This November we will have the opportunity to vote for six constitutional amendments. Is it unprecedented to have this many amendments on one ballot?
August 3rd, 2018 by Brooke Medina | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Economics, Elections, Government

This November we will have the opportunity to vote for six constitutional amendments. Is it unprecedented to have this many amendments on one ballot?
July 18th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Government

The saying “nix all six” is gaining traction from ideologues on the Left who value partisan victories and power over all else. Of course, “nix the six” refers to voting against all the state constitutional amendments on the November midterm ballots. Regardless if any amendment makes sense for you, your family, or community, apparently. It’s better to “nix all six” they say rather than even pondering support for possibly just one. No need to think outside the collective, we’ve prepared this ready-made slogan for you!
One could follow the advice of activists and ideologues and be guided by a simplistic political slogan, and no doubt some will, but it doesn’t seem like a very wise and informed choice given that there are diverse and even bipartisan amendments for voters to choose from.
The Right to Hunt and Fish amendment is not controversial and will most likely have broad support from various political factions in the state. Don’t believe me? Check out the lopsided vote totals by state lawmakers.
Additionally, Florida and North Carolina are the only states in the Southeast without this language in their constitution. It has never been voted down in any state when placed on the ballot. Sure, some uber urbanized Lefties or extreme anti-firearms folks may be hostile to the amendment, but then they only reinforce its need. Just over 20 states have this language in their constitution, and more states are considering adding it.
Capping the income tax at 7 percent offers voters an opportunity to place additional constitutional limits on state government and spending. This to me is not fundamentally pro-Republican or anti-Democrat, but rather gets to the basic question about what is the role and purpose of government? It’s a detriment to our state when one party is primarily seen as more competent or responsible when it comes to managing revenue and the state budget.
While most Democrats are pushing back aggressively on Voter ID, it has broad support from the electorate, not just in North Carolina but across the nation. And when it is implemented in other states, the hysteria immediately dies down. The crisis crowd just moves on to their next pet issue.
Marsy’s Law will probably prove to have broad support from voters and it’s virtually impossible to make the case that it’s a partisan power grab or ploy to turn out the vote. It’s a victims rights bill that started in California and has been adopted by other states. Most of the money is provided by Henry T. Nicholas, whose sister was murdered by an ex-boyfriend. It will be on the 2018 ballot in five other states besides North Carolina.
Again, the larger point is “nix the six” is devoid of any critical thinking when it comes to voting on these amendments. Full disclosure: I’m probably not voting for all six but I support some of the proposed amendments and voters too should look at all six individually instead of being entrapped by a slogan for the sake of partisan politics.
Trying to make a decision about constitutional amendments from a reflexive partisan position is never a good idea. The people and political parties in power inevitably change. Constitutions are meant to be more permanent to preserve our rights and rule of law. They are meant to empower people not government. Even though the two amendments that may appear more partisan on the surface, the judicial vacancies and the state board of Ethics and Election Enforcement reform amendment, your partisan loyalties may not determine your vote. You may feel that having a weaker governor or stronger legislator is good for North Carolina no matter who holds power. Different states give different levels of power to the governor for good reasons.
Be a smarter voter than a slogan voter. That way you can offer your best vote to North Carolina instead of merely being an automaton enslaved by partisan group-think.
July 13th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Government

