This is National School Choice Week. It’s time to show your support for allowing parents to choose the school that is best for their children. Attend one of the events in your area. If you’re in Raleigh this Wednesday, visit the America’s Future Foundation discussion on the future of school choice, featuring Darrell Allison (Parents for Educational Freedom North Carolina; Dr. Terry Stoops (John Locke Foundation); Donald Bryson (Americans for Prosperity. Time 5:30p.m. Place: Natty Greene’s Raleigh 505 W. Jones St. Raleigh. Cost: Free for America’s Future Foundation members. All Others: $5.
Education
National School Choice Week
Steps toward financial transparency in schools
Financial transparency is not the strong suit of most public schools. That said, last week Rick Hess gave kudos in his Education Week column (subscription required) to one district that is doing a good job. Hess lauded Clark County (NV) School District for their effort to show the public how their money is spent. The district encompasses Las Vegas and a large chunk of southeast Nevada. Clark County School District is the sixth largest school district in the nation. True it’s easy to tell why NV’s costs are lower than its larger, more urbanized peers. Still the data and the breakdown is a good first step in allowing citizens to get their heads around the costs of public education.
Texas has the best transparency requirements in the country for public schools. They even require school districts to publish check registries. While North Carolina is not quite there yet, we can certainly do better.
In 2011-12, North Carolinians spent $11.9 billion (state, federal and local funds) on public K-12 education. Why is it so difficult for citizens to learn how their money is being spent?
Does Indiana lead the way against Common Core?
An interesting debate and — one well worth watching — is playing out in Indiana. Senator Scott Schneider (R-Indianapolis) introduced a bill (SB 193) to reverse the State Education Board’s decision to use Common Core State Standards and replace them with Indiana education standards.
Yesterday a Senate education committee heard about five hours of testimony on the bill. Critics of the standards said they were written with little input from parents and educators. In addition the Obama administration made adoption of common core a requirement for receipt of federal education funding. A vote on the SB 193 is expected next week.
If approved Indiana would be the first state to adopt common core standards and replace them with other standards. Forty five states have adopted common core standards. However as parents and educators look more closely at how the standards are being implemented and how they change teaching and learning, opposition is clearly growing.
For additional information on the Indiana story and criticisms over common core standards see here and here.
More reasons not to like the common core
If you’re reading this you know the world didn’t end in 2012. But the world of American education may end in 2014, when the Common Core is scheduled to march into thousands of schools in the United States and end a “chaotic, fragmented, unequal, obsolete and failing” system that has accompanied the rise of a nation with the largest economy, most scientific discoveries and technological innovations, best universities and largest collection of Nobel laureates in the world today. In place will be a new world of education where all American children are exposed to the same content, delivered by highly standardized teachers, watched over by their equally standardized principals and monitored by governments armed with sophisticated data tools.
That thoughtful paragraph is from Yong Zhao, Associate Dean for Global Education at the University of Oregon. It’s from a January 8th blog post where Zhoa asks five very important questions about Common Core standards.
Yes, I know lately I’ve been camped on the problems with the Common Core Standards. But sadly, I believe most parents and teachers don’t know what’s coming down the pike. It’s true North Carolina and 45 other states have adopted the standards. However it’s never too late to educate yourself and to try and stop the train.
What makes Zhaoa’s piece interesting is that he writes from an interesting perspective. He’s a self-proclaimed globalist. The perceived need to make ourselves globally competitive has propelled the development of common core standards. However, Zhao’s not buying. He believes the common core is based on fallacious assumptions and does little to meet our real challenges. It’s a different slant on an important topic. If you’re a parent or anyone interested in how our children are being taught, it’s worth a read.
Jim Martin’s surprising comments
In a committee meeting earlier this week where school administrators updated Wake County School board members on a new law that gives a letter grade to each school and ends the practice of social promotion, board member Jim Martin called the new grading law “a bad idea”. News accounts said Martin called the grading system an attempt to subject the schools to public ridicule.
I guess Jim Martin believes parents have no right to know if their child’s school is performing poorly. I doubt that I’m the only one bothered that Martin seems more concerned about making sure the schools don’t look bad than in actually fixing what needs to be fixed.
Martin also doesn’t like a new law which requires school districts to remediate students who aren’t reading at a third grade level. In fairness, Martin said the mandate comes with no additional money. Still social promotion is a problem that only becomes worse down the line. We’ve learned that hard lesson as we try to improve dropout and graduation rates. Social promotion is not a solution.
