice what "progressives" are up to in Utah.
There, teachers unions, whose idea of progress is preservation of the status quo, are waging an expensive and meretricious campaign to overturn the right of parents to choose among competing schools, public and private, for the best education for their children. (More.)
Poverty and the Public Schools
Hood gives the N&O and Comrade Schofield a lesson in statistics and common sense on the issue of schoolchildren and poverty (after bad reporting by the N&O Schofield stumbles clumsily into this post).
-Max Borders
Misleading Us About School Choice
What’s the best way to dismantle public education and privatize schools? School choice. That’s what our friend Chris Fitzsimon says in a guest editorial in last week’s Public School Forum’s Friday Report. Amusing, but certainly not true — ask the Milwaukee Public Schools. If I really wanted to dismantle public education, let’s just say I could find more effective ways. Fitzsimon and anti-choice advocates like to demonize anyone who favors school choice and portray themselves as the guardians of the public schools. But are they? The real goal of those who oppose school choice seems to be not providing students with quality educational opportunities, but the preservation of the public school “system.” Yes, school choice may contribute to some schools losing revenue due to a loss of pupils. But curiously, liberals always only look at such a development as a “system” loss. No consideration is ever given to the benefits of less crowded classrooms, having children attend better schools or the potential benefits of market forces on institutional performance. A genuine interest in students generates an interest in why students choose to transfer to another school. I’m still looking for any examples by anti-choice advocates of the slightest expression of concern over any of the reasons WHY students and parents might want to flee a failing system.
At the heart of this issue is a simple question: Is government created to serve the individual, or merely to perpetuate the state? School choice empowers parents and families. And, it works. We trust students and families to make informed and wise decisions about which colleges their children attend. Could we ever contemplate not having that choice? Has doing so lead to the dismantling and ruination of public higher education? The silence is telling.
Education and Economics 101
If you subsidize the price of a good, you’ll increase demand for it –and ultimately, increase the price of the good. That’s one of the basic laws of economics we all should have learned in school. If you don’t believe me, look at the ever escalating cost of attending public and private colleges and universities in this country. Earlier this week, the College Board announced that tuition and fees at public and private institutions of higher education rose at more than double the rate of inflation. Tuition and fees are up 6.6 percent from last year, and 5.7 percent from the year before, outpacing both the consumer price index and prices in the economy.
One of the biggest culprits in ever rising college costs is student aid. Has student aid really helped to make college more affordable? I’d say the opposite is true. Over the last thirty years, it has helped to increase demand and has contributed to ever rising tuition costs (See Trends in College Pricing 2007 and Trends in Student Aid 2007. Want to reduce tuition costs? Get rid of some of the frivolous student aid programs, limit student enrollment and provide alternative career tracks for the many students who would be better off elsewhere. There would be no choice but for colleges to reduce tuition. If we would only try it.
The Teacher Shortage: What We seem to be forgetting..
Earlier this month, I attended the UNC Tomorrow Commission’s final listening session at North Carolina State University in Raleigh. For the past six months, the commission has been touring and soliciting suggestions from citizens on how UNC might work with businesses and communities to help redress the many challenges currently facing the state. One of these challenges, referred to in a ten minute opening video, is North Carolina’s need for 34,000 new public school teachers by 2014. That’s a significant shortfall and a serious problem. However, as I sat and listened, it was hard not to think that much of the current “crisis” was self inflicted.
Low teacher-student ratios (one of Governor Easley’s favorite initiatives and largely based on the results of inconclusive research) have artificially inflated the need for more classrooms and teachers. Student class size regulations have placed a heavy burden on growing school districts. Granting temporary waivers to school districts or increasing class size regulations by merely one student can provide immediate relief and more reasonably spread out the costs of growth. In addition to class size regulations, cumbersome teacher certification requirements have made it nearly impossible for qualified individuals to use their skills and experiences in the classroom. A number of states like New Hampshire and California have shown the way by developing new alternative teacher certification programs that speed the process of getting trained teachers in the classroom. The teacher shortage is a serious issue. We’d be wise to remember the policies that helped get us here, but also not ignore those that do much to help us move on.
Zany Lil Idea to Improve Public Education
Short of full privatization subsidized with vouchers for the poor, we have to think of ways to improve public education — which pretty much stinks.
So here’s a thought: Why not introduce an element of competition? No, I’m not talking about free-market fundamentalism for schools, I’m talking about competition among schools. Why not pit schools against one another for academics just as we do athletics? Why don’t we add some incentives in there?
For example: the XYZ Elementary School Bears goes up against the ABS Elementary School Eagles. Whoever has the best aggregate improvement in test scores/writing scores or whatever gets to go to the waterpark! Kids love friendly competition. It takes not only our inherently competitive and groupish drives to win, but adds in some fun. I bet you’d get positive secondary effects like smarter kids being more likely to help struggling kids ("We want to win, so I’ll help!").
Just a thought.
-Max Borders