Embarrassing is the word I would describe the Durham City Council’s nonsensical statement against Jordan Peterson. Civitas has covered the kerfuffle or fake outrage already this week from Durham leaders here. The link includes Peterson’s response.
What is perhaps so amusing is that looking over Peterson’s recent tour dates, Durham is not even one of the so-called more “progressive” cities on the list. Peterson has been all over urban enclaves in the Western world promoting his bestselling book “12 Rules for Life: An Antitode to Chaos.” It’s primarily a book about personal responsibility. Portland, San Francisco, Seattle, and Boston are just a few of the American cities he’s visited.
Peterson has a large following not just in North America, but internationally. He packs out venues in Western Europe. This is why this part of the Durham statement is especially comical: “However, we wish to emphasize that a person’s right to free speech does not include the right to a platform or an audience.” As was already stated, Peterson has an international platform now. The government doesn’t regulate who does or does not have a platform, nor do they get to take control of the narrative about who is deserving of an audience. The market and free people decide that. The whole statement is littered with inconsistencies and embarrassing illogical fallacies.
All I can surmise here is that the Durham City Council thinks it’s making some sort of heroic charge for the illiberal agenda, but Peterson’s statement exposes the preening for what it is, an embarrassing fool’s errand devoid of reality.
Finally, we’ve heard over and over again from some cultural leaders and entertainers about how House Bill 2 was this great embarrassment for North Carolina because it sought to reaffirm gender norms in public restrooms. We’re so often bombarded with propaganda about how the policies of the General Assembly “takes us back to another time” or embarrasses the state because of disagreements over policy.
I moved to North Carolina in 2015, I don’t think I’ve seen anything more politically embarrassing and absurd than the statement by the Durham City Council about Jordan Peterson, who is a popular professor out there helping people gain self-confidence, particularly young men who desperately need some manly guidance and direction in their lives. Peterson has the courage to stand up to much of the odious and noxious political correctness that is destroying the Western world and I can’t think of too many things more important or urgent in today’s broken culture.
July 1st, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Government

Thomas Jefferson, the author of the Declaration of Independence, called the document “an expression of the American mind.” The late historian Pauline Maier referred to it as “American Scripture.” Lincoln and others helped to elevate the text towards an even greater reality for all. One of the best attributes the document’s ideas is a reminder to put tyrants on notice. Its ideals are an inspiration to people everywhere who strive and suffer for something other than tyranny.
The enduring relevance of the Declaration of Independence must be at the center of the nation for our self-governing experiment to survive.
The ideals are revolutionary because it teaches that natural rights aren’t granted by government but are inherent. The government doesn’t order our lives, we bring order and rule to the government. The right to self-government is so inherent in the people that Jefferson once noted that “it is to secure our rights that we resort to government at all.” It’s an amazing but simple rebuke of central planning and top-down control of government over the people. If a government has any authority or “just power,” it is given only by the “consent of the governed.”
The English philosopher Jeremy Bentham offered a mocking rebuke of the declaration in 1776, noting:
What they call sell-evident truths. “All men,” they tell us, “are created equal.” This rarity is a new discovery; now, for the first time, we learn, that a child, at the moment of his birth, has the same quantity of natural power as the parent, the same quantity of political power as the magistrate.
Of course, Bentham is being dismissive of the declaration but he elevates an important point despite his mocking tone. It’s a reminder of the immense power in our natural rights and that those that are placed above us can only be servants and not masters of the people. Yes, a newborn comes into our world with rights that transcend man-made governments. Furthermore, nobody is supposed to be above our laws or entitled to special rights.
In part, Jefferson was tasked with writing our Declaration of Independence to unite the colonies against the tyrannies and abuses of the English Crown. Today, this nation is deeply divided and we live in an era where many citizens are not marching to expand freedom, but to restrict it. They grovel to the government to take the rights of others away for their own political preferences and lust for power.
This is occurring because many people largely look to the government for their rights, believing them to be dispensers of truth and all justice in this world. In fact, this is proven abundantly so by the meltdowns and hyperventilating over Supreme Court nominees. Partly this phenomenon has happened because of the rise of secularism, but also because we have entrenched too much power and authority in Washington. Does anybody else find it unhealthy that people are actually declaring that the fate of mankind hinges on one unelected judicial nominee to the Supreme Court?
To secure self-government and our Republic, we should continue to celebrate the ideas of our independence boldly, particularly the ideas that our rights transcend government. We should denounce tyranny and the concentration of power against the people. Many on the Left believe we must evolve beyond our founding documents, but doing so only invites the kind of tyranny and oppression that America rightly fled in 1776.
Non ducor, duco.
June 27th, 2018 by Brooke Medina | Topics: Federal Affairs, Government