People are held accountable in jobs. Children are held accountable by teachers and parents. Schools are held accountable by the public. The public has a right to know which schools are succeeding and failing and expect third graders to be reading at a third grade level.
Some WCPSS board members need to learn accountability is not a one-way street.
Common Core standards: where things aren’t quite as they appear
With the threat of losing millions in federal aid dollars in 2010 North Carolina joined with 44 other states and adopted common core academic standards for grades K-12 in math and English. The standards – we are told – help to ensure that students throughout the country learn the same content and skills. They have also wrested control of the curriculum from states and localities and put it in the hands of the federal government.
Sadly, parents most of whom are occupied with keeping their own families humming along, have been unaware of the common core standards. Nevertheless, the new academic standards will be in place by next year. And then the changes start. Take English for example. The new standards require that nonfiction texts represent 50 percent of reading assignments in elementary schools and grow to 70 percent by grade 12.
That’s quite a chunk of literature to be replaced by nonfiction and “informational” reading. Instead of reading Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland or The Little Prince, fourth and fifth graders may be reading The Evolution of the Grocery Bag and Invasive Plant Inventory from the California Invasive Plant Council. If you’re an eleventh grader, instead of reading Shakespeare, Twain or another great author, you may find your son or daughter thumbing through Google Hacks: Tips and Tools for Smarter Searching or the Tipping Point by Malcolm Gladwell. Think I’m kidding? Review for yourself some of the suggested common core informational texts here.
In addition to ensuring students have a common experience, the common core standards are an attempt to make students more college ready. Really? Seems to me that tackling great literature is the best way to expand minds and make students more college ready. There are a variety of reasons why students are not ready for college. I don’t know a single reason however that is tied to what is or isn’t taught in English Literature classes. Infusing nonfiction or “informational texts” into the curriculum does nothing but drive great literature out of the classroom.
Common core standards? The concept sounds great in theory. Until you ask: Where have they been tried and worked? How do “dumbed-down” educational standards improve education? Do states and local communities really want to lose control over what is taught in the public schools?
Politics bite law makers on dues check off law
Almost a year to the date that the State Legislature overrode a veto by the Governor in a late-night session, Wake County Circuit Court Judge Paul Gessner ruled that legislation prohibiting the state from collecting membership funds for the North Carolina Association of Educators (NCAE) via dues check off was unconstitutional (see article). Judge Gessner agreed with NCAE attorneys who argued the law unlawfully targeted the largest teachers association in North Carolina. It’s no secret NCAE has been a focus of many Republican law makers because of its strong support for Democratic candidates and causes.
Eighteen months ago, I wrote of my support for the bill (SB 727) eliminating dues check off legislation. However, I favored government eliminating the practice of dues check off for all entities. Government shouldn’t play favorites.
Such sentiment found its way to the floor. Nevertheless, an amendment to do so failed. Of course I understand there were political reasons to vote against the amendment. However I wonder if they justify today’s outcome?
No word yet on how the legislature will respond.
Common Core Standards: There’s Plenty to Dislike
North Carolina continues to work its way through one of the most significant but least reported stories of the last year: the adoption of common core standards by states and school systems.
The common core is a set of guidelines written for both math and English by the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers. Where adopted the common core standards will replace state standards and provide a common curriculum and a better means of comparing students across subject areas.
At least that’s what it says in the glossy documents. For parents who know little about the common core standards, there are many reasons to be concerned. Find out why you should be, here, here and here.
In an interesting article in a recent issue of Atlantic Magazine, Barry Garelick outlines why parents should be concerned about common core math standards.
Many of these standards require that students be able to explain why a particular procedure works. It’s not enough for a student to be able to divide one fraction by another. He or she must also “use the relationship between multiplication and division to explain that (2/3) ÷ (3/4) =8/9, because 3/4 or 8/9 is 2/3.”
It’s an odd pedagogical agenda, based on the belief that conceptual understanding must come before practical skills can be mastered. As this thinking goes, students must be able to explain the “why” of a procedure. Otherwise, solving a math problem becomes a “mere calculation” and the student is viewed as not having true understanding.
This approach not only complicates the simplest of math problems’ it also leads to delays. Under the Common Core Standards, students will not learn traditional methods of adding and subtracting double and tripled digit numbers until fourth grade. (Currently most schools teach these skills two years earlier). The standard method for two and three digit multiplication is delayed until fifth grade; the standard method for long division until sixth. In the meantime, the students learn alternative strategies that are far less efficient, but that presumably help the m “understand” the conceptual underpinnings.
