This is an archive of the Civitas Institute website, preserved by the John Locke Foundation. It is no longer updated. For current research and polling, visit johnlocke.org.

Skip links

Right Hand – Left Hand?

The House budget released today has a few inconsistencies. Take, for instance, the $193,000 increase for Tarheel Challenge at the same time House budget writers are placing the Tarheel Challenge program under continuation review. (Continuation review, for those who don’t know, is a new tool the Legislature started using last year which requires that select programs justify their existence in order to receive funding in the future.) The $193,000 increase for Tarheel Challenge is one-time money, but it doesn’t make a lot of sense to throw any extra money at a program while you are supposedly considering whether or not to continue it. Last year, programs that received continuation reviews not only didn’t get any extra money, the money they were already getting was made nonrecurring – future funding of any kind was made contingent on the results of the review.

House Money Report (pdf)        House Budget Bill (pdf)

N&O: Perpetuating the Tax-Growth Myth

The News & Observer is playing handmaiden to the left again. This time it’s another "we need higher taxes to deal with growth" narrative. Don’t believe it for a second. These are social engineers who want your money to expand social services and build expensive, but useless projects such as light rail.

Think of it like this: a 100 lb. woman and a 200 lb. man both blow .08 on the Breathalizer test when pulled over by the police. While the 200 lb man may have drunk much more alcohol, the percentage of alcohol in his blood is the same.

Analogously, why would we need higher taxes if more people are here paying taxes (and the influx is coming largely from people who are either buying property, or buying property AND spending money AND holding jobs)? That’s all a proportional tax revenue increase. The only reason we would need more or higher taxes is if government is being wasteful or social engineering. Of course, it goes without saying that…

But when’s the last time you heard the N&O or the government think about making cuts or efficiency measures? Speaking truth to power, they don’t.
-Max Borders

The Public Disconnect Between Bonds and Taxes

While reading through this article in the Greensboro News-Record about a county commissioner’s push to increase their local sales tax, this specific passage jumped out at me:

"Guilford County voters this month approved $651.4 million in bonds for schools, GTCC and a county jail. And after the vote, many commissioners said the only option to pay for the debt would be through property tax rate increases. On that same day, a quarter-cent sales tax failed by a 3-to-1 vote."

The fact that bonds are approved by voters so routinely while local tax increases continue to be defeated by wide margins provides more evidence to a theory of mine: many voters simply are not aware of what it means when they approve a bond. I believe many of them do not understand that they are authorizing an increase of their local government’s debt. A debt that will have to be repaid – with interest – using their tax dollars.(For many years, I was one of those people) This lack of understanding explains, in part, why voters approve bonds so frequently while rejecting tax increases – they don’t realize that approving a bond will put upward pressure on their tax burden.

Another factor, I believe, is that the bonds are always sold to the public as paying for something specific like schools or parks, so citizens are made to feel guilty about "rejecting" such projects.

How can we fix this disconnect? How about some "truth in lending" practices on bond referenda, one of our recommendations in our Budget & Taxes Blueprint:

"The state should mandate that “responsible lending” language be included on bond referendums. Specific details about the total amount required to repay the debt, including a breakdown of principle and interest, should be required in the ballot language. Voters should also be clearly informed that the spending of bond funds is above and beyond the current operating budget and thus constitute a new spending burden. Finally, the ballot language should clearly explain that the debt will be repaid using tax dollars and that a tax increase might be required to finance the debt."

I would be very curious to see the approval rate of bonds if government became more transparent about the debt they are issuing.

Budget Myth: Cig Taxes Will Pay for Teacher Salaries

All we’ve heard this week on the Governor’s budget is that he proposes raising the cigarette tax by $0.20 per pack to "give teachers a 7 percent pay increase."

Well, the numbers don’t really add up.

Increasing the cigarette tax is estimated to bring in roughly $99 million next year.
Increasing teacher pay by 7% (and administrators by 6%) will cost $302.7 million.

Yet, nothing is said about where that extra $200 million is coming from.

And if the cigarette tax is "successful" in getting less people to smoke, then there will be less revenues each year.
Teacher salary increases are permanent and never go down.
You, me and every other taxpayer is on the hook for the rest of the money.

So don’t believe the budget hype that the cigarette tax is "going to pay for" teacher salary increases.  It’s just not true.