In an historic move, the Supreme Court issued a 5-4 ruling in favor of Mark Janus, a public employee in Illinois. Justice Samuel Alito, delivering the opinion of the Court, wrote, “Forcing free and independent individuals to endorse ideas they find objectionable raises serious First Amendment concerns” (emphasis mine).
What was this case all about? Mark Janus a child welfare worker in Illinois claims compelling him to pay dues to a union whose policies he doesn’t agree with is a violation of his constitutional rights. Janus argues that non-political dues – called agency fees — that employees have been forced to pay for years to fund collective bargaining are political because they involve the development of public policy and the involvement of tax dollars.
What impact will this ruling have on North Carolina? Collective bargaining by public employees is illegal in our state, which means the effects of this case will not be felt as directly as they will in places with large union representation, like Illinois or California.
However, we can expect to see secondary and tertiary effects as this case will inevitably affect the largest teachers union in the nation, the National Educators Association (NEA), thereby impacting our state’s most entrenched, highly political teachers association, the North Carolina Association of Educators, with regarding to funding and membership. Civitas Policy Director, Bob Luebke, writes that the decline of the NEA will lead to, “a big ripple that will ultimately impact finances and operations in all states.”
At the heart of this ruling are the issues of free speech and individual liberty. Can the government, both at the state and federal levels, compel its employees to fund ideas, organizations, and programs that are antithetical to that individual’s beliefs?
We know from a liberty standpoint that the answer to this is, “No.” Thankfully, the highest court in the land has acknowledged this essential principle, as well.
Today, not only did Mark Janus win, but every liberty-loving, free-speech advocating American won.
June 13th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Government

In the most recent Civitas Poll, 66 percent of North Carolinians support a constitutional amendment to cap the state income tax at 5.5 percent. In the poll, 13 percent were opposed to the measure while 21 percent were unsure. The current cap sits at 10 percent.
While the new personal income tax rate for 2019 is 5.25 percent, this is a positive first step that empowers North Carolinians to protect and secure their property from irresponsible or wasteful spending. Afterall, one of the main reasons constitutional government is implemented is to prevent runaway power and protect property from plunder.
The proposal is initiated through Senate Bill 75. To amend the state constitution it must be approved by the voters.
One of my favorite books on state government is “The Last Hayride” by John Maginnis. It’s not a parable of virtue about state government in Louisiana, but quite the opposite. The book chronicles the political antics and corruption of former Louisiana governor Edwin Edwards, or “Fast Eddie,” just one of his many nicknames. After it was all said and done, Edwards ended up doing a lot of time in federal prison.
It’s a comical tale but you can also find many warnings about deficit spending and bloated public pensions. The lessons aren’t just about the illegal graft and cronyism that plague many state governments. It’s a warning too against the kind of government that feeds off its productive tax base, while its appetite simultaneously grows.
An April Wall Street Journal op-ed by economists Steven Moore and Art Laffer predict that 800,000 will flee New York and California over the next three years because of high taxes. Of course, this has been going on for some time now, people fleeing high tax states where spending is out of control because of lack discipline by state legislatures and a lack of any courage to tackle bloated public pensions. At this time, migration patterns are reversing from descendants of the population who fled the Dust Bowl for California.
States that have their fiscal house in order are reaping the benefits, all the more if a state can virtually guarantee no increase in taxes. We often forget too that debt is a tax increase.
We should continually ask “what is the purpose of government?” One of the reasons we have a national debt in excess of $21 trillion is we no longer understand that question on the federal level. We’ve moved too far from our foundational document or roadmap, the U.S. Constitution.
It’s a great idea to reinforce lower taxes in our state constitution and to remind people that government can only do so much. By limiting taxes we place limits on government, powerfully reminding them that their sphere is limited and our power over them is not.
May 9th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Government

