Here is a Tweet from State Senator Angela Bryant (D-Halifax)
Elections
Angela Bryant Compares Legislation to Require Drug Tests and Photo ID to Pressure Cooker Bombs
Voter Photo ID Bill on House Calendar Today
The 4th edition of House Bill 589 – Voter Information Verification Act (VIVA) is on the House Calendar today. It is listed under “Public Bills – Second and Third Readings.”
We can all hope that this won’t be the final bill – as it stands now, it is weak, confusing and creates a new bureaucracy within the State Board of Elections. It also builds on the Democrats fondness for creating new classes of voters.
Once the bill is passed out of the House, it will then go to the Senate. There, the Senate can make changes that will fortify this Bill so it will serve the people of North Carolina in way they deserve without kowtowing to the liberal left. For some reason the leadership in the House believes they had to water down the bill they presented in 2011 in order to gain pre-clearance from the U.S. Justice Department.
The leadership in the House evidently aren’t paying attention to states like South Carolina who implemented a stronger voter photo ID law earlier this year. Their legislation was pre-cleared by a three judge panel in Washington D.C. in 2012 but the court delayed the implementation of the law until after the November General Election. And speaking of South Carolina, this video is great – Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-SC) takes on the charges of racism in a hearing on the constitutionality of voter ID laws.
http://youtu.be/4JvvT9Dl_Eo
Georgia and North Carolina Voter ID Legislation Comparison #1
As promised I will begin to compare the Georgia voter ID law to the one proposed by the North Carolina State House in House Bill 589 Voter Identification Verification Act (VIVA).
Here are the acceptable forms of photo IDs that are found in North Carolina HB 589 . Take note all of the forms of ID for North Carolina can be up to 10 years out of date – that means none of the ID’s need be valid.
(1) An identification card that bears either a date of expiration or a date of issuance and that is not more than 10 years beyond the date of expiration or issuance, whichever is later, issued by a branch, department, agency, or 1 entity of the United States, this State, or any other state, such as any of the following:
- A North Carolina drivers license issued under Article 2 of Chapter 20 4 of the General Statutes, including a learner’s permit or a provisional license.
- A special identification card for nonoperators issued under G.S. 20-37.7.
- A United States passport.
- An employee identification card.
- A United States military identification card.
- An identification card issued by The University of North Carolina or its constituent institutions.
- An identification card issued by a North Carolina community college.
- An identification card issued to a fireman, EMS, hospital employee, or law enforcement officer.
- An identification card issued by a unit of local government, public authority, or special district, all as defined in G.S. 159-7.
- An identification card issued for a government program of public assistance.
(2) A Veterans Identification Card issued by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs for use at Veterans Administration medical facilities.
(3) An identification card that bears a date of expiration and was not expired on the day the voter reached the age of 70 issued by a branch, department, agency, or entity of the United States, this State, or any other state.
(4) A tribal enrollment card issued by a federally recognized tribe that bears either a date of expiration or a date of issuance and that is not more than 10 years beyond the date of expiration or issuance, whichever is later.”
And, now for Georgia’s acceptable ID’s:
1) A Georgia Drivers License even if it is expired
2) Any valid state or federal government issued photo ID, including a free Voter ID Card issued by the voter’s county registrar or Georgia Department of Driver Services;
3) Valid U.S. passport;
4) Valid employee photo ID from any branch, department, agency, or entity of the U.S. Government, Georgia, or any county, municipality, board, authority, or other entity of this state;
5) Valid U.S. military photo ID; or
6) Valid tribal photo ID.
State Board of Elections Vastly Over Stated the Numbers of Voters Without an ID in Previous Reports
So, why haven’t we heard much about the latest SBOE analysis on people who may not have a valid form of ID? That’s right, this month the SBOE has done another comparison of the statewide voter registration database and the NC Division of Motor Vehicles database.
