Budget & Taxes
Fairtax?
Mini Budget Debate
John Hood tries to explain some of the nuances of fiscal responsibility and infrastructure development to someone steeped in what you might call "more-spending macroeconomics". See the comments section, too.
Cola or Cherry?
As I was reading through the House and Senate passed budgets over the weekend drawing up some comparisons, I noticed a nice little slush fund for the DOT board…
FUNDS FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, SPOT SAFETY, AND TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM PROJECTS
SECTION 27.3. Of the funds appropriated by this act to the Department of Transportation in fiscal year 2007-2008, nine million three hundred thirty-eight thousand four hundred four dollars ($9,338,404) shall be used for economic development transportation projects recommended by the member of the Board of Transportation representing the Division in which the project is to be constructed in consultation with the Division Engineer and approved by the Board of Transportation. These funds, in addition to any remaining funds which were appropriated to the Department pursuant to Section 28.27 of S.L. 2005-276, shall be allocated equally among the 14 Divisions.
The Secretary of Transportation shall not prevent or delay the implementation of any projects approved by the Board of Transportation pursuant to this section.
The Senate version which gives each member approximately $667,000 while the House version gives each BOT member $1 million. Basically, each of the 14 members of the Board of Transportation gets a nice little chunk of money to use for "economic development" in his or her region.
Hmm… I wonder how much it would cost to get the road repaved in front of my house?
Budgetary Steps Away from Statism?
Rob Schofield’s lamentations notwithstanding, if the rumors were right, the budget would’ve turned out better than we thought. Read Schofield’s whole post. Most of these rumored proposals strike this eye as pretty positive – particularly the pilot program designed to marketize Medicaid (I imagine similar to the one in Florida). That would have been a good idea.
Why "progressives" are so enamored of the undynamic, sclerotic, expensive, bureaucratic government systems that keep poor people dependent and distort the healthcare market is beyond me. They’ve bought fully the statist party line about "market failure", I guess. But leaving the Medicaid status quo is positively Soviet (and certainly not progressive in any lexical sense). I’d really like to see Adam Searing and Rob Schofield get full scholarships to graduate degrees programs in economics. They’d likely turn out like a couple of Paul Krugmans, but at least they would be able to grasp that a) Medicaid is fiscally unsustainable and gobbling up more and more of state budgets (we do need roads ya know), b) that Medicaid contributes to the very poverty traps you’d think progressives would like for poor people to escape, and c) that it distorts the market in such a way that sends more and more people into it. Then again, c) is their goal — single payer. But hopefully that economics degree would disabuse them of those notions, too. Alas, alas. Such is the redistributionist, zero-sum thinking of the left.
(Update: We could find nothing in the budget to justify Schofield’s fears. Leftism lives another day.)
The Arrogance and Elitism of the Bureaucrat
… was exemplified in these words by Senator Marc Basnight, quoted in the Insider:
"We took a big step in building a knowledge-based economy," said Basnight, D-Dare, adding that a vote of the people wasn’t a must because the projects are so important. (Emphasis added.)
I know it looks like we’re picking on Basnight, but he is one of the most powerful members of the General Assembly and he should take it on the chin. (Please, no horseheads in my bed.)
Seriously, though, what sort of arrogance and elitist thinking goes into a claim that: billions in debt should bypass a referrendum of the people, that he and his technocrat cronies know how to build a "knowledge economy", much less, that he knows the first thing about the money he’s spending, where it’s going, and its effects on the economy? I don’t know what should sicken taxpayers more, the "we know better than you" mien, or all the debt set at the feet of our children (sure to cancel whatever positive effects may rise out of their subsidized education). -MB
Corporate Welfare Meets Central Planning
(Almost) to the delight of this congenital right-winger, I’d at first thought the "report card" over at NC Policy Watch was going to end as strongly as it started:
The Dell and Google experiences have also highlighted the danger of over-bidding – that is, paying too much for the jobs that are created. Over-bidding is chiefly a result of the fact that corporations have most of the information. They know who and how much each jurisdiction is bidding, their own bottom line, and how the competition compares with respect to non-incentive strengths and weaknesses. Public sector officials are in the dark. The courted business is, therefore, in a stronger position to bluff and browbeat any community (especially a needy one) to do almost anything to make a deal.
