Here’s why. And here. And here, too.
-Max Borders
Economics
Minimum Wage: Still a Terrible Idea
Gas Prices: Bicycle! Bicycle!
As China comes online thereby increasing the demand for gas (thus raising gas prices), Americans are turning to their old friend the bicycle. A strange role-reversal, indeed.
So, if people are riding bikes and driving more fuel efficient cars, why are environmentalists griping about oil prices/profits? Bicycle! Bicycle!
-Max Borders
Gas Prices: Harmless Holiday
Brian Caplan has a great NYTimes piece on why the Clinton/McCain gas tax holiday is a relatively harmless symbolic gesture in a sea of possible bad policy options:
The first is that the tax holiday is a relatively cheap symbolic gesture that makes truly bad policies less likely. The main causes of high gas prices are probably factors beyond our control, like rapid growth in China and India and low real interest rates. But voters don’t want to hear this; they want politicians to “do something!”
During our last big energy crisis, in the 1970s, “something” turned out to be a salad of populist nonsense: price controls, rationing, windfall profits taxes, arcane loopholes and lots of lawsuits. That political response turned an inconvenience into a disaster.
We can do better this time. Since in an election year Congress will feel compelled to show the voters that it feels their pain, let’s do something that at least keeps energy markets in good working order. The tax holiday fits the bill. Markets will adjust to it, no problem. And it won’t cost much — the estimated $9 billion in lost revenue is about $30 per person. That’s not a bad price to pay for a little insurance against a rerun of misguided ’70s measures.
I’m glad they’re letting some free-market "fundamentalists" into the NYTimes lately. Tyler Cowen, Brian Caplan and Alex Tabarrok are such a refreshing antedote to the incessant Krugmania we usually see.
-Max Borders
Down, Doomsayer
Great article from the Denver Post on chicken littles and economic demogoguery:
As market strategist Ed Yardeni (hat tip
to U.S. World and News Report) claimed, "this profits recession is very
much limited to the Financials sector and the Homebuilding industry
. . . . Removing these two reveals that profits rose 15.9 percent in Q4
and around 12.0 percent during Q1. The resilience of ‘core’ profits and
of the economy in the face of the worst credit crisis since the 1930s
is impressive indeed."
That kind of perspective is, typically, lacking in economic
coverage. Take, for instance, the housing crisis. It is real. It is
painful. Yet more Americans own their own homes now than ever before.
Those evil corporate warlords who had the audacity to offer
low-interest mortgages put millions of families that otherwise would
never have been able to afford it into homes. Only a fraction risk
losing their investment.
And speaking of doomsaying, Boston’s NPR affiliate is lamenting the lack of jobs for teens during the downturn. Professor Boudreaux explains that minimum wage laws are largely to blame:
I listened to your segment documenting teenagers’ struggle to find
summer jobs (May 2). Several times you asked why teens are suffering
this difficulty, but not once did you mention, as a possible
explanation, the higher minimum wage.
The economic theory (and much evidence) of how minimum-wage legislation
affects employment explains remarkably well the patterns you document.
Teenagers have few skills, so their value to employers is low. It is
precisely such low-skilled workers who are priced out of the job market
by minimum-wage legislation. In addition, the fact that the teens
having the hardest time finding jobs are minority kids from inner
cities is also explained by economics: by creating a surplus of
low-skilled workers, the minimum-wage encourages employers to
discriminate in favor of white suburban kids and against minority
youths.
The government reaps what it sows.
-Max Borders
Government Jobs: Broken Windows Fallacy
This is the saddest thing I’ve read in a long time. The worst is the quote from Mike Walden, an economist at N.C. state who actually does stuff for JLF!
"Government jobs are an important cushion for the economy when the private sector falters," says North Carolina State University economist Michael Walden. Huh? Somebody please take away this man’s Keynesian crackpipe.
Perhaps they took Mike out of context, but Lordy Lord, surely he knows about deadweight loss and the broken windows fallacy.
There was a light of reason in the article, on these dim circumstances of public sector growth:
"More hiring has nothing to do with good government or economic policy," says economist Kenneth Brown, research director at the Rio Grande Foundation in Albuquerque. "It has everything to do with government being slow to react to economic change." (HT: Hayes)
-Max Borders
Subprime Crisis: A Reasonable Post-Mortem
General hysterics about the subprime fallout and associated calls for government intervention make perfect demogoguery fodder for pundits, presidential candidates and economic illiterates. But if you’ve been looking for an intellectually honest, well-researched and thorough post mortem? Here’s your paper.
