Senate and House leaders have come to an agreement on a final version of the legislature’s spending plan. All eyes will move to the Governor after this week. Click on the video report…
June 20th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Economics, Education, Environment & Energy, Healthcare, Immigration, Public Safety, Transportation & Infrastructure
Senate and House leaders have come to an agreement on a final version of the legislature’s spending plan. All eyes will move to the Governor after this week. Click on the video report…
June 19th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Transportation & Infrastructure
State Senate Rules Committee Chairman Sen. Tom Apodaca (R-Henderson) began an investigation of accusations Gov. Perdue’s staff created misleading letters to support funding of the Mid-Currituck Bridge and the Garden Parkway near Gastonia. He introduced as evidence the letters bearing the signature of the Department of Transportation Chief Operating Officer Jim Trogden. The letters were used on the Senate floor by Sen. Stan White (D-Dare) in an attempt to restore funds in the budget for the Mid-Currituck Bridge in his district. His attempt failed. Another allegedly false letter to Rep. Bill Current (R-Gaston) supported funding in the current budget for the planned Garden Parkway toll road. Sen. Apodaca said the problem was Trogden had already written a letter to budget writers saying the money wasn’t needed this budget cycle for either project because of possible legal challenges.
Sen. Apodaca said he wanted to hear from an official from DOT at a Rules Committee meeting Wednesday morning and wanted someone from the Governor’s office to address the investigation Thursday.
After the meeting he said he could refer the matter to the Wake County District Attorney if that’s where the evidence leads them.
June 19th, 2012 by Brian Balfour | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Education, Healthcare
Blue Cross Blue Shield of NC president and CEO Brad Wilson urges citizens to double down on the failed status quo government education establishment in this N&O op-ed. The piece is yet another mindless plea for more money for government-run schools – with zero thought about actually empowering students and their parents by allowing them to choose what sort of education they value. Instead, Wilson insists the next batch of money will turn around the stagnant, top-down, one size fits all failing system.
Most interesting in the article, however, is how Wilson either contradicts himself, or is mind-numbingly oblivious to the current state of North Carolina’s economy. First, he says this:
There’s a constructive cycle that keeps spinning when good education begets good talent, which, in this knowledge economy, begets growing businesses and a growing tax base.
Our education system is the fulcrum. North Carolina’s quality of life pivots up or down from that central point. Businesses will choose North Carolina – or not – because of the quality of our workforce and the institutions that train it.
Wilson is saying here that our economy hinges on the quality of our education system. Then he says this:
The same is true with early childhood programs, K-12 schools, community colleges and our university system. They are not broken. They are not failing.
So to follow Wilson’s logic, NC’s education system is doing just fine. And because – according to him – the state’s economy hinges on the quality of our education system, therefore our economy will reflect that.
I guess Wilson missed the memo that NC has the fourth highest unemployment rate in the country, and that our job growth and per capita income growth has been falling further behind the national average for the past decade plus. Our state’s true economic record, then, indicates that businesses must view our workforce as not being of very high quality – if we are to take Wilson’s points to their logical conclusion.
But Wilson emerges from his own contradictions and the economic reality of our state undeterred, and insists taxpayers pony up yet more money into a failed system.
Adding irony to the story, of course, is how the head of the organization leading what is essentially a government-created health insurance cartel (thanks to countless state mandates and controls) throws support behind another cartel: the government-run schools. Both feature strictly limited options for consumers, very little competition and a third-party payer system. The predictable result in both has been exploding costs with disappointing results.
Also of interest is Wilson’s objection to the “public option” that was part of the debate over Obamacare. Wilson lamented the fact that “You can’t compete with government.” Yet Wilson offers no hint of support for school choice initiatives, which would help non-traditional schools “compete with government,” only more coerced money from taxpayers to subsidize the government education establishment.
June 14th, 2012 by Brian Balfour | Topics: Budget & Taxes
During floor debate today on the Senate budget plan, GOP leaders introduced an amendment to increase the state sales tax. Basically, they wanted Senators to go on record with their support or opposition for the tax hike.
After all the talk from Democratic leadership in the General Assembly about raising taxes to “fund education”, it was put up or shut up time.
They shut up.
The amendment was rejected by a unanimous vote.
The Senate budget plan, however, was approved and now goes to the House. The House is unlikely to approve, which means a Conference Committee consisting of House and Senate budget writers will work to iron out the differences between the two plans. The Committee’s budget will then need to be approved by both houses of the legislature, then sent to Gov. Perdue’s desk.
June 14th, 2012 by Brian Balfour | Topics: Budget & Taxes
The N&O writes another yawner about the state budget, warning – you guessed it – against the state government not spending enough of your money. Here’s the opening ‘graph:
Preparing and adopting North Carolina’s state budget is all about making choices – how much money to raise, who to raise it from and what to spend it on. A conscientious budget seeks to address the most needs at the lowest cost. But those making the decisions must be mindful that aiming too low can have lasting consequences for the state’s well-being.