This is at least the third time the SBE has performed such a comparison since the Republicans gained the majority in 2010. Barely a month after the election, Bob Hall of Democracy NC emailed SBOE Director Gary Bartlett with the idea of running a comparison of the records. (He got the idea from an AP article of South Carolina doing something similar). Here is the first email from Hall to Bartlett on the subject, which ultimately results in more than 200 additional emails between Hall and SBOE staff. Most of the subsequent emails are planning and “perfecting” the methodology and results for the first-ever comparison of North Carolina voter registration to DMV numbers.
Here is the last email, dated March 15, 2011, in the long string of emails that included recipients such as Representative Deborah Ross (D-Wake) and Mark Binker (at the time, a reporter for the Greensboro News and Record, and now a reporter for WRAL). There were also directions on what to include and not include in the data comparison and press releases that charged that almost 1 million registered voters would be disenfranchised if the new Republican majority were to pass voter photo ID.
The second comparison was conducted in January 2013 and in March 2013, when the SBOE added a supplemental report. Unfortunately, Civitas doesn’t have any emails that relate to second set of comparisons, but the results showed that more than 600,000 voters “may” not have valid ID and would thus be disenfranchised. We must keep in mind that when the Left refer to these results, they just go ahead and say these people don’t have ID, not that they don’t match a DMV list. The first two reports were paraded to the media by Bob Hall of Democracy NC and backed up by the SBOE, who validated his claims.
In the introduction of the latest analysis (April 2013 Report), Gary Bartlett explains that the January and March 2013 reports were never “intended to be a “comprehensive study on the number of voters who may not have any ID, regardless of source”. He also informs us that the only reason they prepared the January analysis was as a “result of various legislative and media inquiries”.
The newest update came as a result of recent requests from legislative leaders and staff.
And wow — is it an update! This time the number of voters who the SBOE could not identify as a NCDMV match was 318,643 and of those only 255,160 were active voters. And we should also note that of the 318,643 total active voters without a matching DL number, only 138,425 voted in the November 2012 General Election.
We know why we haven’t seen or heard much of this new voter analysis in the mainstream media — it doesn’t promote their point of view and they haven’t had the liberal-left promoting it. We also must conclude that the leadership in the Legislature didn’t think it was important enough to hold a press conference.
But here is a new question: Why does the Republican leadership keep going to the SBOE for validation? The SBOE has worked against them since January 2011. Along with the pushback on voter photo ID, the SBOE worked alongside Bob Hall and Democracy NC to attack the majority over HAVA funds. So, why is it so important for this SBOE to issue a new report that shows less people may be affected by a voter photo ID bill? And, let’s face it, even this report probably vastly exaggerates the number of voters who may need to receive a free voter ID.
As always, I contend that North Carolina need only look as far as the State of Georgia to find the answers to their voter photo ID questions. Brian Kemp, Georgia’s Secretary of State, testified just a few short weeks ago to the North Carolina House Elections Committee that Georgia has issued less than 30,000 free ID’s and their law has been in effect since 2006! There are a lot of things we should have learned and copied from Georgia’s voter ID bill and tomorrow we will begin to look at them on this blog. See you then.
Press Conference on the 2013 Voter Photo ID Bill
North Carolina’s Voter Photo ID legislation will be a phase in style bill and not completely effective until 2016. Soft launches in 2014 election.
The bill will be filed today (April 4, 2013)
Government issued ID’s with either an issue or expiration date will be accepted
Will accept out-of-state drivers licenses!
Extensive outreach program
ID’s can be expired (within a time period)
Special provisions include:
Voter’s over 70 – expired ID ok – no time limit
People that meet a federal definition of a person with a disability won’t be required to provide an ID
Included in the bill will be provisions to make the absentee process more secure – this will take effect “immediately”
We will update this information when the bill is filed today.
An End to Taxpayer-Funded Political Campaigns in NC?
No sensible person would support a law compelling citizens into forced labor for a political campaign – including campaigns of candidates with whom they disagree.
