A trend that has slowly, yet steadily been sweeping the nation at local levels has a North Carolina city council following suit. Durham City Council voted 5-to-2 on Monday, Nov. 15 to allow identification cards issued by the Mexican consulate to be viewed as a valid form of ID. Questions still remain to be answered as to how these cards will be viewed through a legal lens.
Immigration
Unlawful and Illegal is All the Rage this Holiday Season
Durham City Council Could Make History on Contentious Issue
While Winston-Salem Police Chief Scott Cunningham has said he has decided to partner with CHANGE to create its own type of identification card for people who currently do not carry any form of identification with them, Durham City Council soon will make a decision on whether it’s going to be the first city in the state to accept the Matricula Consular, an ID card issued by Mexico’s consulate offices to Mexican citizens living outside the country. The meeting is Monday, November 15.
SOCIAL CHANGE and POWER
Please tell me this is a joke. A group called Communities Helping All Neighbors Gain Empowerment (CHANGE) approached the Winston-Salem Chief of Police, Scott Cunningham, and offered to issue ID cards to people without identification (some of them “undocumented”). Here, I am afraid, is the punch line, Chief Cunningham has accepted the offer and even held a press conference detailing the joint venture.
The police chief says that the ID’s will be issued to people who don’t have identification already and will help the police when they interact with these people. He went on to say that the group CHANGE will “be looking for different forms of identification that they verify…and after the verification that they do, then they will issue their ID card.” CHANGE describes itself as an organization of good power and is one of the “57 affiliates of the oldest and largest community organizing networks in the United States, The Industrial Areas Foundation (IAF).” Click here to read a Civitas Blog on who funds CHANGE.
IAF’s purpose is to create independent organizations (see CHANGE) inventing and establishing new social realities. The IAF website also proclaims that they “build organizations whose primary purpose is power and whose chief product is social change.
The ID card the police chief used as an example at his press conference looked very much like an official ID card. The Winston-Salem Police will now recognize these cards, while admitting they might not be based on reliable information. Who else will accept this very unofficial card as official identification?
This ID card might be very helpful to someone wanting to register and vote at the last minute. In 2008 more than 2.5 million voters voted in the 2 ½ weeks leading up to Election Day and more than 100,000 people registered at the same time that they voted. The people who use Same Day Registration (SDR) are required to show some sort of ID (the term ID is used very loosely here because utility bills and notes from colleges are recognized as ID’s). Could a poll worker mistakenly accept this as official identification?
After your read a little about CHANGE and IAF, I think you will agree that these organizations sound a lot like ACORN or maybe North Carolina Public Interest Research Group (NCPIRG). Both ACORN and NCPRIG have been involved (at least) in voter registration fraud. But, CHANGE asserts that they are “not a movement, a protest group, a political action committee, or a service organization.” And they say, “We do not run programs, endorse candidates, or take government money. But, they did lead a successful effort last year to make school-board elections nonpartisan in Forsyth County. They were helped by Sen. Linda Garrou, D-Forsyth, who promoted the bill in the Senate and the Democrat Legislature. Some people believe that this was an attempt to break the Republican majority on the Board.
2010 was the Forsyth school board’s first nonpartisan election and for the record, CHANGE failed to replace any incumbent Republican members – all the incumbents (Republican and Democrat) won re-election.
Coming Soon: Rush of Illegal Immigrants to Winston-Salem
CHANGE (Communities Helping All Neighbors Gain Empowerment) has partnered with the Winston-Salem Police Department in an effort to identify residents who do not have a government-issued identification card. At first glance, it’s not difficult to see who propels this group, who declares they are “not a movement, a protest group, a political action committee, or a service organization.” They also claim, “We do not run programs, endorse candidates, or take government money. But what we do is to cultivate skills of our local leaders by identifying shared concerns and needs so that we may act together for the common good.” Funders include: The Catholic Campaign for Human Development, The Mary Reynolds Babcock Foundation, The Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation, The Winston Salem Foundation, and the Lutheran (ELCA) Domestic Hunger Project. No liberal agenda here.
Will NC Join Texas in ‘Arizona Style’ Immigration Law?
Less than one hour into the filing period for Texas’ 2011 Legislative session, State Rep. Debbie Riddle filed a measure similar to that in Arizona which requires law enforcement officers to check an individual’s immigration status when enforcing other laws. The Arizona legislation is currently on hold until later this month when the federal government will argue that its federal immigration laws supplant those of the state. Riddle hopes the measure will help curb the growing number of Mexican and Latin American gang incidents across Texas.
With 13 states now supporting Arizona’s move to enforce existing immigration laws and a newly elected Republican majority in the North Carolina Legislature, the question arises as to whether Republican legislators will propose similar legislation in the 2011 Session.
A June 2010 Civitas poll revealed that 91 percent of voters rate the government’s enforcement of immigration as fair or poor while 64 percent said they support Arizona’s new law. Fifty-eight percent said they think North Carolina should enact a similar law.
While voters recognize that immigration enforcement should be handled by the federal government, they also see how badly such enforcement has failed and support Arizona handling the issue themselves. Will the North Carolina State Legislature heed the wishes of voters and file a measure to enforce illegal immigration laws in 2011?
