A new Civitas Legislative Report is available on new tax incentives to recruit three new companies to North Carolina. Its the same old debate over “do we play” or “does it matter.”
Legislative Activity
Civitas Legislative Report – 5-26-10
A Dish NC Taxpayers Shouldn’t be Forced to Swallow
The $800 million budget shortfall the state of North Carolina currently faces has been well documented. Just last week, the Senate voted 30-16 to approve a $20+ billion budget that, according to Democratic leaders, would close the revenue gap, while still protecting the most important state services from being ravaged. The House of Representatives is currently drafting their own version of the budget, and just last night members held a public forum where constituents were allowed to offer their own ideas. One thing is for certain, and that is legislators will have to prioritize their spending and only fund the most important government services.
In light of this ongoing struggle to balance the state budget, one particularly frivolous bill was introduced today on the House floor by Rep. Sandra Spaulding Hughes (D-New Hanover). If passed, HB 1937 will appropriate $500,000 to Cooking for Change, Inc., a non-profit organization based in Wilmington that helps provide economically disadvantaged adults with skills for careers in the food service industry.
Perhaps Rep. Hughes has forgotten that the state already offers high-quality, easily accessible education to its citizens in the form of the community college system. In particular, Wilmington is the home to Cape Fear Community College, which offers a program in culinary technology. This curriculum is designed to provide “specific training required to prepare students to assume positions as trained culinary professionals in a variety of food service settings.”
Simply put, it is irresponsible for legislators to use taxpayers’ money to fund their pet projects, especially those that unnecessarily duplicate already existing programs.
Who Decides How Much Energy You Use?
A bill titled in short “Promote Electricity Demand Reduction (SB567)” sponsored by Senator Hartsell (R-Cabarrus) would promote allowing public utilities “real-time control” over your energy usage in order to achieve a measurable reduction in electricity demands for the purpose of assisting public utilities in achieving mandates set forth by the General Assembly in August 2007.
The August 2007 legislation, “Promote Renewable Energy/Baseload Generation (SB3),” requires that, by 2021, 12.5% of retail public utility energy sales in North Carolina be from renewable energy sources (solar, wind, etc), up to a quarter of which can be achieved through encouraging energy consumption reduction by consumers — hence the introduction of SB 567.
SB567 allows public utilities to achieve the required energy portfolio diversification through demand-side control of how much energy you may consume. And while energy usage reductions may keep prices down overall, it will not control per unit energy prices and will result in less comfortable lifestyles. For example, your public utility may want you to run your AC fewer hours on a hot day to conserve energy.
Senator Hartsell apparently sees fit that some other entity should decide how much energy you consume for the purpose of achieving the goals of SB3’s excessive regulation. The broader problem here is the state’s encroachment on the free market in the name of “sustainability” and the “green economy.” We must be aware of the government edging its way into our lives.
Collecting DNA from Felons
One of the seemingly more interesting bills making its way through the General Assembly this week is HB 1403, sponsored by Reps. Wil Neumann (R-Gaston), Pearl Burris-Floyd (R-Gaston), Darrell McCormick (R-Yadkin) and Thom Tillis (R-Mecklenburg) which would allow for a DNA sample to be taken from every person arrested on a felony charge.
I’m not going to get into the civil liberties vs. security debate right now, but we polled this very question back in our February statewide survey.
Attorney General Roy Cooper recently announced a plan to collect DNA samples from every one arrested on felony charges in North Carolina before going to trial and enter that information into a statewide database. Do you support or oppose this idea?
Support – 60%
Oppose – 29%
Not Sure – 11%
State Aircraft Waste
The state of North Carolina deserves some credit for selling off two planes, one each from the Department of Commerce and the Department of Transportation, per the suggestion of an April 2010 report on the massively inefficient and startlingly cost-ineffective operation of state-owned aircraft. The Department of Commerce sold a 27 year old passenger aircraft in October 2009 and the Department of Transportation sold a 27 year old passenger aircraft in January 2010.
Currently, the Department of Commerce and the Department of Transportation own two aircraft each, all four of which are used to fly our government officials, Governor Perdue and UNC chancellor Holden Thorp among them, to destinations like the ACC men’s basketball tournament and destinations far from Raleigh, not easily accessible by car, like Jacksonville, NC.
While the current Senate Budget does specifically say that any travel to collegiate events must be fully paid for by the state officials who are traveling, the fact remains that the state officials are using state aircraft to travel when commercial travel or chartered flights are good enough for the rest of us. The budget does not address the travel of state officials to destinations easily accessible by car. Intuitively, vehicular travel is cheaper than air travel and, when traveling from Raleigh to Charlotte, is as time efficient. That is, unless there is traffic because the Highway Trust Fund’s budget continues to be raided to pay for many of the wasteful expenditures in the General Fund and is thus unable to provide adequate vehicular transit infrastructure.