Policy victories may be few and far between for Rep. Walter Jones (R-NC) since he is far from loved by the GOP leadership in Washington. Still, the congressman helped secure an important pledge from Speaker Paul Ryan (more on that below).
In 2015, Rep. Jones and Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky) introduced a bill that sought to end taxpayer funds for the former U.S. House Speaker to set up an office and salary for staff. It appears many lawmakers didn’t even know about the perk. Here is the 2015 Roll Call article on the legislation.
Perhaps most humorous about the action is that yesterday Speaker Ryan took to social media to brag about his support:
For decades, former Speakers of the House have been provided an official government office after leaving Congress. Asking taxpayers to foot this bill is not something I’m willing to do. I fully support
@HouseAppropsGOP‘s legislation to eliminate all funding for former speakers.
Humorous because Rep. Massie pointed out that Speaker Ryan previously blocked the legislation as Speaker. At any rate, dropping the perk is not law quite yet but stands a great chance with Ryan changing his tune. While the savings is far from even being a pittance to our federal budget, it at least reinforces the essential notion that federal elected officials are servants of the people and not our masters. It’s a very small step towards reclaiming our power over the political class that too often rules over us from Washington.
Chalk up an important policy victory for Jones, who also secured a win in his contested primary yesterday. He says if re-elected he will serve one more term. Hopefully, more federal lawmakers from our state will continue to challenge the entrenched power and graft so prevalent in our nation’s capital.
May 3rd, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Civitas Events, Government

Some lawmakers across North Carolina are reminding us today is the National Day of Prayer. The National Day of Prayer Task Force lists 112 events across the state. U.S. Rep. Walter Jones sent this message out on Twitter:
Today on
#NationalDayOfPrayer, my biggest concern is that America needs to come back to the word of God. Today we reaffirm the important role that prayer has in this country. Not just today, but every day I will pray for our men & women in uniform & the future of this country.
A good word. When we pray for our nation it should remind us too of the limits of what government can accomplish. Most Americans believe, in some fashion, that they have a destiny and transcendent purpose beyond the state. The very way we might petition the state is very different than how we petition a transcendent power, reminding us that government can only do so much.
At the Conservative Leadership Conference in April, several speakers I heard there touched on the topic of the rising tide of secularism in the nation. Their fear is that secularism causes many to look to government first to solve their shortcomings and ills. Lt. Gov. Dan Forest touched on this is his remarks.
Christopher Scalia talked about how his late father Justice Scalia often used his speeches to inform citizens that virtue was required for a free republic to flourish. The American Framers, even those who weren’t Orthodox in their Christianity, believed that a religious ethic or influence is a must for sustaining freedom. In many of his legal opinions, Justice Scalia wrote about how the American Constitution is unique because it placed structural limits on the power of government. Lots of collectivist and totalitarian nations throughout history have offered up a long list of rights and protections for its citizens without offering essential limits to the power of government or the state. That is key because without that the road to entrenched tyranny is a short one. In contrast, our system is unique, in part, because of its religious influence and a belief in the transcendent. That in itself played a monumental role in the separation of powers and limiting the power of government over the lives of the citizenry.
Dennis Prager expressed that at CLC with a simple yet profound line, saying the American framers had the audacity to claim “We are free because God wants us to be free.”
April 26th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Government

