October 2nd, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

If you’re a college student or the parent of a college student, you know all too well about the high cost of higher education.
Something you may not know about however are a couple of new programs specifically designed to help hold down the cost of attending college. In 2016, The Republican led legislature approved a fixed tuition plan for all UNC campuses. The plan provides fixed tuition for students who stay continuously enrolled at a UNC campus for four years. In addition, in 2016 the legislature also approved the the NC Promise Tuition Plan that provides $500 semester tuition for students at three UNC institutions and $5,000 tuition for out-of-state students. The lower cost tuition plan applies to students at UNC-Pembroke, Elizabeth City State University and Western Carolina University.
A recent poll found that few North Carolinians had heard of either of these programs. To make sure more students can benefit, the legislature recently appropriated money for a campaign to publicize the programs.
Want to attend college and not spend a fortune? These programs can go a long way toward making that goal a reality.
September 27th, 2018 by Leah Byers | Topics: Education

October 8, 2018 – The interactive infographic below has been updated to correct for a data error and now reflects accurate values.
Last week, Civitas Policy Director, Bob Luebke, answered an important question: Do North Carolina schools shortchange poor students?
Luebke points to a common misconception that schools in low-income areas receive less funding than schools in higher-income areas. He clarifies that state and federal funding formulas aimed at helping disadvantaged students prevent this from happening.
State funding accounts for about two-thirds of the average school district budget. Such a high percentage helps to minimize the variations among districts whose main source of revenue is the property tax. In addition, higher spending levels among low income districts are also tied to funding formulas designed to aid poor districts.”
Practically, this translates to a system where school districts in lower-income counties tend to receive more money per pupil on average than those in higher income areas.
We can view this relationship by comparing per pupil expenditures in each district to the per capita income of the county. Want to know where your local school district falls on the distribution? Check out the interactive infographic below to learn more.
September 26th, 2018 by Brian Balfour | Topics: Economics, Education, Liberty

Earlier this week, the Duke Chronicle published a piece warning about the “dangers” of the school’s acceptance of funding from the Charles Koch Foundation for a “Center for History of Political Economy.”
Written by a PhD candidate at Duke, this article irresponsibly makes claims about the works of Friedrich Hayek and the Austrian School of economic theory somehow “fueling the violent Alt-Right.”
Naturally, there is zero evidence provided, and the absurd accusation itself reveals this PhD student to be completely ignorant of the subject matter.
Duke alum, and occasional Civitas contributor Tyler Bonin, responded in the Chronicle here. A few highlights from Bonin’s response:
It (the original article) furthermore paints a caricature of Nobel Prize winner Friedrich Hayek that is inconsistent with his most famous writings. I expect more from the history department at Duke….
Populist movements which seek to make swift change by building up and utilizing the most extreme of coercive governmental powers leads to a violent expansion of government that curtails individual liberty and the free market principles that Hayek posited. The violence associated with the alt-right is thus incompatible with the points put forward by Hayek and other economists from the Austrian School.
Perhaps what is most appalling about this is the fact that the Chronicle editors decided to run the original piece, full of sloppy innuendo and wild and unsubstantiated claims, in the first place.
September 18th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

The deck is stacked against poor students because poor schools don’t have the resources to meet their needs and allow them to succeed educationally.
That’s an argument that is frequently made by people and often accompanied by an appeal for more resources or a dim view of the future. Add the editorial page of the Transylvania Times to that list of appeal makers. Last week the paper lamented how North Carolina grades schools for school report cards. The editors said “the report cards revealed a direct link between poverty and academic growth and achievement. In fact, poverty is the single greatest variable when it comes to predicting whether or not a school or school system is performing well or poorly.”
Such statements paint a grim picture of poor kids trapped in poor districts with little hope for the future.
Is that true? Do poor schools really lack the resources they need to help their students succeed?
If you examine the data more closely, you see this is simply not the case.
A 2015 analyses by Brian Balfour of the Civitas Institute is helpful in answering these questions. Balfour compared total per pupil funding by district to county per capita income in North Carolina. Balfour found the conventional wisdom to be wrong, “There is no correlation in the data backing the claim that low-income counties receive lower levels of per-pupil funding.” Balfour continued:
- Poor counties receive more school funding: Out of the 20 poorest counties (as measured by per-capita income), 15 received more than the state average in total funding per student.
- The 20 poorest counties averaged total school funding of $10,000 per student – eight percent above the state average.
- Higher-income counties receive lower levels of school funding: Out of the 20 highest-income counties, only 6 received funding above the state average.
- Average per student total funding for the 20 highest-income counties was $8,954, below the state average and more than 10 percent less than the funding levels of the 20 poorest counties.
How schools are funded in North Carolina explains some of these differences. State funding accounts for about two-thirds of the average school district budget. Such a high percentage helps to minimize the variations among districts whose main source of revenue is the property tax. In addition, higher spending levels among low income districts are also tied to funding formulas designed to aid poor districts. Examples of this aid includes Federal Title I assistance and money for special education children. State formulas designed to assist low income districts include: low wealth supplemental funding, at-risk students funding, disadvantaged students supplemental funding, small county supplemental funding, and limited English proficiency funding, to name a few.
Of course, there are variations and differences among communities and some of the differences may be greater or lesser than the averages. However, to say poor children are doomed in poor schools because the schools lack resources is without basis. There is no correlation between income and spending on schools.
If anything, the new information should reveal we’re not only spending more than what people thought, but the additional resources don’t seem to be having the desired outcomes. How to improve student achievement among low income students is another topic for another time.
That said, a good start would be to stop pointing to funding as the problem. The truth paints a different picture.
September 11th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

