More than once outgoing UNC President Erskine Bowles has suggested revising the UNC enrollment funding formula. Now a report from the Program Evaluation Division of the General Assembly recommends tying the formula to campus retention or graduation measures – a more than sensible idea. The report also found that while the formula paid out $386 million in funding from 2003-04 to 2007-08, it was not possible to gauge the accuracy of enrollment projections since most campus level projections are not standardized and funds generated by the formula can’t be tracked.
Education
UNC enrollment funding formula under review
School Funding Report; what’s new?
Yesterday the left-leaning NC Justice Center published a report titled: North Carolina’s Public School Funding System: Underfunded, Unclear and Unfair. You needn’t read past the title to get the message.
The crusade for unabashed liberalism continues; same old template, same old solutions.
One the plus side, there was one thing we could agree on: it’s too hard to track expenditures and actually determine how much a school district — or a school for that matter — is spending. That is true. And. I second the call for greater transparency.
The report supports revising many of the funding formulas that drive state money to school districts. No news there. Policymakers have been calling for revisions for years and a committee to do just that has been meeting for the past two years.
I guess there aren’t any savings to be found in a “bare boned” $9 billion public education system with 183,000 employees.
The misuse of research
This week’s Public School Forum newsletter highlights a study by a UNC professor with a curious headline “Study Proves Obesity Worsens from Teen to Adulthood.”
That’s a pretty big claim since most studies worth their salt are upfront about their limitations and measured when discussing the significance of their findings. The claim is all the more puzzling when the very next sentence states:
According to a study published this week in the Journal of the American Medical Association, nearly 40 percent of obese teenagers are bound to become severely obese young adults.
Last time I checked, 40 percent represented less than half of anything being discussed. That means less than half of obese teenagers are “bound” to become severely obese adults. Proof? I don’t think so.
The article continues:
Health problems are already appearing in doctors’ offices and hospitals across North Carolina, where obesity rates for both children and adults are higher than the national average, said Dr. David Collier, a pediatrician and director of the Pediatric Healthy Weight Research and Treatment Center at East Carolina University’s Brody School of Medicine. Collier believes the findings of the study should be a call to action for local, state and national leaders to redouble their efforts tackling the problem. He said that includes political decisions that affect what foods are sold cheaply, and community efforts to build parks and bike paths so people can be more active.
I bet you didn’t know it’s those cheap foods and lack of parks and bike paths that are at the root of the obesity problem?
Instead of assuming society is the culprit, how about individuals do the sensible thing: learn to eat in moderation and practice saying that little two letter word: no. Easy? No. But it’s the best and most economical solution — and you don’t need politicians and community activists to be successful.
The Washington Monument Strategy or Reality?
Have you heard of the Washington Monument Strategy? Erskine Bowles may have used it when he said recently that the UNC System may be forced to consider closing a campus if the General Assembly goes forward with large budget cuts. Or perhaps Bowles was simply being forthright with the public.
The Washington Monument Strategy is simple: when budget cuts are on the way, bureaucrats and interest groups decry the cuts and whip up anger by saying that some popular program will be eliminated. The name is derived from the National Park Service threatening to close the Washington Monument, obviously a popular tourist destination, if their budget was cut.
Of course, given the possible size of the budget cut facing the UNC System, Bowles is right to say that closing down a campus should be considered. The alternative is to cut funding for each university in the system – cuts that might compromise the quality of education at universities that rely heavily on state appropriations.
Bowles may also have floated a political “trial balloon” to gauge public reaction to a campus closure for future reference. As a current UNC System student, I have been surprised that the mention of a closure has not been a more toxic issue on campus and in the public at large.
A more in depth discussion of the issue can be read here.
Alves Plan: new criteria, same old problems
That the Wake County School Board is splitting along partisan lines on whether to use test schools in deciding where children attend school is not news.
All the buzz is about a plan put forth by school consultant Michael Alves that uses test scores — in place of socioeconomic diversity — as one four criteria on which to base student assignment decisions.
