Sen. Charlie Dannelly (D-Mecklenburg) has the dubious distinction of being the primary sponsor of the budget bill for fiscal year 2010-11. Read the bill, SB897, and the money report. For the first time since 2003, the annual budget was passed prior to the start of the fiscal year. Perhaps lawmakers should have been more concerned about correcting some of our long-term fiscal issues and less concerned about getting out of town on time.
Budget & Taxes
Civitas Bad Bill of the Week: SB897
Tax Hikes, Stimulus Funds Helped Fuel Half a Billion Spending Increase in FY 2009-10
The Office of State Controller has posted its General Fund Monthly Financial Report for June; which is significant because it contains year-end summaries for actual revenue collections and expenditures for the 2009-10 fiscal year. Some notable data includes:
- Tax revenue collections totalled $17.7 billion for FY 2009-10, compared to the budgeted amount of $18.05 billion.
- Tax revenues were up from the 2008-09 total of $16.8 billion, due largely to the tax increases
- Total budgeted spending came to $18.5 billion according to the report, compared to the budgeted $19.01 billion
- The spending amount, however, does not reflect the roughly $1.7 billion in stimulus funds used to backfill state programs. Adding in that spending brings the total to $20.2 billion for 2009-10
- Actual spending for FY 2008-09 was $19.65 billion, meaning that spending on state programs in 2009-10 was up by $550 million year-over-year
- The total spending budgeted for the current 2010-11 fiscal year comes to $20.6 billion. If revenues are sufficient to enable that level of spending, then that would mark a year-over-year increase in spending of $400 million over total spending for 2009-10.
- Lastly, if the state does spend the entire $20.6 billion this year, it would be a two-year increase of nearly a billion dollars over 2008-09 actual spending
New Interactive Legislative Pay Graph
Civitas is proud to release a new tool for visualizing the pay of the North Carolina General Assembly. With it you can see at a glance not only how much your legislator is paid relative to others, but the breakdown of what that money was for. You can also narrow it down to house or senate only and Republican or Democrat only, and sort it by any of the numbers for easy comparison. The numbers are just for 2009 at this point, but as more years pass, more years will be available.
So how much does your legislator make? Head on over to Carolinatransparency.com/disbursements and try it out!
Big Surprise: Home Sales Drop After Tax Credit Expires
In one of the most predictable events in history, home sales in the U.S. have dropped dramatically since the expiration of the home buyer tax credit.
Sales of previously occupied homes fell to the lowest level in 15 years last month as the economy weakened.
The National Association of Realtors says July’s sales fell by more than 27 percent to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.83 million. It was the largest monthly drop on records dating back to 1968.
Home sales picked up in the spring when the government was offering tax credits. But the market has struggled since the tax credits expired on April 30.
The credit was a nice temporary giveaway to the realtor and home builder lobbies, but terrible for the economy. Now that the credit has expired, home sales will once again continue their downward decent. Those that bought a home and redeemed the credit will quickly see the value of their credit evaporate as the value of the home they recently purchased will plunge.
And because these home buyer tax credits weren’t “paid for” by reductions in federal government spending. taxpayers are footing the bill for a massive boondoggle to major special interests, and whose benefit to the home buyers themselves will vanish in mere months as housing values drop.
It will also be interesting to track over the next several years how many of the people who purchased a home courtesy of the credit will end up in foreclosure.
As usual, government intervention into the marketplace will leave economic destruction and chaos in its wake.
In What Part of NC is Lake Wobegon?
In the fictional town of Lake Wobegon, “all the women are strong, all the men are good looking, and all the children are above average.”
As noted in this N&O article, it appears that the North Carolina state government workforce is suffering from the Lake Wobegon effect:
Rest assured taxpayers: State employees, almost to a person, meet or exceed expectations.
A 2008 report and a follow-up audit released Thursday claim that the state’s system of performance reviews is often pointless since ratings are inflated and offer no real incentive to spur improvement.