Over at the Acton Institute, I penned a review of the new film “Chappaquiddick.” My main point was to go deeper than the political partisanship that largely still drives the tragic incident from almost 50 years ago. The major critical players in the saga are now dead so it’s essentially unhelpful to use the tragedy as a talking point to try and claim any partisan superiority.
Chappaquiddick derailed a possible future presidency for the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy. The abuse of power and cover-up by the Kennedy clan was immense, but I think the film allows us to see the limits we need to place on government too. We sometimes believe government can transform society and make for us a new beginning, but the people leading us are so often deeply flawed. They too are constrained by our fallen nature, often more so because of the temptation and lure of power. Ronald Reagan once asked, “But if no one among us is capable of governing himself, then who among us has the capacity to govern someone else?” Chappaquiddick definitely helps to reinforce that truth.
From the review:
The crash occurred just two days before the Apollo 11 moon landing on July 20, 1969. While the lunar landing knocked the tragedy off the front page, it also contrasted man’s highest technological achievement with our deeply fallen and sinister nature. The 1960s, particularly at the decade’s outset, was a time of high ideals. President John F. Kennedy heralded a “New Frontier.” It was a decade too of enormous political and moral failings that reminded Americans that while it could land a man on the moon and safely return him home, there remain limits at the core of man’s being, depicted so well at decade’s end through Chappaquiddick.
April 18th, 2018 by Ray Nothstine | Topics: Budget & Taxes, Economics, Education, Elections, Government, Legislative Activity, Life & Family Issues

Below is the cover article from the current April print issue of NC Capitol Connection that will fill out the goals and objectives of our Toxic Agenda campaign at Civitas. The campaign is essential because there is nothing more important than an informed and engaged citizenry when it comes to public policy. Keep reading to find out more.
Toxic Agenda Aims to Shine Light on True Goals of Political Left
By Ray Nothstine
The Civitas Institute is launching a comprehensive campaign to further educate North Carolinians on the dangerous goals of leftist policy and ideology for the state and nation. Toxic Agenda: What the Left Really Wants for North Carolina is a signature project for Civitas that delves into a wide array of issues, focusing on the failures, and at times, the absurdity of the Left’s desire for control over the citizenry.
An additional reason for the need for the Toxic Agenda series is that the Left could potentially thrive more and more in a society and culture that becomes increasingly politicized.
The rise of cultural Marxism in many segments of corporate America, academia, and the government is empowering the Left to new heights, which includes a propensity to overreach to enact their agenda. And while their power and objectives are currently stymied in North Carolina, this could potentially change after just one election.
“Poisons and harmful chemicals are always required to come with a warning label. We believe harmful, detrimental policies should too,” reads a March press release from the Civitas Institute. Civitas President Donald Bryson added that “It’s time to have a candid conversation about what progressives want for the Tar Heel State. It’s important to read the ingredients when a charlatan is selling snake oil.”
While everyday citizens might not be laser-focused on specific policy proposals, especially outside of election season, Civitas has the staff and resources to inform supporters and the general public of what they can expect under a progressive political takeover. Furthermore, the need for accountability and transparency is essential since many traditional news outlets continue to grow increasingly partisan, often taking sides or cheerleading for particular agendas and left-leaning political campaigns.
Readers can expect Civitas to cover a host of issues from gun control to abortion expansion to crony capitalism and unethical election policies. “In this [Toxic Agenda] series, we have articles on a range of issues that will affect all North Carolinians, both economically and socially,” Bryson said. “There is an essential watch-dog component and civil vigilance to this work as well.”
Issues like the dangers of minimum wage myths and the expansion of abortion are already up on the website. Gun control is an increasingly popular issue that will be covered in June. Many other topical issues will be covered with examples that include poverty programs, religious liberty, and school choice.
“Our Toxic Agenda series lays out what to expect if the Left returns to power,” says Bob Luebke, director of policy at Civitas. “We chronicle the Left’s response to major policy problems and the disasters that followed. Toxic Agenda will not only fuel our love of freedom and our conservative values but also soberly remind us of the consequences of those who have taken the Left’s medicine. In simple terms, consider Toxic Agenda a big long warning label that highlights the discomfort that follows a wrong diagnosis by the Left and the bad medicine that follows.”
Thomas Jefferson warned that “The natural progress of things is for liberty to yield and government to gain ground.” Civitas is confident that the Toxic Agenda campaign will help to foster a further engaged and educated citizenry, that will hopefully move the needle to roll back regulations and barriers that prevent North Carolinians from flourishing while preserving freedom.
All of the pieces that have been completed so far can be found at ToxicAgendaNC.org.