While most of the nation has been fixated on the Supreme ruling on Obamacare, last week Congress agreed to freeze for one year the interest rate on some student loans. Interest rates on low-cost federal student loan some federal loans had been expected to rise from 3 or 4 percent to nearly twice that amount. The actions by Congress will save the average borrower $7 to $9 dollars a month. Do you think fall elections had anything to do with the outcome? If you’re a student loan borrower you’re probably happy with this announcement. If you’re a taxpayer, you’re not. Once again, Congress showed no willingness to make tough decisions and come to grips with the reality that federal student financial aid programs aren’t a good deal for students or taxpayers. Richard Vedder discusses why in a compelling article, Federal Student Aid and the Law of Unintended Consequences. Is it a coincidence that ever-escalating tuition tracks with the availability of student financial aid? Is it a coincidence that five-year student graduation rates hover around 50 percent? Why — after borrowing thousands of dollars for college — are so many students unemployed burdened by excessive debt? These are all questions Congress should address — but won’t. Get the feds out of the student loan business. Then watch what happens.
Education
Congress punts on student loans — again.
NC Judge Perpetuates Monopoly on Education
School choice in North Carolina has taken a major hit. Superior Court Judge Abraham Jones recently barred a virtual charter school from operating. NC Learns, a non-profit organization, wanted to open a virtual charter school that planned to enroll almost 2,000 students across the state. The school in question, NC Virtual Academy, received approval from the Cabarrus County school board to open and operate, but the State Board of Education would have none of that. I guess it didn’t want its death-grip on education policy to be weakened.
The State Board of Education found a comrade in the courts. Judge Jones handed down a ruling stating that the NC Virtual Academy first needed approval from the State Board of Education. Classes at the Virtual Academy were to commence this coming August but the court ruling has subsequently delayed any virtual charter school from even being considered, let alone opened and operated in North Carolina, until at least 2014. NC Learns has yet to decide whether or not it will appeal the ruling.
This ruling could set a precedent which inhibits county school boards from developing the type of schools that best fits the needs of the students they serve. The ruling reaffirms the State Board of Education’s control over who can authorize charter schools. Counties who feel they know the needs of their students better than members of the State Board of Education, they need not apply. As a result, parental choice and improved educational opportunities and outcomes have been sacrificed.
Why does the education establishment in our state not want virtual charter schools to prosper? It’s simple: follow the money. If virtual charter schools are allowed to operate, funds granted to traditional public schools will be siphoned away. Public schools do not want to lose funds to unconventional educational alternatives. Furthermore, virtual schools offer direct competition to public schools and challenge its control over public education. When school choice is an option, government-run schools are rarely the first choice of parents and students.
There is a deeper cause of contention, though. This involves the education establishment’s hatred of for-profit educational enterprises. While NC Learns is a non-profit organization, it had planned to use K12, a successful for-profit company that specializes in providing online education, to run the virtual school. Oh, the insanity! If the word “profit” is used anywhere or at any time, the idea must be wretched nonsense. We all know that the only responsible, qualified, efficient, and successful progenitor of education is the government, right?
If education is so vitally important, and it is, why not allow the market to spark innovation, efficiency and increased achievement in North Carolina’s schools? If there is an aversion to competition, it is usually a sign of a larger problem. Let’s solve it and move on. A little competition may challenge the State Board’s monopoly control of public education, but it would also improve our educational system. That’s a good thing.
First GOP Led Session Ends With High Notes for Republicans
Republicans, along with some Democrats, dealt Democratic Governor Bev Perdue multiple blows with veto overrides to conclude the first legislative session led by Republicans in 140 years. Click on the video report…
Spotlighting Success: Civitas Review magazine profiles Upper Room Christian Academy
Our nation was founded as a great experiment. In its infancy, its founders knew that there were many forms it could have taken. They chose to fashion it into a republic, and with that system it has endured through the generations. The founders realized that progress requires a daring, entrepreneurial spirit and the courage to try something new in the face of adversity.
The administrators, faculty, and staff of Upper Room Christian Academy (URCA) in Southeast Raleigh have boldly undertaken their own experiment and the result has been a success similar in spirit to that of our great nation. We at Civitas spend a lot of time talking about government, politics and the problems we uncover. In the upcoming edition of Civitas Review magazine – mailed to our donors – we wanted to showcase a solution for one of the most serious problems facing our state and nation – the failure of the public education system.
