This week we’re discussing the millions of taxpayer dollars that were mismanaged by the state-run ABC Commission, as well as making a few midterm predictions, and the recent findings of a school safety survey that could boost support for school choice policies in the state. Want to leave a comment about this episode? Shoot us an email at radio@nccivitas.org!
Miscellaneous
An ABC Liquor Scandal, Midterm Predictions, and School Safety – Civitalk

Scientology and WCPSS

Human rights declarations are usually flowery expansive documents that assert our common humanity and enumerate rights that have been trampled on or forgotten altogether.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Abridged for Youth) is one such document. It claims to be about rights but UDHR for Youth is disturbing for several reasons…First, it claims to be about rights, but UDHR lays claim on some wooly areas. For example. Consider the following sample from UDHR:
We all have the right to a good life. The right to an education. Primary school should be free. We Should learn about the United Nations and how to get on with others.
We all have a right to affordable housing, medicine, education and childcare, enough money to live on and medical help if we are ill or old.
If we are frightened or badly treated in our own country, we all have the right to run away to another country to be safe.
Of course, if you read all 30 points in the Abridged for Youth UDHR, you’d realize, not all of these are rights. They are hopes and policy prescriptions. And of course, the question becomes who is teaching this and why is it in our public schools?
Last week a friend handed me a copy of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), Abridged for Youth. He said his daughter, a fifth grader in Wake County Public Schools, had brought home a copy of the document. From the titling on the document it looked like it was part of a specific lesson in a Grade 5 curriculum.
UDHR is produced by Youth for Human Rights International (YHRI). YHRI was founded, staffed and largely financed by members of the Church of Scientology.
If you hadn’t heard already, the Church of Scientology occupies a questionable and controversial place in American religion and society. There are more than enough examples to establish Scientology’s place as a religious oddity, even a cult, according to some (see here, here and here). Some skeptics question Scientology’s credentials for being a church at all and say it’s merely a real estate company masquerading as a religious organization.
YHRI says its goal is to teach tolerance and cooperation and educate young people about their rights. Mary Shuttleworth, a Scientologist founded YHRI is 2001. Although there are no obvious references to Scientology on the YHRI web site, Shuttleworth is not shy about talking about the connection between Scientology and YHRI. This theme is also expanded at Scientology.org.
The Executive director of YHRI is Tim Bowles, Bowles served as General Legal Counsel for the Church of Scientology. Bowles also serves as an advisor to the Scientology’s Citizen’s Commission on Human Rights.
The Church of Scientology is listed on YHRI web pages as an “international collaborator.” YHRI has grown into a global movement, including hundreds of groups, clubs and chapters around the world. YHRI creates and sponsors videos, materials and events to further YHRI and Scientology.
If you think this sounds like an uncomfortable combination, you’re not alone. This is not the same as a traditional religious organization asking WCPSS to distribute materials in the schools. Rather it’s an organization with a troubled tax history and called anything from a cult to an international business. Another red flag is the clandestine nature of YHRI’s relationship with The Church of Scientology.
Numerous individuals and organizations have accused Church of Scientology of using YHRI as a front to recruit for members for the Church.
Accounts abound from Australia, Florida and Germany about problems with the church and how it recruits new members and interacts with local populations.
Considering these incidents, plus the negative perception of Scientology in the public’s mind, it makes one wonder: Why is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights for Youth being taught in Wake County Public Schools?
Marsy’s Law: #NixAllSix’s Latest Victim

