Part of what makes the blogosphere interesting is controversy and conflict. However, sometimes people can go over the line — either to get in their dig, or simply to use ad hominem tactics. DJ over at Wizbang! has an experiment to see whether people can have constructive debate without the use of such tactics. For some, this will be tough, because many of us are masochists to some degree. But enlightened discourse demands we quell the urge to call names.
Miscellaneous
On Constructive Debate
Giuliani’s Remarks about Democrats
Giuliani said two things today at the Conservative Leadership Conference that lit this blogger up:
First, he said: "I’ll be darned if I’m going to concede that Democrats care more about poor people than we do." This is a message that was awkwardly put by Bush in 2000 as "compassionate conservatism." But what Giuliani is angling at is that conservative/free-market types want to quibble with the idea that a) government can help people more than free individuals can (social entrepreneurship), that the liberals have cornered the market on benevolence in general, and that government programs actually help the poor rather than trap them in poverty. (Besides: it’s easier to be generous with other people’s money.) And if Rudy has in mind compromise measures to aid the poor? They’ll be more about helping them with credits and tax breaks than handouts and new programs. (Note his record in NYC.)
Second, Giuliani said: "They’re moving toward socialized medicine so fast, it’ll make your head spin." And he’s right. They’re doing it at the state level and national level. If they don’t do it incrementally through the expansion of SCHIP (Medicaid), they’ll do it by enacting a single payer system at the national level. Single-payer is codeword for socialized Medicine. I’ve raised my concerns about it here, here and here. It will do nothing but displace the costs of routine care, and make you wait in line for months for a broken leg–all while paying more in taxes. Is that really what we want?
Southern Fried Corporate Welfare
Our southern "hospitality" — i.e. economic development subsidies and tax breaks — is apparently making waves. (See this excellent John Sugg piece on the South’s, particularly NC’s, corporate welfare.)
But there are serious problems with government’s picking winners and losers in the economy. Never mind that it’s wrong for big companies to get special treatment, while little guys lose out — as with Google. Instead of showering them with gifts, why not just make the business climate fertile with low taxes?
Hayes: Strike Two!
Our own Chris Hayes weighs in (again) on the newest iteration of the smoking ban.
Buy Local?
Top-notch economists discuss the problem with the "buy local" fixation.
Basic Economics
Anyone looking to bone up on their economics should check out this book by Stroup and Gwartney. The former is an environmental economist currently working at NC State. Both authors have tremendous brains and distill complicated market principles into a palatable format for students and lay audiences alike. Strongly recommend the book for all members of the NC General Assembly.