Club for Growth has put up a blog devoted to junkies who delight in V.P. speculation. If you share that interest, you’ll enjoy VP Watch. Their motto: "Look before you Veep."
-Max Borders
Politicians & Politicking
Veep Watch
Mike Munger: Third Wheel?
Telemarketers Telepollsters are (systematically?) ignoring gubernatorial candidates in the general election, apparently. That is if you can even believe those third party candidates. I’ll trust them when they can get their parties on the ballot. Of course, they’ll have to get elected to change the rules–Wait. Lemme think about this.
-Max Borders
Guilt by Association? A Thought Experiment
Let’s say you had a friend who starting going to lodge meetings. At this lodge, anti-Semitic remarks and jokes are made routinely by known neo-Nazi sympathizers. Suppose also that, after telling you all about this anti-Semitism, your friend returned to the lodge, not once, not twice, but on numerous occasions week after week. You might reasonably infer one of three things: 1) your friend is a neo-Nazi; 2) your friend inexplicably tolerates heavy doses of anti-Semitism; or 3) your friend puts up with anti-Semitism because he believes he can benefit from the folks at the lodge in some way.
When you ask your friend about his continued association with the lodge he doesn’t offer any alternative reasons. So, it is still not unreasonable for you to infer that it’s either 1), 2), or 3)—none of which are very good (as in upright) reasons for consorting with neo-Nazis. Indeed, you would have every reason to question this association until which time your friend offered a more satisfactory explanation. Perhaps his response to you is: "It’s none of your business."
But surely his possible embrace of neo-Nazi doctrine is your business if you’ve made a commitment not to be friends with anti-Semites. So, his dealings with the lodge might give you reason to discontinue your relationship with him. In fact, you may – justifiably – decide not to be friends with him anymore at all until he explains his association with a group you find so unsavory—maybe even immoral. You have your principles after all.
Now, weeks have turned to months have turned to years—twenty years, let’s say. Your former friend returns to you after those many years and says: "I’d like for you to write a letter of recommendation for me." You see, there’s this great job he’s trying to get. But you reply: "I’d like to write that letter for you, but I still have so many questions about that neo-Nazi lodge."
"Don’t worry about that," he replies. "That’s water under the bridge. I stopped going to that lodge a couple of years ago." At first, he doesn’t tell you he stopped going because he had disavowed the beliefs he may have once had in common with the lodge membership. He doesn’t tell you he stopped going because he no longer found the lodge useful in furthering his career (though you do suspect the lodge had recently become a career liability). In fact, he doesn’t give you any good reason at all and – apart from some hemming, hawing and disavowals that seem too little, too late – he is unable to tell you whether he ever shared the views of the lodge all those years he was a member.
So, in the absence of any good explanation, do you have a duty of any sort to write him that letter of recommendation? At best, you have incomplete information. At worst, your friend is either an anti-Semite and/or an opportunist.
Nevertheless, people eventually come along and say that because you have refused to write the letter and because you question your former friend’s association with the lodge, you have committed a fallacy. "That’s guilt by association" they say. But is it? Why would one go to a lodge for twenty years unless he either wanted to draw from the wellspring of neo-Nazi fraternity, or expects some type of personal gain? (No alternative theory about your former friend – like going under cover for the FBI or Southern Poverty Law Center – seems to make much sense.)
The people who are accusing you of "guilt by association" are not only being rash. They, themselves, should be questioned for their want of skepticism; ready, as they are, to sign that letter of recommendation without further reflection. That is, if they suspend their questions about your former friend’s possible extremism and eagerly recommend him for the job, then you are right to question their scruples, too. After all, they’re putting pen to paper on his behalf. They have refused to ask the tough question: Doesn’t people’s desire for personal gain sometimes get them to hide their most cherished beliefs when it seems expedient? It’s been known to happen.
As you move forward this election season with serious questions about the goings, doings and core beliefs of political candidates – including their records, past associations (not to mention the kind of political opportunism that comes with the territory) – don’t let people make you feel as if you’re doing something wrong. You’re not. You’re doing the best you can with what information you have, none of which requires you make leaps of faith. And when too many questions linger, sometimes – sadly perhaps – appearances are all you have to inform your judgment.
Finally, we should also remind ourselves that when these kinds of questions come up in campaign ads, it is part of a healthy national conversation and a thorough democratic process. While it can get unpleasant, even ugly, it’s all the by-product of a society that values and protects free speech—warts and all. Your questions, as well as those raised by partisan enemies, represent healthy skepticism … even if that skepticism eventually translates into a vote for someone that captures your trust more than your imagination.
-Max Borders
Guilt by Association
A lot has been made recently about whether "guilt by association" has a valid place in political campaigns. Raleigh attorney Pressley Millen made an impassioned plea against its use on the editorial page of the News & Observer yesterday. His conclusion:
In the end, both logic and law counsel that we judge our candidates
personally and not based solely on associations with others, whether it
be other persons, groups, ideas or even products. Obama has held
elective office since 1997 without ever uttering one word that might
cause someone to think that he holds some of the more egregious views
attributed to his former pastor. In 22 years of public life, Lt. Gov.
Perdue has never given any indication that she pines for the antebellum
South. The associations — thin as they are — don’t lead to guilt.
It’s nice that the N&O would allow a Democratic Party insider such as Mr. Millen make a passionate defense of the candidates he supports.
According to NC State Board of Elections and Federal Elections Commission reports, Mr. Millen and his family has donated over $25,000 to Democratic candidates in the past few years. He has even given money to Bev Pedue and Richard Moore — two candidates he makes sure to defend valiantly in his op-ed.
