House Republicans were able to force Democrats to go along with a motion to reconsider the vote by which the GOP failed to override the Governor’s veto of HB2. The bill would allow people in North Carolina to opt out of the health insurance mandate in the national Healthcare Act. It would also require the state Attorney General to join the national lawsuit against the federal law. Many of the Democratic representatives were missing after a long recess so Republican majority leader Paul Stam made a motion to suspend the rules so the vote on the override could be reconsidered, but at a later date. Democratic leader Joe Hackney had no choice but to go along in order to avoid an immediate vote with so many of his people missing. The majority would need 3/5 of those present and voting to override a veto.
Healthcare
Obamacare repeal resurrected
Tea Party groups lobby for override of Perdue’s veto of Obamacare repeal
Over a hundred members of Tea Party groups from across the state walked the halls of the General Assembly today trying to persuade Democratic lawmakers to override the Governor’s veto of HB2. The bill would have opted out of the insurance mandate in the National Healthcase Act and joined the national lawsuit against Obamacare. Below is an excerpt of a conversation Republican House Speaker Thom Tillis had with Tea Party members outside his office.
One lady said they talked to the Democrats who voted for the repeal and were told those lawmakers wouldn’t commit to voting in favor of an override. While the veto is on the House calendar Republican leader Paul Stam told the crowd there was no guarantee there would actually be a vote today.
Veto Override Vote Expected Wednesday for H2, Protect Health Care Freedom Act
On Wednesday, Republicans will attempt to override Governor Perdue’s veto rejecting the Protect Health Care Freedom Act (H2), which would challenge the individual mandate provision of ObamaCare.
Governor Perdue vetoed the bill over the weekend stating it violated the U.S. Constitution. The veto came somewhat of a surprise as she had said in the past that she would not veto the bill. However, the Governor seemed to change her tune after speaking with President Obama and other U.S. Democratic leaders.
A three-fifths majority vote is need in both the House and Senate to override the veto. House Republicans may need a few Democrats to join them in order to meet the minimum requirement. If the override succeeds, the bill will become law.
Governor vetoes bill that would opt out of Obamacare
Governor Perdue chose a weekend to veto HB2, the Protect Healthcare Freedom Act passed by the General Assembly. In a press release she listed reasons for the veto, the most important she said was
“The attorney general and solicitor general have talked to me and the leadership of the General Assembly and explained clearly that there are some unintended consequences of House Bill 2 that dramatically affect our medicaid program, potentially hurting the childrens’ health insurance program, attacking our process of requiring uninsured motorists to have insurance, attacking college students for having insurance.”
State Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger expressed surprise at the veto of a bill he said Perdue said “was not worth the battle.” The Republican leader released a statement saying
“There’s no doubt this veto is a political move designed to protect the interests of Barack Obama, Nancy Pelosi and Washington Democrats. But it hurts North Carolinians by forcing them to follow an unconstitutional law. The people of North Carolina expect their leaders to change the course of state government, not score political points or protect their political patrons.”
GOP leadership would have to convince a few Democrats to join them in order to override a veto. A Florida judge has given the Obama Administration a week to appeal his ruling Obamacare is unconstitutional. If the administration doesn’t file the appeal on time the judge says states can consider the federal law invalid.
Bill would allow a murder charge for the death of an unborn child
Republican Representative Dale Folwell introduced HB215 that would create a penalty of life in prison without parole for the murder of an unborn child. The bill also lists lower class felonies for such offenses as assault and manslaughter. It could not be applied to abortions. Folwell had relatives of murdered unborns speak at a press conference. Below is a link to testimony from Effie Steele of Durham.
The proposal has been introduced in previous sessions of the General Assembly but never received a hearing. Folwell said he knew it would get at least 100 votes on the floor if the bill was only heard. He said with Republicans in charge he was confident the bill would go forward.
Tort Reform Moves to NC Senate Floor
Senate Judiciary I Committee considered S33, the Medical Liability Reforms Act today. The latest version would provide limited protection from liability to those required under federal law to provide emergency medical care, authorize the bifurcation of trials on issues of liability and damages, and authorize periodic payments for future economic damages in lieu of a lump-sum payment.
