It’s often said that most illegal immigrants are decent, hardworking folks who only want to come to America to work. But what happens when they have to break the law in order to obtain employment? During a recent raid at Smithfield Foods in Tar Heel, North Carolina, investigators found that 86 percent of workers arrested for immigration violations had also stolen identities from American citizens. Likewise, during a raid conducted last month at a Fresh Del Monte plant in Portland, Oregon, authorities found that 78 percent of illegal alien workers were using a stolen Social Security number. But don’t expect the federal government to do anything about this problem anytime soon. Money collected from mismatched names and Social Security numbers goes into an Earnings Suspense File (ESF) administered by the Social Security Administration. Currently the fund contains more than $420 billion in uncollected earnings.
Immigration
Illegal Immigrants and Identity Theft
What We Don’t Know
With Hugo Chavez, president of Venezuela, wrapping up his “Terror 2007” tour of countries (Russia, Belarus and Iran) interested in joining his “global anti-American alliance,” it is worth remembering that Venezuela has already been working with Iran for some time now to smuggle terrorists into the United States. According to a 2006 report by the House Committee on Homeland Security:
“U.S. military and intelligence officials believe that Venezuela is emerging as a potential hub of terrorism in the Western Hemisphere.”
“The Venezuelan government is issuing identity documents that could subsequently be used to obtain a U.S. visa and enter the country. Continues the report: There is an ever-present threat of terrorist infiltration over the Southwest border. Data indicates that there are hundreds of illegal aliens apprehended entering the United States each year who are from countries known to support and sponsor terrorism. … According to senior U.S. military and intelligence officials, Venezuela is emerging as a potential hub of terrorism in the Western Hemisphere, providing assistance to Islamic radicals from the Middle East and other terrorists.
“General James Hill, commander of U.S. Southern Command, has warned the United States faces a growing risk from both Middle Eastern terrorists relocating to Latin America and terror groups originating in the region. General Hill said groups such as Hezbollah had established bases in Latin America. These groups are taking advantage of smuggling hotspots, such as the tri-border area of Brazil, Argentina and Paraguay, and Venezuela’s Margarita Island, to channel funds to terrorist groups around the world. Venezuela is providing support—including identity documents—that could prove useful to radical Islamic groups, say some U.S. officials.
“The Venezuelan government has issued thousands of cedulas, the equivalent of Social Security cards, to people from places such as Cuba, Columbia, and Middle Eastern nations that host foreign terrorist organizations. The U.S. officials believe that the Venezuelan government is issuing the documents to people who should not be getting them and that some of these cedulas could be subsequently used to obtain Venezuelan passports and even American visas, which could allow the holder to elude immigration checks and enter the United States. Recently, several Pakistanis were apprehended at the U.S.-Mexican border with fraudulent Venezuelan documents. “Hugo Chavez, President of Venezuela, has been clearly talking to Iran about uranium,” said a senior administration official quoted by the Washington Times. Chavez has made several trips to Iran and voiced solidarity with the country’s hard-line mullahs. He has hosted Iranian officials in Caracas, endorsed Tehran’s nuclear ambitions and expressed support for the insurgency in Iraq.
“The Times reports Venezuela is also talking with Hamas about sending representatives to Venezuela to raise money for the militant group’s newly elected Palestinian government as Chavez seeks to build an anti-U.S. axis that also includes Fidel Castro’s Cuba. “I am on the offensive,” Chavez said on the al Jazeera television network, “because attack is the best form of defense. We are waging an offensive battle….” Given all that is happening in Chavez’s Venezuela, some American officials regret that terrorism is seen chiefly as a Middle East problem and that the United States needs to be looking to protect its southern flank. A U.S. intelligence official expressed concern that “counterterrorism issues are not being aggressively pursued in this hemisphere.” Another intelligence official stated terror suspects held at Guantanamo Bay are not being interrogated about connections to Latin America. The bottom line, when it comes to terrorism so close to U.S. shores, says the official, ‘We don’t even know what we don’t know.'” -Jameson Taylor
The Immigration Rift
Conservative types are truly divided on immigration. And for once the division comes down to the fact that the problem is somewhat intractable, not so much because one side or the other is dead wrong. Ultimately, past compromises and bureaucratic bungling have left us with this immigration status quo, and we will have to find our way out of the conundrum.
On the one hand – apart from a few blood ‘n’ soil xenophobes – Americans are enamored of the Ellis Isle phenomenon that marked the early part of the Twentieth Century. During that time, millions came to US shores not to balkanize and to take, but to work hard and to succeed–and in a generation or two to assimilate, to make us stronger economically, and make us more diverse. Most people still appreciate the fact that this is the land of opportunity and that it’s open to anyone with the core American values of thrift, personal responsibility and a work ethic.
On the other hand, our overly generous entitlement system creates dependency and waste. Freeridership becomes a problem as more and more immigrants take advantage of social services, which citizens must pay for. Business and corporate interests sometimes benefit unfairly from this de facto system, pushing the costs of healthcare for cheap laborers onto fellow citizens. The fact of an alien’s illegality also means that people often remain in the shadows, afraid of deportation. This is no way to encourage assimilation. Barios and other unsavory places spring up. Yet people have been waiting in line for years to enjoy the benefits of a simple green card. Would it not be unfair to these people to change the law in the direction of amnesty?
Probably. But something has got to give. Someone in this state of affairs is going to get shafted. 11 million people fleeing the destructive, corrupt, socialist governments of their homelands are only criminals in very weak de jure sense. Not in a moral one. It is time for our national leaders to figure something out. And conservatives or protectionist liberals who try to take a hard line are likely to lose, as walls and mass deportations are not only impracticable, but morally dubious.