Time to give up corporate welfare. Chris Hayes, I’m sure, hates to say he told ya so, but…
-Max Borders
Economics
Economic Incentives: Told Ya
On Pessimism and Not Repeating Depression-Era Policies
Don Boudreaux reminds people to ignore the pessimism coming from "progressive" circles — those who would take the mildest economic downturn and use it to justify more government intervention in the economy (intervention that is largely responsible for boom/bust cycles). Boudreaux suggests folks read Bryan Caplan’s Myth of the Rational Voter which every thinking person should use to temper the "Pessimistic bias" one of five major biases that plague non-economists and poor Naomi Klein. Here’s a slice:
"Russ [Roberts] and myself (because we’re economists?) and many of the commentors here at the Cafe are not pessimistic about the long-run. Problems come; problems are solved. Inability to see the details of the future scare many people; this inability doesn’t scare me. As long as individuals have a sufficient quantum of freedom, their self-interest and creativity and inevitable competition will "solve" almost any problem over the long-haul. It’s a pattern repeated countless times over the past two-hundred years in capitalist countries. (Please, please don’t trot out the Great Depression as a counter-example. First, it was clearly worsened by the Federal Reserve’s catastrophically bad monetary policy, and by the worldwide spread of protectionism — helped along by the Smoot-Hawley tariff. More importantly, there’s compelling evidence that the risks of full-throttle socialization of the economy were then real enough to scare investors away until the mid-1940s. And even this greatest of all of America’s depressions lasted only ten or fifteen years, depending on how you define the end of the Depression.)"
I’ve pointed to a lot of bad editorializing recently (from the N&O in particular) and would recommend Cafe Hayek as a daily dose and The Myth of the Rational Voter as an antidote to these horrible rehashings of your junior high textbook on the Depression and progressive-era thinking. Been there, done that.
-Max Borders
Journalists do Econ Redux
Here’s what happens when kids who grow up getting overdoses of revisionist depression-era history written by liberal non-economists in the public schools. They write this when they grow up and become journalists (read: not economists):
It’s safe to assume President Bush and his advisers wince at that description, since it calls to mind another Republican president, Herbert Hoover, whose free-market, time-will-tell, all-things-run-in-cycles attitude helped plunge the United States into financial catastrophe.
First of all, the republican/democrat distinction was totally different in those days. So trying to paint republicans as any kind of caricature of today is totally off the mark. Also, Herbert Hoover was not a free-marketeer at all. While you may have heard this in junior high because FDR did so many zany things in the name of regulation, this characterization of Hoover is completely false. In fact, they called him the "engineer" and he certainly thought he could engineer the economy. He simply got out engineered by FDR who ended up making things much worse, not improving anything as your progressive textbook would have you believe. Business cycles are largely the result of fed policy and regulation (read: intervention), not the other way around. Read this for a good history of the Depression. And read this to see why "engineering" the economy a la Hoover or FDR or the Fed causes crests and troughs, booms and busts.
But the N&O gets worse in its editorializing on economic matters:
For while it’s true that individuals must use good judgment in their financial affairs, and surely some didn’t when taking out their troubled mortgages, for one example, the free-and-easy regulatory system contributed to making it easier for them to get themselves in trouble. And to obtain their mortgages, after all, they didn’t rob banks. They applied for loans that somebody approved.
The free-and-easy regulatory system? Try the free and easy pressure by "progressives" HUD and other agencies for mortgage lenders and other institutions to push loans onto high risk populations. Let’s also remember that government interventions and bailouts yield more profligacy and risky behavior, not less, because the market is stern with punishment and people learn from their failures. Government is simply trying to legislate away risk. I’m weary of the media fifth column calling for the government to be our mommies and daddies when it comes to economic matters–particularly that of people AND lenders who were irresponsible. Success and failure are two sides of the same coin when it comes to creating wealth. N&O’s economically ill-informed editorializing contributes to terrible myths about the supposed social benefits of government paternalism — ideas that have thoroughly been discredited.
This media narrative of markets as enemy is getting old and tired. It’s spun by people who have absolutely no authority to speak on such matters. Their proposals are completely counterproductive.
