Conservatives who support school choice and parental rights should be pleased by yesterday’s press conference urging approval of a tax credit for parents of special needs children. The presence of Democratic ( Lucas and Glazier) and Republican (Stam and Wiley) leaders attests to the bill’s broad appeal, as well as to its chances for passage. The bill has already been approved by the House Committee on Education. Results of a statewide poll conducted by Public Policy Polling reveal 80 percent of all North Carolinians favor a bill allowing tuition tax credits for parents of special needs children. The legislation underscores the right of parents to provide a free and appropriate education for their children, no matter their health status. According to House Republican minority leader, Rep. Paul Stam, the bill would save counties about $6 million a year. Florida and Arizona have similar programs. Let’s hope North Carolina is added to the list and that this legislation is merely a first step in providing all North Carolinians more choice in education.
Education
Special Needs Tax Credits: A Ray of Hope?
Charter Schools in New Orleans
Fantastic piece
in the Washington Post on the birth of an education revolution in
post-Katrina New Orleans.
Since Katrina, charters have become the norm in the educational system of New Orleans, with over
half of all students attending charter schools now. Success here could go
a long way towards furthering the charter movement.
Note the one quote from a dissenter:
Leigh Dingerson, education team leader for the Center for
Community Change in the District, says Louisiana school authorities have "opened a flea market of entrepreneurial
opportunism that is dismantling the institution of public education in New Orleans."
Um, no. Not dismantling public education. Dismantling government-run public education.
Myrick Petitions ICE on Colleges
Congresswoman Sue Myrick has petitioned Assistant Secretary Julie Myers to explain just what ICE’s policy is regarding the admission of illegal aliens into taxpayer-supported colleges and universities.
Download 52808_letter_to_asst_sec_julie_myers_illegals_comm_colleges.pdf
Following the state’s decision to cease admitting illegal aliens, the News & Observer published an unsigned letter from ICE that stated, “It is left for the school to decide whether or not to enroll out-of-status or undocumented nonimmigrants.”
As Myrick’s letter points out, there is cause for “concern that ICE’s stated position conflicts with the intent of federal law and undermines ICE’s recent progress to enforce immigration laws.”
Indeed.
More for More at Four? Think Again.
Before voting to spend another $23 million to expand More at Four, lawmakers should be required to read the Charlotte Observer article by Ann Doss Helms, “Does Bright Beginnings really work?” Helms shows how Bright Beginnings – which in part, served as the model for More at Four – was passed on the promise that CMS would track students throughout school. CMS has not followed through on its promise. Albeit, initial results show the program provided early educational benefits to disadvantaged children. Third grade math and reading scores reveal the gains of many disadvantaged students had shrunk considerably. The difficulties of keeping a control group together limited evidence about Bright Beginnings long term impacts. Despite the failed efforts at tracking and lack of positive evidence, the program continues to grow.
Sound familiar? More at Four has developed much the same way – and regrettably shows many of the same shortcomings. Helms notes that More at Four students are tracked only through kindergarten and also lack a viable control group. Just like Bright Beginnings, there were lots of promises from pre-school advocates but now there seems to be little proof. All the more reason to stop expanding More at Four and have it evaluated not by a UNC child development office, but by the Program and Evaluation Division of the General Assembly.
Ed Budget Update
Even though the number crunching is far from over, there’s good and bad in Wednesday’s release of draft budget recommendations from the Joint Appropriations Subcommittee on Education. While the current numbers still must be reviewed by Chairs of the Appropriations Committees, the lack of extra money has worked to keep spending – relatively speaking — in check. The increase in the K-12 budget is about a 1 percent increase over approved FY2008-09 budget levels. On the negative side, there’s still enough questionable K-12 spending in the education budget to infuriate most North Carolinians. Some of the worst examples include:
ABC Bonuses
The subcommittee recommended $90 million in ABC bonuses ($70 million in FY 2007-08) for schools that meet or exceed expected growth in 2007-08 school year. That’s a lot of money. Is it worth it? Since 2000, NC has paid out approximately $760 million in bonuses. I’m all for rewarding excellence, but last I checked 42 percent of NC schools did not make AYP goals (2005). In 2007 Only 46 percent of white and 14 percent of black eighth grade math students were classified as "proficient" or above on 2007 NAEP math tests. Performance is an issue as well as how the ABC bonuses are distributed. ABC bonuses are based on school performance, NOT on individual merit. In my view, ABC bonuses merely dilute and work against the concept of true merit pay — a concept the entire system sorely needs.
Low Wealth
The subcommittee recommended a second year of one-time funding ($2.9 million in non-sSupplemental Funding from FY 2007-08. I always assumed a drop in the need or eligibility for Low Wealth Counties Supplemental Funding was a good thing. The committee is saying, we need to provide additional assistance because improved economic conditions are creating a hardship for the district. Go figure.
