Russ Roberts on the wisdom of stimulus packages.
My favorite bit:
The money has to come from somewhere. If you raise taxes to fund the plan, the people who are taxed are poorer and they’ll spend less. If you borrow money to fund the plan, the people who buy the government bonds have less money to spend and that offsets the stimulus. It’s like taking a bucket of water from the deep end of a pool and dumping it into the shallow end. Funny thing—the water in the shallow end doesn’t get any deeper.
(Ha! Update: Bryan Caplan weighs in on irrational voters and stimulus packages.)
-Max Borders
Economics
A “Stimulating” Piece
Prosper: So Cool… Microlending in the USA
OK, so I’m probably the last to hear about this, but a friend got me interested in Prosper, a micro-credit organization that facilitates loans between two independent parties.
In other words, you can loan someone $100 to get out of a bind at %15 interest. Someone might come along and offer them the same loan for 14%, so it relies on something of a reverse auction model.
In any case, this is another way that markets and social entrepreneurship are helping people. And don’t forget about the fortune at the bottom of the pyramid.
-Max Borders
No Better off than 1975?
If you believe that the average worker is no better off than in 1975, then you may be missing something.
(Beautiful addendum to this post from Steven Landsburg in the NYTimes.)
-Max Borders
Economic Freedom Index
Heritage’s Economic Freedom Index is out. (I wish they would do this for the individual states within the US.) Not suprisingly, Hong Kong is still the most economically free place in the world. The US is 5th, behind Singapore, Ireland and Australia.
-Max Borders
Forget Paul Krugman…
Tyler Cowen is the NY Times columnist you should be reading. Check out this amazing piece, especially this section on "predatory borrowing":
There has been plenty of talk about “predatory lending,” but “predatory borrowing” may have been the bigger problem. As much as 70 percent of recent early payment defaults had fraudulent misrepresentations on their original loan applications, according to one recent study. The research was done by BasePoint Analytics, which helps banks and lenders identify fraudulent transactions; the study looked at more than three million loans from 1997 to 2006, with a majority from 2005 to 2006. Applications with misrepresentations were also five times as likely to go into default.
Which prompts the question: are "we as a society" (read: government nannies) going to bail out fraudulent borrowers?
-Max Borders
Milton Friedman v. Naomi Klein
Posthumous argument.
-Max Borders (HT: Brian Balfour)
N&O: Recession Coming, Get the Handouts Ready
This N&O editorial reports gloomy economic forecasting, which the writer(s) believes justifies shoring up the welfare state (read: expanding yet further). Of course, ‘compassionate’ journalists aren’t expected to understand the relationship between taxing, spending, and making people more state-dependent on the one hand, and economic hardship on the other. These phenomena are self-reinforcing, among myriad other factors. But the welfare-state/economic-hardship nexus is difficult even for lefties to deny in the wake of Welfare Reform.
The article gets one thing right, though: "Maybe the economic boat will right itself — but if not, we can’t complain that we weren’t warned."
-Max Borders
Boudreaux on Today’s Krugmania
I’m starting to think that Paul Krugman is so enamored with being a darling of the left, that he has forgotten – or perhaps abandoned – even the fundamentals (law of comparative advantage). Boudreaux pits him against himself again:
Paul Krugman worries that, although trade between high-wage countries is mutually beneficial, "trade between countries at very different levels of economic development tends to create large classes of losers as well as winners" – and so is suspect because it likely harms ordinary American workers (“Trouble With Trade,” December 28).
A famous trade economist argues that this concern is misplaced. In a 1996 essay, this economist – responding to a protectionist who worried that western trade with low-wage countries would harm workers in the west – wrote that this protectionist "offers us no more than the classic ‘pauper labor’ fallacy, the fallacy that Ricardo dealt with when he first stated the idea, and which is a staple of even first-year courses in economics. In fact, one never teaches the Ricardian model without emphasizing precisely the way that model refutes the claim that competition from low-wage countries is necessarily a bad thing, that it shows how trade can be mutually beneficial regardless of differences in wage rates."
Oh – the economist who wisely warned against the pauper-labor fallacy is none other than Paul Krugman.*
-Max Borders
Roberts on Economic Pessimism
Sky falling? Nah. Onward and upward.
-Max Borders
The Narrative of Subprime Villainy
What are markets? Markets are nothing more than individuals engaged in exchange. Nothing more, nothing less. Now, sometimes in the process of trading, there is fraud. One party can lie or cloud the terms of an agreement to his or her benefit. We can all agree that it’s the government’s responsibility to protect people from said fraud. Otherwise, markets are just people engaged in free activity — mutual benefit, mutual gain–with risks sometimes involved. If such a relationship didn’t exist, there would be no trade and therefore no market.
