Republican Representative Glen Bradley introduced HB65 that says the federal government has no jurisdiction over food products made and sold within the state’s borders. The bill is called the North Carolina Farmers Freedom Protection Act. It cites the 10th amendment of the U.S. constitution to proclaim the feds cannot regulate intrastate commerce. There is word Congress may soon consider a bill that would set up new and stricter food safety rules.
Legislative Activity
Another bill to keep the feds at arm’s length
Balanced Budget Act tentatively approved by House after testy debate
The debate took over three hours but SB13 was given tentative approval by a 66-51 vote. Democrats objected to third reading so the bill will be on the House calendar Thursday.
The proposal lets the Governor find $400 million in savings in this year’s budget but goes beyond that to find another nearly $400 million in savings by transferring some money from various funds. There was a lot of verbal fencing over those transfers. Democrats complained withholding million from the Golden LEAF Foundation, job incentive funds and other sources would hurt job recruitment. Several amendments were offered to stop them but failed. Former Democratic Speaker Joe Hackney said it was too fast, too soon and there should have been more collaboration with his party. Republican Representative Nelson Dollar stood and asked “when are we going to get serious?” He said the Democratic majority said when they were writing the budget they would worry about next year, next year. Dollar said, “well, its next year.”
At one point Republican Representative Dale Folwell confronted the Democrats’ chief budget writer of last year Micky Michaux. He asked Michaux if he would accept the blame for the shape the budget is in now and Michaux said yes. Michaux said “you do what you have to do.”
The bill faces one more vote before being sent to the Governor.
Second Reading of SB 13 Debated and Passed in House
SB 13, the Balanced Budget Act of 2011, was debated on the House floor today. Rep. Brubaker began by explaining the bill. The legislation has been offered to address the $3.7 (or $2.7 according to the Governor) billion budget shortfall in the coming fiscal year. Specifically, it would authorize the governor to hold back $400 million from state agencies in the current budget year of 2010-11. It would further transfer millions from various state accounts such as Gold LEAF, the Tobacco Trust Fund, the Health and Wellness Trust Fund, the Wildlife Resources Commission and the Parks & Recreational Trust Fund. By reducing these types of unnecessary expenditures, more unspent funds will be available to carry over to next year’s budget. This would allow NC to reduce the size of the budget gap that will need to be closed.
After a very lengthy debate with ample opportunity to speak on both sides, the second reading of the bill passed 66-51. The final reading and vote will be tomorrow.
Governor says new revenue picture and some savings shrink budget shortfall
Governor Beverly Perdue now says the budget shortfall for next fiscal year has dropped from $3.7 billion to $2.7 billion. This comes out just as the House was debating SB13 that would redirect money from the Governor’s One North Carolina Fund to the General Fund and other sources.
The Governor’s press office sent an email with some details:
$700 million in better than expected revenue (don’t have a breakdown yet of income v. corporate v. sales)
$200 million in controlling Medicaid costs, meaning we planned to have to spend it but didn’t have to.
$50 million in controlling state health plan costs, (ditto above)
$50 million in a hodgepodge of savings, such as controlling debt costs.
Source on all this is OSBM
The bill being debated in the House would find roughly $800 milli0n in savings for this fiscal year.
Gov. Perdue Rules!
Now that I’ve got your attention….this post is actually about Gov. Perdue and rules.
Gov. Perdue submitted a list of just over 900 state agency rules and regulations she would like to see repealed.
Perdue stood by a stack of papers identified as 900 rules and regulations she wants the Legislature to examine and eliminate, half of which originate from the Department of Health and Human Services. They were culled by her administration after she announced an effort in October to eliminate rules she believed discouraged commerce or were downright silly.
Members of Perdue’s budget office, who undertook the review, said many of the proposed changes released Tuesday stemmed from rules that are unnecessary because the programs connected to them have been disbanded or are dormant. She said more than 1,000 additional rules would be analyzed in coming months by her office.
Purdue is encouraging lawmakers to create a bill dropping the rules. It would seem such a measure would be taken up by the legislature in light of Senate Bill 22 that bans the implementation of any new agency rules unless the new rule is in response to a very specific exemption, such as public health or safety or required by federal law.
It appears state agencies have been on a rulemaking bender over the last decade, with more than 15,000 new agency rules being implemented over the past 10 years.
I would further advise a measure to ensure rulemaking doesn’t get out of control: for every new rule an agency creates, it must eliminate two old ones.