The two aircraft owned by the Department of Commerce are, in the Senate Budget, being transferred to the Department of Transportation. As is an appropriation from the General Fund to pay for the increased costs to the Department of Transportation. That will leave the Department of Transportation with a total of four aircraft to fly our state officials around. Still, Department of Transportation dollars will be spent on flying the governor instead of providing highway infrastructure to ease traffic congestion in your town. So, next time you’re sitting in traffic and you hear a plane flying overhead, be sure to wave because it just might be your governor jet-setting in a taxpayer-owned airplane to some faraway place like Burlington or Greensboro.
Legislation Will Hurt Small Business SB829
The House Commerce, Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee will consider legislation on Wednesday that will augment the power and widen the profit margins of large corporations at the expense of small businesses and citizens. The bill, Regulation of Appraisal Management Companies (SB829), will, as currently written, place onerous regulations and assess fees on these companies that will disproportionately affect small business and bolster the market share and power of large corporations.
To qualify for registration, companies must register with the state, pay a filing fee of $5,000 and pay a subsequent annual free of $2,500. Large companies will much more easily be able to pay these registration fees while smaller appraisal management firms, the small businesses that create jobs, opportunity and wealth for many North Carolinians, will be burdened excessively, perhaps to the point of being unprofitable. Furthermore, companies that are able to pay the fee will simply pass along the added expense to consumers, making it more expensive for North Carolinians to do business.
Additionally, the legislation will require that each individual who owns more than ten percent of a registered company to be of “good moral character” as though it is falls under the purview of state government to ensure that business owners are of good moral character. Such intrusions into the lives of business owners and the subjectivity involved in assessing what qualifies as “good moral character” are inconsistent with the free market and individual liberty. The state continues to amass power and, as always, does so at the expense of its citizens.
Companies that are successfully registered will be required to designate compliance managers who will be tasked with ensuring that their respective companies operate in compliance with the legislation. The employee assigned this duty will be forced to spend time going through this bureaucratic red tape instead of being a productive worker and the overall productivity of the company will suffer as a result. For small businesses operating on the margin, this, in addition to the burdensome fees, may force the small business out of business.
It should come as no surprise that federal, state or municipal government entities as well as banks and credit unions are exempt.
It is no surprise that big business supports this legislation as it will decrease competition by forcing small businesses out of the market and creating a high barrier to entry for any new firms seeking to enter into the market. Onerous regulation will decrease the productivity of each company and the fees will simply be passed on to the consumer. Bottom line: the citizens of North Carolina will suffer while the state assesses the moral character of business owners and large corporations increase their profit margins.
Some Bills of Note Being Introduced on Day #2
Today marks the second day of the legislative session, and there are a flurry of bills on the legislative calendar slated to be introduced. Many of you are already familiar with the Civitas Institute’s Bad Bill of the Week series from last session – a series we plan on continuing this session – but we also like to call attention to legislation we feel will have a positive impact on North Carolina.
Four such house bills are scheduled to be introduced today.
HB 1659, sponsored by Rep. Stam (R-Wake) and Lewis (R-Harnett), is a bill that would strengthen private property rights by amending the state constitution to protect against eminent domain abuse (an issue highlighted in the Civitas Institute’s 20 Changes for 2010: A Primer for State Reform).
Two bills will be introduced to address the rule adopted by the State Board of Community Colleges that allows illegal immigrants to enroll in North Carolina’s Community Colleges. HB 1672, sponsored by Rep. West (R-Cherokee), Rep. Guice (R-Henderson); and HB 1679, sponsored by Rep. Cleveland (R-Onslow), Rep. Neumann (R-Gaston), Rep. Burris-Floyd (R-Cleveland), and Rep. Moore (R-Cleveland) would change North Carolina’s general statutes regarding the community college system to include the term “who are lawfully present in the United States” to the eligibility criteria for community college enrollees. The bills would also update state law to include the following:
The admissions standards of the State Board of Community Colleges and the admissions standards of all local community colleges shall prohibit the admission of persons who are not lawfully present in the United States, except as otherwise required by federal law.
Lastly, HB 1674, sponsored by Rep. Stam, Burris-Floyd, Tillis (R-Mecklenburg), and Barnhart (R-Cabarrus), is a bill that would authorize the General Assembly to consider a bill “TO BE ENTITLED AN ACT TO PROTECT THE FREEDOM TO CHOOSE HEALTH CARE AND HEALTH INSURANCE.” (caps in original). In other words, this bill would allow the introduction of and debate on a bill to exempt North Carolinians from the federal health care reform’s mandatory requirement forcing citizens to purchase a government-approved health insurance plan. Disappointingly, this bill will not see the light of day, as Attorney General Roy Cooper has refused to join dozens of other states in a lawsuit against this mandate.
