Healthcare
The “Progressive” Vision for US Healthcare
Expanding SCHIP
The Democratically dominated N.C. General Assembly is keen to expand the SCHIP part of Medicaid (families with children).
A good compromise may be found here.
Spinning Mental Health Parity
Here’s a great example of how the left spins an issue:
"The citizen lobbyists also encouraged lawmakers to end discrimination against people with mental illness and addictions by passing parity legislation."
Now, if you actually look at this policy, its only discriminatory in the most trivial sense — i.e. the sense that any product or service is discriminatory. That is, Burger King doesn’t sell steaks. AutoZone doesn’t sell groceries. Davey Tree does give massages. The law some N.C. legislators and liberals want discriminates against many more people. That is, in order for you to buy health insurance in N.C. you are forced to buy a policy with mental health coverage. And the monopoly insurance interests are forced to provide it. In a time when this same group of leftish activists are (justifiably) shedding crocodile tears about the uninsured and access to healthcare, they are simultaneously driving up premiums for everyone. Such twisted logic is couched in language like "discrimination" because there is a concerted effort to make healthcare a "civil rights issue." Down is up. Up is down. Left advocates will use language games and obfuscation to further their agenda. N.C. Policy Watch is clearly singing from the liberal hymnal on such matters. But don’t be fooled: all of this is a means to destroy healthcare markets and usher in an age of socialized medicine.
Progressives Want Health Insurance Even MORE Unaffordable
Rob Schofield is dazzled by the idea of "mental health parity" — a regulation that means IF you buy health insurance at all, you are forced also to buy health insurance that covers mental illness (Read: expensive). Schofield’s also disappointed that it may be thwarted in the legislature. We can only pray. But in timeless lefty fashion, Schofield blames the insurance industry. The truth is, BC/BS enjoys a virtual monopoly position here in NC for the individual and small group markets. They probably will benefit from the legislation unless this is the one healthcare mandate that finally drives the "death spiral" — i.e. when people simply go uninsured because the mandates have driven up the price too much. (Then unhealthy people stay in the pool, driving up costs further, encourage yet more people to forego insurance.) This is the kind of stuff do-gooders-by-non-voluntary-proxy like. They don’t care that their utopian health insurance is unaffordable. (Schofield claims that mental health parity will decrease hospitalizations. Maybe. But I doubt it’ll make up for the 5-10 percent increase in premiums.)
Hey Progressives: I don’t want to buy mental illness insurance. Can’t you respect my preferences?
(I’ve argued elsewhere that mental health parity is insane.)
Markets Improve Healthcare Access
A noteworthy article by the high-priestess of consumer-driven healthcare. (Government is already way too involved in healthcare. This is how the market is responding despite the problems the state has created.)
SCHIP Reform – a Compendium
Here is a great publication (pdf) that compiles thoughts on the desperate need for SCHIP reform. As N.C. confronts the future of healthcare for families, serious thought should be given to the dangerous direction we’re currently headed in. This paper is a great place to start on the issue, if you’re a concerned citizen or legislator.
The playbook for Universal Coverage
During debate on the passage of the High Risk Pool (H 265), the authors of the bill continuously referred to the 1.4 million North Carolinians who are uninsured, when the bill itself, will do very little to make a dent in that number.
The High Risk Pool is designed more for the uninsurable. There’s a big difference between those two words.
Well, it turns out that supporters of universal coverage (I’m using the generic term here because they haven’t figured out whether they like government must-carry laws or single payer yet), see the High Risk Pool as the first step in a delineated march to universal care.
Rep. Verla Insko (D-Orange) laid out the plan at a press conference on Wednesday trumpeting the passage of the High Risk Pool. According to her, the steps towards universal coverage are:
1. High Risk Pool – done
2. Cover all children – Introduced (H 1476)
3. Cover their parents
4. Cover everyone else
The magic number she says is 10%. If they can incrementally get the number of uninsured down to under 10% through government programs, they can "easily" cover the rest either through a Mitt-care style system or some other universal coverage scheme.
Notice there’s not one word said about eliminating coverage mandates and letting individuals shop for the plan that best fits their needs. Who needs that silliness when government can just either tell people to buy it themselves or pay for it for them?
That’s their playbook. Get ready.