The 2-year-old report from the Office of State Personnel, presented to the legislature, found that less than 1 percent of some 98,000 workers subject to personnel laws were rated as working below expectations. The report concluded those results were “inflated.” And since the legislature has awarded raises on an across-the-board basis in recent years, the reviews are irrelevant when it comes to pay.
…..
Wood’s office sampled appraisals and found that among 697 reviews examined in the Department of Correction, none included measurable criteria upon which to judge employees. And in the few cases when employees fell below expectations, reviews included no plans for improvement or consequences for continued substandard performance, auditors found.
“Saving” Jobs Means Destroying Wealth
State Representative Pryor Gibson (D-Anson) a couple of years ago declared that it was in the state’s best economic interest to “save” jobs, “even if they’re making buggy whips.” Such a ridiculous statement not only earned Gibson scorn from Civitas staffers, it exposed a broader mindset among politicians that “saving” jobs is somehow conducive to economic growth.
But saving jobs through political means, as this Freeman article points out, stands in the way of economic progress.
Let’s make the obvious point first: Creating jobs is easy, but it’s nothing to be proud of. In fact, destroying jobs is the real path to wealth.
To use an example I’ve used before: One way to create jobs on a big construction project is to take away the machines that dig out the foundation, and limit the workers to shovels. Or better yet, spoons. That will create lots of jobs. But that is not progress. Using more labor than needed to get the job done costs wealth. Better to use the machinery and free up all the shovel- and spoon-toting workers to produce output in addition to the foundation. By the same logic, we could create lots of jobs by destroying all the farm machinery. Surely, though, we would not be richer for doing so.
…..
Saving jobs means putting the engine of human creativity in neutral if not reverse. The healthiest economies are those that consistently destroy jobs by inventing new and better ways to satisfy existing human wants with less and less labor, while freeing other labor to satisfy new and not-yet-dreamed-of wants.
Remember this point when you hear about the North Carolina General Assembly’s next targeted tax credit or corporate welfare giveaway scheme. Such policies merely serve to freeze in place the state’s economy, impeding the dynamic process by which new and more efficient means of production and innovation of new products are discovered. By propping up certain companies and industries through political favors such as tax breaks and handouts, state lawmakers are in fact not helping the economy grow, but rather creating a roadblock to progress.
Class Envy Rhetoric Hurts the Poor
Gene Nichol, a professor of law at the UNC School of Law, and director of UNC-Chapel Hill’s Center on Poverty, Work & Opportunity continues the N&O’s promotion of economic fallacies with this article in which he advocates for ending the Bush-era tax cuts on the highest income earners.
Much of the article is diluted with Nichol’s stale, thoughtless, envy-driven class warfare demagoguing and as such is devoid of any true economic analysis. But he attempts to assure readers that taxing the most productive participants in the economy is somehow good for growth and job creation:
a recent study from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office … examined 11 options to stimulate growth and job creation. The report found not only that that making the tax cuts permanent would dramatically increase the long-term deficit; it was the worst proffered option to nudge the economy forward. Extending unemployment benefits, staunching state budget cuts and providing job-creating tax credits would generate at least three times as much additional economic activity as retaining the top tax rates.
What Nichols fails to account for, however, is that CBO studies like this one include the assumption that government spending is the key to economic recovery and growth. So naturally the study will recommend government spending, because that conclusion was already determined beforehand, the “study” is just for show.
Nichols then reveals his true Keynesian colors with this line:
The poor and near-poor will spend every cent they can get hold of. Those making over $250,000 will be far more apt to save the proceeds. If the rationale is job creation, the Republicans seem to have it backwards.
In reality, it is Nichols whose rationale is backwards. The foundation for his reasoning is the easily discredited notion that consumer spending is the key to economic growth. To the contrary, ups and downs in consumer spending are the result of, not the cause of, economic booms and busts. It is investment spending that determines the economy’s fate.
Without an adequate pool of real savings to provide productive investment spending, the economy will stagnate. Those most harmed by stagnant or backward economic progress are those at the margins of employment – the low-skilled and low-income population. Unfortunately, the policies that Nichols champions have devastating results for the very people he claims to want to help through his work at the UNC Center on Poverty, Work and Opportunity. If he was truly interested in reducing poverty, Nichols would do some economic homework and understand how economies grow, thus actually providing work and opportunity to our state’s poorest citizens.