-Max Borders
When Journalists Comment on Economic Matters
…you get stuff like this. First, the N&O says:
The Bush era has been for businesses of all kinds sort of like a rebirth of the "free love" movement of the 1960s. Anything goes.
But is this true?
The slightest investigation into regulations would reveal that it is a non-partisan phenomenon and the regulatory state expandes with pretty much any administration. If anything, the Bush Administration has been as reg-crazy as any other, so to characterize it as "free love," means they were more interested in evoking the cute analogy than actually looking into the expansion of the federal register.
The less-than-informed commenters at the N&O would also do well to think outside the regulatory box when it comes to achieving regulatory outcomes. The common law, which is more distributed, precise, and less likely to bring about unintended consequences, is preferable than letting college-grad hill staffers craft legs that uninformed pols simply sign off on for political reasons.
In any case, is the Bush Administration anti-regulation? If anything, they – via the OMB- have made cost-benefit analysis and scrutiny of regs a higher priority, but they have not slowed the growth of the regulatory state to any appreciable degree. A shred of investigation would reveal that regulators regulate — D or R. More investigation would reveal that regulations have very high social costs that these articles are pretty flippant about. Facts straight, please.
-Max Borders
Bailouts: Bad, whether Big Guys or Little
Russ Roberts hits a home run with with NPR piece on the Bear Stearns and (likely future) mortgage bailouts:
Yes, letting Bear Stearns go under would have been dangerous. But helping JP Morgan devour Bear Stearns is dangerous, too. Where does the government stop in protecting people from irresponsibility? Home owners and lenders are next. The political pressure is inexorable for some sort of bail out. And then comes more regulation of investment banks.
In a world where people who make bad decisions are spared the full consequences, only one thing is certain. We’ve encouraged more people to make more bad decisions in the future. The real price to be paid isn’t the dollar costs of any bail out but the encouragement of recklessness and irresponsibility. That will make all of us poorer down the road.
-Max Borders
Minimum Wage: A Bad Idea that Won’t Go Away
More spurious labor economics from our friends at the Progressive Pulse (and Gubernatorial candidate Richard Moore apparently):
Earlier this week, Democratic gubernatorial candidate Richard Moore called for a $1 per hour increase in the state’s minimum wage. That one move would boost the wages of 632,000 people or 16 percent of the state’s workforce.
And this proposed while recession threatens? Populism-cum-broken-windows-fallacy. Here’s my response.
-Max Borders
Economic Incentives: WWMS (What Would Mises Say?)
Mitch Kokai cites a great passage from Mises on economic incentives by government.
-Max Borders
WhoTube? Complexity and Economics
Wanted to share these video entries to the APEE/MBM Communicators contest. Check ’em out while gnoshing your lunch, maybe learn a lil something:
Thanks,
Max Borders
North Carolina: Losing Our Edge
North Carolina is losing it’s edge. This eye-opening state-by-state index by Art Laffer and Steven Moore illustrates convincingly the close correlation between state policy and economic prosperity.
Years of one party rule mean NC is moving toward the Jennifer Granholm/European socialist model that has left Michigan and Old Europe in economic stagnation for years now. Nearly double-digit unemployment, outward migration and capital flight mark the states with policies hostile to entrepreneurship and economic freedom.
The more North Carolina gets into the upper marginal tax rates, continues to overcompensate by giving away corporate welfare (unsustainable), and spends like drunken sailors, the faller we will slip on this index and the further we will sink into the economic malaise that puts us at #19 – fair to middling – but poor next to our southern neighbors (Tennessee 5, Virginia 4, and Georgia 8).
-Max Borders
Paul Krugman Just Got Destroyed
For all those people who’s only source of information on economic issues is the New York Times – more specifically Paul Krugman – take the time with this. It’s devastating.
If you’re tired of warmed over Keynesianism, of Have-nots rhetoric, and of analytic ineptude, you’ll enjoy this very well done critical review of Krugman’s work. (What’s most interesting is that they have catalogued a number of contradictions and difficulties with his own avowed principles.)
-Max Borders