Three bills in the General Assembly would raise the cap on charter schools. Civitas Institute Senior Policy Analyst Bob Luebke urges caution over state control in them.
Legislative Activity
Charter school cap bills sit idle but carry caution
Bill Introduced to Eliminate 25 State Aircraft
Reps. Jim Crawford (D-Granville), Nelson Cole (D-Rockingham), and Larry Hall (D-Durham) are the primary sponsors of HB1823 entitled “Sell Underutilized State Aircraft.” The bill would carry out the recommendations of a study completed by the Program Evaluation Division calling for the elimination of 25 state owned aircraft. The elimination of these aircraft is long overdue. Legislators should expect a push back from agencies which own aircraft that would be eliminated.
According to the report, the elimination of 25 underutilized aircraft and five aircraft hangers may yield up to $8.1 million and save the state $1.5 million annually. This is certainly a step in the right direction. Now, if only our elected officials would continue to eliminate waste in government, like traveling to Jacksonville, NC via car instead of via aircraft, this state may yet pull itself out of its current fiscal crisis. Read about the structural fiscal issues facing North Carolina here.
Texting While Legislating
In North Carolina it is illegal to send text messages while driving. Evidently it is not illegal for the Speaker of the House of Representatives to send text messages while presiding over budget proceedings on the House floor. Earlier today, Rep. Joe Hackney (D-Orange) was seen doing just that.
We’re Government, We Know Better Than You
The state Senate voted 39-5 to let the Robeson County town of Pembroke impose a tax on hotel rooms there.The only hotel in Pembroke, a 62-room Holiday Inn Express, opposes the tax, which would be 3 percent of the price of a room and be levied in addition to the 7.75 percent sales tax.
Estimates for the tax’s annual revenues ranged from $21,600 to $40,000, depending upon who was doing the figuring. The law would say the money must be used to promote tourism in Pembroke.
Who cares if you don’t want to be taxed. Government knows better than you how you should promote your business.
New Regulations Scrap July 4 Fireworks
You may remember last year, in a typical knee-jerk legislative overreaction to a tragic accident, the General Assembly passed, and Gov. Perdue signed into law SB 563, which implemented new measures to regulate, permit and require training for all fireworks shows in the state.
Well, with annual July 4 fireworks displays just around the corner, what is beginning to happen? Cities and towns are having to cancel their shows because of the overly burdensome requirements.
For example — Hatteras and Ocracoke, the very place that triggered the new law.
Dennis Robinson, president of the Hatteras Village Civic Association, which organizes and pays for the Hatteras village fireworks, said the association’s board made a decision in February to cancel this year’s show.
“We have cancelled our show,” said Robinson. “We had the fire company explain all the new regulations and give us an overview and a timeline, such as when the class and training could be and how long it would take to get the necessary permits after that. We reviewed this information and also talked about the money aspect and the liability, and the board came to the consensus not to have the show for 2010.
And for the record, the accident last year had nothing to do with the decision according to Rudy Austin, president of the Ocracoke Business and Civic Association.
I’m pretty sure that as more local communities figure out all these new rules we’ll be hearing much, much more of this in the coming weeks.
HB1403: Collecting DNA Upon Arrest Legislative Update
The House Judiciary I Committee met today to debate HB1403 entitled “Collect DNA Sample on Arrest.” Last week, Civitas posted an article on its website outlining the philosophical debate within the conservative movement surrounding the bill. Today, the debate continued as interests from both sides were given time to address the committee.
Privacy advocates from the North Carolina Chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and Grassroots North Carolina voiced their concerns. Representatives of each group claimed that collecting a DNA sample prior to conviction without informed consent or a warrant would be in violation of the Fourth Amendment. Furthermore, the ACLU pushed for statutory assurance that DNA samples and data would be destroyed and that the state would initiate the process of expunction.
The committee heard from supporters. Two women, one of which was a representative from the Surviving Parents Coalition addressed the legislators. Both women were mothers of murder victims – the murderer in both cases being a repeat offender. They argued that their children would still be alive today, or at least the suspect would have been apprehended more quickly, had a system similar to that created in HB1403 been in place in their respective states (Florida & Tennessee) prior to the murders.