General Assembly Considers Tax Credits for Hollywood Studios at the Expense of Taxpayers
The North Carolina House of Representatives is currently considering HB 713, legislation that would award tens of millions of dollars in tax breaks to billion-dollar movie studios and production companies. Supposedly designed to create additional jobs during these trying economic times, this bill will in reality only further burden the hardworking taxpayers of North Carolina.
According to a fiscal note accompanying the bill, the total amount of lost revenue associated with this tax credit is estimated to be between $40 and $60 million annually. Should the General Assembly not pass any corresponding spending cuts this session, this shortfall will inevitably have to be closed by state taxpayers.
To make matters worse, there is little evidence to suggest that targeted film incentive programs actually promote sustainable job growth. In a January 2010 report published in response to similar legislation being debated in Iowa, the non-partisan Washington, D.C.-based Tax Foundation reported that such incentives fail to both “encourage economic growth overall” and to “raise tax revenue.”
In a news conference held earlier today, House Speaker Joe Hackney cited fiscal responsibility as being one of the primary focuses of the House Democrats during the upcoming legislative session. Amidst reports that the Senate Democrats will be dropping a proposed teacher pay raise from their budget proposal, one has to wonder whether or not it is responsible for the state to waste up to $60 million in an unproven tax credit program.
Bill Socializes Risk; Hold on to Your Wallets!
Today in the General Assembly, the House of Representatives voted unanimously to not consider HB530, the Life Sciences Development Act, on the floor and send it to a conference committee. Do not be fooled, this legislation will be considered in the halls of the General Assembly sooner rather than later and will expose North Carolinians to immense financial risk.
The bill will bring the failed policies of Fannie Mae, the giant mortgage securities firm that caused the housing bubble and subsequent burst, to the Tar Heel State. By insuring investors’ against loss, the legislation will socialize risk while privatizing profit and leave taxpayers exposed to as much as $100 million in losses.
The core of the bill allows investors, likely to be large corporations like Goldman Sachs, to pour money into a government entity with a statutory guarantee that the loan will be repaid plus a set rate of return, no matter whether the investment fails, via either direct payments or tax credits.
Supporters of the legislation will point to the provision in the bill saying that the financial obligations of the government entity making the loan are not obligations of the state but of the entity itself. In other words, supporters will claim that taxpayers, because of this provision, are not on the hook. However, the bill states that should the government entity not be able to pay its investors their guaranteed return, tax credits will be granted in lieu in the amount of the payments.
These tax credits seem innocuous enough but they represent lost tax revenue for the state thus leaving taxpayers on the hook to pay off failed investments made by private entities. Profits from the investments will be paid to private entities while the risk is socialized and failure paid for by taxpayers.
Furthermore, the government entity will make loans the private creditors refuse to make, that is why the bill was drafted, thus rendering the investments at an increased risk of failure. When experts at credit institutions who evaluate risk for a living decide not to invest they do so for a reason and it is likely a smart idea that the taxpayers of North Carolina not risk their resources either.
This type of underhanded socialism represents a dangerous step for North Carolina. Should this legislation become a reality, the state of North Carolina could become, by proxy, the proud owners of the life sciences industry in the state. HB530 represents a significant shift towards the left and away from limited government and free market capitalism.
Quality proficiency standards lacking in most states.
The development of strong state academic standards were considered a major selling point for No Child Left Behind legislation. They gave states flexibility and also provided a means by which the feds would gauge progress. How have the states done in developing useful and academically rigorous standards? The record is a mixed bag at best. That’s the assessment of a new study by Harvard University researchers Paul Peterson and Carlos Xabel Lastra-Anadon and reported on the web site of the influential education reform journal Education Next.
In the report the authors compared the percentage of students who were classified as “proficient” by state standards with the percentage of students deemed proficient under the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). Grades were then assigned based on the level of divergence from NAEP scores on math and reading for 2009. Peterson has done similar tests in previous years (e.g. 2003, 2005, and 2007). He writes about last year’s results here.
What did Peterson find?
Every state, for both reading and math (with the exception of Massachusetts for math), deems more students “proficient” on its own assessments than NAEP does. The average difference is a startling 37 percentage points.
As far as trend lines, the authors found there has been a little improvement in reading scores while state scores for math actually worsened.
How does North Carolina fare? Peterson gave the Tar Heel state a C. The two states that received Race to the Top Funds, Delaware and Tennessee received grades of C- and F respectively.
This last development raises a whole set of other questions. Does the data confirm what many of us have thought for a long time: states have no incentives to set high standards? Also, what does it say about Race-to-the-Top, when the “winners” have below average and failing standards? Are the feds once again merely rewarding mediocrity and failure?