A bunch of people marched on Washington this weekend to fight against pork spending. We asked congress to give us more transparency when it comes to earmarks. Check out the video.
Budget & Taxes
See-Through Pork
Goodyear at it Again
Apparently, Goodyear is threatening to pull out in another state, so Ohioans are offering to build them some Taj Mahal that will require eminent domain abuse. I don’t know what is worse, the corporate welfare here or the eminent domain abuse there.
No use in picking just on Goodyear, though, I’m sure the incentives game is being played everywhere around the country.
-Max Borders
Googled from Behind
If you haven’t had a chance yet, please take time to read this article in today’s News & Observer updating the Google project in Caldwell County. If this doesn’t emphasize how fundamentally flawed the incentive shell game is, I don’t know what will.
It turns out that after waiving Google’s property taxes for the next 30 years, the Caldwell County Commissioners turned around and raised property taxes on everyone else by 22.2%!
Unbelievable.
Hopefully as more things like this are revealed, the tide will begin to turn on this incentive game. Would Caldwell County residents still have supported the Google deal if they knew their property tax bills were going up by nearly one-fourth? I guess they’ll have a referendum on that next fall when those Commissioners stand for re-election.
A sign of things to come?
Virginia Governor Tim Kaine announced today that the state is facing a $641 million budget shortfall next year and is asking state agencies to cut their budgets 5%.
Similarly, Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley says his state is facing a $1.5 billion shortfall.
Both Governors lay blame on the slowing housing market and over-zealous projections of revenue growth and the resulting spending that is now coming back to haunt them.
Obviously there are lessons to be learned for North Carolina, unfortunately those lessons only come after the leadership of the General Assembly increased spending 9.5% and issued over $500 million in non-voter authorized debt.
So, will there be a budget shortfall for North Carolina when the General Assembly returns next May? Even if our housing market has been somewhat isolated from the national slowdown, you have to figure that the irresponsible budgeting over the past two years will come back to haunt us sometime real soon.
Pork Spending: Schofield’s Screed
Schofield over at Policy Watch can’t even let our pork report go without shrieking his objections. In his "reality check," he attempts to compensate for his lack of intellectual firepower by thumbing through his thesaurus and including as many inflammatory adjectives he can find. Here is the final tally:
Schofield describing our ideology: "Far Right," "extreme, market fundamentalist right," "cramped and bizarre worldview"
Schofield describing the pork report: "half-baked," "misidentify and mischaracterize," "recklessly tarring," "harmful libel," "absurd," "just plain wrong," "attack," "slimed," "flat wrong," "sloppy and inaccurate attacks," "Ill-conceived," "obvious and egregious errors," "slapdash, ideological diatribe"
It seems to me he needs to cloak his "analysis" with such flowery language in order to assure himself he possesses exclusive rights as a moral authority, and anyone he disagrees with should be either silenced or shamed.
Oddly enough, he barely stops short of defending wasteful government spending on the grounds that "waste, fraud and abuse have always been with us." So I guess it should just continue? Not very "progressive" to advocate the status quo.
He continues:
Think that waste is only a phenomenon of government? Then read some of the descriptions of the lavish spending practiced by America’s new “imperial CEO’s” or the vast sums that cycle through our bloated pharmaceutical industry.
What he doesn’t understand is the fact that the market punishes excess on the part of private companies. Such CEO’s end up in jail, are fired, or punished by fed-up consumers who are free to spend their money elsewhere. What happens when government wastes money? It simply rewards itself with more of our tax dollars.
The main point that needs to be made is this: Collectivists such as Schofield do not hesitate when advocating the use of force by government to take tax dollars and divert them to projects and causes they deem "worthy." He defends items we identified in the report as pork on the basis that he deems them "worthy initiatives." Guess what, there are countless other nonprofits devoted to very worthy causes that don’t receive tax dollars. In fact, I can think of several I would prefer to support – and this list likely wouldn’t include any of Michaux’s pet groups who are happy to engage in political quid pro quo. Even if we were to suppose that government may justifiably support non-profit organizations, wouldn’t it be better to have a comprehensive (competitive) grant process rather than allowing certain politicians to divert funds to their favored organizations?
What people like me with "bizarre worldviews" oppose is a government that has such omnipotence to decide for us which causes are worthy, and then take our money by force in order to fund them. Where is the social justice in that?
Schofield exemplifies hypocrisy by claiming our Pork Report should be labeled "things we don’t like" and then goes on to defend certain items because they are "things he likes." Some reality check. Our point is not that we "don’t like" such causes, it’s that we want to be free to choose for ourselves which causes are worthy of support. Never mind that it’s dangerous for nonprofits to become dependent on the government for funding – a dependency that will cause them to become complacent, less responsive to those in need and less innovative.
Special Provisions in the Budget
In today’s N&O, Dan Kane fleshes out the story behind one of the special provisions that were added into the budget behind closed doors and never debated before a committee.
Well, that is just one of more than 100 new items inserted in the budget. Take a look at this report we compiled last week on the full list of special provisions.
Jim Black’s prison door hasn’t even been shut and locked and the General Assembly is back to doing the exact same things that led him down the road to corruption. So much for cleaning up the process. The lip service given to ending the corruption lasted about half a session.
The 2007 Legislative Session: What should they have done?
What did the General Assembly fail to do that they should have done in this session? (This can include bills not passed, or bills not drafted.)
Comments wide open…
Pork Report
They’ll try to raise taxes to fix N.C. bridges and pay for the health insurance of middle class children. But there’ll be plenty of bacon they could cut instead. Check out Brian Balfour’s pork report here (pdf).
Budget & Budget Rules Broken
This legislative recap that should be of interest to all concerned citizens.
Sticker Shock
Under the Dome has a good post on the growth of budget and government.