High Risk Pools – A Pragmatic View
Adam Searing is happy about high-risk pools in N.C. They aren’t a bad idea, but only relative to the horrible status quo left us by N.C. liberals, historically. Here, Searing picks on conservatives for their support on the issue:
It was highly amusing to see ideologically-driven Republicans who can’t seem to stop yelling from the rooftops how important it is to cut government services solemnly intoning into their microphones how critical it was for NC taxpayers to fund health insurance coverage for people who couldn’t afford it. Republican Curtis Blackwood talked about how important it was to fund health insurance for small businesses. Republic Pat McElraft tried to make the point that if the state funds education – a critical service – than it should certainly fund health care coverage for those who can’t afford it.
The reason that Rs welcome high-risk pools is to, well, help save people money — both people with such conditions and people without them. A little investigation would result in an understanding that to create a high-risk pool helps pull high-risk patients out of the insurance market for relatively healthy folks, thereby saving the rest of us money. Sure, it’s a pragmatic compromise involving wealth-transfers, but in this healthcare climate, it could be a necessary one. (Particularly since the "uninsurables" will just take their expensive needs to Medicaid–expanding those "government services". Or worse, N.C. could be looking for "guaranteed issue" — which would be crippling)
Now, the question is: how to fund it? If the rest of us are going to be expected to pay for high-risk patients out of our already skyrocketing premiums, then the very existence of the pool does little good on that score. But isn’t part of the debate about health insurance how to bring down those premiums? Is that the Holy Grail? The conservatives would like to see it funded out of the general fund. Searing writes as if the profit-thirsty insurance companies are behind the alternative funding proposal offered by the conservatives. Actually, the conservatives are looking out for premiums of N.C. citizens (the Progressives are not).
Mental Health Parity is Insane
The same people (legitimately) whining about insurance premiums are whining for the passage of mental health parity — an insurance mandate that could drive up prices by as much as a percent (and those percents add up). That means, even if you don’t want it, you have to pay for it. You have to pay extra so that Prozac can be dispensed like candy, and therapy can be doled out, etc etc — so they’ll not have to pay for it out of pocket. I don’t want to downplay the problem of depression and mental illness in America, but this is just more social engineering that encourages people to gorge unnecessarily on healthcare goods and services — which (duh) makes it more expensive for everyone.
Also, higher premiums due to mandates like mental health parity mean employers may find it impossible to offer health insurance at work, and drop it. As this brief analysis from the NCPA suggests:
"According to a Blue Cross Blue Shield estimate, for every 1 percent increase in the cost of health insurance premiums due to mandated benefits, 3 percent of small employers are forced to drop health coverage for their employees. Thus if parity legislation increases the cost of premiums by about 10 percent, 30 percent of small employers would no longer offer coverage to their employees. A Congressional Budget Office study estimates that for every 1 percent increase in premiums, 200,000 Americans lose their insurance. This implies that a nationwide parity law would cause 2 million additional people to be uninsured."
One more step closer to socialized medicine. Many more uninsured and on Medicaid. It must be stopped.
Cannon: Medicaid
Cannon (paraphrasing): Conservatives don’t understand that they have the better side of the argument:
-Tax burden of Medicaid: $1100 per capita.
-Covers 4 people for the price of 10 (6 people lose their health insurance).
-Increases price of private care (prescriptions by 13 percent!)
-Traps families in low-wage jobs.
-Covers more than just the poor. Creates artificial poverty among those who could afford it.
-Lowers the quality care of care.
-Makes states grovel to DC for (matching funds).
Costs of Medicaid are growing. The trendline shows that the system is gobbling up more and more people. Why does Medicaid grow? In your state, you can get Big Government at 1/3 the price! Consider the following:
-NC pays 1/3, DC pays 2/3.
-Incentive to expand, never an incentive to cut.
It’s the best hope for socialize medicine (since more and more are people entering every day).
How does Medicaid trap NC families in low wage jobs? There is no financial incentive to get higher wage job after a certain point (due to total gov’t benefits). That is, the more you earn, the fewer overall benefits you recieve — which creates incentives to subsist (much like Welfare did prior to 1996). When the worker improves her condition with a better job, the effective tax rate on her earnings becomes 100 percent. In other words, she starts losing out by doing better. Medicaid thus keeps people in poverty, keeping them in the low-wage trap. Expanding medicaid would result in more of the same trap, only deeper. Incentives matter.
Expand Medicaid, then? Bad Idea. Instead: Make it only for the truly needy and cut it back. It’s analogous to Welfare Reform, which was a HUGE success. The same could be true for Medicaid.
If you want to make it more affordable, reduce mandates! (I, for example, don’t need to buy coverage for alcoholism, in vitro fertilization etc. etc. But I’m forced to pay for it in NC.) That makes our state among the most regulated states in the US. But we can change that.