A voucher program that sent poor minority students to the school of their parents' choice in the District of Columbia has been killed by liberals in Washington. Why do they fear giving parents a choice? The education industrial complex is hell bent on making sure they keep an iron clad monopoly on our students. Reason has a great take on the matter. This cartoon from Red Planet Cartoons recalls my experiences with a global warming hysteric masquerading as public school science teacher. Keep your political agendas out of my children's classroom.
Education
DC Vouchers, RIP
Hypocrisy with a capital “H”
If 40 percent of Congressmen have enrolled their children in private schools at one time in their lives, why is Congress and the Obama administration working so hard to kill the D.C. school choice program and consign poor families to inferior schools? Dan Lips and Lindsay Burke of the Heritage Foundation expose the hypocrisy in School Choice for Me, Not You.
To show you how much the debate on school choice is shifting even the liberal Washington Post is lininig up. Commenting on the Heritage School Choice study, the Post opined:
No doubt there are those who would argue that personal choices should not dictate decisions of policymakers. Fair enough, but where is the objective examination of this program, a rational discussion of the pros and con? Where is the humanity of not wanting to hurt children, who won't be able to continue in their current schools if the scholarship program is eliminated? No one has been able to offer any evidence of the drawbacks of this small local program, while evidence of its benefits has been mounting. It has been disappointing that many of those one would expect to speak up for the educational rights of poor, minority children — and Mayor Adrian M. Fenty (D) tops the list – have been almost mute or, or as has been the case with D.C. Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton (D) downright hostile. Meanwhile, former mayor Anthony A. Williams and former D.C. Council member Kevin P. Chavous continue to champion school choice as the civil rights issue it is.
Unfortunately, thousands of school kids in North Carolina are relegated to the same fate. Law makers have refused to give poor families the same options many of them enjoy: access to good schools. Heck, many legislators can't even bring themselves to expand the number of charter schools, as recommended by the Blue Ribbon Commission on Charter Schools. There are currently about 5,200 students on charter school waiting lists in North Carolina. Maybe the teacher's unions could lend a hand in explaining this to students and their families.
Free Speech and an Exotic Dancer at UNC
The second round of the suppression of free speech at UNC-CH happened last night, April 22nd. You may recall that, last week saw secure borders advocate, former Congressman, Tom Tancredo yelled down by liberal thugs in Chapel Hill while attempting to express his free speech rights before a conservative student group opposed to illegal immigration. Since they couldn't get their way inside of the lecture hall, these stalinist bullies smashed a window and the UNC Police canceled the rest of the event. Civitas' own Bob Luebke wrote about it here and here.
Another former Congressman with strong opinions on illegal immigration came to UNC in the wake of the Tancredo incident and the university administration was quick to point out that there would be no trouble this time from the lunatic left. Well, guess what happened? When former Virginia Congressman Virgil Goode began to speak, the looney leftists played a verbal game of wacka-mole. One would shout out an incoherent screed long enough to be warned by police only to sit down and be replaced by another mouthy Bolshevik. These so called students of higher education also thought it would be cute to bring a noise makers to the event but to no avail.
Final Score: UNC Police 6 arrests, Lefties 0, College Windows broken 0, Free Speech immeasurable.
While the university administration has claimed victory by actually having a conservative speaker complete a speech on campus, questions remain about the administration's handling of the first incident. (Rumor has it that there are now 4 honor code violation investigations underway.)
Incidentally, another controversial speaker at UNC didn't run into protests or disruptions last night. Crystal Gayle Mangum, of Duke Lacrosse Witch hunt fame came to gripe about how poorly she was treated in the media. Fortunately, there were no reports of lacrosse players smashing windows during the event. I guess her speech was just a little more free than Virgil Goode's.
UNC and Virgil Goode: Not a Very Strong Statement.
“The speaker tonight was able to express his views and have a give-and-take with his audience.” That was Holden Thorp’s assessment of former Virginia Congressman, Vigil Goode’s talk last night at the UNC Student Union. Youth for Western Civilization, a UNC campus group, invited Goode to speak one week after demonstrators had forced cancellation of a similar talk on illegal immigration by Tom Tancredo.