Where to begin?
First, the underlying premise here is that the “state’s well-being” hinges on more concentration of power in the hands of the ruling class. Funny, I thought we were a society that cherished freedom and that human beings have a right to pursue their happiness (i.e. well-being) in peaceful means that they see fit. In a free society, citizens do not become dependent upon their rulers for their well-being. That the N&O’s editors hold this vision for a dependent, command and obey society is troubling.
Furthermore, this article is only the latest of countless N&O editorials warning that state lawmakers should be “mindful” or cautious when considering slowing the growth rate of the state budget. But how many articles has the N&O published with warnings about being cautious when considering rapid expansion of state government, and thus reducing individual liberty and taking more taxpayer dollars out of the real economy? I certainly can’t recall N&O editors ever saying “Whoa, you may want to be cautious before you double the size of that government program and take more money from hardworking taxpayers.” When it comes to expanding state power, N&O editors think no rate is fast enough.
In addition, the N&O fails to take into account the true state budget, which includes federal dollars sent to Raleigh as well. True state spending is at an all time high, and has more than tripled in the past 40 years – even after adjusting for inflation and population. Indeed, NC’s true state budget has become more and more reliant on federal dollars – which means the state is granting more of its sovereignty to DC.
Lastly, warning about the state budget “aiming too low” is laughable when put in proper context. As mentioned in the previous paragraph, the state budget has been exploding in size for decades. Even looking exclusively at the state’s General Fund, we see a long-term spending binge, and that doesn’t even include the billions in unfunded benefits promised to state retirees. Imagine a man who weighed 180 pounds at age 25, but over the next 30 years he embarked in an overeating binge and bloated himself to a morbidly obese 400 pounds. During the last couple of years, however, he managed to trim back to 390. According to N&O logic, he should be cautious about becoming too skinny, and go for extra helpings at Golden Corral to resume his pace of weight gain.
June 13th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes
Senate Democrats may have killed their chance to establish a multi-million dollar fund to compensate people who were sterilized under the Eugenics program. The House budget included over $10 million for a Eugenics Reserve Fund but the Senate spending plan didn’t include it. As the Senate debated it’s budget Sen. Clark Jenkins (D-Edgecombe) offered an amendment that would set up a Eugenics reserve of $11 million. The amendment however was tabled, technically making any such fund ineligible for further consider in the Senate. Senate rule 53 states “after an amendment has been tabled…the contents of such amendment or the principal provisions of its subject matter shall not be embodied in any other measure.” Techinically that means the Senate cannot consider a compromise budget worked out between the Senate and the House that contains a Eugenics reserve fund.
Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) confirmed that would be the case. He said the only way a fund could be considered is if the rules of the Senate were suspended to allow introduction of the issue. A majority of the Senate would have to vote to approve such a suspension.
Update: Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) released a statement saying the amendment offered by Sen. Jenkins was full of tax and spending increases besides the Eugenics fund. Berger said Republicans could not vote for the amendment.
Here’s the statement released through Sen. Berger’s office:
“The morally reprehensible action taken several decades ago by the North Carolina eugenics program is a tragic episode in our state’s history that must never be repeated. It is unfortunate that Democrats decided to politicize the issue of providing compensation by including it in a controversial amendment filled with tax hikes and spending increases they knew Republicans could not support. Under a longstanding rule (Rule 53) created during the Democrats’ leadership, the amendment’s failure now prohibits the Senate from considering compensation for eugenics victims in any other measure for the rest of this session.”
June 13th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes
This statement was made by Charlotte Mayor Anthony Foxx in response to the City Council’s bi-partisan rejection of an eight percent property tax increase: “We have just become like Washington, folks. Frankly, it’s disgusting.” Think about the irony of that comment. Last time I checked, Washington was having trouble making cuts. The Mayor also stated that the rejection was possibly, “the most irresponsible decision in council history.” That’s a bold statement, especially in response to a $1 billion capital plan.
The rejection by four Democrats and two Republicans was a responsible decision that avoided spending sprees on items such as a streetcar and a renovation of a sports center. Residents of the city came to public hearings prior to the vote to voice their opinion on this property tax increase. Charlotte residents realize that spending at that amount at a time when unemployment in North Carolina is at 9.4 percent is, to borrow the phrase, “the most irresponsible decision in council history.”
Spending cuts, responsible fiscal decisions, and response to public opinion: maybe Washington should be a little bit more like the Charlotte City Council. Mayor Foxx might want to hold off on the baseless accusations and listen to the people of his city.
A word to North Carolina citizens: stand up to your local governments. Let them know that fiscal responsibility is the only solution to achieve a prosperous society. Let them know that your money shouldn’t be wasted on pointless projects.
I applaud the Charlotte City Council. One step in the right direction.
