Democrats slip public financing into ethics bill.
Legislative Activity
Civitas Legislative Report 6/23
Irony of the Ethics Bill
The bill (HB961) is 34 pages, was sent out late last night after being hammered out in darkness, and was considered for little more than an hour in the Senate Judiciary I Committee. Ironically, it is a bill entitled “Government Ethics and Campaign Reform Act of 2010.” The portion of the act that strengthens ethics in government enjoys wide, if not unanimous, support.
However, numerous Republicans in the Judiciary Committee, all of which did not see the bill until this morning, oppose the portion of the bill that would expand publicly financed campaigns to include the Commissioners of Agriculture and Labor, the Secretary of State, Treasurer and the Attorney General. Passage of the expansion of public campaign funding for Council of State races likely would not pass as a standalone bill so the rather contentious issue was included in a broader ethics bill to ensure passage. The powers that be know that legislators who oppose public financing will face a tough political choice – they must vote in favor of a policy they do not support (expanding public financing) or be forced to defend voting against the ethics provisions in the bill.
This, my friends, is how the sausage is made but the irony is too egregious not to note. That a contentious provision is being rammed through the General Assembly in an ethics bill is the essence of what many voters despise about the current political culture in Raleigh. Public financing is certainly bad policy but it does deserve to be debated, separately, on its merits.
Civitas Legislative Report – 6/22
Senate Democrats add public financing to House ethics bill
The committee later passed the bill and it was sent to the Senate floor. Concerns over the public financing section on the floor prompted Democratic leader Martin Nesbitt to send the bill back to the Senate Judiciary I committee for more debate.
Senate approves Internet sweepstakes ban
The Senate Monday night approved a ban on Internet sweepstakes cafes in North Carolina. It does not prohibit sweepstakes used for products sold in stores.
The measure passed 47-1. The one dissenting vote was from Democratic Senator Julia Boseman of Wilmington. She is sponsoring a bill that would legalize the sweepstakes games and tax them. Boseman claimed Lottery Commissioner Tom Sheehan would not oppose the legalization.
That’s the sentiment of more Representatives in the House. In fact, some are blocking any move on the sweepstakes games because they want them taxed, that includes members of the Black Caucus. House Democratic leader Hugh Holliman said he doesn’t expect a vote on the ban or legalization in his chamber.
Republican Senator Tom Apodaca asked the Democratic sponsor of the ban Josh Stein if the bill would affect any current appeals over cases involving the Internet sweepstakes houses. Stein said it would not.
Public Money for Campaigns?
June 22nd, tomorrow, is “Voter-Owned Elections Lobby Day” at the North Carolina General Assembly. Sponsored by the North Carolina Voters for Clean Elections (NCVCE), the day will be dedicated to garnering support for HB120, which would allow large municipalities (pop. >50,000) to publicly fund municipal campaigns. SB966 which would expand publicly funded statewide races to include Secretary of State, Attorney General, Treasurer, Commissioner of Agriculture and Commissioner of Labor, will also be emphasized. Partners of NCVCE, including the NAACP of NC, the League of Women Voters and the North Carolina Association of Educators, are all co-sponsoring the lobby day.
The goal of voter-owned elections, which is a nice way of describing campaigns paid for by government, is to minimize the impact of money in elections. However, doing so would come at the expense of legitimate government expenditures on such things as education and infrastructure. Budgeting is about prioritizing and funding elections is not a cause worthy of taking money out of the productive private sector through taxes, especially considering the cuts that K-12 education and the UNC system are facing.
Currently, you have a choice on whether funding campaigns is a worthwhile investment; you can choose to contribute to candidates that you support. Publicly funded campaigns would take that decision away from you. Government is supposed to run elections but it is not the purpose of government to fund candidates. Candidates accepting public funds would be required to adhere to strict campaign regulations, a form of government control.
When considering policy, it is always good to ask the following three questions: Does the policy increase freedom? In this case, no – in fact, it restricts freedom. Does the policy make government more efficient? No, these two bills would needlessly increase the size of bureaucracy and impose onerous regulations that would require government oversight. Does the policy promote fairness? No. What is fair about forcing taxpayers to fund the political campaigns of candidates that they may not even support? A fourth question: all things considered, are voter-owned elections a good policy?
Civitas Legislative Report 6/18
Senate set to ban sweepstakes cafes; outcome less certain in the House.
Tax Refunds for NASCAR
Call it the “NASCAR tax credit.” SB1215, “Economic Incentives Alignment & Changes,” is another piece of wish list economic incentives legislation that, among other things, refunds sales and use taxes to NASCAR teams while the citizens of North Carolina work to cover the budget deficit created by our spendthrift elected officials. Primarily sponsored by Rep. Clark Jenkins (D-Edgecombe), the bill has passed the Senate and is waiting on action in the House.
The bill would entitle motorsports teams (NASCAR teams) to a refund of the sales and use taxes paid on aviation fuel for the rest of 2010. Furthermore, the bill would allow a 50% refund on sales and use taxes paid on the purchase of motorsports accessory items such as paint until 2014. The NASCAR tax credit is especially egregious relative to the other tax credits in the bill.