With misguided people like Nichols guiding anti-poverty efforts in the state, there is little wonder why North Carolina’s poverty rate has climbed steadily in the last decade.
Idle Resources Excuse Doesn’t Validate Stimulus Spending
Defenders of economic “stimulus” schemes insist that during a recession,government must step in to get idle resources working again. Spending on anything, anywhere will put idle resources such as labor and equipment back to work, so the theory goes.
But such crude, superstitious notions overlook (among many) an important point. As economist Steven Horwitz reminds us, capital is not homogeneous. That is, workers are trained to perform certain tasks and most machinery is designed for very specific purposes – to be performed with specific complimentary inputs.
One of the gravest sins of modern economics is its tendency to treat resources, both capital and labor, as essentially homogenous aggregates. Capital is more or less interchangeable with other capital, and labor is treated much the same. One reason for this is that such homogeneity and aggregation make mathematical modeling much more tractable, as well as making it easier to engage in econometric studies. But these assumptions can lead to major conceptual errors that matter for policy.
The problem with this is that it assumes that the idled labor and capital will be equally productive no matter where the additional spending takes place. That is, it is treating resources like lumps of clay that can be shaped into whatever form is needed to produce the goods demanded from the rise in spending. The problem is that resources are not clay. Both people and machines are more productive at some things than others, and are not productive at all at quite a number of things.
It is this mindset of indiscriminate “pump priming” that leads to government expenditures on projects such as preserving dead bug collections and administering cocaine to monkeys. But was there a glut of idle university scientific researchers amid the fallout of the housing market crash? Of course not, and thus randomly throwing money into the economy is not a harmless stimulant to economic activity.
Defenders, of course, will then argue that the stimulus spending at least gets money in the hands of those university researchers – money that they will then spend to stimulate the economy.
But let’s not forget that the government must first remove capital (through borrowing) from the economy in order to finance stimulus spending – leaving less money for entrepreneurs to productively invest in profit-seeking ventures as producers attempt to realign their production to the preferences of consumers. This process is especially damaging in light of the fact that it is investment, not consumer, spending that drives economic growth.
Saving jobs that haven’t been lost
Interesting how we’re now learning that the $300 million in federal money North Carolina is receiving to save teacher jobs might not be used to save teacher jobs. Why? The massive layoffs many school districts feared haven’t materialized.
Officials from the governor’s office spent yesterday trying to figure out how the money could be spent. As usual, there was no shortage of answers. The idiocy in this scenario is that the money needs to be spent — even when the need is different than originally envisioned.
With next year’s budget deficit projected to be around $3 billion is it too much to expect restraint and forethought? Ever wonder why our national debt is $13.3 trillion.
State Health Plan Update: Still in Bad Shape
Today’s meeting of the Committee on Employee Hospital and Medical Benefits included a financial update of the State Health Plan (SHP). Among the highlights:
- For FY 2009-10 recently completed, the SHP had a net loss of $42.7 million – meaning that it paid out nearly $43 million more than it collected in revenue from premiums, co-pays, etc. Remember, most of the SHP premiums are paid by the state courtesy of your tax dollars. The $42.7 million loss was lessened in part by $52 million in premiums being prepaid – out of the rapidly sinking state retirement system.
- Updated projections for the current fiscal year 2010-11 that started July 1 suggest total expenses for the Plan to be $52 million higher than allotted in the state budget – where will that money come from?
- Estimates for the 2011-13 biennium include a 10.7% premium increase each year, putting heavy upward pressure on funding requirements
- The premium increases are projected to require an additional $717 million total in funding over the 2011-13 biennium, $572 million for General Fund supported employees alone. Most of this additional burden will necessarily be borne by taxpayers.
Something’s got to give with the State Health Plan – soon. The State Health Plan’s unsustainable condition just further reminds us of the growing divide between North Carolina’s haves and have-nots.