State Representative Paul Stam and several other Republicans have introduced HB41 to give families a tax credit if they want to put their children in charter schools or private schools. The credit would be $1250 for each of two semesters per year. A married couple would have to make under $100,000 per year to qualify. There are other restrictions, such as, the child can’t have spent any time in a public school during the semester.
Budget & Taxes
Tax credit proposed for education expenses outside of public schools
More debt can’t be a solution in the new budget
Several legislative budget subcommittees will meet next Tuesday to look at alternatives for filling a budget shortfall in the new spending plan. One solution Republican leaders probably won’t touch is increased debt to fill the hole. They in the past have complained about increased debt, especially the use of COPS to borrow more money without asking voters for permission. The COPS issue was the subject of a recent article by the Civitas Institute. The budget writers also have a warning from State Treasurer Janet Cowell. Her office released a report this week showing the state had exhausted its capacity to take on anymore debt.
“The annual analysis found that the state has exhausted its General Fund debt capacity until fiscal year 2013. Additionally, the combined debt capacity of the Highway Fund and the Highway Trust Fund has been more than utilized until fiscal year 2014.”
The report also points out liabilites the budget writers will have to consider:
“These liabilities include: the unfunded portion of retiree health care benefits, which totaled $32.8 billion as of December 31, 2009; the $2.15 billion to the U.S. Treasury for funds borrowed to make unemployment benefit payments; and the failure to fund the annual required contribution rate to the Retirement Systems that will result in an increase to the State’s net pension obligation. Although these liabilities do not impact the calculation of debt capacity, they may have a negative impact on the bond ratings.”
Recently the state’s triple-A bond rating was reaffirmed.
A closer look at UNC finances
Has the economy put North Carolina’s largest public colleges and universities on shaky financial footing? Not so, says a recent article in Triangle Business Journal (subscription required). The article reviewed recent state audits of North Carolina State University, East Carolina University and UNC-Chapel Hill. It found:
Despite lean times in Raleigh, state contributions to all three institutions actually rose in fiscal 2010, as lawmakers continued to fund growth.
At UNC the state contribution figure inched higher by a mere .6 percent, to $542 million. NCSU fared better with a 23 percent increase to $472 million, while at ECU, state appropriations rose by 9 percent, to $263 million.
Despite the current gloom and doom, the audits suggest all three institutions are weathering the downturn — and even prospering. So much for conventional wisdom.
State Senate tentatively approves $800 million in savings and cuts for current budget
While the Governor asked permission to cut $400 million from the current budget SB13 goes much further by finding another $400 million in savings. That includes transferring money from several funds including the Golden LEAF, the business incentive fund, and the Governor’s One North Carolina fund. Republican Senator Richard Stevens said the transfers involved money that was unencumbered. Over $67 million would be taken from the Golden LEAF Fund but Stevens says the fund had over $550 million in the bank. Democratic Senator Doug Berger offered an amendment to stop the transfers saying the funds were needed for job recruitment. Stevens countered there was plenty of money left. GOP Senator Bob Rucho said the small net number of jobs created didn’t justify some of the huge tax credits. Berger’s amendment was defeated. Democratic Senator Dan Clodfelter told the chamber lawmakers shouldn’t give up the authority to make cuts to the Governor because they were elected to make the tough choices. The bill was tentatively approved intact but faces one more vote on Monday evening (Feb 7) before going to the House.
Purdue to State Senate: “Hands Off My Corporate Welfare!”
Big surprise – the Governor doesn’t want to cede control over millions of taxpayer dollars she uses to bribe corporations so that her office can issue a press release declaring she is “doing something to create jobs.” I’ve written before about this practice of crony capitalism, and how it consolidates more power into the hands of the ruling elite and away from consumers. Moreover, political meddling in the market process hampers growth and the net result is actually fewer jobs.
Moreover, the objections over diverting some money away from Golden LEAF is highly uninformed. Golden LEAF offers nothing unique, and is extremely redundant in its efforts. It is also an unaccountable organization headed by a group of political cronies. You can see a list of some of Golden LEAF’s “economic development” efforts here– which include funds for the Randy Parton Theatre, Teapot Dome Museum and bee trainers.