Let’s remember: using test scores in school assignment decisions is not the same as using socioeconomic factors. Socioeconomic status is rarely – if ever – changed. It’s also a condition a child has no control over. A child’s test scores are influenced by a myriad of personal and societal factors. Most importantly however, a child’s test scores as well his or her intellectual development — often change over time. Using test scores in school assignment decisions ignores those realities, to the detriment of the student.
Aside from these concerns one of the reasons the Wake County School Board scrapped the school assignment policy is that it failed to significantly improve graduation rates and test scores among minority students.
Having the right balance of test scores in a school does not improve minority student achievement any more than a plan that used socioeconomic diversity in school assignment decisions. And, that’s the problem. The sooner we realize it, the better.
Reality hits UNC System
At yesterday’s UNC Board of Governor’s meeting, outgoing UNC President Erskine Bowles said if proposed budget cuts continue to be higher than anticipated, a campus closing would be preferable to constant budget reductions at all campuses. Count me in for adopting the strategy now. Let’s face it; across the board cuts only allow campuses to avoid a stark reality: not all campuses and programs are equal.
With the state facing a projected $3 billlion budget deficit, hard decisions need to be made. Still there are places to find savings. For starters, how about a thorough review of academic programs. A strategy that forces institutions to recognize and deal with long-term budget realities is far better than thinking campuses should absorb budget cuts equally.
A mixed bag of education ballot initiatives
In addition to generating a political earthquake that reached from shore to shore, voters decided on a varied group of state ballot initiatives involving education. A few of the highlights include:
- Oklahoma: Rejected (20%/80%) an amendment that would have required the state to match the per-pupil spending average of other states in the region.
- Florida: Defeated a measure (54%/46%) that would have increased class size and given more principals control over how to implement budget reductions.
- Arizona: Defeated (70%/30%) an amendment that would have diverted money from early childhood education programs to the state’s general fund.
- Washington: Rejected (66%/34%) a ballot initiative that would have raised corporate taxes and provided additional monies for education.
- California: Rejected (58%/42%) a proposal to rollback new corporate tax breaks to help fund public education.
For a good wrap up of state ballot initiatives involving education, click here.
Charting College Costs
The ever-escalating cost of college is a topic with which many American families are all too familiar. How much has the cost of college increased? That’s the question The Tuition Over Time Interactive Database attempts to answer. The database, developed by the College Board and highlighted in this week’s Chronicle of Education, charts cost data for the past dozen years for 3,500 private and public two and four year colleges and universities. Aside from the tons of data, users will find the graphs and cost comparisons helpful. One relative bright spot in all this continues to be the affordability of the UNC System. Even though parents know UNC costs have increased — when compared to other large state universities — UNC tuition continues to be a real bargain.
It’s school report card time
The 2010 North Carolina State School Report Cards are now available. Among other things, report cards provide information about student performance, spending class size and teacher quality. While I have my issues with some of the indicators — for example, spending totals including daily operating costs only; figures do not include capital costs or community service programs — report cards are usually a good place to begin the discussion about school performance. So take a look and learn how your school is doing. Data is available for multiple years as well as for both public and charter schools.
Calling all school board members!
On November 12th Civitas Institute will be offering a half day of professional development training. The training takes place at the Holiday Inn Crabtree in Raleigh. Registration is $50.00 and includes lunch. After November 5th registration is $60.00.
Sessions and presenters include: Roles and Responsibilities of School Board Members (Kay McGarry, Member, Board of Education, Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools); The Do’s and Don’ts of North Carolina’s Ethics Law (Jason Kay, Attorney North Carolina Institute for Constitutional Law); and How to Boost Student Achievement: What I’ve Learned From My Time on the School Board (A.J. “Buddy” Collins, Attorney, Member, Board of Education, Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools). Sessions begin at 9a.m. and will conclude at 1p.m. To register, click here. For additional information, call Bob Luebke 919-834-2099.