This week The J.W. Pope Foundation’s publication Liberty Leader tells the story of Baker Mitchell, an engineer from Texas who traded a comfy retirement to develop highly successful charter schools in North Carolina based on tried and true instructional methods and classical virtues. It’s a story worth reading. Thank you Baker for all you do for young people and our state!
Miscellaneous
Who is Baker Mitchell?
Gov. McCrory Vetoes First Bill – HB 392 Drug Testing for Public Assistance
Gov. McCrory just vetoed his first bill of the 2013 Legislation Session. The bill he vetoed is HB 392 “Warrant Status/ Drug Screen Public Assistance.” Civitas recently reported on the bill when it was passing through the Legislature and many people thought the bill would be a victory for public assistance.
In McCrory’s press released on 8/15/2013 McCrory gives an explanation about why he vetoed the bill. “This is not a smart way to combat drug abuse,” Governor McCrory continued. “Similar efforts in other states have proved to be expensive for taxpayers and did little to actually help fight drug addiction. It makes no sense to repeat those mistakes in North Carolina.”
While the bill was a Republican Bill there was a Democrat who has a say in tweaking the bill to benefit the poor. Sen. Angela Bryant (D-Edgecombe) stated, “I only did it because I was given the opportunity by the sponsors to have some influence addressing the unconstitutional(ity) of it — particularly the drug-testing part,” Bryant explained. “That bill started out drug-testing everybody.” Bryant said there was a suggestion coming out of the House to change some of the language in the bill and to test those where there was a reasonable suspicion of drug use. “There was an opening to further define and narrow reasonable suspicion so that everybody wouldn’t be tested,” Bryant said. “That bill had already passed in the Senate over my objection. Since it looked like it was going to pass in some form anyway, it seemed to me more helpful to get in there and try to narrow it than to stand in complete opposition.”
While the question of long term cost is questioned the requirements of the bill would allow for those who truly need help to be given the assistance the need and encourage good responsible behavior.
What happens next to HB 392? According to the General Assembly’s website:
“The Governor is required to reconvene the General Assembly if a bill is vetoed after adjournment, unless a written request is received and signed by a majority of the Members of both houses that it is not necessary to reconvene.
If the Governor vetoes a bill, the bill is returned to the original house where 3/5 of present and voting members can vote to override the veto. If the original house votes to override the veto, the bill is sent to the second house where 3/5 of present and voting members must also vote to override the veto before the bill can become law.”
State lawmakers may very well be returning to Raleigh to attempt a veto override.
Racial Justice Act Case Headed to State Supreme Court
The News and Observer reported today that a Racial Justice Act case is headed to the state Supreme Court. According to the article, “Prosecutors will be challenging a Cumberland County judge’s 2012 decision converting Robinson’s death sentence to life in prison without possibility for parole.”
While Civitas reported several weeks ago that the Racial Justice Act rulings are up in the air – we posed the question: Could these hearings be the first of many prior rulings on their way to reversal?
While reading the N&O’s description of people lining up to defend the 2012 decision, something stuck out::
Among those who support upholding Judge Gregory Weeks’ 2012 landmark ruling are former senior military officials, families of murder victims from across North Carolina, potential jurors who contend they “were denied a voice in capital decision-making because of their race,” professors and social scientists, and the N.C. Advocates for Justice, a nonprofit, nonpartisan association.
“Families of murder victims?” Which ones did they talk to? While some family members of murder victims may support the ruling – they obviously did not talk to the families who were affected by Judge Weeks ruling. I believe that if you talk to the Turner or Lowry (2 of the families that had their loved ones murders sentence commuted from Death to Life without parole in the December ruling) their opinion would be different!
It seems as though the media is only looking at one side of the story and the side they want to look at. What about the True Victims of the Racial Justice Act?
North Carolina Man Sentenced to 7 Years in Prison for 17th DWI
Many of you have probably heard the news about the North Carolina man being sentenced to 7 years in prison for his 17th DWI.
Such news may lead many to wonder: So what is the difference between a DUI and DWI? Do they mean the same thing? What verbiage does North Carolina (NC) use? What are the consequences of driving under the influence? There are so many questions about the law but what happens when someone is charged and sentenced with their 17th DWI?
DUI is an acronym for driving under the influence. DWI stands for driving while intoxicated. In some cases, depending on state law, the two terms are both used to describe impaired or drunken driving. North Carolina’s Safe Roads Act of 1983 did away with all of the state’s previous drug- and alcohol-related driving laws and put everything under a single offense―North Carolina only has driving while impaired, or DWI.