The magazine’s cover story showcases URCA, which has grown tremendously in the past few years and has great potential for the future. It exemplifies how ordinary people saw a problem with their schools and had the courage and determination to do something about it. It demonstrates the way in which rigorous academics, a strong community, and ethical guidance can help students flourish.
While not everyone may embrace the school’s approach, many other families would treasure having multiple options for their kids’ education. Unfortunately, we know that many families don’t have all, or any, of the educational choices that they should have. Our nation is strongest when it leaves people free to experiment and solve problems in their own ingenuous ways. It is strongest when we give families and communities the opportunity to live lives consistent with their faith and values. URCA gives parents and students this option. We would like to see a day where every North Carolina family has such choices.
Check out this video for a look at what URCA offers students and families and why we at Civitas commend their successful experiment with school choice.
What Comes First: Families’ ‘Wants’ or Society’s ‘Needs’?
You have to give credit to the chairman of the Wake County School Board for frankness in discussing what’s important.
Someone in the district passed along to us an e-mail Kevin Hill sent to at least one parent in response to an inquiry about the assignment plan:
Thanks for sharing. I do not know where the Board will go, but I continue to hear from more than a few parents about issues with the current plan. I do not intend to return to the “old” plan, but whatever direction we go will provide entrance points for parents moving to Wake County and to parents who have had children in private schools and wish to take advantage of the public schools. I agree with the following: ” ‘Parent choice’ proceeds from the belief that the purpose of education is to provide individual students with an education. In fact, educating the individual is but a means to the true end of education, which is to create a viable social order to which individuals contribute and by which they are sustained. ‘Family choice’ is, therefore, basically selfish and anti-social in that it focuses on the ‘wants’ of a single family rather than the ‘needs’ of society.” -Association of California School Administrators
Respectfully,
Kevin
Kevin L. Hill, Chairman
Wake County Board of Education/District 3
A little background: Some Internet sleuthing indicates that quotation Hill cites has been linked to the Association of California School Administrators since at least 1979. I’m awaiting a call-back from that organization to see if such a link is accurate.
However, the saying has achieved a life of its own on in cyberspace, with quite a number of blogs quoting it. In any case, Mr. Hill took it to be a useful summary of his views, whatever its provenance, and that of course is the real point.
In response to a query from us, Hill emailed back that the email was genuine, and by way of explanation he enclosed a copy of his response sent to two people who had asked about it:
You both have asked about the quotation I shared with a parent and asked for an explanation. I have been out of town eight of the last ten days (Home Sunday) and am now just catching up. In hindsight, I chose a poor example to link the birth of the common school movement and compulsory attendance laws in Massachusetts with the desire to educate all children. The “viable social order” I think about comes from the 1850s and refers to the importance of a free public education and reinforces the importance of democracy and the American way of life. Public schools are just that, public schools and they are tasked with providing the best education for all children. My comment refers more to what many people believe — That our current generation is more of a “me” generation, as opposed to generations past which were more of “we” generations.” There is no way that any assignment process will please all parents. My point is that our task as a community is to look for the most good for the most children. Hence, the good of the public as a whole.
Any effort to read more into my comment is a stretch and directs attention away from what we as a community should be talking about – Providing an excellent education for all children! I will refrain from using historical context for examples in the future. Now that I have explained myself, maybe we can get back to the important work at hand . . . Providing for all children in Wake County.
Respectfully,
Kevin
Kevin L. Hill, Chairman
Wake County Board of Education/District 3
In his response to us, he also noted: “The letter is a matter of public record. I consider the matter closed.”
It still seems to be darned interesting to me. He admits it may have been a poor choice of example. Yet we can’t help but think that many liberals share these views, even if they are more tactful about expressing them.
Let’s take another look at the quotation, starting with the first section:
‘Parent choice’ proceeds from the belief that the purpose of education is to provide individual students with an education. In fact, educating the individual is but a means to the true end of education, which is to create a viable social order to which individuals contribute and by which they are sustained.
Does that mean a democratic social order? Or another kind of order? Tragically, in modern history, sometimes social advances become vehicles for domination by government.
Some bloggers see this in the ACSA statement as far left-wing. But you don’t have to go that far; it seems to me to be a rather clear, if unusually candid, expression of what liberals everywhere actually think. They believe society comes first. To be charitable, let’s assume they believe that upholding the “viable social order” is the best way to improve the lives of individuals.
However, my colleague Brian Balfour points out:
“But this notion of ‘the public as a whole’ or a ‘common good’ is an indefinable concept. There is no such thing, only a collection of individuals.
