Raleigh is among the worst for commuting times, says Forbes. Great! That’s why we should build light rail, so we can relieve less than one percent of congestion. (Duh.)
-Max Borders
Transportation & Infrastructure
Raleigh Among Worst for Commuting
Priorities Off the Rails
Big blue ribbons are found on big, big pigs. $8 billlion!
-Max Borders
An Idea for Charlotte
Since Charlotte’s LYNX Blue Line light rail doesn’t have turnstiles or ticketing gates you must pass through, they basically have an honor system of paying your fare to ride the rail. They threaten you with a $50 fine if you are caught, but that enforcement is probably quite difficult to pull off.
Maybe they should borrow an idea from Vancouver where transit police there are tasering people who do try to skip out on paying the fare.
The country’s only armed transit police have been tasering passengers who try to avoid paying fares.
According
to documents provided in response to a Freedom of Information request,
police patrolling public transit in the Metro Vancouver area have used
tasers 10 times in the past 18 months, including five occasions when
victims had been accosted for riding free.
That’ll scare me into buying a ticket a heck of a lot more than a fine.
(And no, you squeamish lefties, I’m not really advocating this, just though it was interesting.)
Skybus & Corporate Welfare
Chris Hayes’s and my Skybus article is now on the Web.
-Max Borders
Durham: And Speaking of Light Rail
According to this article (registration required), Durham is thinking of copying Chapel Hill by providing "free" (read: fully tax-subsidized) bus transit. Now, notice that Chapel Hill’s massively increased bus ridership has been used to justify building light rail. Notice also that Durham is slated to get part of the light rail line that planners hope to build in the Triangle – despite myriad problems, low density, exorbitant costs, etc. etc. I wonder: is this sudden spell of generosity to Durham denizens merely a pretext to set up the argument to justify the construction of light rail in the Triangle? I’m just asking.
It also leads me to ask a fairly obvious question: why can’t all these yuppies that the taxpayers of N.C. are going to be subsidizing to take rail transit ride a bus? Surely it costs less by about a factor of 20-or-30.
-Max Borders
Does Rail Transit Save Energy or Reduce GHGs?
Nope.
Skybus: What the…?
Piedmont Publius is, perhaps, as confused as we are at the rationale behind central planners like Henry Isaacson o’er there in the Triad. Here’s Isaacson – quoted by the PP – opining about the market dynamics:
I want people in the Triad to understand that Allegiant is an altogether different airline than Skybus,” Isaacson said. “They’ve been around for awhile; they’ve been making money; they’re established. I think the only reason they were leaving us is that Skybus was sort of permeating the low-fare territory. They don’t compete at the point of origin with another low-fare carrier.”
Is this 20/20 hindsight or something Isaacson could have sussed beforehand? Seriously, a company that hasn’t been around for awhile, isn’t making money and isn’t established in an industry plagued by multiple factors like unstable inputs (jet fuel)… Why are these bureaucrats throwing our cash at such poor investments? This attempt to pick winners and losers is just wacky. Isaacson, et al, couldn’t possibly have had the prescience to predict what Allegiant called the "destablizing" factor of Skybus — never mind that these subsidies contributed to the destabilization. Nor does 20/20 hindsight help matters once everything goes haywire.
Excuse me, Mr. Isaacson, I think I’d like to invest my own resources. I’m pretty sure Vanguard or I could do a heckuva lot better than you.
-Max Borders
See, The Drought was Good for Something
Faster trips to the beach this summer!
Clayton bypass to open one year early.
See ya’ll in Atlantic Beach!
Triangle Rail: You Want my Opinion?
The people trying to build pyrami- uh light rail in Raleigh are asking for opinions. Whether or not that was another April Fool’s joke, I’m giving mine. There are a lot of justifications for light rail, and none of them are any good:
1) Gas prices are getting to be too high, so people need alternative transportation.
While gas prices are at numerical records, as a percentage of income they aren’t as high as the early 80s. Further, some of the TTA trains will run on diesel, which is more expensive than gas and more polluting. According to expert Randall O’Toole, the average light rail uses more energy per passenger and pollutes more per passenger mile than cars. If we’re talking about subsidizing the working poor, there are a lot better ways to do it (like give them tax waivers on gas). North Carolina has the highest motor fuels taxes in the Southeast last time I looked.
2) It will change land use patterns to make cities more livable and less energy dependent.
Uh huh. So you’re going to spend billions to build rail where rich white folks (who can afford gas) travel, make those areas more congested. When you do so, you can count on housing prices in those artificially scarce (subsidized) areas to go up, making housing less affordable. Poorer people will move to the suburbs away from the subsidized trains and pay higher gas prices to commute into town. Brilliant. While you might get the accretion of special interest dollars around the choo choo – making wealthy folks have a better urban experience – you’re sacrificing dollars that would be spent on a distributed transportation system (roads) to one, big monolithic, centralized system that will cost at least 5 times more than a highway lane, but carry only a fifth as many people. Everyone else gets to subsidize the "urban livability" of the few – to the tune of billions. Perverse–that is, even if you think crowding people together around trains makes for livability. I’d rather have a yard for my little boy to run around.
3) It will help relieve traffic congestion.
1%, 2% at most – for maybe a year or so. This is not significant.
4) Auto travel is subsidized, so why not transit?
O’Toole: "So transit costs are nearly three time auto costs, while transit subsidies are more than eight times auto costs."
Light rail is, and always has been, a kind of totem. People worship it, but it has no magic in the real world.
-Max Borders
Better Than Light Rail
Idea for commuters, better than light rail.
-Max Borders