Your blood alcohol concentration (BAC) is the most common way NC determines whether you’re legally impaired.The legal limits are:
- 21 or Older: 0.08%
- Commercial drivers (CDL): 0.04%
- Younger than 21: Any alcohol concentration
- Prior DWI: 0.04%
NC DWI penalties are serious business and should be for endangering people’s lives. Based on your age, the offense number, and your license type, you may face penalties like:
- Fines, including court costs and lawyer fees.
- License suspension or revocation.
- Jail time. For some offenses, the jail time is mandatory rather than possible.
- Community service.
- Higher car insurance rates.
17 times is a lot in anyone’s book to be charged with DWI. Should the penalties be harsher for the habitual offenders? Should the Legislature in NC look into laws concerning habitual offenders next session?
Will Convicted Felon and Home Leave Participant be Arrested While Out for Weekend?
Changes have been made to the Prisoner Home Leave Program but there are still questionable convicts being released on the weekend. One of the new rules to the policy was that the District Attorney had to be notified when a new prisoner has qualified for home leave by the Department of Corrections. The District Attorney in Rockingham County has recently been notified that Claimon Lee Tyler was approved for participation in the program. Claimon Tyler has a wrap sheet a mile long and is eligible for parole but what you might find interesting is that he has an outstanding Order for Arrest in Forsyth County. Will Claimon Tyler be arrested this weekend?
Click here to see the Letter Objecting to Tyler’s Home Leave, The Outstanding order for Arrest, and the District Attorney’s Original Letter pertaining to the Home Leave Program
Should We Even Consider “Banning the Box?”
This morning we are hearing about another case of a church volunteer being inappropriate with a child in a church facility. While we all want to believe that people who want to work with children have a great heart and no other motivation, there is a need to be smart.
Read here to get more information about the story.
This past legislative session we heard about “banning the box” on job applications, about checking if you have been charged with a felony. Supposedly if we ban the box on job applications, this will give employers more initiative to hire convicted felons and give them a chance to go back into normal situations. If situations like the one mentioned above keep happening, however, and no one is checking workers’ background – what will happen to the children?
Eliminating teacher tenure: What does NC think?
NCAE and others have been vocal in criticizing provisions in the State budget that would eliminate teacher tenure. As the largest teacher association in North Carolina and an arm of the National Education Association, NCAE’s actions are not surprising.
Still it’s fair to ask: Are Republican legislators stripping away teacher protections and ramming through unpopular changes? Let’s look at the facts.
Opponents fail to mention that teachers will be offered a series of one to four year contracts depending on their years of experience and that they will still enjoy the same protections against unjust dismissal and due process that they have always had.
Second, poll results suggest North Carolinians don’t support tenure. Over the last few years, the Civitas Institute has asked for voter views on tenure as well as views on proposals to end it. What did we find?
March 2013 Poll asked:
Do you favor or oppose the concept of tenure for teachers?
Favor – 37.5%;
Oppose – 49.9%
Don’t know/Refused – 12.6%
Do you favor or oppose allowing assistant principals and other administrators also have the opportunity to obtain tenure?
Favor – 30.4%
Oppose – 56.2%
Don’t know/Refused – 13.4%
May 2012 Poll asked a split sample:
Would you support or oppose a proposal to end tenure for teachers in North Carolina Public Schools?
Sample A
Support – 75.3%
Oppose – 16.7%
Don’t know/Refused – 8%
Sample B
Support – 67%
Oppose – 21.4%
Don’t know/Refused 11.6%
January 2012 Poll asked:
Would you support or oppose the elimination of tenure?
Support – 49.6%
Oppose – 32.9%
Don’t Know/Refused – 17.8%
So are the views of North Carolinians on teacher tenure out of line with those in the rest of the country? A 2012 National Survey in the education reform journal Education Next asked the following question:
Teachers with tenure cannot be dismissed unless a school district follows detailed procedures. Some say that tenure protects teachers from being fired for arbitrary reasons. Others say that it makes it too difficult to replace ineffective teachers. We want to know what you think of tenure. Do you favor or oppose offering tenure to teachers?
All Respondents
Favor: 39%
Oppose: 61%
Teachers
Favor: 55%
Oppose: 45%
Parents
Favor: 38%
Oppose 62%
It’s not difficult to see why the legislature passed legislation to eliminate teacher tenure or why NCAE’s message is not resonating.
House Resolution 1020: What’s Your Location?
“10-20” — “What’s your location?” — is what you will hear over law enforcement radio pretty often. Today in the North Carolina House of Representatives 10-20 has a whole new meaning.