As an unabashedly pro-life woman, I have no problem with laying my cards on the table: I welcome the day when one of society’s most vulnerable populations – unborn children – are afforded their constitutional (and natural) right to life protections. I am also committed to advocating for a culture that empowers women and men to parent the children they conceive in a way that protects child and mother, honoring the physical and emotional bond that exists.
But be that as it may, Marsy’s Law was never designed to be that vehicle of change for North Carolina’s youngest citizens. It was created to provide additional recourse and resources for violent crime victims and their family members.
However, despite the facts and bi-partisan support for this legislation, there are some extreme-left influencers that have expressed an unwillingness to be intellectually honest when it comes to Marsy’s Law, which seems to be the latest victim in their war on reality.
Marsy’s Law, or more specifically, H551/S595, recently came under attack by James Protzman, a former gubernatorial candidate and owner of BlueNC, a blog dedicated to “progressive politics in North Carolina.” Protzman encouraged voters to vote against this amendment, writing that although he can “sympathize with those who advocate for victim’s rights…they are being used by a devious legislature in pursuit of an extremist, right wing agenda.” Protzman went on to insist that it would pave the way for making abortion illegal, which set off alarm bells among pro-choicers.
As compensation for his impressive, but dishonest, mental gymnastics, Politifact NC gave him a “Pants on Fire” rating. Although Politifact states that they don’t generally cover blogs in their fact-checking project, they believed Protzman’s claims warranted a review because of the hundreds of social media shares– including former state Representative Frank McGuirt (D-Union) – it had already received.
In addition to Politifact’s coverage, Marsy’s Law for NC chastised Protzman and others for, “Their glib misinformation campaign,” describing it as, “an attempt to mislead voters, and ultimately will hurt crime victims and their families who deserve equal rights in the state constitution — rights that the accused and convicted already have.”
The spin that has been created by the #NixAllSix campaign is unfortunate but unsurprising. When you’re a hammer, everything is a nail…even when it’s a bill that expands protections for victims of violent and heinous crimes.
Why a New Podcast Called ‘Civitalk?’

As some are already aware, Brooke Medina and I have launched a new podcast here at Civitas called “Civitalk.” Obviously, podcasting is a booming market, but to be successful, they must be good and offer something unique considering all the competition. We know we have to compete for your valuable time. I only listen to two or three regularly myself. That is why I want to offer just a few thoughts on the general direction and goals of this podcast from the get-go in hopes it can capture 30 minutes of your week.
We promise to keep you up to date on what is going on in North Carolina, particularly in our state government and upcoming elections. However, we will always seek to go deeper than any ideological talking points and the headlines. We’ll offer up stories when relevant and get into discussions about things like the importance of conservatism for today. What does conservatism mean and what should it look like? This is an essential question, especially given that we live in an age of deep moral confusion, angst, and general aimlessness amongst large swaths of our state and nation.
In this hyper-politicized society, Brooke and I will strive to talk about more than mere policy or politics alone. We want to talk about life too, and how that intersects with policy and how ideas have consequences for all of us. Afterall, culture is upstream of politics and it’s the culture that ultimately determines the success or failure of a society. It’s the Left that believes politics and government action is what can save or rescue our society from all ills. Particularly in this crazy era, so many mythically believe that just swapping out one set of politicians for whom they deem to be the right ones is all that is needed to flourish.
Most importantly, we want you to know that our audience is the only asset to us and Civitas. Authenticity is a diminishing virtue, but you will always get that with us here at Civitalk. We hope to be civic educators and we know we have much to learn from our listeners too.
We welcome your feedback and definitely give us a chance to inform and entertain you as well.
If you haven’t had a chance to listen yet, below is our latest episode. In the upcoming episode, Brooke and I will discuss the looming midterm elections in North Carolina, perhaps even make some bold predictions, and amongst other topics, delve a little into the ABC liquor scandal in the state.
Thanks for listening!
Southern Coalition for Social Justice: A Mapping the Left Profile

