The state House could vote as early as Tuesday on HB2 to repeal the mandate in the national healthcase act that would require individuals to buy health insurance. Although a federal judge in Florida ruled the federal law was unconstitutional, the case still has to go through appeals and could get derailed. State Democrats again tried to make their case the legislature had no business trying to interfere with federal law. Democratic lawmakers brought in health advocates to hold their own press conference at the General Assembly. They used the same arguments, nothing new.
Legislative Activity
State House could vote on healthcare repeal this week despite Florida ruling
A new bill wants more money for Children’s Advocacy Center
Despite the budget crisis some Democrats want the legislature to fork over $575,000 to the Children’s Advocacy Center. That’s $200,000 more than lawmakers allocated in the last two years. House Bill 16’s primary sponsors are Representatives Diane Parfitt, Rick Glazier and Marvin Lucas. The center coordinates training for professionals to deal with reports of child abuse and neglect. The bill could be part of the budget negotiations but Republicans have said this year they want accountability. We will likely see many more such earmarks but will any of the sponsors have to prove they are worth the cost?
Legislative panel passes bill to challenge the national Healthcare Act
Republican leaders in the General Assembly are not wasting time in fulfilling promises. The state House Judiciary Committee approved the bill Thursday that would have North Carolina join a national legal challenge of so-called Obamacare. The bill said the federal government cannot force citizens to buy healthcare because it would be unconstitutional. Democrats on the panel tried to delay the vote saying there should be a public hearing and they didn’t know how much the legal challenge would cost.
A recent Civitas poll showed 63 percent of those polled agreed with joining the legal challenge while just 25 percent didn’t.
As the Civitas Institute has pointed out previously, forcing people to purchase a certain product is an assault on our individual liberty and quite possibly a violation of the U.S. Constitution.
Republican committee chairman Leo Daughtry will decide if the bill has to go to an appropriations committee before going to the House floor.
Bills of Note on Legislature’s First Day of Business
The first day of business for the new 2011 North Carolina legislative session included the introduction of a number of notable bills.
The bill likely to garner the most attention is House Bill 2, “Protect Health Care Freedom.” The bill has four primary sponsors and 57 co-sponsors, and essentially attempts to counter the Obamacare mandate that everyone must enroll or purchase some sort of health insurance coverage. From a legal perspective, it will be interesting to see if such a state law can override the federal mandate – something that will be hashed out in the courts.
Another two bills introduced deal with property rights. HB 8 deals with the issue of eminent domain, with the intention of ending the government’s practice of seizing private property (with minimal compensation to the owner) only to hand it over to another private interest. The bill would amend the state constitution to include the provision:
Private property shall not be taken by eminent domain except for a public use. Public use does not include the taking of property in order to convey an interest in the property for economic development. Just compensation shall be paid and, if demanded, shall be determined by a jury.
Furthermore, HB 9 would enact a moratorium on involuntary annexation until July 1, 2012.
By the way, all three of these issues were included in the Civitas Institute’s publication last year entitled 20 Changes for 2010.
On the Senate side, SB 3 would expand the ban on video sweepstake games to include sweepstakes that have “any visual display” in addition to the current ban that outlaws such games that feature “game play or simulated game play.”
One curious note in SB 3 derided sweepstake games because they entice people into believing they will get “something for nothing.” Isn’t it ironic that politicians would find this offensive, given the fact that so many of them base their campaigns on promising certain groups of people something for nothing?
Concerned about a Specific Issue? Find the Right House Member to Contact
Incoming Speaker Thom Tillis has announced draft committee assignments for Republicans. The Speaker will soon consult with the Minority Leader to choose Democrat member assignments. Here are the following likely committee assignments for the majority party:
Appropriations Subcommittee co-chairs: Responsible for writing (and cutting) the budgets for their specific agencies.
- Health and Human Services: Nelson Dollar and Justin Burr
- Education: Bryan Holloway, Mark Hilton, and Hugh Blackwell
- General Government: George Cleveland
- Justice and Public Safety: David Guice and Shirley Randleman
- Natural and Economic Resources: Carolyn Justice and Roger West
- Transportation: Ric Killian and Philip Frye
Other (non-budget) committee chairmanships:
- Environment: Pat McElraft, Ruth Samuelson, and Roger West
- Health and Human Services: Bill Current and Mark Hollo
- Transportation: Frank Iler and Grey Mills
To see the full list of assignments, click here.
Civitas’ Chris Hayes to Join Tillis Team
Rep. Thom Tillis (R-Mecklenburg), the House Speaker-Designate, has announced new key players of his staff who will serve in the Speaker’s office when the General Assembly convenes at the end of January. Our very own Chris Hayes, Senior Legislative Analyst, will join Tillis’ team as one of his Policy Advisors. Before working with Civitas, Chris served in various policy roles both in Raleigh and Washington. Congrats to Chris and we all wish him well in his new position!
Governor Perdue Presents 2011 Agenda to Legislators
In a fifteen minute speech to a crowded room of legislators, press corps, and members of the public, Governor Perdue addressed the state’s economic problems while introducing her political agenda for the coming year.
Her speech began by lamenting the economic woes of North Carolina and reiterated a commitment to reducing the size of government in anticipation of a $3.7 billion budget shortfall for FY2011-12. She also alluded to a potential backlash from special interests in pursuit of this goal.
