September 26th, 2018 by Brian Balfour | Topics: Economics, Education, Liberty

Earlier this week, the Duke Chronicle published a piece warning about the “dangers” of the school’s acceptance of funding from the Charles Koch Foundation for a “Center for History of Political Economy.”
Written by a PhD candidate at Duke, this article irresponsibly makes claims about the works of Friedrich Hayek and the Austrian School of economic theory somehow “fueling the violent Alt-Right.”
Naturally, there is zero evidence provided, and the absurd accusation itself reveals this PhD student to be completely ignorant of the subject matter.
Duke alum, and occasional Civitas contributor Tyler Bonin, responded in the Chronicle here. A few highlights from Bonin’s response:
It (the original article) furthermore paints a caricature of Nobel Prize winner Friedrich Hayek that is inconsistent with his most famous writings. I expect more from the history department at Duke….
Populist movements which seek to make swift change by building up and utilizing the most extreme of coercive governmental powers leads to a violent expansion of government that curtails individual liberty and the free market principles that Hayek posited. The violence associated with the alt-right is thus incompatible with the points put forward by Hayek and other economists from the Austrian School.
Perhaps what is most appalling about this is the fact that the Chronicle editors decided to run the original piece, full of sloppy innuendo and wild and unsubstantiated claims, in the first place.
September 24th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Liberty

A simple Google news search of Hurricane Florence produces some very depressing news. Just one example that made national headlines was the good samaritan and woman who was arrested for essentially saving and housing pets without a permit. Her crime? Providing basic medicine to suffering animals without a veterinary license. While it’s always difficult to judge a story from afar it appears her motives were nothing but one of compassion.
The story too of the death of Kaiden Lee-Welch absolutely broke my heart. There are many others of course.
However, I’m drawn to many of the heartwarming stories too, particularly given the brokenness we are currently seeing in Washington and from politics more generally. While we never want any kind of weather-related tragedy, it can serve as a reminder of the good deeds that come from so many North Carolinians and Americans in times of trial. “We’re so grateful for other states throughout the country who have sent their personnel and equipment here to help us out,” declared Gov. Roy Cooper. It reminds us of the importance of civil society and that politics is really limited in its ability to transform us or meet the deeper needs we may have.
Now for some good news.
Operation BBQ Relief is ongoing and quite a feat. From the News & Observer article:
Operation BBQ Relief was founded in 2011, by two Kansas City, Missouri, competition barbecuers who started cooking meals for people affected by a catastrophic tornado in Joplin, Missouri. Their effort turned into an organization that can now be found trailing most natural disasters across the country ready to serve free meals.
The group doesn’t cook a specific type of barbecue, when doing relief projects, instead relying on whatever sauce has been donated.
Today, the group was using “Bone Suckin’ Sauce,” which is made by Ford’s Foods out of Raleigh. A volunteer described it as a mix between Lexington-style sauce and Eastern North Carolina-style sauce.
Since their founding, Operation BBQ Relief has served 1,780,375 meals during disasters.
Another story is about a four-year-old girl named Florence in Chicago who used her name to capitalize on helping people by collecting supplies. Technology helped the story go viral and they amassed enough goods to fill a truck. From the profile in People:
Florence’s mother, Tricia Wisniewski, says she showed her daughter photos of the destruction, reminding the little girl that it’s important “to help people who aren’t as lucky as us.” The pre-schooler agreed, saying, “people need toiletries and diapers and pacifiers. They need formula and water and baby food.”
The St. Louis Post Dispatch reminds us there is nothing more powerful than images. They offer up some visuals of rescues during Florence. A Gov. Cooper press release noted that “first responders have reported 5,214 people rescued.”
There are a lot of powerful stories from Hurricane Florence still to emerge. In the rush to politicize everything today, sadly even natural disasters, we should focus more on our common humanity. I continually find the extraordinary generosity of ordinary Americans to be one of our best testaments. Bill Clinton said it well in his first Inaugural Address when he noted, “There is nothing wrong with America that cannot be cured by what is right with America.”
September 11th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Civitalk, Economics, Liberty