I attended last night’s talk and I’d call the chancellor’s remarks a little on the rosy side. The UNC release that quotes Thorpe implies Goode was heckled and jeered only in the beginning of his talk. That’s incorrect. Despite a clear warning by UNC officials that further disruptions would result in removal, heckling marred the entire evening.
In addition to six protestors facing charges of disorderly conduct, protesters set off body alarms, unfurled profane banners and insulted Goode throughout the evening. If UNC had decided to back up their own warning, three times the number of arrests would easily have been made. It also would have allowed those who came to hear Mr. Goode the opportunity to hear him talk and not be assaulted by the endless taunts of young people who appear to be as angry as they are ignorant.
Sadly, it seems an event that records no vandalism and violence equates with success in the minds of UNC administrators. If so, I’d say the bar has been set too low. If protesters continue to do all they can to disrupt a presenter’s remarks it’s hard to use give-and-take as a way to describe the evening. Let’s remember UNC officials have the authority and the responsibility to create an environment that fosters debate and discussion. If the administration is hesitant to use all the tools it possesses to create a climate conducive discussion, is it at all surprising why some question UNC’s commitment to free speech?
Teacher Layoffs: Part II
Senators will be expecting lots of phone calls from teachers in the coming days. The Senate has passed a budget which includes provisions to raise class size by two students. The change saves the state approximately $322 million each year for the next two years and is a big step in balancing the budget. The governor – a former teacher – contends this will result in the loss of over 6,000 jobs. Perdue and the state’s major teacher organization, the North Carolina Association of Educators (NCAE) are doing all they can to fight the layoffs.
Before the volume gets turned up, let’s fill in this picture. For one, I’ve never been sold on smaller classes as a way to spur student performance, but that’s already been discussed. True, laying off teachers appeals to no one, however, the reality is North Carolina is still experiencing a severe teacher shortage. A 2006 Department of Public Instruction report states North Carolina has hired 10,000 new teachers a year for most of the past decade. I always thought those numbers were a little high, but the number is out there. Over the last few years provisions (i.e. removing retirement penalties and streamlining alternative certification) have been included in the budget or approved separately to help make it easier to get more teachers or qualified professionals into the classroom – further evidence of a serious teacher shortage. In addition, Teach for America has 160 teachers working in eastern North Carolina in hard-to-fill positions. While increasing class size will reduce the number of vacancies, the scope of the current shortage — coupled with high turnover in the field – benefits teachers who need jobs and will work to significantly reduce the number of long-term layoffs.
Larger Class Size: Not the end of the world.
Yesterday the State Senate rolled out a budget proposal that includes a provision to raise the average class size by two students for the next two years. The changes would save the state about $322 million for each of the next two years. Not chump change. Governor Perdue’s office said she is “troubled” by the proposal and said the changes would result in the elimination of about 6,200 teaching positions and a reduction in the amount of individual attention children receive in the classroom. The battlelines are being drawn.
While class size is not unimportant, for too long it’s been sold as the panacea for all educational difficulties. It’s not. I think it's one of the five big myths of public education. It’s been debated endlessly. North Carolina has spent millions over the last few years to reduce class size. You couldn’t tell from the test results. Most class size reduction proponents point to the Tennessee STAR study as evidence that reducing class size does improve student learning. While benefits did accrue to disadvantaged students, a closer look reveals methodological shortcomings impacted test results.
Teachers unions are big proponents of the class size argument – and for obvious reason. However, the research suggests we’d be far better off to focus resources on teacher quality rather than simply bringing in more teachers to teach smaller classes. Yes, reducing class size may help in some cases. Still it's wrong in theory and practice to think such a solution would have the same results in all districts. Blindly forcing school districts to hire more and more teachers to meet class size requirements is not without consequence. Oftentimes, teachers must be hired who don’t have the proper background or training. A 2002 study by the Public Policy Institute of California suggested that smaller class requirements in that state actually worked against the best interest of California students since it forced many school districts to hire unqualified teachers.
This noise merely tells us the teachers' unions have successfully used the class size issue to derail debate from a needed focus on improving teacher quality. Next time you’re in a discussion with an advocate of smaller class sizes ask two questions: 1) If class size is so important why do other countries with significantly larger average classrooms consistently outscore the United States where smaller class sizes are the norm?; and 2) Would you rather have your child taught by a good teacher in a large class or an average teacher in a small class?