June 12th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Education
State Senate Democrats focused their criticism on the education portion of the Senate spending plan drawn up by Republican leaders. The debate in the Senate Appropriations Committee Tuesday targeted raises for state employees versus letting local school districts decide if their teachers deserve raises. Under the Senate budget non-teaching state employees would receive a one point two percent raise. The plan would allot 84 million dollars to school districts and let administrators decide if teachers would get merit raises or use the funds for other purposes. Senator Martin Nesbitt (D- Asheville) said that would penalize teachers…
Senator Jerry Tillman (R-Randolph) said the Democrats would just go back to paying everyone the same without rewarding those who stood out…
For years when the Democrats controlled the General Assembly state employees complained that teachers were getting bigger raises as the state raced to reach the national average for teacher pay.
The House budget called for a one-time bonus of $250 for all state employees.
The budget passed by the Senate Appropriations Committee was just the Senate’s idea for a budget. It is common practice for both chambers to offer different versions so the areas in conflict can be worked out in a conference committee. That’s what will happen when the Senate plan gets back to the House this week.
June 6th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Economics, Legislative Activity
Despite Rep. Tom Murry’s (R-Wake) open acknowledgement of Civitas’s Bad Bill of the Week article about HB 1149 (New Market Jobs Act), he turned a blind eye to reason and espoused the bill’s virtues in a Commerce and Job Development House committee meeting earlier today.
The bill would provide a 7% tax credit on investments in small businesses after three years and an 8% tax credit each year for four additional years. In other words, the money has to be invested for a minimum of seven years for investors to receive the full amount of the tax credit, which cannot exceed $2 million per investor. Supporters of the bill call it a good plan because the state would only be giving $40 million of tax credit for every $500 million invested. What’s another $40 million anyway?
The bill, which was approved and will now be sent to the Finance Committee, was criticized in the meeting by Rep. Mike Stone (R-Harnet, Lee), who expressed concerns that the tax breaks would encourage bad investments. Rep. Stone also asked about the bankruptcy of a Chicago business, Protein Solutions, a meat-packing company that went bankrupt after receiveing tax credits from an Illinois statute identical to the one being proposed here.
Rep. Murry, along with an “expert” who spoke about the bills adopted in other states, directly addressed the concern over Protein Solutions. The argument in favor of the bill hinged on the idea that Protein Solutions’ plight was the result of the ongoing recession, not the fault of the tax credit plan. He also noted that the government was able to recollect the tax money and put it towards other business’s equity investments (which might also fail).
If you didn’t know any better you might think from these arguments the recession just magically happened and that there was nothing that could have been done to prevent it. You might even think that such businesses as Protein Solutions fail, not because they are bad businesses or because the market does not provide the demand for their product, but because they have no control over such economic hardships. This argument fails to realize, however, that the recession happened for a reason. It happened because of government policies exactly the same as the one supported by Rep. Murry and approved today by the House committee.
The housing bubble was caused by artificially low interest rates on loans, set by the Federal Reserve. Banks were encouraged to give loans to people who could not pay them back. A lot of people were able to live in nice homes who otherwise would never have gotten loans to purchase them and many of those homes were eventually foreclosed. HB 1149 would create an identical situation. The bill would allow investors to artificially lower the interest rates on high risk loans because government money (your money) would be insuring these reckless business ventures.
Many bad businesses would be supported, businesses that would fail in the free-market, while the owners of good businesses would get no benefit from such a program. In fact, their tax dollars would be going to support it. Many people think that it is unfair when small businesses have to close. It is more unfair when good businesses are forced to support bad ones. As Rep. Stone commented, when the government starts picking winners and losers, it “does a lousy job”.
June 5th, 2012 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Economics, Healthcare
US House Representative Paul Ryan (R-Wisconsin) stopped by Raleigh this morning for a brief breakfast with local business leaders. Ryan came to promote Mitt Romney’s economic message, while simultaneously criticizing the current president’s record on the economy.
Ryan noted that much of our nation’s economic trouble stems from an atmosphere of unpredictability and uncertainty in our nation’s capitol. The US House has drafted and passed a budget, but the US Senate has stubbornly refused to consider it. Ryan noted that this type of political game the Senate is playing harms business because business owners don’t know what to expect regarding taxes and regulations. A “wait and see” approach is embraced which naturally leads to economic stagnation.
On taxes, Ryan mentioned reform was greatly needed and that US tax rates should be competitive with other countries. His tax proposal would simplify the tax code. Tax rates would be set at 10 percent on income up to $100,000 for joint filers, and $50,000 for single filers; and 25 percent on taxable income above these amounts. He also noted the need for removing tax loopholes that deprive the government of funds.
Ryan also talked about healthcare. Regarding Medicaid reform, Ryan wants the federal government to issue block grants to states, allowing them flexibility in funding their Medicaid programs. Furthermore, the congressman hammered Obamacare and stated that the president’s ultimate goal with his healthcare monstrosity is to over-regulate the healthcare and insurance industries, burdening them in such a way that government-run alternatives look appealing.
It was good to see the congressman in Raleigh. He brought a clear, conservative message that our state and nation needs to hear during this this time of economic strife.