If you ask the average person about private schools, most will say they are expensive and cost more to attend than traditional public schools.
That’s what we’re told and that’s what many of us believe.
Well it might not be so.
Yahoo Finance is reporting that in 34 states the cost to attend a private school is actually lower than the average amount spent per student on K-12 public education. One of those 34 states is North Carolina.
According to the article, the average K-12 public school spent $11,392 per student in 2017. The average private school tuition in the United States in 2017, was $10,413. According to Yahoo Finance, in 2017 the average private school tuition in North Carolina was $9,133. The average per student expenditures for North Carolina public schools in the same year was $9,172.
Such findings put school choice in a different light – as they should.
Things aren’t always as they appear.
September 6th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

Flat. That’s the best way to generally describe recent results of North Carolina students and schools on annual performance and growth tests. Over the next few weeks, there will be more opportunities to drill down in the data. Still, the message will be the same: over the past five years, there is very little improvement in student achievement. In fact, in some areas there have been slight declines in student achievement. Some important numbers from yesterday’s release:
- 35.7% – the percentage of students in grades 3-8 who score at the “college and career readiness” (Level 4 or above) level in both math and reading. 2017 figure was 35.5%
- 45.9% – The percentage of students who demonstrate grade level proficiency (GLP) for both reading and math. This represents no change from 2017.
- 55.9% – Despite the creation of the new Read-to-Achieve program, designed to improve reading scores by the end of Grade 3, the percentage of students demonstrating Grade Level Proficiency in Reading at the end of Grade 3 has declined; from 57.8% (2017) to 55.9% (2018)
- End-of-Course Subjects -The percent of students scoring at Grade Level Proficiency for End-of-Course tests in Biology, English II and NC Math I was mixed. Scores for Biology increased (56.1% (2017) to 58.3% (2018). However, scores for English II and NC Math I showed declines from the previous year of .08 % and 6.9% respectively.
- ACT Composite Scores – 57.9 % Percent of 11th grade students met the UNC System minimum admission requirement of an ACT composite score of 17. This marks the second year these scores have declined.
- School Accountability Growth Results: 45.7 percent of all NC schools met expected growth measures, a decline from 47.4 percent in 2017. Moreover, 27 percent of schools exceeded expected growth, while 27.3 percent of schools did not meet expected growth.
- School Report Cards: The distribution of schools receiving A, B, C, D and F grades, largely stayed the same. 35.6 percent of schools garnered A & B grades, 42.2% of schools received C grade, 18.6% of students received D grades.
There is not a lot to get excited about. Only more to fuel the ongoing discussion on needed reforms.
Comprehensive test results can be found here.
September 5th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

Unfortunately, it’s become an all too familiar scene in recent years. At a meeting to discuss the first draft of the Wake County Public Schools School Assignment plan, parents from western Wake County pleaded to school officials not to assign their children to a school outside of their local neighborhood.
According to WCPSS officials, the assignment plan is needed to alleviate overcrowding and help fill four new schools: Green Level High and Alston Ridge Middle School in Cary, Parkside Elementary in Morrisville and Southeast Raleigh Elementary.
I have long opposed the school reassignment policies believing the benefits that accrue from children attending neighborhood schools far outweigh the supposed benefits that come from a more economically and racially diverse district.
At Monday’s meeting an official – who I assume was from WCPSS – made a presentation that referenced WCPSS’s expected enrollment growth over the next six years (2017-18 to 2023-24) to be 14,564, or 2,427 new students each year.
I have long complained that WCPSS growth estimates are too high (see here and here and here). Last year, the News and Observer offered some justification for my position when it reported, “Wake County saw its’ smallest growth in 34 years, gaining only 880 students while charter schools grew at nearly double that amount this school year.”
I’m hoping such realities influenced the size of this fall’s school bond referendum. Initial estimates were around $1 billion. Voters will be asked to approve $548 million for WCPSS school construction, renovation and technology projects.
Still it’s disappointing to see WCPSS ignoring the facts and refusing to revise its overly optimistic growth projections. Having only a third of projected student enrollment growth translates to a lot of empty seats to fill – and a lot of anxious parents.
August 29th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