Mapping the Left (MTL) is an ongoing project of Civitas Institute. MTL’s primary purpose is to provide researchers, journalists, and engaged citizens with the information necessary to understand the deep-pocketed organizations, groups, and individuals that make up the North Carolina Left.
These groups are well funded and hold significant influence in state government, education, and culture. Oftentimes they possess political power that reaches far deeper than what is visible on the surface. All of these factors make Mapping the Left an invaluable resource for understanding the elaborate network of progressive organizations in our state.
Our researchers have done years of digging, carefully unearthing the connections that all informed citizens need to know about North Carolina’s ultra-progressive groups, the money they receive, and the connections they have.
Group: Southern Coalition for Social Justice (SCSJ)
Background: SCSJ was formed in 2007 by Anita Earls, a Durham attorney and current Democrat candidate for North Carolina Supreme Court. SCSJ uses lawsuits and community organization to advance radical left-wing policies in the area of elections, environmental and criminal justice law. SCSJ has led the effort against common-sense elections reforms, such as voter ID.
Issues: Social Justice; Elections, Environmental Policies, and Criminal Justice.
Networks: Blueprint NC, Democracy NC, Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation, Moral Mondays
| Financials: Source IRS 990s | |||||
| Year | Revenue | Expenditures | Net Assets | ||
| 2014 | $1,420,540 | $1,274,788 | $689,144 | ||
| 2015 | $2,918,692 | $1,785,917 | $1,821,929 | ||
| 2016 | $2,440,198 | $2,419,420 | $1,842,697 | ||
Key Players: Anita Earls, Founder and Former Executive Director
Major Donors: SCSJ has received more than $1.4 million from Z. Smith Reynolds since 2014 and more than $3.7 million from the extreme leftist organization, the Ford Foundation. George Soros’ Foundation to Promote and Open Society has donated more than $1.5 million to SCSJ since 2010.
All of this, and much more, can be found in our comprehensive database at http://www.mappingtheleft.com
By Leah Byers
Hate Speech, Certificate of Need Laws, and an NAACP Lawsuit – Civitalk, Episode 2

Was the NYT’s right to hire Sarah Jeong to their editorial board after a long history of racist statements? Could North Carolina finally see an end to its unconstitutional Certificate of Need laws? And what are we to make of the lawsuits filed by the NAACP, Clean Air Carolina, and the Governor’s office last week? We’re talking about it all on this week’s episode of Civitalk!
Blueprint NC: A Mapping the Left Profile

Mapping the Left (MTL) is an ongoing project of Civitas Institute. MTL’s primary purpose is to provide researchers, journalists, and engaged citizens with the information necessary to understand the deep-pocketed organizations, groups, and individuals that make up the North Carolina Left.
These groups are well funded and hold significant influence in state government, education, and culture. Oftentimes they possess political power that reaches far deeper than what is visible on the surface. All of these factors make Mapping the Left an invaluable resource for understanding the elaborate network of progressive organizations in our state.
Our researchers have done years of digging, carefully unearthing the connections that all informed citizens need to know about North Carolina’s ultra-progressive groups, the money they receive, and the connections they have.
Group: Blueprint NC
Background: This organization is famous for the Blueprint strategy memo that described the game plan “progressive” groups should use to attack North Carolina’s Republican leaders. Blueprint NC was formed by the Z. Smith Reynolds Foundation in 2006 to help “progressive” advocacy groups coordinate activities and messaging.
Issues: Political, Social progress and policy
Networks: Blueprint NC, Democracy NC, Z Smith Reynolds Foundation
| Financials: Source IRS 990s | |||||
| Year | Revenue | Expenditures | Net Assets | ||
| 2011 | $1,037,947 | $757,488 | $367,291 | ||
| 2012 | $1,558,934 | $1,669,645 | $315,572 | ||
| 2013 | $923,332 | $926,388 | $312,516 | ||
| 2014 | $1,241,194 | $1,188,282 | $365,428 | ||
| 2015 | $1,352,863 | $814,165 | $852,682 | ||
| 2016 | $4,305,619 | $4,072,915 | $1,085,381 | ||
Key Players: Erin Byrd, Executive Director; David Neal, Founder
Major Donors: Z Smith Reynolds Foundation, Mary Reynolds Babcock Foundation, New Venture Fund
All of this, and much more, can be found in our comprehensive database at www.mappingtheleft.com.
Lawmakers back in special session tomorrow

Less than a month after adjourning, the North Carolina General Assembly is being called back in special session.
According to a notice from House and Senate leadership proclaiming the special session for Tuesday, July 24th, the purpose is “to consider bills concerning matters the General Assembly elects to consider.” That means the legislature can consider anything it so chooses during the session. The real purpose of the session however, is growing concern among Republicans, that an obscure commission – with a Democratic majority and empowered to write summary captions for six proposed constitutional amendments — might seek to influence how individuals vote on the amendments.
The commission, officially called The North Carolina Constitutional Amendments Publication Commission, is made of up three state officials, Elaine Marshall, Secretary of State (D), Paul Coble, Director of Legislative Services (R) and Josh Stein, Attorney General (D).
Officially, the commission is charged with writing a short paragraph which will appear on the ballot. It may also however provide a summary of one or two paragraphs in length of each constitutional amendment which can be provided to local boards of elections or anyone who requests them.
The legislative special session begins at 12 pm tomorrow.
More state-funded pre-K? Not so fast

