Congress, in exchange for caving on war funding, must have struck a deal to get in their economically unsound minimum wage legislation that is sure to hit to small businesses particularly hard. I have argued elsewhere that this type of intervention in the economy is a bad idea for a number of reasons. Congressional lefties clearly don’t understand the nuances of labor supply and demand — clouded as they are by meaningless concepts such as "living wage." Alas, here we have another blow against the margins of businesses already plagued by the price of healthcare they’ve been saddled with the responsibility for providing due to our skewed tax code. Sigh. No joy watching these government circuses in our state and in Washington trying to fix and plan our economy like ‘intelligent designers.’
Politicians & Politicking
Minimum Wage Blues
Electing a President
Last night, the NC Senate passed SB 954 which would enter the State of North Carolina into a compact with other states that gives each state’s electoral college votes to whoever wins a plurality of the national popular vote for President.
I’ll save you all the "intent of the Founding Fathers’" and the urban v. rural arguments for another time and just point out two huge problems with moving to a popular election of President.
First, with North Carolina’s hugely restrictive ballot access provisions, it is theoretically possible for North Carolina to give all 15 of its electoral votes to a person who did not receive a single vote for President in the state. For example, a headline in the Washington Times today: "Bloomberg poised to spend $1 billion to run for President." Under a popular election scenario, Mayor Bloomberg would not need to campaign or be on the ballot in all 50 states. He could strategically target the states that could get him a plurality of the popular vote and ignore other states. If his poll numbers were horrendous in North Carolina, he could choose to ignore the state, not even attempt to gather the signatures to be on the ballot, and focus his time and money on states where he could gain the most votes.
Second, the potential for a nationwide recount and legal challenges. Imagine what happened in Florida in 2000 on a nationwide scale. That should be enough to scare anyone away from this proposal.
N.C. Budget Roundup
For a roundup of Civitas policy briefs on the N.C. state budget, visit here.
Politicians Distort Data and Pander to Us
Russ Roberts nails the trouble with ignoring economics in this video. Data manipulation by politicians results in their pandering to a closed, populist mindset.
Unpopular Sovereignty
The N.C. General Assembly will debate a measure to circumvent the will of the Electoral College by making the US popular vote outcome the default position of N.C. electors. Such a measure would run counter to the spirit of representative democracy, distribution of power, and the intentions of the Framers. (While you might not like that Bush won in 2000, you can see why the Electoral College is not just some quaint artifact here, here (pdf), and here.)
Edwards v. Giuliani
Consider this from the Progressive Pulse, where the author attempts to contrast Giuliani with Edwards (after accusing the former of profiteering from his leadership after 9/11):
Edwards, on the other hand, works with families who have been injured through medical negligence or defective products. He helps them navigate our judicial system as they seek due process for their injuries. True, there is significant financial reward for Edwards, but there is societal good in his role as advocate for those who are less powerful, so that they may seek justice within our legal system. After all, are we not a nation of laws?
Edwards, the ambulance chaser, benefits from a system in which medical malpractice suits pay out exorbitant sums due to simple human error. Edwards benefitted directly from racking up massive jury sums. "You can’t put a value on human life" liberals are fond of saying, but Edwards tried to do so asymptotically by adding as many zeros as possible to these awards, then taking his cut. Many of these cases are tried before a jury of our "peers" — people who no more understand the minutiae of medicine than how these astronomical awards affect the price of healthcare for the rest of us, and drive competent professionals out of areas like ob/gyn.
The John Edwards of the world don’t care about people, they care about money and power. Edwards, for example, benefitted from convincing ignorant juries that bad outcomes for babies = negligence on the part of physicians. (This has got to stop.) Could Edward’s own soak-the-rich populism be an outgrowth of his own self-loathing? Maybe he’s a true believer in socialism. But he, like Marx, probably feels guilty about his affluence… particularly when gotten by duping jurors with pity parties, blaming doctors, and accusing good companies of everything under the sun. I’ve no doubt Edwards tried some good, just cases. But let’s not conflate lawyers with the rule of law. And let’s not try to paint Edwards as anything more than a populist ambulance chaser. For that is what he is.