“Tough on Immigration” Democrat is an Oxymoron
How many opportunities has the North Carolina General Assembly, controlled by Democrats, had to implement a comprehensive immigration policy and has instead, decided to ignore or quash any attempt at fixing a growing issue? So why have many Democratic candidates decided to jump on the “tough on immigration” bandwagon? Could it be perhaps because the majority of North Carolinians support tougher immigration standards?
Some Democratic candidates, including Margaret Dickson, Tony Foriest, and Dewey Hudson have even directly accused their Republican opponents of hiring illegal immigrants. As I mentioned in a recent blog post, David Redwine also suddenly supports “tough new fines for corporations caught knowingly hiring illegal immigrants.”
In the past, these same Democrats have opposed Arizona’s immigration reforms, E-Verify, and other legislative proposals to secure and maintain our borders while adamantly defended the DREAM Act and amnesty for illegal immigrants currently residing in America. Why would you attack Republican candidates for hiring illegal immigrants if your platform to date is, “Illegal immigrants should be allowed to stay and work in this country no matter the reason?” Why would they care if their opponents hired illegal immigrants given their position on the matter? To me, the hypocrisy is glaringly obvious. Are these candidates really whistling a new tune when it comes to immigration policy or are they just doing whatever it takes to get elected and then return to their “business as usual?”
I want to know what my candidates really stand for – not just what they’re willing to say to get elected.
Should noncitizens vote?
Next Tuesday voters in Portland, Maine and San Francisco, California and Portland, Oregon will decide on whether to grant noncitizens the right to vote in local elections (see article here). Yes, you heard it right; voters are contemplating giving the right to vote to those who do not have citizenship.
And once, that’s achieved – as it has been in several municipalities across the country — does anyone doubt what the next item is on the agenda of radical immigration groups?
NC Democratic Party Supports Arizona Immigration Law?
David Redwine, a Democratic candidate for NC’s Senate District 8, and his campaign have mailed out a flyer that is sure to raise some controversy among the Democratic Party. His flyer states, “David Redwine wants to throw the book at CEOs who just won’t quit hiring illegal immigrants.” His platform includes “tough new fines for corporations caught knowingly hiring illegal immigrants;” “jail time for CEOs who are repeat offenders;” and “bringing the Arizona immigration crack down to North Carolina.” What’s most interesting about the flyer, however, is that the NC Democratic Party paid for it. These reforms would get many “amens” from several conservative voters and organizations but to most liberals and their liberal-backing organizations, such rhetoric is contrary to everything they believe when it comes to immigration law. I just can’t see the NC Justice Center or the NC Dream Team supporting Redwine any time soon. Is the NC Democratic Party losing sight of their base or are they finally conceding that illegal immigration is a real problem that needs to be addressed with real solutions.
Does this flyer lead us to conclude that the NC Democratic Party supports Arizona’s immigration laws? If they endorse candidates with such a platform, one can deduce that the answer is a resounding “yes.”
ICE Draft Policy Seeks to Further Limit Local Immigration Authority
According to a recent Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) article, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has taken additional steps to weaken the immigration enforcement authority of local and state agents. Through a draft policy, ICE chief John Morton plans to prohibit not only his own agents, but also local officers with 287(g) immigration authority, from retaining and deporting illegal aliens who are discovered as a result of traffic violations.
Ann Yom Steel, a political appointee, has stated the policy is in response to immigration detainers, claiming such detainers could distort the state criminal process or open the window for “pretextual, minor criminal charges.” In other words, she believes local officers will make up charges to get illegal aliens deported.
Furthermore, under the policy, officers may not issue a detainer unless a law enforcement agency has exercised an independent authority to arrest the alien. Immigration officers may not issue detainers for aliens who have been temporarily detained by the law enforcement agency (i.e. roadside or Terry stops) but not arrested.
Should local law enforcement be allowed to make up or exaggerate charges? Absolutely not! However, most officers just want to do their jobs well by respectably enforcing U.S., state and local laws; and the last time I checked, it was against the law to come to or remain in America illegally. Officers should be given the authority to follow reasonable steps and guidelines to have illegal aliens deported, especially those found breaking not only our immigration laws, but our traffic and criminal laws as well.
If you would like to comment on this proposed policy, you may submit them to Ann Yom Steel at ann.yom@dhs.gov no later than September 30,2010.
Higher tuition for international students? And, that other issue.
In an effort to find additional revenue for the cash-strapped UNC system, UNC Board of Governor’s member and former State Representative, Bill Dautridge wants international students to pay higher tuition. Dautridge contends that since international students pay no state or federal taxes, North Carolinians are providing significant subsidies to such students (See news article).
Dautridge raises a ticklish though interesting point. UNC campuses enroll over 4,000 international students. However the reality is many of those students are concentrated in graduate programs in the sciences and engineering. A simple review of the largest graduate engineering programs in the UNC system over the last decade show international students comprise in some cases between 40 -50 percent of graduate enrollments.
Since graduate programs in engineering require significant capital investment, large subsidies are involved. So I think Dautridge’s question should be on the table. However the former legislator’s comments point to yet another issue. Many UNC campuses seem more than happy to have international students fill our graduate programs. Yet, does it make sense to incur all the expense of educating these students when our laws make it virtually impossible for many of them – who oftentimes graduate with highly marketable skills – to gain employment in this country? Hopefully, Dautridge’s comments will spur this discussion as well. It’s much needed.