Dropout Prevention Grants.
The subcommittee recommended an expansion of the dropout prevention grants from $7 million to $10 million. While this may look like a good thing, don’t be fooled. Terry Stoops of the John Locke Foundation raises some legitimate criticisms of the program. Instead of being targeted to high need areas, many of the grants are going to schools that already have considerable resources to address dropouts or don’t really have a dropout problem. A good program evaluation – such as those being conducted by the Program and Evaluation Division of the General Assembly — would normally bring to light such shortcomings. However, if the Joint Legislative Commission on Dropout Prevention and High School Graduation gets its way, that will never happen. As I wrote about previously, the final draft of Commission’s report deleted language requiring the Program and Evaluation division to evaluate the impact of dropout prevention grants. The current language merely requires DPI to evaluate the recipients and report back to the legislature. There are several problems here. First does anyone really think DPI is going provide an unbiased and better evaluation than the Program and Evaluation division? Secondly, and equally important; why are we expanding a program that is poorly targeted and lacks sufficient evidence to say it is even working?
Liberals for School Choice?
Florida seems to be undergoing a school choice revolution – finally – with liberals coming aboard. A sliver:
When Florida passed a law in 2001 creating the Corporate Tax Credit Scholarship Program for underprivileged students, all but one Democrat in the state legislature voted against it. Earlier this month, lawmakers extended the program – this time with the help of a full third of Democrats in the Legislature, including 13 of 25 members of the state’s black caucus and every member of the Hispanic caucus. What changed?
Our guess is that low-income parents in Florida have gotten a taste of the same school choice privileges that middle- and upper-income families have always enjoyed. And they’ve found they like this new educational freedom. Under the scholarship program, which is means-tested, companies get a 100% tax credit for donations to state-approved nonprofits that provide private-school vouchers for low-income families.
-Max Borders
Education: Funding Formulas Reformed?
North Carolina spends $7.9 billion on K-12 education. Much of that money is distributed to LEAs and local schools through 13 different formulas. Doubtless, the average citizen finds many of these formulas dated, convoluted and unnecessarily complicated. To remedy these issues, the Joint Legislative Study Committee on Public School Funding Formulas has been meeting for the past several months in hopes of improving how the state distributes money to the schools. This past Thursday the committee issued its interim report. Some of the committee’s recommendations include:
· Mentoring Allotment – The commission recommends a significant expansion to the current Mentor Pay program ($8.1 million) to provide mentors for all first and second year teachers and instructional personnel. The committee also wants the state to pick up the tab for mentors for teachers as well as those who aren’t paid by the state (Why?). The cost to provide mentors to all first and second year teachers and instructional personnel: $7.9 million. I see little evidence touting the success of such programs. Double the money and give LEAs more flexibility in spending? It doesn’t sound like a good plan.
· Transportation – Funding inconsistencies between LEAs have occupied much of the committee’s time. To remedy an immediate shortfall in funding due to the rapid escalation in gas prices, the committee recommends transferring $47 million from general fund estimates and another $7.5 million to a reserve fund to cover additional increases in costs.
· Education Lottery Reserve –To compensate for counties that don’t qualify for Education Lottery supplemental proceeds, the committee recommends using $32 million from lottery reserve and distributing it to districts to equalize the ADM distribution for FY07-08. Yes, there are things wrong with the current formula, but this proposal is much worse than the problem.
Reviewing all thirteen funding formulas is a large task and won’t be finished this year. The highlighted recommendations and the inevitable tweaking are sure to keep the committee in the news. More later.
Public School Monopoly (on your kids’ minds)
Great Aussie video on the public school monopoly. Time for reform.
-Max Borders
Education Wish Lists……..and Reality
$42 million. Remember that number. That’s the number the Education Appropriations Subcommittee identified as the upper limit for additional education spending in order to stay within the assigned spending target of $11.3 billion. With little room for expansion, the Governor’s recommendations for significant increases for K-12 (6.4 percent); UNC (6.5 percent) and Community Colleges (4 percent) quickly lost some of their significance. Included in the total recommended budget are $501 million in salary expansions, including 6.9 percent salary increases($392 million) for teachers. Yes, you heard me right the first time: I did say 6.9 percent. What’s that I heard about a recession and the need for tightening our belts?
The Storm that Washed Away the Public Schools
A beautiful post from Alex Tabarrok on how Katrina washed away Orleans parish public schools (and the unions) and charter schools came to the rescue. Apparently it’s working.
Here’s the original NYTimes article on the matter.
-Max Borders