House Resolution 1020 was heard this morning and Rep. Allen McNeil (R-Randolph) spoke about a fallen comrade. The standing ovation for the adoption of House Resolution 1020 would move anyone to tears. The Summey family stood on the balcony, trying to contain their emotions about fallen Deputy Sheriff Toney Clayton Summey. According to sources, Deputy Sheriff Toney Clayton Summey served with the Randolph County Sheriff’s Department for four years before he was killed in the line of duty in 2003. Summey’s murderer was sentenced to death and the family is waiting for justice to be served. Closure for the death of their loved one is drawing nearer with SB 306 becoming legislation.
Rep. Allen McNeill noted how many people miss him. While Deputy Sheriff Toney Clayton Summey may not be present with us here on earth, we do know his location.
Conservatism: Not Mean, But Moral
With an adoring liberal media bounding along happily at his heels, William Barber has managed to portray North Carolina politics as a moral crusade. Perhaps you used to believe that conservatives simply held a different worldview and a different philosophy about the role of government? How naïve of you. Didn’t you know? According to Barber, conservative legislators only do what they do because they hate the poor, despise women, and want North Carolina to plunge into a thousand years of darkness.
Of course, William Barber isn’t the first person to paint conservatism as something it’s not: Conservatives are often labeled as reactionaries – “old white men” whose politics spring from knee-jerk resistance to change. It is a tired myth whose existence is maintained by constant reinforcement in biased liberal media. Rather than informing and educating the populace about both sides of a major philosophical debate, the media has largely echoed Barber’s demonizing rhetoric. Conservatives discuss pro-life legislation? They hate women. Conservatives argue for voter ID? They’re extreme. Conservatives pass tax reform? They’re immoral. The media’s failure to engage this sort of demagoguery reinforces the straw-man of the “mean” conservative, and makes substantive political discourse impossible.
If it even needs to be said, the legislative agenda currently pursued in our General Assembly is not the product of some regressive conspiracy against the downtrodden. It is, by and large, a rational response to the problems facing North Carolina after decades of failed liberal-progressive policies. What’s more, it comes from a rich intellectual tradition that is guided primarily by moral considerations.
Conservatives and liberals differ on many things, but the central wedge is the question of the role of government. Liberal political philosophy has its roots in the Progressive Era and the “social justice” movement of the 1890s. Basically, progressives believe that the purpose of government is the realization of “social justice,” which they believe can be achieved through scientific administration. In other words, the government should actively work to bring about a just society. The problem, of course, is that the liberal conception of justice is often at odds with the conservative conception of justice.
Conservatives have a different idea about the role of government. They believe that the central role of government is not the realization of social justice — not because conservatives do not find justice objectively appealing, but because they question the government’s ability to provide it. Conservatives do believe in helping the homeless and the poor, but wherever possible they believe that assistance should come from civil society, not from the government. In other words, relief should come from friends, neighbors, churches, and community associations – not from an overweening state authority.
The reason for this is twofold: first, government cannot be trusted to responsibly exercise power. As Ronald Reagan once quipped, “A government bureau is the nearest thing to eternal life we’ll see on this earth.” This is a problem, for as government grows, it inevitably treads on individual rights.
Conservatives believe that government is not merely abusive, it is also debilitating. Much like a “helicopter parent” who raises a fearful and dependent child, a large government undermines the liberty and entrepreneurial spirit of its citizens. In the early 19th century Alexis de Tocqueville warned that centralized power could produce a dangerous, seemingly innocuous variant of despotism:
Above these [citizens] an immense tutelary power is elevated, which alone takes charge of assuring their enjoyments and watching over their fate. It is absolute, detailed, regular, far-seeing, and mild. It would resemble paternal power if, like that, it had for its object to prepare men for manhood; but on the contrary, it seeks only to keep them fixed irrevocably in childhood … can it not take away from them the trouble of thinking and the pain of living?
Conservatives know that an ever-expanding set of government programs will inevitably descend into a welfare state that robs its citizens of their initiative and freedoms. As a result, conservatives aim to keep the state within the bounds of its proper and essential functions: the protection of individual rights like life, liberty, and property.
Conservatism is not a negative ethic, but a positive one. It does not seek to resist change, but rather aims to preserve those things which allow freedom, hope, and social mobility to thrive. Conservatism does not keep its citizens in perpetual childhood, but treats each citizen like an adult capable of making his or her own choices.
Conservatism is not mean. Conservatism is moral.
Home Leave for Prisoners: Delayed Press Conference?
The Commissioner of the Division of Public Safety, David Guice, and the Secretary of Public Safety, Kieran Shanahan, called a press conference today to address home leaves for prisoners, an issue Civitas recently raised. As the media was ready to take their notes, we were notified that the press conference was canceled due to “unforeseen circumstances.”
The time of the next press conference has not been released and we were told that they would notify us when it is rescheduled.
This leads to the question: Is the policy going to change soon?