The University thanks you for your gift — and for paying your gift tax.
From the stranger than fiction file, The Chronicle of Higher Education (Subscription Required) reports that more and more colleges are taxing donations to help pay for cash-strapped fund-raising operations.
A tax on a gift? Seems like the last thing development officials would want to inform a donor — some of whom colleges have spent years wooing – is that 3 to 5 percent of your donation will be siphoned off to help retain development staff. And, oh yeah, it’s in an office that can no longer gather enough support to maintain the size of its staff. University officials are hopeful they can “educate” potential donors about the need for greater flexibility in the current economic climate.
A couple of questions emerge from this scenario. First, while I’m not in favor of anyone losing their job, if the development office can’t raise enough funds to justify the additional staff, why should donor funds be used to retain staff who – based on results — haven’t been able to justify their existence? Second, if the “economic slowdown” is used to justify the measures, can we expect colleges will do away with the fees once the economy improves? Yeah, right.
Gov. Say — And Gov. Do
For only being in office two month’s Governor Perdue is already perfecting the art of saying one thing and doing another. At her remarks at last week’s North Carolina Association of Educator’s convention in Raleigh, Perdue used the time to reiterate her promise to fight for teacher jobs and protect public education from state budget cuts.
Interestingly, the Governor’s own numbers show the FY2008-09 education budget was cut $146 million in recent months to deal with revenue shortfalls. In addition, the Governor’s FY2009-10 state budget requests a net reduction of $ 297 million in state funds for public education (See: The North Carolina State Budget: Summary of Recommendations, 2009-2011, page 5). No doubt, the Governor’s plan to use over $1 billion in federal stimulus funds to backfill the state education cuts will soften the impact – and the criticism. Still the governor's promise, doesn't quite square with reality.
No, I'm not arguing for more education funding — only honesty. Let’s hope we see some of that in the future – as well as a plan for what the state will do to replace federal stimulus funds. It may come in handy.
Free Community College for Convicts
In a recently introduced bill, Representatives Larry Womble (D-Forsyth), Earline Parmon (D-Forsyth) and Pricey Harrison (D-Guilford) propose to give free tuition to recently released convicts.
While the merits of giving people that have committed crimes against society a leg up after they complete their obligations to the state can be debated at length, there remains one huge question.
Will there be any room at Mayberry Tech for ex-offenders after North Carolina's Community Colleges allow illegal aliens to go to school at reduced, instate tuition rates? How will these two groups get along in class? The very jobs that ex-offenders hope to get with their new found education will likely go to illegal aliens (whose criminal background outside of the United States is undeterminable) at a cheaper price.
We have a choice to make. Give convicts a chance at a new life on this side of the bars or give their chance to someone that is not supposed to be here in the first place.
Students Want Guns On Campus
Students at NC State University last month held a clever little protest where they wore empty holsters on campus to call attention to the vulnerability of so called "gun free" campuses. After the massacre at Virginia Tech, students want to know why they can not lawfully defend themselves against an armed attacker. The universities have, in effect, become a soft target for the killer who only wants to end as many lives as possible before taking his own or going down in a hail of police bullets.
How different would Blacksburg been if students were armed? We don't have to guess what would have happened because it did happen. Five years before and only 130 miles from the Virginia Tech massacre a killer was stopped in his tracks by armed students that had retrieved guns from their cars. The Appalachian school of Law in Grundy, Virginia (Bev Perdue's hometown) was the scene of an on campus shooting that was stopped by armed students. (Needless to say, the media wasn't quick to tell the story.)
But, if you are a student that would like to see legally carried guns on campus, you might want to keep that proposal to your self. A student in Connecticut laid out his position during a class project in his communications class as was promptly reported to the university administration as a violence risk and questioned by campus police. UNCW's professor Mike Adams has the details.
We used to have a concept in this country known as criminal intent that tended to keep honest people from being charged with gothcha style justice. What ever happened to that idea? Hang in there Holster Boys! Common sense may appear on your campus one day.