The practice of corporate welfare, which involves politicians handing out special privileges to politically-connected firms, is widely despised by members of the public and policy shops spanning all ends of the political spectrum. The one group of people still quite fond of the practice is politicians (and of course the recipients of the goodies). Politicians love the ribbon-cutting ceremony and taking credit for “creating jobs,” but are nowhere to be seen when their chosen projects go belly-up. More importantly, they fail to see damaging effects inflicted on those firms forced to compete against companies that have been granted political privilege, and therefore an unfair advantage.
Senate Republicans save twice as much as Governor requested
State Senate Republicans have gone beyond the $400 million the Governor wanted authority to cut in the current budget. The Appropriations Committee passed SB 13 that would give the Governor permission to cut up to 5% in the current budget. But they didn’t stop there. Below is a list of the cuts that add up to $800 million:
Changes to the 2010-11 Availability Statement
Information Technology Fund 1,000,000
Information Technology Fund (Internal Service Fund) 7,586,800
Information Technology Services -Wireless Fund 5,000,000
Cap Cancer Research Fund (Maintains $50 million in the Fund) 4,700,000
Correction Enterprises 3,000,000
One North Carolina 5,208,333
Agriculture and Consumer Services Special Funds 1,500,000
Farmland Preservation Trust Fund 1,800,000
Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) Commission 950,000
Industrial Development Utility 2,500,000
Job Development Investment Grants (JDIG) 3,000,000
Soil and Water Conservation Special Funds-(Conservation Reserve
Enhancement Program) 500,000
Aquariums Special Fund 1,500,000
Parks and Recreational Trust Fund 8,500,000
Industrial Commission (over realized receipts) 1,000,000
E-Commerce Reserve 4,630,891
General Assembly Reserve 1,901,522
Department of Insurance Reserve 1,150,693
Wildlife Resources Commission (Increase Transfer) 5,000,000
Subtotal Cash Balance Transfers To the General Fund $ 60,428,239
Golden Leaf Funds (Section 4) 67,563,760
Health and Wellness Trust Funds (Section 5) 11,648,800
Tobacco Trust Funds (Section 6) 2,800,000
Subtotal $ 82,012,560
Total 2010-11 Availability Adjustments (Senate Bill 13) $142,440,799
Session Law 2010-123 (2010 Budget Bill) Unappropriated Balance $ 22,768,282
Revised Balance Remaining $ 165,209,081
FY 2009-10 Reversions (Senate Bill 13 – Section 2) $ 400,000,000
Year-End Credit Balance FY 2009-10* $ 236,902,393
Total Other Items $ 636,902,393
Total From All Sources $ 802,111,474
*The size of the credit balance is a result of the early receipt of federal funds, and may be impacted by potential repayment of those funds.
Balanced Budget Act of 2011 – Proposed Committee Substitute S13
Other Items (No Impact to the 2009-10 Availability Statement)
Senate Appropriations Committee
February 2nd, 2011
Restoring Fiscal Responsibility
Today’s Durham Herald-Sun includes my piece discussing two items I believe should be at the top of state lawmakers’ priority list. A slice:
If the new majority is serious about controlling spending they will first adopt what is commonly known as a Taxpayer Bill of Rights, or TABOR. The basic premise of a TABOR is to tie the annual growth of state spending to equal the rate of inflation plus population growth.
…
If such a built-in spending restraint had been in place during the past few years — instead of desperately grasping at billion-dollar tax hikes and billions more in federal stimulus funds — North Carolina budget writers would have been asking “what budget gap?”
…
The second piece of legislation desperately needed to get North Carolina’s fiscal house in order is a legal requirement to ensure that all new state debt receives voter approval. Thanks to a funding mechanism known as Certificates of Participation (COPs), the state has been able to circumvent voter approval for new state debt since 2000.
Unsurprisingly, without this accountability measure North Carolina’s state debt has exploded. Per-capita state debt has more than doubled in less than a decade, annual payments to pay down the debt have more than tripled, and the State Treasurer’s Office has warned that the state’s bond rating is in jeopardy if it continues to skirt voter approval for new debt.
Certainly, an examination of North Carolina’s long-term spending growth suggests there needs to be some legally-imposed restraint put upon the spending appetites of state lawmakers. They surely haven’t proven they can restrain themselves.
