On Monday the Educator Effectiveness and Compensation Task Force issued its final report. Critics have chided the Committee for stopping short of endorsing specific pay increases for teachers, but that was not the goal of the Committee. Those decisions can and should only be made when North Carolina knows what its budget will look like and what money it will have to spend. Getting teacher pay right is a complex issue ( For more see Teacher Pay: A Problem Money Can’t Fix) and involves more than just throwing money at a problem. The Task Force raised a lot of important issues and traced the outlines of the challenges North Carolina faces. It’s a good first step in a long process.
Education
Teacher Compensation Report: A Start
Colbert Mocks Common Core Math
[iframe id=”http://media.mtvnservices.com/embed/mgid:arc:video:colbertnation.com:a7fad90e-0ea5-4d7a-8638-7ab3c34fd4ea” mode=”normal” align=”center”]
Stephen Colbert took to the Comedy Central stage last night and expressed concerns about schools adopting the Common Core by mocking some of the sample math problems assigned to students.
He sums it up best when referring to the answer a California 2nd grader gave on one of the math problems: “Folks this child has a bright future. He is only in second grade, and can already clearly explain what it feels like to think. Now we just need to get him to explain what that feels like to whoever wrote the Common Core questions.”
New campaign tells stories of those seeking Opportunity Scholarships
Last year the North Carolina General Assembly passed and Governor McCrory signed legislation creating the Opportunity Scholarship program. The program provides vouchers of up to $4,200 to low income students to attend the school of their choice. Over 4,500 families qualified and applied for the program and were anxiously awaiting the opportunity to attend a new school this fall. In late February however, Wake County Superior Court Judge Robert Hobgood issued an injunction blocking implementation of the law. The injunction prevents the state from awarding about 2,400 vouchers for the 2014-15 school year.
The judge’s actions freeze the hopes or aspirations of thousands of families who were counting on the Opportunity Scholarship as a vehicle for a better education. The families and students who applied for the scholarship are real people who are often trapped in difficult circumstances. The Opportunity Scholarship is a powerful tool that empowers parents and students to take control over their education.
Our friends at Parents for Educational Freedom in North Carolina have started a new campaign that chronicles the stories of the North Carolina parents who qualified for and applied for the Opportunity Scholarship but were subsequently denied when a judge’s injunction stopped the program from moving forward. The campaign is titled, One of 4,500.
Listen to their stories; hear of their hopes and disappointments and learn why North Carolina should move forward with the Opportunity Scholarship Program.
“Building the Machine” film available online
So you want to know what Common Core is all about but you don’t have time to read all those policy papers, newspapers and education articles? Yesterday the Home School Legal Defense Association released Building the Machine for viewing online. While the 39 minute film doesn’t unearth any new information, it does a good job of telling how the standards were developed, the challenges they pose and — most importantly — how they threaten the principle of self governance. For anyone who wants to know more about what the Common Core Standards are all about, the film is worth your time.
View the film’s trailer here.
Indiana repeals Common Core
Congratulations to our friends Erin Tuttle and Heather Crossin of Hoosiers Against Common Core. Earlier this week Indiana became the first state to repeal the Common Core Standards.
On Monday Indiana Governor Mike Pence, signed legislation (subscription may be required) saying Indiana will no longer use Common Core math and English Standards. Indiana was one of the first states to adopt Common Core Standards in 2010.
Pence said “I believe our students are best served when decisions about education are made at the state and local level. By signing this legislation, Indiana has taken an important step forward in developing academic standards that are written by Hoosiers, for Hoosiers, and are uncommonly high, and I commend members of the General Assembly for their support.
Let’s hope the final standards are uncommonly high. Writing new standards is a process with no guarantees and always a contentious process, even more so when the clock is running (an April 24th deadline looms) and the stakes are high. There is already concern that the new standards may incorporate too much of Common Core and may not reflect the consistency and rigor desired by those who fought to stop Common Core’s implementation. Let’s hope the Hoosiers get it right. A lot of states — including North Carolina — will be watching.
Education and productivity; dare we ask?
Andrew Coulson at the Cato Institute has authored an interesting study tracking academic performance and state spending over 40 years. What does he find? Despite more-than-doubling in inflation adjusted per public school spending, SAT scores have declined by an average of 3 percent while scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) have remained essentially flat. Data for North Carolina mirrored the overall findings.
Coulson writes.
…consistent with those patterns, there has essentially been no correlation between what states have spent on education and their measured academic outcomes. In other words, America’s educational productivity appears to have collapsed, at least as measured by the NAEP and the SAT.
….Not only have dramatic spending increase been unaccompanied by improvements in performance, the same is true of the occasional spending declines by some states. At one time or another over the past four decades, Alaska, California, Florida and New York all experienced multi-year periods over which real spending fell substantially (20 percent or more of their 1972 expenditure levels). And yet, none of these states experienced noticeable declines in adjusted SAT scores – either contemporaneously or lagged by a few years. Indeed their score trends seem entirely disconnected from their rising and falling levels of spending.
How many different ways can you say; money is not the problem.
John Fund: ‘Racial Preferences Under Siege’
Noted writer John Fund (who will be at CLC) has a new post on National Review Online suggesting that the era of racial preferences may be drawing to a close.
First, racial preferences have lost political clout. In California, he writes, “liberals have long deplored the 1996 passage of Proposition 209, which banned racial preferences at state universities.” Democrats in the legislature planned to put up a referendum question on the fall ballot to repeal Prop. 209.
Asian-Americans were furious, because quota systems, however disguised, discriminate against them. Other voters also told lawmakers to keep their hands off Prop. 209. Democratic lawmakers had to back down and the plan was shelved. Even in liberal California, racial preferences don’t fly.