“If we are to take the concept of ‘the public as whole’ to any logical conclusion it means it is good for every single individual – an impossible task, especially for some central figurehead. There is no way to know what each individual views to be “good,” and then to somehow satisfy all of their criteria without overriding the preferences of some.
” Therefore, Hill is merely justifying his desire to force upon the community what he considers to be ‘good,’ and apparently feels morally entitled to impose his views upon others, for their own good of course.”
Moreover, as history has shown, making the individual primary is not in conflict with establishing a viable social order, but the best way of promoting the social order. When individuals are free to make their own choices, society also flourishes. You can go back to ancient Greek democracy and the Roman Republic, and look at societies up to today’s free countries, and it’s clear that where individual freedom is nourished, society also benefits.
Let’s go on to the conclusion of the original quote:
‘Family choice’ is, therefore, basically selfish and anti-social in that it focuses on the ‘wants’ of a single family rather than the ‘needs’ of society.”
Think about it: In this quotation, a family’s values and goals are not the most important thing in society. They are not even a flawed but legitimate and necessary endeavor. They are wrong – “selfish” – and destructive – “anti-social.”
At the Conservative Leadership Conference, American Enterprise President Arthur Brooks spoke on the primacy of moral concerns. That is, for human beings, moral issues are more important than anything else. (And he will return to such themes when he speaks at our luncheon event July 18 in Charlotte.)
In other words, for the left, this is a moral issue. In the quotation, the family really is morally wrong. It is not just a social institution that can be improved; it is an institution whose selfishness is opposed to the “viable social order,” and therefore is an enemy of that order, and thus of the primary good.
I hasten to explain that I’m confident Hill surely didn’t consciously mean that. But one problem is that underneath liberalism’s bright face lie subterranean currents that are far darker. Many liberals don’t understand this; but nevertheless they imbibe these dark ideas, which inevitably color their ideas and behavior.
And this need not be anything nefarious; often these values just fail on their own terms. Let us return to Hill’s explanation, as it pertains to a current controversy: “There is no way that any assignment process will please all parents. My point is that our task as a community is to look for the most good for the most children. Hence, the good of the public as a whole.”
Now, just looking at the assignment plan, no one expects any plan to satisfy all people. But the previous plan tried to give people the power to make their own choices, as much as possible. There is a lot of spinning about the new plan, but it’s hard to see it as anything but putting the district’s “needs” first. As in so many cases, that probably means families’ “wants” will be a distant second. For liberalism, this is not about efficient use of resources; it’s about right and wrong, and those who claim families come first are just wrong
Finally, that is why (as Brian Balfour suggests) any centralized plan is likely to fail. Some families are most concerned about diversity, some want a school nearby, some want the best academic programs, some want the best sports teams, others just want friendly teachers, and on and on. No single plan can satisfy more than a small fraction of them. And when the plan aims at one broad, abstract principle, it likely will fail to satisfy anyone.
The whole problem with trying to achieve “the good of the public as a whole” is that there is no whole, just 146,000 students who all have their own unique needs and wants. Trying to serve “the public as a whole” is a recipe for failure. It seems like a paradox to liberals, but if you instead try to offer families and students the most choices so they can control their education, in the end you’ll have the best results for the most students. (See Frederich Hayek’s “The Road to Serfdom.”)
This may seem like a minor business, but it’s revealing nonetheless. We are sure Mr. Hill wants to do the best by the district. But he’s mixed up on what’s most important. And until a majority on the board puts families and students first, that faction is likely to flunk out in their quest to improve the district.
Clock is Ticking on Budget Deadline; No Hint from Gov’s Office
Governor Beverly Perdue summoned the press to the Capitol Building Tuesday to talk about the budget. There was much anticipation about what she would say or do, but there wasn’t much substance. The Governor said legislators needed to spend more for education and left. Republican leaders in the General Assembly are suprised Gov. Perdue is holding off signing the budget over a small difference in funding. House Speaker Thom Tillis (R-Mecklenburg) says they are just a fraction apart…
Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) says the Governor wants to move money from reserves into education, but he says that money is needed to shore up Medicaid overruns expected in the next fiscal year. Berger says a veto would do much more harm because the state would then be operating on last year’s budget with no expansion…
There’s more than money at stake. There is a provision in the legislative budget that would allow parents to tell schools what their children could eat and drink in homemade lunches. They could opt out of federal nutrition standards that led to the infamous “chicken nuggets” incident in a Hoke County school. Another provision would prohibit state regulators from taking school lunches into account when assessing pre-K programs at public schools. The Hoke County school pre-K program was downgraded because homemade lunches didn’t meet nutrition standards. Those provisions would go away with a veto and House Speaker Tillis says there wouldn’t be enough time to handled them separately.