Here come more earmarks
State Democratic Representatives Marvin Lucas, Diane Parfitt, Rick Glazier and Elmer Floyd introduced a bill to give $1 million to the Partnership for Defense Innovation. It’s a non-profit organization that is supposed to help businesses and inventors connect with the military for contracts. It is located in Fayetteville which is in the district the bill sponsors represent.
Representatives Lucas and Glazier also filed a bill to grant the North Carolina Congress of Parents and Teachers Incorporated $500,000. The money is for continuing the North Carolina PTA Parent Involvement/Dropout Prevention Initiative.
Senate committee taking up annexation moratorium
State Senators had their first look at a bill that would impose a one year moratorium on involuntary annexations. The Senate State and Local Government committee began discussion on SB27 which would stop any involuntary annexations under consideration around the state. Bill sponsor GOP Senator Andrew Brock said he has heard of several proposed annexations and was afraid of a “wild west” annexation rush. He said that started after Republicans won the majority in November because cities knew the Republicans were trying to stop cities from annexing communities in which people didn’t have a vote on it. Republican Senator Harris Blake and Democratic Senator Stan White said there should be consideration for cities that are already in the process of an annexation because of the cost. Blake said it should be taken on a case by case basis. While this would be just a moratorium Brock said there would be legislation coming to make permanent changes so annexations would be fair. The committee did not vote on the bill.
Senate Judiciary Takes Up Protect Health Care Freedom Act
The Senate Judiciary II Committee held a hearing to discuss HB2, the Protect Healthcare Freedom Act. Rep. Barnhart (R-Cabarrus) and Rep. Stam (R-Wake) began by explaining the bill. Its two primary provisions include prohibiting the individual mandate as applied to North Carolinians and allowing the Attorney General to join 28 other states in filing a lawsuit to challenge the individual mandate. Furthermore, there was a provision added that ensures that any costs associated with filing a lawsuit comes from the Attorney General’s existing budget.
Both sides were allowed to make their points. Rep. Hollo (R-Alexander), a physician’s assistant, asked whether it was right to force people to buy a product they don’t necessarily want or choose not to have. Rep. Stam, referring to the paternalistic nature of the federal bill added, “Are we children or citizens?”
Sen. Doug Berger (D-Franklin) asked several questions. He raised concerns about cost increases if people are not mandated to carry coverage (spread the risk of loss). Rep. Barnhart addressed his comments by agreeing that we need to drive down costs but forcing people to carry coverage is not the right way to do it. Sen. McKissick (D-Durham) also addressed costs concerns. Rep. Stam countered that NC could actually save $1.1 billion on Medicaid by not forcing our citizens to purchase health insurance due to the increased participants in Medicaid under a mandated program.
The federal government will cover the majority of the increased costs for the first 3 years but after that, states will be left with the heavy financial burden of covering much of the additional Medicaid participants’ costs.
As for costs associated with filing a lawsuit, the amount should be limited, with an estimated maximum of $100,000 if North Carolinians decide to challenge the individual mandate under a class action lawsuit. If NC chooses to join Florida’s lawsuit, the costs could be as low as 44 cents to mail the letter and as high as $5,000, the voluntary maximum amount Florida requests from co-plaintiff states.
Other arguments discussed turned on how the federal insurance mandate is different than Medicare or auto insurance. The distinction can be described in three words – “Because we breath.” Medicare applies only to those who have worked and only to individuals over the age of 65. Auto insurance applies only to drivers – no one has to drive a car. The individual mandate applies to everyone who is living simply because they exist in the world and draw breath.
This debate is sure to continue into the future, both on the state and national level. A vote on H2 is not expected in the Senate Judiciary Committee until Thursday.
State Senate passes Balanced Budget Act
The North Carolina Senate approved SB13 which targets twice as much savings for which Governor Perdue asked, around $800 million. Repuclican Senator Richard Stevens did amend the bill to drop the transfer of nearly $5 million from the University Cancer Research Fund. After a short debate the bill was passed 31-16. The bill was sent to the House.
Tax credit proposed for education expenses outside of public schools
State Representative Paul Stam and several other Republicans have introduced HB41 to give families a tax credit if they want to put their children in charter schools or private schools. The credit would be $1250 for each of two semesters per year. A married couple would have to make under $100,000 per year to qualify. There are other restrictions, such as, the child can’t have spent any time in a public school during the semester.