Via the amendment process, the committee drew nearer to an acceptable balance between the competing interests today by inserting language requiring suspects arrested without warrant to appear before a magistrate, where probable cause can be determined, prior to DNA sample collection. Also, the committee adopted an amendment allowing individuals whose DNA is not deemed appropriate for expunction to appeal the state’s decision to a court for review. Legislators were also assured that the DNA samples and data markers would be completely destroyed if a suspect were to be found innocent and that the DNA markers used in databases would not reveal medical, gender, racial or other personal information.
It is imperative, if the General Assembly moves to pass this legislation, that there are sufficient safeguards to ensure that the Fourth Amendment Rights of all individuals are protected because it is likely that this system, which exists in similar form in over 20 states, will eventually be argued before the Supreme Court. A February 2010 Civitas Poll indicates that 60% of North Carolinians support the premise of HB1403. North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper supports the bill as well.
5/28 Bad Bill is on the Move
S.B. 1114 sponsored by Sen. Kinnaird (D- Orange), has been introduced in the House as H.B. 1888 by Rep. Insko (D- Orange) and Rep. Faison (D- Orange). This bill, last week’s Bad Bill of the Week, has passed the second and third readings in the Senate and is currently scheduled to be considered by the State and Local Government II Committee.
If it is found favorable, it will be passed on to the House Committee of Energy and Energy Efficiency. If there existed a Committee for Encouraged Patronage, this bill would surely need to stop there before moving on.
Senate Bill to Injure Athletic Trainers
A little over a week ago, Sen. David Hoyle (D-Gaston) introduced SB 1210, a bill that would arbitrarily double the cost of license fees for Athletic Trainers from $100 to $200, as well as increasing renewal fees and fees to reinstate a lapsed licenses.
The bill, which is currently in committee, states no reason for raising fees, but there is the obvious implication of state government seeking another avenue of income. Rather than looking to cut costs or root out inefficiencies within extant and financially encumbering bureaucracies, Sen. Hoyle perfectly exemplifies government’s preference to raise money at the tax payer’s expense. Additionally, Sen. Hoyle is taking a more clandestine route to revenue enhancement, as raising fees on a small subsection of society would not draw as much public attention as would raising taxes to a large sect of the population.
Athletic trainers generally earn in the neighborhood of $30-$40,000 a year, thus to an athletic trainer this extra $100 is no trifle. This boils down to a barrier to entry that will make it at best uncomfortable, at worst difficult, for start-up individuals in this vocation.
This is an example of the slow creeping growth of government, like a vine that extends itself a few inches more overnight. While some might see this as individually insignificant, it is indicative of a larger, more universal propensity that must be restrained.
Bad Bill of the Week 5/28
The Bad Bill of the Week is back!
This week bill(s) are S.B. 1113 and S.B. 1114:
“What these bills would do is encourage city councils to invent projects that could be termed ‘aimed at energy efficiency’ in order to line the pockets of any contractor they favor with the money of Carrboro and Chapel Hill taxpayers.”
Oh, and the no-bid contracts that can be awarded for the projects are just peachy too.
Read the entire article here.
Senate Democrats scramble to find votes on “charter lite” bill
The state Senate passed a bill that would allow school districts to turn low performing schools into what it terms “charter schools” that would still be run by the school system. But Senate Democrats couldn’t find enough sure votes at first to assure quick passage. There were apparently several head counts during a recess among Democrats until they thought they had enough votes. At one point Republicans thought they had enough votes to stop the bill. Three Democratic Senators announced pairs rather than register a vote, they were Don Davis, Steve Goss and John Snow. That was enough to get the bill through the Senate. The final vote to concur with the conferene report was 21 to 19. The GOP members would rather see two bills in the legislature approved that would raise the cap on real charter schools to 106. Democrats said Governor Beverly Perdue needed the low performing conversion bill to include in an application for the next round of the “Race to the Top” federal grants. The state lost in the first round.