But some of our favorite Mercedes Marxists think of markets as some abstract enemy — a Darth-Vaderish force that inhabits the greedy and puts Vampire eyeteeth in the necks of the poor. Perhaps this mien – common among progressives – is fueled by guilt. Perhaps by ignorance. Who can say? But of course, anything that happens that’s perceived as a social bad is the market’s fault and the market’s alone. Markets aren’t perfect (whatever perfect means — I guess by their lights that no one should ever have to take risks or fail at anything.) And the government is the almighty, allgood, fix-er-up-er of justice–an objective Board of Control that with the smartest, morally upright people will set straight all the little people who clearly can’t make economic decisions for themselves. (What could be more condescending, except perhaps putting a Wikipedia link to the word Schadenfreude as if people have never heard of it?)
Most recently, for example, Progressives have a post that lays blaim for the mortgage crises squarely at the feet of "Republicans" and of course those they derisively refer to as free-market fundamentalists — despite the fact that the former and the latter don’t always occupy the same area of the Venn diagram. Evil capitalists, the story goes, are drinking the blood of the homeowner (forgetting that some of these companies, and their employees, are teetering at the edge of bankruptcy themselves due to poor decisions). For support of their view, they throw in the Left’s favorite neo-Keynesian hack Paul Krugman as evidence that they’re right, as if this polemicist has said anything sane since 1999 — or whenever it was Krugman started getting paid more to think less.
Instead of looking for villains in any other places besides his favored place — that horrible market he (and all of us) have benefitted from — he sticks to his master-narrative. And if any consideration falls outside of that haves- and have-nots story he jealously guards, he will ignore it, wish it away, or search frantically through Paul Krugman archives for witty retorts. Because rectitude courses through his veins. To consider other ideas ruins that good feeling righteousness brings. In the case of the subprime "crisis", he ignores the fact that HUD regulations have pressured and even forced lenders – either politically or by law – to "serve" populations that would otherwise fall out of the risk calculations lenders use to remain solvent businesses. But no, the government can do no wrong. So this couldn’t be a factor.
And while in the wake of the dotcom bubble there was certainly an excessive migration of capital to real estate fueled by Fed policy, our Robin Hoods of home ownership write as if they a) knew all along, suggesting some crystal ball living where the sun don’t shine (hindsite being 20/20 and all), b) that Alan Greenspan is any better at planning an complex economy than their favorite progressive politicians are of fixing it, and c) ordinary people are simply not capable of making risk calculations for themselves and to live with the consequences of their choices.
And if we, as our champagne socialist bloggers might hope, had regulated away the kinds of loans they finds so abhorrent, how many of the 97+ percent of those subprimers who still own and are paying for their mortgages would very likely still be renting? So which is the "crisis"? Never having the opportunity to begin with? Or freely accepting the risk? Our gentle paladins for social justice know better than YOU what risks you should take. And so do the government nannies they serve with such utter faith and obsequiousness. (I’ll pass over the irony in that this author simultaneously derides "market fundamentalism" [yes, again] while taking shots at the former Chairman of the FEDERAL Reserve — you know, that august government body.) When the government monkeys come around to over-regulate the mortgage industry so no one in the lower quartiles EVER gets a lone, what will they say? ‘Screw ’em’ I suppose. Or perhaps they’ll hand out 3% fixed-rate loans like candy to everyone and bail them out whenever they default–all at everyone else’s expense. Either way, they’ll know what’s best.
To our progressives blogger’s false dichotomy I’ll say this: the lending industry has already corrected itself. Bailouts will only skew the risk assessment of lenders and buyers more than the government and Fed have already done. Over-regulation a la SARBOX will result in unintended consequences that will be with us well beyond the healing of this burst bubble. We’re now paying for a confluence of factors not even a majority of which were products of the market. But more importantly, the cure will be much worse than the disease if you, Bush and Congress get your way.
Despite all the sarcasm they can muster, our Mercades Marxists won’t be able to explain away (much less acknowledge) myriad other factors in the subprime issue. They will be content instead to throw out non sequiturs about war or wiretapping. They will offer no substantive solutions. They will be content to hide behind rhetorical devices their readers will happily lap up without reflection. But they will not get into the actual critical thinking. (That’s Krugman’s job, apparently). No, they are, and will remain, second-hand dealers in bad ideas.
-Max Borders