Perdue then highlighted many issues she felt her administration had done right and spoke at length about her priorities throughout her tenure as governor.
After addressing the fiscal issues facing the state, Perdue revealed her own political agenda for the coming year and stressed a desire for bipartisanship in pursuing her goals.
She detailed a three-part plan which includes:
1. Limiting the session length of the General Assembly: ninety days for the long session and forty-five for the short session. This measure, she stated, would save money and cause legislators to act with “deliberate urgency.” She reported that a single day of the General Assembly being in session costs $50,000.
2. Creating an independent redistricting commission. The Governor’s warming to this idea is not exactly unexpected coming after her party lost control of the General Assembly for the first time in over a century.
3. Increasing transparency of the legislature modeled after her executive branch. This final point was also her most vague. Perdue commented primarily on how well she believes her own agencies to be doing and suggested that the legislative branch follow suit without explaining why the current situation is inadequate.
She then regaled legislators with an arsenal of lofty ideals and idealistic tributes to the roles of their offices and commitment to progress.
While Perdue’s support of trimming down the budget promised “millions and millions in savings,” it does not provide enough specific measures to reconcile such a massive budget gap.
Perdue didn’t stick around to answer questions following her speech.
The highlights of her speech can be found in a video below.
Lobbyists Line Up to Charm New Legislators
North Carolina’s special interests waste no time in trying to turn the heads of the new legislature. Late Tuesday afternoon a curious line started outside a closed wooden door in the General Assembly, as anywhere between seventy-five to a hundred lobbyists lined up to introduce themselves to the new legislators. The line of well groomed men and women, many with flashy nametags that reflected the fluorescent lighting above, wound itself around a large courtyard, down a narrow hallway, and out into the foyer. These lobbyists represented all manner of industries and special interests around the state, each desiring for the state to look favorably upon their organization.
The physical representation of the plethora of special interest groups vying for influence with state legislators was very nearly lining up out the door. Some wanted state money, some wanted advantageous legislation, while others were very clearly playing defense in anticipation of deep budget cuts to reconcile a multi-billion dollar budget shortfall.
The line slowly filtered through the wooden door into a conference room where each lobbyist spoke briefly at the podium before a number of dimly interested soon-to-be freshmen legislators. Some kept it short and sweet, congratulating them on their recent victory, while others were more forthcoming with their agendas, arguing that their industry creates jobs, is vital to North Carolina’s interests, or courting legislators with a variety of other talking points.
Competitive Districts Can Reduce Partisanship
The News & Observer is reporting that Senator Bob Rucho (R-Mecklenburg) will chair the Senate redistricting committee. The article says that the GOP “could district lines that make it easier for GOP candidates to win elections.” A fair and impartial drawing of the electoral map, as opposed to the obviously gerrymandered districts we currently have, would certainly make it easier for Republicans to win. Have a look at the current US House districts in North Carolina. A map can be found here. Note the especially contorted 2nd, 3rd and 12th districts.
Our obviously gerrymandered districts were drawn by Democrats after the 2000 Census. Hopefully the GOP will resist the temptation to gerrymander and will draw districts that adhere to county and municipal boundaries. In fact, more competitive elections would benefit the state.
Much of the electorate decries excessive partisanship and the ideological rigidity that plague the political system. Competitive electoral districts tend to draw more centrist candidates because party nominees are forced to appeal to the middle in order to win instead of to their respective bases. Moderate candidates serve as a means to limit partisanship. Whether that is a good thing depends on your own political perspective. As always, the redistricting process should be interesting.
Requiring Photo ID to Vote
“Who are you? Tell me who you are.” These are infamous words of former United States Congressman Bob Etheridge (D-NC). You can watch the video of the incident here. The next time you head to the polls, precinct workers may, by law, require that you provide photo identification to answer former Congressman’s question. Per the News & Observer, Republican General Assemblymen strongly support requiring photo identification in order to vote in North Carolina.
The foundation of democracy is the “one person, one vote” principle. Each time voter fraud occurs, the integrity of our democratic electoral system is compromised. Requiring photo identification at the polls will surely reduce voter fraud. Those opposed to requiring photo identification say that fraud is a small, insignificant issue. Further, opponents argue that photo identification will be difficult for some citizens to obtain and will depress voter turnout.
First, any voter fraud is too much. The N&O article notes that there were only 18 confirmed cases of double-voting in North Carolina in 2008. Essentially, because 18 of those votes were illegitimate, 18 citizens who legally voted were disenfranchised because their votes were canceled out. Furthermore, successful voter fraud does not show up in the statistics. How many cases of successful fraud might there have been?
Additionally, if voters are able to get to the polls they should be able to obtain a photo ID. Sure it will be a bit of an annoyance to go through the process of obtaining photo identification; however, that should not be an excuse to compromise the integrity of elections. To prevent the appearance of a poll tax by proxy, photo identification would likely have to be provided free of charge.
Lastly, many will accuse the GOP of playing politics with the issue. Depressed turnout favors Republicans, they argue. On the other hand, does that mean that compromising the integrity of the electoral process through weak identification standards benefits Democrats? The argument here is double-edged. The integrity of our democracy is at stake and photo identification requirements should be seriously considered.