I’m all for higher standards, but when the standards prove ineffective, come with strong arm tactics that threaten states the loss of federal dollars, lower existing state standards (Massachusetts) and result in less control over public education; the damage outweighs the benefit.
Think the problems are limited to math standards? This morning Sandra Stotsky of the University of Arkansas outlined how common core standards will negatively impact literary study and analytical thinking.
Easley & NC State stick it to taxpayers
It’s good to be Mary Easley these days. Easley’s attorneys negotiated a settlement with attorneys from N.C. State University that not only more than doubled her state pension payment but also gives her a pension ($80,597) that is more than the pension her husband, Mike Easley is receiving ($71,088) for his service as a state prosecutor and for two terms as North Carolina’s governor.
For those of you unfamiliar with this story, Easley was hired in 2005 to run a speaker bureau series for N.C. State. In 2008, Easley’s responsibilities expanded, her salary increased a whopping 88 percent and she was given a five year contract.
The developments caught the eye of a few reporters and newspaper editors. In early 2009 newspaper accounts revealing how Easley was hired with the help of the Governor along with budget cutting, took away most of her responsibilities and led to calls for Easley’s resignation. She refused to step aside. The developments led to the resignation of Chancellor James Oblinger. And, NC State eliminated the position in July 2009. Easley sought to have her job restored and lost. She also claimed wrongful termination, but never took the case to court.
The deal, negotiated by attorneys and signed off on by N.C. State Chancellor Randy Woodson keeps Easley from bringing any “breach of contract” action against the University. Woodson said he signed off on the deal because it offered a better deal for the university than the prospect of the added costs of prolonged litigation and the bad publicity for the university.
The deal also allowed Easley to essentially “unretire” and get credit for three years that she hadn’t worked. Huh? Easley is now credited with having worked three years at a salary of $170,000. The settlement also dictated that both sides would have to make payments on premiums. NC State paid approximately $90,000 to cover state benefit obligations to Easley during this period. Woodson said the payments were made from private donations.
The settlement gives NC State the opportunity to move on without ever having to bring to light the sordid details of why Mary Easley was hired; why she was paid an exorbitant salary and what exactly she was supposed to do. Yes, the settlement protects NC State’s interests. However you have to ask: Do the interests of NC State trump those of the taxpayer? Why should taxpayers pay for the university’s mistakes?
The settlement sweeps the episode under the rug and ensures that no one will be held to account for their actions. Is that the kind of leadership we expect from the state’s largest public university?
Student Financial Aid: Begging for an Overhaul
What’s the next financial disaster? In an alarming piece in yesterday’s American Thinker, Gary Jason argues the ducks are finally coming home to roost on an overbuilt, overpriced and overvalued system of American higher education. The culprit? Federal student financial aid. The evidence is hard to ignore. Average student loan balance ($26,682) is growing rapidly. The percentage of households headed by someone younger than 35 with student loan debt is 40 percent. And, the two-year default rate rose from 8.8 percent in 2008 to 9.1 percent in 2010; the fifth consecutive rate of increases.
Want more bad news? Remember these stats don’t count borrowers who are allowed to postpone payments because of economic hardship. With half of all recent graduates unemployed, you can bet the default rates will only increase.
Remember for the last four decades student financial aid has been fueled by the perceived “need” to make college more affordable and to ensure our students are able to compete in the global economy…. And what have we gotten for the billions that have been spent?
Educational attainment has increased, but at a hefty price. The availability of student financial aid has spurred endless increases in college tuition and fees and contributed to administrative bloat, with no real increase in educational quality. Furthermore, expanding college access to students of average ability has only decreased real net returns on investment in higher education.
You’d think such outcomes would cause us to rethink federal policy. Don’t bank on it. Earlier this spring Congress and the President both proved themselves without spine when the possibility of potential increase in student loan interest rates. Election year politics? Maybe. Still name the last time any politician had the courage to cut entitlements?
Jason provides the real reason why we the current program needs to be overhauled. He writes:
Remember, under recently adopted rules, payment on student loans will be capped at only 10 percent of the borrower’s “discretionary” income, and the balance “forgiven” after twenty years. What this means is that more and more massive amounts of bad student loan debt will be saddled on the backs of taxpayers, many of whom never got to go to college in the first place.
There you have it: another bailout. In the meantime, let’s refuse to make any changes and keep doing the same thing. What did they say about the definition of insanity?