Nor do preferences have intellectual clout today. “The intellectual case for preferences is looking increasingly shaky. Last month, a packed auditorium at Harvard Law School featured an Intelligence Squared U.S. debate on whether ‘affirmative action does more harm than good,'” Fund wrote. Whatever appeal racial preferences have in theory, in the real world they hurt those they intend to help.
Check out the whole article. One conclusion from reading it: the day of special preferences for certain groups is over.
Fund writes on a wide variety of topics, and he’ll bring that expertise to Raleigh on Saturday, March 29 at our Conservative Leadership Conference, along with speakers such as Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal and Stephen Moore of the Heritage Foundation. To find out which CLC tickets are available, click here.
Oh, you want to know how the survey was conducted?
Last Sunday The Charlotte Observer ran an editorial, Lawmakers, listen: People say education deserves better. It reported on the findings of a survey (The Public Schools Our Children Deserve?) by two UNC-Wilmington education professors Robert Smith and Scott Imig. The authors of the survey found that respondents don’t much like the policies of the Republican legislature.
Observer editors parroted some of the survey’s findings:
…respondents overwhelmingly disapprove of the direction public education is headed in the state. More than 94 percent said North Carolina was headed in the wrong direction on education. A sample of the comments: “These laws will not improve N.C. public education, but destroy it.” “We have two children enrolled in public schools now, and have witnessed firsthand the exodus of quality teachers and the swelling of class sizes… we will be paying attention to candidates’ attitudes, statements, and actions… and will vote accordingly.”
And editors reported the intensity of the animosity.
Respondents were particularly dissatisfied with legislators’ action on teacher pay, teacher tenure, master’s degree changes, vouchers and rewarding only 25 percent of the state’s teachers. Lawmakers gave teachers no salary bump last year, the fourth time in five years teachers got no pay increase. More than 94 percent of survey respondents said raising teacher pay should be lawmakers’ top priority. More than 78 percent disagreed with lawmakers’ decision to eliminate teacher tenure. Ninety-six percent think teachers should get extra pay for earning a master’s degree; lawmakers eliminated that. More than 85 percent disagreed with the state providing vouchers for families to attend private schools; 76 percent disapproved of giving annual pay raises to just 25 percent of N.C. teachers, designated as the top teachers.
And editors urged lawmakers to listen to the “people”. The editors however didn’t have a problem with not disclosing how the poll was conducted. A visit to the methods section of the survey is instructive.
Methods
The purpose of this study was to gather opinion data from North Carolina citizens on recent education policies passed by the NC Legislature. This document offers findings from a quantitative survey of residents of North Carolina. Participants completed the survey online. A link to this survey was shared with mulitple PTA organizations across North Carolina and it was posted on multiple websites, including personal Facebook and Twitter pages and the Charlotte ObserverFacebook page. In addition, individual respondents also forwarded and/or posted the survey link. The survey was opened on January 23, 2014 and closed on February 10, 2014.
So let’s start with the obvious, the findings are far from scientific a scientific poll. A full 62 percent of respondents said they had been employed by the a public school (either currently or previously). Eighty-five percent of the respondents were women and almost half (45 percent) of respondents had family ncomes above $80,000.
Sharing a survey with multiple PTA organizations and posting to multiple websites or Facebook pages — including the Charlotte Observer — does little to ensure a representative sample and a lot to ensure you get the response you want.
No editors did not say the poll was scientific. Neither did they say anything about the questionable methodology — or about a December 2013 poll by the same authors that surveyed teachers and administrators about legislative changes but used a similar and questionable methodology .
Of course public school teachers, administrators and supporters have a right to advocate for their concerns and to make their opinion known. However supporters or editors don’t have a right to misrepresent those opinions simply because they disagree with the policies.
WCPSS board and teachers say no to legislative merit pay plan
“For complex long-term tasks like teaching, performance pay has not proven to be effective,” Kushner said. “In fact, it’s proven to be counterproductive.”
Those are the words of Christine Kushner, Chairwoman of the Wake County School Board. After hearing the views and protests of nearly a hundred teachers — most of them members of the state’s largest teacher association, the North Carolina Association of Educators — last night Kushner and other board members approved a resolution opposing a new law that offers bonuses to top teachers in exchange for giving up career status.
No merit pay is not perfect. But there is plenty of evidence to suggest merit can work (see here and here) . Plus, it’s far better than the current system of how we pay teachers.
I wonder; if performance pay is not only ineffective but as Kushner says “counterproductive” why did WCPSS accept Race-to-the-Top money from the feds for such a plan?
If teachers want to be treated like other professions, they need to do what all other professions do: accurately assess how well their members are performing or not performing.
School Choice and Common Sense
Our friend State Senator Jason Nelsen of Oklahoma is out dispensing a whole lot of common sense — again.
Earlier this week Jay Greene’s Blog included an interesting exchange between Nelsen and a reporter interviewing Sen. Nelsen about his proposal to provide parents in Oklahoma with Education Savings Accounts (Read entire interview by Oklahoma Watch here).
The reporter asked:
Q: If the students who are left in public schools are the least likely to succeed, doesn’t it almost guarantee those schools won’t do well?
I’ve got two children in public school. I’ve not yet talked to any parent that sees their child as a funding unit for the public school system. None of us see our kids that way. It’s silly to make an argument like that: “Your child needs to come to this school because they’re a funding unit and we need to have that.” The people who are leaving are the people that aren’t getting their needs met. If you’re happy, then you’re going to stay. If the school’s not working for your child for whatever reason, you should have no obligation to stay
I can’t add anything to that.