I evacuated just a few days before Hurricane Katrina made landfall on the Mississippi Gulf Coast in 2005. I wanted to stay because the experts said it was moving west of New Orleans, but it hit Mississippi like a freight train. My dad, who was out of state at the time, was wise to order me out of his house. I was in graduate school in Kentucky so I had a place to go, but I’ll never forget going back.
If you’ve ever seen pictures of Hiroshima and Nagasaki after the dropping of the atomic bombs in 1945, it had that feel. A lot of concrete slabs. No trees. Boats from the harbors washed far inland, a few boats somehow suspended in the trees that remained. It was brutal and there was a significant malaise and fatigue from folks trying to put their life back together. Where do you start when all your possessions are gone?
I wrote a feature titled “The Church and disaster relief: Shelter from the Stormy Blast” for the Acton Institute related to the charitable mobilization for Katrina and other natural disasters. Here is just a short excerpt:
I was amazed at the quickness Southern Baptist Disaster Relief cut through the rubble to meet immediate needs,” said one Katrina survivor. The Southern Baptists’ North American Mission Board raised a total of $25 million to assist Hurricane Katrina victims. An American Red Cross representative in Alabama said, “I don’t believe the Red Cross could do what it does in terms of feeding people without the Southern Baptists.” She described the Southern Baptist food delivery system as a “well oiled machine.
All that to say, hopefully, there are no similarities between Hurricane Florence and Katrina. We all desire the very best outcome for this region.
Donald Bryson highlighted the importance of charitable giving in an earlier post. If you can give to one of those organizations, do it because of the way that they powerfully transform lives. Having a little involvement in the recovery efforts in Katrina, one of the ways churches are so effective at meeting needs is because they are not hemmed in by a massive bureaucracy and regulatory state. They don’t have to means test you to help. There is usually no mountain of paperwork to fill out to receive assistance. Church charities learned a lot of lessons from Katrina and if anybody has ever seen the efficiency of the Southern Baptist Disaster Relief in a crisis they would know that kind of service is hard to replicate either by for-profit organizations or government.
While emergency church disaster organizations are often the first on site, big box companies with massive resources are right behind them. NPR noted how much quicker they provided help over the government in the wake of Katrina. And locally, WRAL posted a video about the efforts being made by Food Lion to meet the needs of those preparing for this impending hurricane. This is no doubt being replicated by many of the big stores across parts of North Carolina.
Again, give if you can and be thankful for not just the many first responders risking their lives, but also the charitable groups and businesses that are truly equipped to assist people by meeting their needs in a crisis. I’ll always remember the armies of church groups who poured into the Gulf Coast after Katrina. Not only because they were first, but also because they were there helping long after the government.
September 10th, 2018 by Leah Byers | Topics: Liberty, Miscellaneous

On August 20, 2018, a mob destroyed a Confederate war memorial on the campus of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Known as Silent Sam, the statue was 105 years old and honored UNC students that fought in the Civil War.
Eighteen people have been arrested in connection with the night of vandalism and subsequent protests. Of those arrested, one is an associate professor at UNC Chapel Hill. So, who are the other individuals and groups responsible for this egregious act of total disregard for the rule of law?
This week, WRAL reported an updated list of the names of the arrested along with their charges and the date of their alleged crimes.
One alleged vandal is Raul Arce Jimenez, who is charged with misdemeanor riot and misdemeanor defacing of a public monument in connection with the August 20th destruction of the statue. Some news sources are calling him an organizer of the rally.
Jimenez appears to have a history with these types of mob-style acts of vandalism. Earlier this year, Jimenez was found not guilty on charges related to the toppling of a Confederate monument in Durham.
Additionally, Jimenez has ties to an array of Left-leaning groups in North Carolina that are featured in the Civitas Mapping the Left project. One group, the Youth Organizing Institute (YOI), still lists Jimenez as one of its two co-directors. YOI receives funding from the Ben & Jerry’s Foundation and the Proteus Fund. YOI’s parent organization, the Southern Vision Alliance, receives funds from prominent progressive donors such as the Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation and the Mary Reynolds Babcock Foundation.
Jimenez’s rationalization the vandalism of the monuments is best expressed in his own words. In one interview with Fox News, he said, “if they are upset with the way the community took action, they should look for a way to reverse that law passed in 2015 protecting those monuments.” Fox also quotes Jimenez as saying the toppling of the monument was a “righteous act of people power.”
This is an incredibly dangerous mindset that abandons the rule of law in favor of mob rule. Our legal processes are in place for a reason; they provide legitimate outlets for citizens to express their grievances. Our state is a diverse place. One small group should not be allowed to completely disregard the will of their fellow citizens, as expressed through their elected government representatives, just because they are able to rally the brute force necessary to make their desired change.
When people or groups decide to circumvent the established forums for public discourse, based on some illusion of righteousness, where do we draw the line? Is any crime excusable if it is motivated by a criminal’s genuinely held belief in its righteousness?
There are fringe radicals on either side of the ideological spectrum. But in a society that glorifies “social justice warriors” and their tantrum-like behaviors, the Silent Sam incident should raise red flags. Will the Leftist establishment, with which Jimenez is tied, condemn his alleged actions? Or are we moving towards a society that rewards vigilantes who take “justice” into their own hands?