The North Carolina Senate has voted to take a business's private property. SB967 was passed by a vote of 44 to 4 and would set up a trust intended to take over a hydroelectric dam operated by Alcoa, Inc. Here's the rub: Alcoa built the dam and has maintained it for decades and they do not want to sell it. What private property will government take next?
Legislative Activity
Senate Votes to Take Alcoa’s Dams
Banning Texting While Driving Misguided
The North Carolina House gave final approval yesterday to H9, a bill that would "ban" texting while driving. I use the term ban in parenthesis because while the practice may legally be banned, for all intents and purposes, the law is toothless and unenforceable.
But the entire approach to government solving this supposed problem is backwards. Sure texting while driving is distracting, but so is changing the radio station, talking on the phone, snarfing down a Bic Mac or putting on makeup — things we routinely see people do while attempting to drive a car. How is texting any different?
The problem isn't people texting while driving, it's people being distracted while driving.
Instead of trying to regulate individual behavior, government should penalize consequences. If I can safely navigate a car and send a text message and not harm myself or others, why should the government care? It should only care enough to make the penalty for harming others so severe that I would think twice before doing it.
If I know that causing a wreck while texting forfeits my driver's license (and yes, driving is a privelege not a right) or sends me to jail, then I am discouraged from doing so.
But banning it to only have a $100 fine IF the police catch me — that's not going to stop anyone.
But the members of the NC House can go back to their districts and tell their constituents that they are "doing something" about the supposed problem. All the while drivers will continue to be distracted by eating, drinking, smoking, fiddling with their GPS or changing songs on their Ipods while driving. But good thing texting will be banned. That should fix things.
Best Bill Ever
Every week we've been highlighting our "Bad Bill of the Week" pointing out some of the most ridiculous or dangerous legislation introduced in the General Assembly.
I wanted to take a moment and do something different. Recognize a bill, I feel, is one of the best to ever be introduced:
H Res. 1517 — "A joint resolution recognizing the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill men's basketball team for an outstanding season culminating in the 2009 NCAA division I championship."
I sit in eager anticipation of it coming to the floor of the NC House and Senate.
“Model” Legislation or saying no to Little Miss Sunshine
A tough week to pick our "Bad Bill of the Week" as there is so much competition. But Christine DiPietro found a real "winner" with Study Regulation/Beauty Pageant/Under 13 Yrs.
Folks you can't make this stuff up. Read how our elected representatives have nothing better to do than introduce legislation to regulate the details of beauty pageants.
One suggestion - a better title: Tots In a Regulatory Environment Atmosphere (TIARA)
Legislative Hypocrisy
Attending a meeting of the House Committee on Election Law and Campaign Finance Reform I listened to two bills (among others) being discussed and couldn't help but be struck by the hypocrisy in the reasons given for passing these bills. HB 120 - Public Municipal Campaigns and House Bill 76 – School Board Candidate Filing Fee.
In the case of the HB 76 the argument was that there was TOO MUCH LOCAL CONTROL in fees for filing and that in some cases the fee was TOO LOW and would allow people to file who were not serious candidates. Later when arguing for HB 120 the argument was given that this bill allowed FOR LOCAL CONTROL and how important local control was. The argument was also given that public financing would allow MORE people to run for office.
What we had was the same legislator (a primary sponsors of both bills) arguing in one bill for taking away local control and discouraging people from running for office and within minutes arguing for local control and wanting more people to run for office in another bill.
The hypocrisy makes my head want to explode. Of course it is just another day in the General Assembly as legislators spend money and reduce freedoms.
Any Way This Comes Out Fair?
We've already learned how the General Assembly leadership loves to stack the deck of "study committees" with people who have their minds made up, so will it be any surprise who gets appointed to this committee.
H952 would authorize a study committee on teacher compensation specifically to look at merit-based proposals. Along with members appointed by the Speaker and President Pro-Tempore, the teachers' union NCAE gets two members of their own — I'm sure those appointees will be quite open minded given one of the bullet points of NCAE's 2009-2010 Legislative Agenda states "Oppose merit and differentiated pay plans."
So here we have another fake committee created by the General Assembly that will just pay lip-service to a serious issue so members can run back to their districts and say they're doing something.
Call me cynical, but this is nothing but a sham.
Two things will come out of this: 1. The committee will never meet. 2. The committee will meet and make a recommendation that merit pay is unfair. When you stack the deck, what else would you expect?
Free Community College for Convicts
In a recently introduced bill, Representatives Larry Womble (D-Forsyth), Earline Parmon (D-Forsyth) and Pricey Harrison (D-Guilford) propose to give free tuition to recently released convicts.
While the merits of giving people that have committed crimes against society a leg up after they complete their obligations to the state can be debated at length, there remains one huge question.
Will there be any room at Mayberry Tech for ex-offenders after North Carolina's Community Colleges allow illegal aliens to go to school at reduced, instate tuition rates? How will these two groups get along in class? The very jobs that ex-offenders hope to get with their new found education will likely go to illegal aliens (whose criminal background outside of the United States is undeterminable) at a cheaper price.
We have a choice to make. Give convicts a chance at a new life on this side of the bars or give their chance to someone that is not supposed to be here in the first place.
Paycheck Protection Act Introduced in NC Senate
Kudos to Senator Andrew Brock (R-Davie) for filing a North Carolina version of the Paycheck Protection Act which was recently upheld by the US Supreme Court.
This bill (S 1032) would protect state employees from being pressured into signing up for payroll deductions for political activities of a labor union.
As I mentioned in an earlier blog post, SEANC SEIU Local 2008 collected in excess of $400,000 last year from state employees for political activities.
Sen. Brock was ranked as the most conservative Senator in the initial Civitas Action rankings.
Your General Assembly Hard at Work
From the "They Don't Have Anything Better to Do?" files…
And no, I'm seriously not making this up.
Rep. Jim Crawford has introduced H683, a bill declaring "The second Saturday in September is designated as North Carolina Hot Sauce Day."
Don't get me wrong, I love Texas Pete on my chicken filet biscuit from Bo's as much as the next guy, but do we really need a whole day to celebrate it?
At a cost of $250,000 per week, members of the General Assembly apparently think this is of vital importance of their attention. Forget the budget deficit, fixing the probation system or trying to revitalize our economy. Let's honor hot sauce!
Marriage Rally In Raleigh
Advocates for allowing voters decide whether or not to amend North Carolina's constitution to define marriage as being between one man and one woman met in Raleigh at the legislature. Though the crowd was smaller than a similar rally last year, supporters of the amendment still turned out a large crowd despite the awful weather. Capitol Police estimated the crowd to be between 3,000 and 4,000 people.
A coalition of conservative and religious groups (including the Civitas Institute) have been bringing new attention to the effort through the group NC4Marriage.
Bills calling for the amendment to be voted on this fall have been filed in both houses. The House version has 66 sponsors, a bipartisan majority. The Senate version is also sponsored by a bipartisan group of
lawmakers but has already been assigned to the Senate Ways & Means committee that hasn't met since 2001. This committee is also know as "bill prison" where the leadership send bills to die.
Despite the legislative roadblocks, protecting marriage is widely supported by voters of both parties and races. The latest Civitas Poll found that 76% of North Carolina's voters want to protect marriage.