The fast-moving trains advocating for state-funded pre-K programs in North Carolina and elsewhere lost some steam this week with the release of two reports.
One randomized controlled study (Dale, Farran and Mark Lipsey, 2018) reviewed the Tennessee Voluntary Pre-Kindergarten Program for low income children. The authors found “positive short-term effects on child achievement (at the end of the pre-K year). These effects dissipated as children entered elementary school and turned modestly negative by third grade. At the third grade follow up, the control group scored significantly higher in math and science achievement than the pre-K group.”
Of particular interest to readers is the comment at the end of the study. The authors tell of the difficulties they faced in publishing the findings since they did not support the or expected — or desired — outcome.
A second article by Grover “Russ” Whitehurst of the Brookings Institute, calls the benefits of government-funded pre-k “overblown.” The article is found on the web site Education Next. Whitehurst, who has written extensively on the subject, has serious reservations about the presence of positive long-term impacts of state-funded pre-K programs. Whitehurst writes:
I have argued elsewhere that the policy path forward for the center-based care and education of young children is muddled. The present analysis reinforces that judgement. Putting nearly all our eggs in the same basket-enhancing access to state pre-K for four-year-old – shows little evidence to date of having a substantive payoff in later school achievement. It is time for enthusiasts for increased investment in state pre-K to confront evidence that it does not enhance student achievement meaningfully. They need to temper their enthusiasm for more of the same and, instead, support testing of other approaches that appear promising.
FYI. Lawmakers added an additional $9.3 million in funding in 2018-19 state budget to expand the NC Pre-K program. As you know the Frank Porter Graham Childhood Development Center at UNC-Chapel Hill, has been an unabashed and often-criticized advocate for early childhood education. We trust legislators will give these findings honest consideration in the often heated discussions about pre-K education.
Jordan Peterson calls out the lunacy of Durham City Council

Anyone who rolled their eyes at the nonsense the Durham City Council’s wrote on a facebook post denouncing the “racist, misogynist, and transphobic views” of University of Toronto Professor Jordan Peterson and his upcoming appearance at the Durham Performing Arts Center (DPAC), will be interested to know that Jordan Peterson offered his own response to the post on his web site. He doesn’t hold back.
Peterson writes….
The City of Durham’s statement is one of the purest demonstrations I have yet seen of the tendency for the ideologically possessed to use denouncement tactically as a means to amplify and exaggerate personal or identity-group virtue. To lay this bare, I have composed this analysis of the psychological motivations and narrative structure of the statement.
It opens with what appears to be a purely objective account of my upcoming 12 Rules for Life tour lecture/discussion in Durham, but is in fact an outright lie, as well as an act of betrayal (quite the accomplishment for a single sentence): “We recently learned from coverage in the Indyweek [a local newspaper self-described as ‘progressive’ and one founded, by the way, by the mayor Steve Schewel, a signatory to the statement] that the Durham Performing Arts Center (DPAC) has invited Jordan Peterson to speak in the venue this September.”
The lie? The Durham Performing Arts Center did not invite me. I rented the theater. There is a world of difference. But, of course, without the allegation of ‘invitation’ there is no one to cast into disrepute. And that leads us to the betrayal, which is the purposeful and motivated casting of aspersions on the character of the people who run the DPAC, who are in any case directly or indirectly under the supervision or jurisdiction of the mayor and councilors. So the perpetrators have been identified.
Peterson leaves his best for last.
Everything that is reprehensible about the radical and ideologically-possessed left – all the moral self-righteousness, the platitudes, the clichés, the mindless celebration of diversity for the sake of the demonstration of tolerance, the naivete, and the appalling malevolence of casual denunciation – is on painful display in this missive. Exposure to such a piece of writing left me with a strong desire for a hot shower accompanied by plenty of soap and a scrub brush.
What more need be said?