The Governor has until Sunday to either sign or veto the budget. The budget becomes law that day if she does neither. Tillis says legislators will stick around until at least Monday.
Senate and House Finalize Budget
Senate and House leaders have come to an agreement on a final version of the legislature’s spending plan. All eyes will move to the Governor after this week. Click on the video report…
Teacher Who Curtails Student’s Rights Gets To Keep Job
North Rowan High School Teacher Who Degrades Student’s First Amendment Rights Gets to Keep Job
In May of this year, a YouTube video (open at your own discretion) of a teacher and student debating President Obama and Mitt Romney’s younger years went viral on YouTube. In case you were wondering who was debating on which side, the teachers “Fact of the Day” was that Mitt Romney was a bully. The North Rowan High School teacher, Mrs. Tanya Dixon-Neely, went on to make audacious claims about the Constitution and Candidate Romney. After a student (rudely) said, “I’ll say what I want,” Mrs. Neely was quick to curtail his First Amendment right to free speech by letting him know that in her classroom criticism of Barack Obama was prohibited speech, “Not about him you won’t.” Additional constitutional conundrums took place, as Mrs. Neely told students as a teacher, “I’m not supposed to allow you to disrespect the President” and that when a citizen is arrested, “they don’t read your rights to you every time you’re arrested.”
Although these remarks are incorrect, leaving her students with a misconception of the Bill of Rights and the Constitution, the most shocking remark centers around President Bush. Mrs. Neely goes on to tell students in her class that, “People were arrested for saying things bad about Bush” and that “Bush was shi**y.” Telling students that they could possibly be arrested for saying bad things about a President is very damaging. If Mrs. Neely’s students are ever in a situation to engage in a debate with a public official, will they with the false knowledge that they could possibly be arrested?
After this video went viral, Mrs. Neely was placed on administrative leave with pay (standard procedure). After an investigation took place, her status was moved to administrative leave without pay. Sarah Campbell of the Salisbury Post reports on the latest developments on Mrs. Neely employment with Rowan-Salisbury Schools, “Although Tanya Dixon-Neely has been suspended without pay, she will return next school year, when she will be required to start a monitored growth plan, Superintendent Dr. Judy Grissom said in a press release.” It has also been noted by Sarah Campbell that Mrs. Neely received two positive results from her classroom observations earlier in May.
Teachers are pegged with an extremely important task, educating future minds in an environment that fosters learning, curiosity, and respectful discourse on topics, among other things. In May, Mrs. Neely failed to deliver on her end of the bargain. We hope that Mrs. Neely, and other politically motivated teachers, take a step back to provide an objective educational experience and if needed, a refresher course for themselves on the Constitution.
Leg. Leaders reveal details of budget agreement
Legislative conferees have come to an agreement on a $20.1 billion budget deal. The document must now be approved by both houses. Major education highlights include:
- 1.2 percent pay increase for state employees and teachers
- Monies for community colleges and UNC pay increases which equate to 1.2 percent increase
- Also included in the budget are major provisions of the Excellent Public Schools Act (SB 795)
Identify and remediate 3rd grade reading problems
End social promotion
Establish NC Teacher Corps
Develop LEA merit pay program
Add 5 additional days to the school year
- No changes to teacher career status, a major component of the Excellent Public Schools Act, were included in the agreement.
- Also not included in the agreementl was the Scholarship Funding Corporate Tax Credit (HB 1104) which the House had attached to SB 795. The bill must still be approved by both the House and the Senate.
WCPSS wants diversity in school assignment plan — again.
Déjà vu. According to the dictionary it’s “the illusion of having previously experienced something actually being experienced for the first time.” That’s the appropriate reaction of any Wake County parent or resident who learned that the Wake County School Board approved a directive on a 5-4 vote (along partisan lines) to revise the school assignment plan for 2013-14 school year. The revised student assignment plan will tie each address to a specific school and establish targets for academics and socioeconomics at schools. Sound familiar?
It is hard to believe that the Wake County School Board would want to reopen an issue when an overwhelming number of residents support the concept of neighborhood schools. This is what happens when government – and in this case a school system — gets too big.