So why does North Carolina compel citizens to fork over their tax money to political campaigns, without even allowing them to choose which candidates their tax dollars support? After all, our tax dollars are taken from our labor, so in essence we are forced to labor to help fund political campaigns.
That is the nature of North Carolina’s “public campaign financing” program, which has been in effect for judicial races and Council of State races.
Thankfully, SB 541, sponsored by Sen. Bill Cook (R-Beaufort) and Sen. Ronald Rabin (R-Harnett), would repeal those programs completely. Passing this bill would be a major step toward restoring our freedom of speech and protect us from – in the words of Thomas Jefferson – the “sinful and tyrannical” practice of being compelled to support political speech we “disbelieve and abhor”.
I have been writing on this topic for years, for instance here, and here – and as many as 83% of likely NC voters oppose the notion of taxpayer funds being used to finance political campaigns.
Another Good Election Reform Bill – Eliminate Straight Party Voting HB 185
As I promised yesterday, I would do my best to present some “good” bills offered by the 2013 Legislature and HB 185, The Ballot Reform Act of 2013 meets the requirements of a good election reform bill.
HB 185 would eliminate straight party voting and change the way parties are placed on General Election Ballots. The Primary Sponsors of the bill are Representatives Bert Jones (R-Rockingham), Susan Martin (R-Wilson), Debra Conrad (R-Forsyth) and Bob Steinburg (R-Chowan).
If this bill is enacted, official ballots in North Carolina would no longer contain any place that allows a voter to vote for the candidates of a party for more than one office with only one mark of the ballot. At this time only 15 states employ some form of straight party voting. At present, North Carolina provides for a straight party choice, but as is the case with most North Carolina election law, there is an exception to this rule. In North Carolina, a straight party vote does not include a vote for the President and Vice President of the United States, thus requiring voters to make separate selections for the President and Vice President and the straight party option. Even the very liberal Brennan Center for Justice called our straight party option a “ballot flaw” in 2008 and said it was “very confusing.” In North Carolina the Democratically controlled legislature instituted the this option when it became obvious that the state’s voters were voting for Republican presidential candidates.
This bill also changes the way candidates are placed on a ballot. HB 185 would have candidates of the same political party as the Governor take the top spot in all contests on the ballot instead of the Democratic candidate. They would be followed by the the candidates of the other parties (alphabetical order by party) and then the unaffiliated candidates.
In North Carolina, Democrats have always been placed first in the list of candidates in a contest on a General Election Ballot. Study after study has found that the first position in a contest is most advantageous. Click here to see a list of summaries of Ballot Placement Journal Articles. In the past, the Democrats in the legislature could point to the alphabet and call it luck that D came before L and R in the alphabet. But, they have been the majority in the legislature since 1898 and they took advantage of their majority and wrote and passed election laws that benefited their party. It would be refreshing to see future changes in election law benefit the voters of North Carolina and not just one political party.
Restore Partisan Judicial Elections – A Good Bill
We know you read Civitas’ “Bad Bills of the Week,” so I thought it would be nice to look at a few good bills introduced by the House and Senate for a change.
Today’s good bill is: HB 65 / “SB39 – Restore Partisan Judicial Elections”. The bill’s primary sponsors are Representatives Frank Iler (R-Brunswick), Rayne Brown (R-Davidson), Dennis Riddell (R-Alamance), Bert Jones (R-Rockingham), Senators Jerry Tillman (R-Randolph) and Thom Goolsby (R-New Hanover).
While the bill makes some changes to residency requirements for judicial candidates, the focus is to put the party designation back on the ballot for judicial candidates.
You may remember that in 2002 the Democratic legislature passed legislation that removed party affiliation from judicial candidates on all ballots in North Carolina. This is a key piece of information that helps voters make their decisions when voting for judges. The 2002 legislation hurt voter participation, in the 2010 General Election, there were 2,700,383 total votes cast, only 2,012,869 voters voted in the first judicial race on the ballot – a 25 percent drop.