Over the past week, Civitas Poll results have been a frequent topic of conversation.
Today, let’s briefly talk about recent results from two national education polls. Last week Education Next released results of their 2018 Education Next Poll and found, growing public support for teacher pay, school expenditures, charter schools and universal vouchers. This poll has interesting techniques and the results are always presented in a visually appealing way (see here).
Earlier this week Phi Delta Kappan (PDK) released results of the 2018 PDK Poll on Public Attitudes Toward the Public Schools. 2018 marks the 50th anniversary of the PDK poll. As the name implies, the poll measures changes in attitudes toward the public schools and the education profession. A few findings are worth noting.
PDK reports that 66 percent of respondents said that teacher pay in their community is too low. A surprising 73 percent of respondents said they would support teachers who went on strike for higher pay.
Teacher pay is always an important topic to query. How you ask a question is instructive. When asking about teacher pay or school spending, Education Next Polls frequently ask questions where respondents are provided information about actual spending or salary levels. In nearly all cases, support for teacher pay and additional spending declined when respondents were supplied with additional information (See Ed Next 2015 Poll and Ed Next 2016 Poll.
A press release on the 2016 Education Next Poll results noted the impact of such information:
Teacher salaries. The percentage of the public favoring higher salaries for teachers, at 65%, reached its highest point since 2008. Seventy-six percent of Democrats favor an increase, as compared to 52% of Republicans. However, respondents, on average, under-estimate the current salary level of the average teacher in their state—$57,000—by approximately 30%. When provided with this information, backing for increases is just 41%.
That’s interesting. I wonder how the results would have been impacted had respondents known actual teacher salaries and spending levels in their local communities. Other topics include:
Teaching Profession
The PDK Poll also queries parents about wanting their children to grow up to be teachers. Only 46 percent of respondents said they would like to have their child take up teaching in the public schools. That’s the first time that figure has ever been below 50 percent. Ten years ago, this figure was 70 percent.
Grading the schools
Like many respondents, when asked to grade schools, respondents seem to like the schools geographically closest to them.
70 percent of respondents graded their child’s school as an A or B; 22 percent received C grades and 8 percent received D or F grades.
43 percent of respondents graded public schools in their local community A or B, 38 percent received C grades while 19 percent received D or F grades.
19 percent of respondents graded the public schools nationally, A or B, 46 percent gave the schools a C, while 35 percent of respondents gave the public schools D or F grades.
Finally, the PDK Poll also asked respondents about whether they thought students today were getting a better or worse education than when they were in school.
55 percent of respondents said students today receive a worse education than what they experienced when they were in school. However, several questions reveal that schools were doing a better job today in some categories. These include: educating children of all abilities and backgrounds (55 percent), encouraging critical thinking (52 percent) and ensuring respect for all (51 percent). On the negative side, respondents think today’s schools do a worse job of teaching interpersonal skills (55 percent), teaching facts and figures (56 percent) and preparing young people for the work force (58 percent).
August 24th, 2018 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education

If you live in North Carolina it seems like a never-ending chorus:
Liberals complain that schools are underfunded. Conservatives point to ever-increasing budgets.
So where is the money going?
The title of a new report by the Bellwether Education Partners helps to answer that question, Benefits Take a Larger Bite Out of District K-12 Education Budgets.
How much has spending on benefits increased? According to the report:
Spending on benefits increased dramatically from 2005 to 2014 for most states. In North Carolina, for example, the state’s K-12 spending increased by 2 percent after adjusting for inflation. Benefit spending, on the other hand, grew by 48 percent over the same period. Because benefit costs so dramatically outgrew overall spending, the state and its school districts effectively delivered $589 million less to classrooms.
In 2017, the average teacher in North Carolina has a benefit package worth nearly $17,000.
Those benefits have been growing over time.
Of the 20 largest school districts, 19 spent a higher percentage of their budget on benefit costs in 2014 than 2005. Of the 20 largest districts in the country, the district with the highest increase in benefit costs over that time period is Wake County Public Schools.
In 2005, 11.9 percent of Wake County District school spending was devoted to the cost of benefits. By 2014, the percentage cost of benefits had increased to 18.66 percent. The largest increase among the 20 largest school districts in the United States (See page 11 of the Bellwether Report).
Those numbers have not slowed in recent years. How do they impact the state’s largest school district, Wake County Public Schools?
In 2016-17, WCPSS spent $308,557,224 for employee benefits or $1,948 per student. Since 2005 the per-student cost of employee benefits has increased 83 percent (Source: Online Statistical Profile North Carolina Public Schools).
Remember that the next time you are in a discussion of education funding and teacher salaries.