But if you keep reading, the author – one William Schweke – is laboring under the same conceit as economic development bureacrats in Raleigh. That is: he thinks governments can pick winners and losers, and plan economies. I’ve argued elsewhere that it just doesn’t work. I’ve given a more abstract argument here. And while I understand we’re in a bitter competition with other states, we’re still better off if we create a hospitable, fair tax environment across the board–a tax environment that doesn’t privelege megacorporations over small businesses, or the reverse for that matter. I’m frankly surprised that the progressives are this utilitarian in supporting such corporate welfare over at NC Policy Watch. In short, offering a report card of economic development concedes a false premise: that it works.
Poor Mouthing the Freedom Budget
Fitzsimon over at NC Policy Watch takes a pot-shot at the John Locke foundation for their annual alternative NC budget, known as the "freedom budget." The Policy Watcher says:
While the House budget looks bad and Berger and Stam’s position that cutting taxes on the wealthy is more important than providing services is worse, neither comes close in absurdity to the latest from Raleigh’s leading free market fundamentalist think tank, a document released Tuesday called the “Freedom Budget”
The bizarre proposal not only ends the temporary tax increases, it cuts the state corporate tax rate too. It slashes funding for teacher assistants, dramatically increases tuition at UNC campuses, effectively abolishes Smart Start, ends the program to help poor schools, abolishes the Housing Trust Fund, cuts health care programs for children, you get the idea.
Fitzsimon goes on to admonish free-marketeers for their concern about tax hikes. So perhaps we should explain why (again): When you remove money from a market economy for the pet projects of a bureaucracy, that’s less money available for economic growth. Of course, NCPW’s soak-the-rich-for-said-pet-projects outlook is clear from the above. But for every dollar that is pulled from citizens’ hands, that’s a dollar than can’t be directed toward philanthropy, investment, or other pursuits that actually contribute to economic expansion and improved communities. NCPW and liberal minds in general just (congenitally) can’t seem to grasp that government growth is zero-sum, while markets are positive sum. (I know which side I’d like my money to be on.) Thus, the Locke Foundation is not so much preoccupied with greed as they are knowledgable about basic economics, i.e. avoiding dead-weight loss and other negative consequences of government expansion. Nevermind that people are getting fed up with Utopians who claim to know better about what should be done with their money than they are. Fitzsimon’s post should be called: "We’d rather crowd out everything."
Fitzsimon continues:
It is more of a Freedom from reality budget than a serious proposal, but it does allow Stam and Berger to seem more rational, with their disingenuous claim that increased state spending is somehow irresponsible, despite exploding enrollments at public schools, community colleges and universities, and the skyrocketing cost of health care.
If we can get past NCPW’s rhetoric and on to the substance of the Freedom Budget as well as to the counterclaims about public schools and skyrocketing healthcare costs, we can point directly at the "progressives" in office for our state’s plight in these areas. We get perennial NOs from the Left on vouchers, educator accountability, and competition for schools–all of which would result in both cost-savings and increased quality. We get NOs on efforts to deregulated and reform the horrible shambles that is state-monopoly/third-party/mandate-riddled healthcare. And we continue to expand so-called "entitlement" programs despite vaults of evidence for deleterious effects to the economy and for people’s increased dependency on the state. So, Chris. We agree: let’s have this conversation.
– Max Borders
An Equitable Tax System
A recent study shows lower-income families pay a higher percentage of income in taxes. The folks over at NC Blue would like to see an equitable tax system for "working families" And we agree. How about the FairTax?