Zywicki and Adamson not only caution us not to regulate away the aspects of the mortgage lending system that enabled millions of people to own homes at all, but not to forget the checkered history that lead up to crisis and helped to create it. In other words, blame is to be apportioned evenly among government regulators, the fed, lenders and borrowers themselves. The point of regulation going forward should not be to bail out irresponsible lenders or create impeditments to ownership, but help lenders correctly to gauge risk and to ensure abuses by either party are curbed.
The authors ask reasonable questions about the "optimum" level of foreclosure, and caution us not to forget the types of speculative investments that count among the foreclosures.In short, this is a rich complicated account written by talented economists. But it’s a breath of fresh air compared to what you read in the papers.
-Max Borders
Gas Prices: Why So High?
Here’s a great econ 101 lesson on gas prices. I’d like to know why the water companies haven’t been hauled before Congress and accused of price gouging.
-Max Borders
Krugman: Two Ripostes
With a recession nigh or here, we should expect the demogogues and the government pundits to start sounding off. But the Don Boudreauxs of the world will be there to check their reasoning:
#1 Paul Krugman repeats the refrain that the economy for ordinary Americans is a shambles ("Crisis of Confidence," April 14). I’m doubtful, but will here assume that he’s correct about this matter. What conclusion are we to draw?
Rather than conclude (as Mr. Krugman does) that this problem reflects a need for higher taxes and greater government control over the economy, why not conclude the opposite? At no time since Mr. Krugman’s imagined Golden Age of the 1970s has Uncle Sam’s budget been severely reduced. Indeed, inflation-adjusted spending on programs such as Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid have consistently risen since then. During the past three decades, some welfare programs have been scaled back, while others have been expanded and even newly created. We now have, as we did not prior to the 1970s, cabinet-level departments to regulate energy, education, veterans affairs, and homeland security. Some regulations have been repealed, while others have been created at both the state and national levels.
Weren’t FDR’s New Deal and LBJ’s Great Society – most of which programs remain with us today – supposed to make life better for ordinary Americans? If Mr. Krugman’s factual claim about the state of the economy is correct, these programs clearly have failed.
#2 Arguing that today’s economy is "considerably worse" than official data suggests, Paul Krugman notes that "The official unemployment rate may be relatively low – but the percentage of prime-working-age Americans without jobs, which isn’t the same thing, is historically high" ("Crisis of Confidence," April 14).
Sounds awful, for Mr. Krugman here implies that Americans between the ages of 25 and 54 have more difficulty finding jobs today than they did even during the Great Depression. But this implication fails the smell test. There are many reasons why some prime-working-age people are without jobs – reasons having nothing to do with being unemployed. Retirees are without jobs; many full-time students are without jobs; stay-at-home parents are without jobs. Contrary to Mr. Krugman’s suggestion, perhaps the economy is trending so remarkably WELL, over the long run, that more and more people remain in school longer and retire earlier, a luxury much less affordable in the past."
-Max Borders
Government Doesn’t Create Jobs
…it creates poverty.
According to (yet another) editorial in the Raleigh News & Observer, government should do what it can to help the poor.
The Good Book famously says that we’ll always have the poor, and no sense arguing with so authoritative a source. But a just society that has the financial power should do all it can to reduce the number of people in poverty’s grip.
So what can the government do? Get out of the way.
Not a dime in welfare benefits or any other program exists without being parasitic on the free actions of individuals in the marketplace — which is also the source of economic growth. Therefore, government must not only learn it’s place, but not kill the goose that lays the golden eggs.
It must also not create incentives for poor people to remain in subsistence poverty. There will be less upward mobility if being poor is easy (i.e. subsidized). There is also no justice in the persistent notion that the "just society" must mean government action. A society is nothing more than an agglomeration of individual actors. And, by the way, those that read the "Good Book" realize that moral responsibility for charity is a personal. It doesn’t not fall on you from Heaven on tax day. So let’s get beyond this idea that bureaucrats should take from A to give to B in the name of justice. No one will get to Heaven by moral proxies in Raleigh or Washington.
Remember, every dime the government spends on this program or that is a dime you can’t spend on the causes you think are most worthy. THEY say compulsory compassion via government monopoly. I say personal passion for social entreneurship in a dynamic market for doing good. Sadly, who’s right comes down to who has the bigger guns.
-Max Borders
Gas Prices: If You’re Thinking Price Controls…
Remember what happens when prices don’t reflect scarcity.
-Max Borders