It would also limit noneconomic damages in medical malpractice actions to $500,000 per plaintiff for judgment entered against all defendants. In addition, judgment entered against any particular defendant for noneconomic damages shall not exceed $500,000 for claims brought by all parties arising from the same cause of action.
Noneconomic damages include damages covering pain, suffering, emotional distress, physical impairment, disfigurement, and any other nonpecuniary compensatory damages. It does not include punitive damages.
After a brief discussion and a failed amendment offered by Senator Nesbitt, the bill was passed on a motion offered by Senator Apodaca. According to Senator Brunstetter’s office, it will be reported out of Judiciary I later this afternoon and will be debated on the Senate floor later this week.
New Poll Further Demonstrates NC’s Unrest with Obamacare
Elon University Poll recently released its latest polling data on major North Carolina issues, including healthcare. Elon’s poll found 41 percent oppose the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, while 39 percent support it.
In the same poll, Elon concluded that less than 25 percent said they would like the entire law repealed, while 18 percent want portions of it thrown out and 14 percent said they like the law as is. That doesn’t appear to be a lot of support for an extremely overbearing and intrusive government-run healthcare program, but these numbers don’t demonstrate overwhelmingly opposition to the idea either. What does the remaining 43 percent think – quite a substantial percentage to not mention their thoughts?
Civitas’ January 2011 poll showed that 50 percent of voters have an unfavorable opinion of the new health care law given while 41 percent had a generally favorable opinion; 6 percent said they have no opinion.
However, while Elon’s poll found only 41 percent opposing Obamacare, 44 percent support the General Assembly’s attempt to pass a law to protect patients’ rights and challenge Obamacare. Only 33 percent oppose the challenge, even though 39 percent apparently favor Obamacare.
In the Civitas poll, 63 percent of voters agreed with the General Assembly’s challenge. Only 25 percent said a law should not be passed, and 11 percent said they didn’t know.
Furthermore, a strong 76 percent of those surveyed in the Elon poll oppose the “individual mandate,” which would require people to purchase health insurance or pay a penalty. Without this provision in the bill, Obamacare loses much of its steam.
No doubt the Elon poll demonstrates that people are unsatisfied with the current health system but also reveals that a lot of confusion about what a world under Obamacare would look like remains and what its consequences would be for Americans.
No matter who conducts the polling, however, the majority of North Carolinians, through their support for the constitutional challenge and their opposition to an individual mandate, remain opposed to further government intrusion into their private lives.
State budget writers lose option as provisions of Obamacare take effect
While a Florida judge says the National Affordable Healthcare Act is unconstitutional North Caroline is still bound by provisions of the bill that have already taken effect. One is state budget writers can no longer alter eligibility for Medicaid to try to save money. It’s not that any of those working on the state budget would want to do that, but it is no longer an option for them. The debate is still going over whether that ruling amounted to an injunction halting implementation of provisions of the federal law. But even the state of Florida continues to implement parts of the bill without challenging them.
In the meantime, The state Senate gave tentative approval to SB32 which would require hospitals to pay an “assessment” into a pool that would be used to reimburse them for losses due to Medicaid expenses. The first year the assessments would generate nearly $216 million in revenue. Some of that would be used in the Medicaid program to pull down nearly $600 million in federal Medicaid funds. A fiscal note with the bill shows all of the private and non-private hospitals in the state would get back a combined $370 million over what they paid in assessments.
Governor Perdue releases budget (updated with GOP reaction)
Governor Perdue released her budget this morning. Here is a link to the summary handed out at press conference. Republicans are already rejecting it. Republican Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger offered his take on it.
Gov. Beverly Perdue is breaking her promise to North Carolina’s taxpayers by proposing more than $1 billion in new taxes in the next two years.
“Instead of making tough choices to tighten the state’s belt, Gov. Perdue is balancing the budget on the backs of North Carolina taxpayers and local governments. She is breaking her promise to end the taxes she raised, she is underfunding our retirement system and she is saddling local governments with hundreds of millions in additional expenses. This is not how to get North Carolina back on track.”
Proposed legislation would spend millions on housing for the disabled
Some House Democrats introduced HB71 to approriate $10 million to the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency. The money would go into the Housing Trust Fund to create more housing options for the disabled. Democrats Jennifer Weiss and Jean Farmer-Butterfield are primary sponsors.