Furthermore, the idea of issuing state debt without consent of the voters (the very ones who will have to pay back the debt) is insulting. Lacking any accountability, state lawmakers have embarked on a reckless borrowing spree – even during years the state was raking in billions in surplus revenue.
Both of these measures would only be effective as amendments to the state constitution – which would mean they would ultimately be decided on a vote of the people. Past Civitas Institute poll results indicate strong public support for both of these measures. The Dec. 2009 poll revealed that voters supported a TABOR amendment by a margin of 54% to 24%. And when asked in the May 2008 poll, a whopping 77% of respondents said the General Assembly should not be allowed to issue new state debt without voter approval, compared to only 14% who said they should be allowed.
More on Yesterday’s Budget Overview at the General Assembly
Following up on Matt’s summary on yesterday’s Joint Committee on Appropriations review of the Fiscal Research Divisions presentation of their updated General Fund Outlook.
A few findings of note:
- Revenue collections so far this fiscal year are on target. However, most of the uncertainty of the revenue projections falls in the last half of the fiscal year (the state’s fiscal year runs from June 1 to July 31).
- Perhaps it is this remaining uncertainty that inspired the filing of Senate Bill 13 which would authorize the Governor to hold back $400 million from the current year’s budget
- State spending items growing at the fastest rate over the last decade are Debt Service (200% increase) and Medicaid (95% increase)
- During that time, the Medicaid caseload grew by 62.6%
The report also touches on the amount the state spends on employee compensation and benefits. General Fund supported payroll exceeds $11 billion annually – and that number does not include extra salary expenditures like premium pay for overtime. Adding in almost $2 billion more for state contributions to the pension system and FICA taxes brings the total to about $13 billion. Moreover, the taxpayers’ bill for fully subsidizing state employees and retirees enrollment onto the State Health Plan comes to about $1.6 billion annually (according to Fiscal Research estimates).
All told, paying for state workers and retirees costs taxpayers roughly $14.6 billion. In the context of an $18.96 billion budget, that comes to 77 cents out of every taxpayer dollar in the General Fund that is dedicated to supporting state workers and retirees.
On a related note, from 2001 to 2009, North Carolina added nearly 35,000 state government workers to its payroll. Moreover, the state faces an unfunded liability of $33 billion for state retiree health benefits – a number up by 38% in just four years and will continue to grow as long as state lawmaker continue to neglect any proactive measures.
State budget writers told economy is rebounding but another year until robust growth
Members of a joint legislative budget panel were told by fiscal researchers revenue collections are on target but still below what is estimated for a new budget. Here’s what the budget writers will have to consider for budget increases:
$300 million for retirement pensions
$150 million more for the State Health Plan
$110 million in enrollment growth for K-12 and colleges
$200 million growth in Medicaid expenses
It was estimated the revenue would be nearly $4 billion short without cuts or new revenue. The new Republican leadership is vowing to make deep cuts to avoid raising taxes. The fiscal staff gave the members what they called “opportunities for change.” They included increasing tuition at the colleges. In fact, the universities are likely to ask for a 6% increase. Budget writers could eliminate or reduce optional Medicaid services, such as prescription drugs or non-physician services. The members were told they could make changes in the Department of Correction as well. For example, they could reduce sentences for misdemeanants or habitual felons. They could also reform probation policies so there would be fewer revocations. There is also $1.5 billion in borrowing that although authorized has not been spent. What fiscal staff did not touch was the subject of layoffs, which the leadership and the Governor have said would be part of balancing act. The budget writers will also have to consider transportation needs and a rainy day fund. Then there is the $2.6 billion the state borrowed from the federal government for unemployment payments. A 4% interest payment on that will come due at the end of September.
Here is a link to the fiscal power point
Senate Bill Takes Action to Reduce State Budget
The Balanced Budget Act of 2011 (S13), filed last night, would give the governor power to take “all action necessary to reduce General Fund expenditures for the remainder of fiscal year 2010-2011.” Under the bill, the governor’s goal will be to reduce the current year budget by $400 million. Sen. Phil Berger will likely discuss the Senate bill at his 9:30am press conference this morning. According to Sen. Berger, the bill will likely be heard in committee this week and on the Senate floor as early as Thursday.