The N&O should have disclosed this. Without this disclosure the reader of the editorial is led to believe that this supposedly neutral 3rd-party is standing up and making a plea against guilt by association, when he is, in fact, guilty of associating with the people he seeks to defend.
Guilt by association is a time-tested campaign tactic. How many times have we seen Democratic candidates put any and all Republicans next to George Bush? Heck, they are even doing it to McCain right now, all the while disavowing the NCGOP ad connecting Moore and Perdue to Obama. Only now as it is hitting those on the left a little harder than usual do we hear cries of "guilt by association" being unfair. Never before have Democratic gubernatorial nominees so embraced the Party’s more liberal nominees for President. (Where was Easley when Kerry came to Chapel Hill? Where’s a picture of Bob Jordan and Dukakis?).
This year we have Moore and Perdue both running as fast as they can to throw their arms around and embrace Sen. Obama. So either they really support Obama and his policies or they are just using his race and popularity to win support for themselves. One makes them a true-believer and therefore guilty by association, the other makes them, well… the oldest profession in the book.
Jim Hunt: Pot Meet Kettle
Good ole Gov. Hunt is on WRAL today "decrying" the use of negative ads in the Governor’s race. Him trying to preach to others on this subject is laughable at best, hypocritical at worst. Negative ads were perfectly fine for him to use during his many runs. But now he says that candidates should stay positive?
Puh-lease.
Check out this Time article from 1984. Anyone remember the "right wing death squads" ad?
The Hunt organization early this summer
ran a television advertisement linking Helms to the right-wing death
squads in El Salvador. The commercial opened with the sound of gunfire
and photos of massacred Salvadoran citizens. A picture of Salvadoran
Roberto d’Aubuisson appeared, and a narrator identified him as
"the man accused of directing those death squads." A picture
of Helms then appeared, and the narrator said, "This is the man
whose aides helped D’Aubuisson set up his political party in El
Salvador . . . Now Jesse Helms may be a crusader, but that’s not what
our Senator should be crusading for."
I guess that is what Hunt considers focusing on "positive messages."
Or how about the ad Hunt ran in 1996 (when he was up 10+ points in the polls and didn’t need to go negative) that said that Robin Hayes thought people should bathe with Lysol to keep from spreading STDs?
Was that a positive message of what he was going to do for the state, as he is advising other candidates to do?
I guess Hunt abides by the old adage of "Do as I say, not as I do" (or did in his case).
Woooooooooooooooooo!
Our YouTube video of the week (heck, this is already odds on favorite to be YouTube video of the Year), features Congresswoman Sue Myrick giving a speech on the floor of the US House of Representatives to honor the career of the one and only, Nature Boy Ric Flair!
Woooooooooooooooooooo!
Hint Hint, says Dome, Early Voting for Obama
IN CASE YOU WANTED TO VOTE EARLY FOR OBAMA… Dome lets you know that the candidate is running Google ads that tell you how if you click on them!
-Max Borders
Polling the GOP Primary
Tom Jensen at Public Policy Polling released their weekly tracking poll in the GOP race for governor today and while it shows a similar overall lead for Pat McCrory (about 10 points) as our poll released last Friday, there are some different demographics that may paint a different picture. One of the main differences between our polls is the age distribution
of who we poll. Our poll tends to be older, PPP’s much younger.
First of all, as always, we did not poll likely Primary voters, we polled likely General election voters, so our poll numbers should not be construed as a true reflection of what Primary voters will do. These are two completely different groups who do not always vote or think the same way.
Our poll skews considerably towards the older age demographic since these are the people who vote in General elections. (In our GOP sample, 37% of the respondents were 65+ and another 23% were 55-64).
Older people vote in greater intensity than younger voters, it’s just the way it is. Our poll shows McCrory leading among older votes by 12-16 points.
PPP’s poll of GOP Primary voters only has 20% of their sample coming from those aged 60 and above. And among those voters, they have McCrory leading Smith by only 1 percentage point (34-33).
The demographics for the GOP Primary is that it has traditionally been composed of nearly half of voters coming from the 60+ age group. So if PPP’s percentages for that demographic are correct, they would show a much closer race between McCrory and Smith if you weighted that result to a larger percentage of the sample.
While our poll isn’t primary voters, it shows just about the opposite of PPPs — older voters voting for McCrory in higher numbers.
Who is correct? I don’t know, it’s probably somewhere in the middle. McCrory is up on Smith, but probably by a smaller margin that either of our polls show.
Effective at What? I shudder.
The effectiveness rankings are out again — Again, I ask: effective at what, really?
Marc Basnight and Tony Rand are considered the most effective in the N.C. Senate. Most effective at getting road money away from places that need it? Most effective at quid pro quo arrangements and backdoor deals? Most effective at steering legislation, silencing internal dissent, or what?
Those effective in the House are those like Rep. Jennifer Weiss who is well known for nanny-state measures and economically backward environmental regs/subsidies/etc. Of course, the lefty organization who does the "effectiveness" survey probably delights in how effective these people are. I don’t. I shudder.
-Max Borders
Who’s Looking Out for Taxpayers?
NTU tells you. (Look at NC Congressfolk, here, scrolling down to page 3.) Looks like 2006’s drubbing at the polls knocked some so-called conservatives back to fiscal discipline, or so the ratings suggest:
NORTH CAROLINA
Butterfield…………..F……………3%
Coble………………….B+ ……….81%
Etheridge…………….F……………9%
Foxx …………………..A …………89%
Hayes………………….C …………53%
Jones ………………….C …………50%
McHenry…………….A …………87%
McIntyre …………….F………….10%
Miller …………………F……………4%
Myrick………………..A …………88%
Price …………………..F……………3%
Shuler…………………F………….15%
Watt……………………F……………4%
State Average …………………..38%