Voter Fraud (and a lot of it) Does Exist
The Pasquotank County Board of Elections will hold hearings to determine whether 60 voters falsely claimed 1704 Weeksville Rd (an Elizabeth City State University address) as their residence address. The hearings will be held on April 18 and 19, 2013. Four voters were challenged before the certification of the November 2012 election, all four challenges were upheld.
In North Carolina, starting in 2008, voters who miss the deadline to register to vote can register and vote at the same time during the 17 days of one-stop voting. A provision of this law was to require all SDR voters to show an “ID” before voting. The types of ID accepted by the Board of Elections includes everything from a North Carolina Driver License to a utility bill. Shortly after the law was enacted, the State Board of Elections decided that the long list of accepted documentation for ID during SDR was not enough for college students, and made provisions for a College or University to provide a list of student names with addresses (for those students who live on campus) to the local Board of Elections. Then, if a student registers and votes during one-stop, the BOE needs only to find their name on the list and that is proof enough of their residence address.
In Pasquotank County, after the election, the Pasquotank Republican Party checked the list provided to the BOE from Elizabeth City State University against the list of voters who voted in the November Election. Any individual who stated that the college address was their residence address when they voted and were not on the college list of accepted and enrolled students were investigated by the Pasquotank GOP. Before certification of the election results, the GOP challenged four voters who were not on the official college list, but used the college address as their residence address.
The three videos (below) are of the hearings that took place on November 16, 2012. Only two of the four challenged voters showed up to defend themselves at the hearing. Ultimately all four challenges were sustained. Three of the four voters had their ballots “pulled” and they were not counted in the official results. All four voters voted absentee, one woman voted absentee by mail. Pete Gilbert, the challenger, noted that the voter who voted by mail could very well be innocent, in that her signature on her registration did not look like her signature on her absentee ballot envelope and her first name was misspelled on the absentee request form – but since she did not appear they could not be sure.
The other challenged voter who did not appear before the Board, was a former student at Elizabeth City State University and now lived in Virginia and was employed by the Department of Defense and was a Business Instructor at Virginia College in Richmond.
The challenged voter who appears on videos #1 and #2 is a former student and now works for the University as Assistant Director of Admissions and Recruitment. He claimed he did not know he had to live where he said he lived. And, even though there was evidence that he lived in Gates County, he said he had lived at an address in Pasquotank for two months. This voter seemed to be confused as to where he lived even at this hearing. He testified his address was 101 Queensland and later in the hearing said it was 101 Cardinal Ct. In the end, a portion of his ballot was counted; his voter record was updated to the new address. To see the discussion about his address and eligibility to vote see video #2 at the 2:20 – 9:50.
The videos are long, and some would even say they were boring, you can even hear a man snoring in video #3 at the 41:00 – 41:10 mark. But, there is good information in these videos. They are evidence that North Carolina election laws need to be rewritten.
I understand that all four of the cases heard in the November hearing have been turned over to the District Attorney. I know that this kind of voter fraud isn’t happening only at Elizabeth City State University. We look forward to these investigations and challenges extending to other colleges and universities in North Carolina.
SB 155: Not-So-Independent Redistricting Commission
This week’s Bad Bill of the Week focuses on legislation intended to create an “independent redistricting commission.” While a supposedly independent commission assigned to handle redistricting sounds appealing, political reality and experience tell us the commission would end up being anything but independent.
SB 155 (as do all “independent” redistricting bills) appears to pass off our elected officials redistricting responsibilities to appointees but, ultimately, the appointees are appointed by the politicians we elect to be in charge of the process. No amount of restrictions placed on who can and who cannot be appointed to the commission, and no matter how convoluted the appointment process, we know that in the end partisans will make the final decisions on the maps. We also know the system can be scammed. All we need to do is look to Arizona and California and their “independent” redistricting committees to see that these committees aren’t what their proponents claim they are, but ultimately partisan cover for politicians.
Read the whole summary here.