North Carolinians pay the second highest gas tax in the Southeast. Florida, the only Southeastern state with a higher tax, does not levy income taxes on its citizens. While the state should be proud that it is home to so many NASCAR teams, granting those teams favored tax status (especially in the midst of the state’s current budget woes) is unacceptable. Perhaps the General Assembly should ease the tax burden on everyone instead of only on selected industries.
Keeping North Carolina Competitive?
Logrolling is a term used in politics to describe when legislators promise to vote for one anothers bills in an effort to keeps the legislative wheels greased. Essentially, logrolling is when legislators say something to the effect of “I’ll vote for your pet project if you’ll vote for mine.”
HB1973, the “Keep North Carolina Competitive Act,” is a somewhat murky example of this legislative maneuver. Sponsored primarily by Reps. Bill Owens (D-Pasquotank), Pryor Gibson (D-Anson), William Wainwright (D-Craven), and Harold Brubaker (R-Randolph) and co-sponsored by a number of other legislators, the bill is a compilation of numerous other bills which contain very specific economic incentives that likely would not have passed individually. The bill sponsors rolled all of the individual bills into the all encompassing “Keep North Carolina Competitive Act” to rally enough legislators around the provisions and ensure passage.
When the 19 page bill was first introduced in committee last week, it came as a surprise to a number of legislators because the bill was not on the agenda. The committee voted on the bill after less than an hour of debate. Reps. Marilyn Avila (R-Wake) and Mitch Gillespie (R-McDowell) complained that they had not even had time to read and fully consider the bill, but their concerns were dismissed.
The bill includes tax credits for, and the creation of, what are called “Eco-Industrial Parks.” These newly incentivized economic development zones are the brainchild of Rep. Owens. He has said explicitly that the parks were specifically designed to benefit his district. Furthermore, the bill greatly expands North Carolina’s generous tax credits for film production companies ensuring that movie stars and million dollar film studios are not excessively burdened by North Carolina’s tax laws. Meanwhile, those of us who do not produce films are left to fill in the budget deficit.
Legislators prefer specific incentives instead of broad-based tax cuts because when the incentivized industry adds jobs, legislators can take credit for “creating jobs.” After two hours of sometimes contentious debate on the House floor, HB1973 passed by an overwhelming majority yesterday. Considering North Carolina’s dismal economy we can only hope that this stimulus works. I have my doubts.
Hypocrisy of Gambling in NC
The hypocrisy on display this morning at the General Assembly with regards to HB80, entitled “Ban Electronic Sweepstakes,” was appalling. The bill would do exactly what its title implies – ban the proliferating electronic sweepstakes gaming industry that only recently emerged.
Privately run video gaming businesses would be banned if the bill passed eliminating private sector gambling in the state with the exception of Native American Indians. Sen. Marc Basnight (D-Dare) favors eliminating the electronic sweepstakes games because they prey disproportionately on the poor. Sen. Josh Stein (D-Wake) said that these electronic sweepstakes games were “competitive impulsive behavior akin to gambling.”
Speaking of gambling, the state of North Carolina’s education lottery comes to mind. This, too, preys disproportionately on the poor and is essentially a regressive tax used to fund education (unless the fund is raided to pay for something else). When asked about his contrasting stance on the state lottery and privately run gaming, Sen. Basnight claimed that “the line must be drawn somewhere.” Apparently for Basnight, the line should be in drawn in a manner that allows the state to profit from a regressive tax but does not let the private sector.
One way or the other, North Carolina and Senator Basnight need to be consistent. Gambling should either be legal or illegal but the state should not be treated differently than the private sector.
More Fees, Subsidies, and the Deliberative Deficit
It’s business as usual in the North Carolina Senate. Wednesday, the Senate Finance committee very summarily gave the nod to two bills that raise costs for North Carolina workers and keep businesses paying disproportionate taxes due to excessive subsidies.
SB 1210, a bill sponsored by Sen. Hoyle (D – Gaston), which doubles the cost of license fees for Athletic Trainers, was given a favorable reading by the committee with very little protest or questions by its members. This bill, originally covered in an earlier blog post, would raise the cost of athletic trainer fees to $200, raise annually required license renewals to $75, and cause the reinstatement of a lapsed license to cost $100. The stated reason for the requested raise in fees is due to lost revenues from a drop in the number of licensees. That is, instead of scaling down the costs of the North Carolina Board of Athletic Trainer Examiners so as not to encumber the decreasing number of athletic trainers, the senate proposes to increase fees on those of this vocation. Perhaps they will move to raise costs again when these whopping fees begin to encourage more North Carolinians to abandon the profession.
SB 1215, a bill sponsored by Sen. Clark Jenkins (D – Edgecombe), allows subsidies on many industries to continue in North Carolina, thus causing the bulk of taxation to fall disproportionately on other industries. Subsidies allow the state government to play god with North Carolina’s economy, favoring some businesses and forsaking others. This is harmful to the economy because it stifles investment by companies that do not fall through the tax loopholes and causes unsubsidized industries to pick up the slack. This bill sets distant sunsets for subsidies on industries like professional Motorsports teams, Bioprocessing, and Aircraft manufacturing. Instead of lowering the sales and use tax across the entire state and letting the market make the most efficient investment choices, the senate feels that they know better what will bring investment to North Carolina. Lowering overall taxes doesn’t seem to be one of their priorities. This bill was also given a favorable reading, and similarly was lacking in democratic deliberation.