Easley wants you to puff more so he can give N.C. teachers a 7% pay raise. That is, if the $.20 additional tax doesn’t get you to quit. Regressive taxes and lung cancer for the sake of those who teach our chirren!
-Max Borders
Education
Burn One for the Teachers
The Lost Founding
Guarino has a good post on civic education and the Founding:
It seems to me that much of the political ignorance we see, and the false perceptions that exist regarding how the citizen should most optimally relate with the state, are rooted in a failure to absorb and transmit the basic ideas of the American founding and, of course, its primary founding documents.
As you can see, I agree.
-Max Borders
UNC: Economic Engine?
North Carolinians have long considered the state’s public universities to be an engine for economic growth. For most of us, a college education is the key to a better job and the means to a more fulfilling life. Such thinking in part helps to explain the ever-rising government appropriations for public higher education — even after adjusting for inflation and population growth. Last year, NC spent about $3.5 billion on the University of North Carolina and Community Colleges. In the past year, state spending for UNC increased 17 percent and community college spending increased by 13 percent.
Is North Carolina getting a fair return on this massive investment of public money? Not according to a new report on North Carolina’s Higher Education System by the Center for College Affordability and Productivity. Dr David Vedder, Center Director and co-author of the report, states North Carolina spends $7,153 per FTE higher education student, far above the national average of $4,871 and more than neighboring states Georgia, Virginia and South Carolina. Such high levels of public investment suggest that North Carolina’s population would be highly educated. However, the data say otherwise. Vedder writes:
In 2006 only one in four North Carolinian adults possessed college degrees, falling noticeably (slightly more than one standard deviation) below the national average of 27.2 percent. Furthermore, North Carolina’s attainment rates have lagged behind the national average every year dating back to 1989 and even back to 1960 for every year data are available. . . A relatively uneducated population despite such a massive investment in higher education suggests great inefficiencies and wasted resources in the system.
According to Vedder, state appropriations aren’t effective in maintaining a higher educational attainment among the state’s population. Vedder writes, “North Carolina spends $10.64 per capita on higher education for every 1 percent of its population possessing a bachelors’ degree, whereas neighboring states Virginia and Georgia spend only $6.64 and $6.61 respectively, to do the same thing.”
The problem? Waste, and there’s plenty of it— bloated faculty salaries, institutional subsidies, ballooning non-instructional costs, and rising numbers of students who attend school for several years, but never graduate.
While investment in higher education will continue to be an important issue, we’d do well to reevaluate subsidies for public higher education. A better option would be to closely link public subsidies to effective management and the realization of public benefits. Read the report and recommendations to learn more.
Incompetent Teacher Protectionism
There’s a good debate about the state of education on Cato Unbound. I particularly liked this thread from Michael Strong. A slice:
The salient question is will we do more harm, on average, allowing parents and students greater decision-making powers in education than we are already doing. It seems unlikely that parents and students would do much worse and highly likely that they will do far better over time once we have created a competitive education market.
There are several features of a prospective competitive market in education that seem to confuse some observers. First of all, education is often somewhat of a natural monopoly in many places; insofar as families have to bear the costs (in time and money) of transporting their children to non-neighborhood schools, there is often a significant implicit tax associated with all but the geographically closest schools. As a consequence, most local education markets are oligopolies rather than competitive markets.
In order to overcome the quasi-natural monopoly of local schooling, we need national educational chains that compete for the opportunity to create new schools, with national brand-name appeal and associated capitalization and focused R&D to support their particular brand advantage. KIPP, Green Dot, and others are the beginning of this trend, but they are all still developing their ability to bring quality to scale. John Merrifield explains why large scale school choice is a crucial prerequisite to reaping the benefits of innovation and how the few existing choices are largely irrelevant.
Speaking of scalable franchises, Thales Academy – for $5000 per year – sounds like a very competitive model. Parents have to decide whether they like Direct Instruction, though. But ignore the unions. It works.
-Max Borders
Dropping the Ball on Dropouts
Reducing North Carolina’s embarrassingly high dropout rate has been an issue that has been much in the news lately. Over 23,500 students dropped out of North Carolina schools in 2006-07. Last week, the Joint Legislative Commission on Dropout Prevention and High School Graduation developed ten recommendations to submit to the Legislature for consideration. (No these recommendations aren’t available online. Maybe commission co-chairs State Senator Vernon Malone or State Rep. Earline Parmon can tell you why). Aside from a recommendation to evaluate the effectiveness of dropout prevention grants –in my view, a good idea — the recommendations are as disappointing as the problem they are trying to correct. They provide nothing new and fail to offer the slightest suggestion that we’re in any way getting a handle on this problem. Recommendations like developing a system of sharing Information about dropouts (Recommendation 1), fostering a better school climate and safety (Recommendation 5) and urging more rigorous academic courses and less remediation (Recommendation 6) are vague and lack impact.
My favorite is recommendation # 4 titled, Parental Involvement and Communication Between Schools and parents. The text continues:
"The Commission believes that parental involvement is important to student educational achievement. . . The Commission believes that it is critical that parents be informed about a school’s expectations for students. . . The Commission encourages principals, teachers and Parent Teacher Association’s (PTAs) to develop methods to reach out to parents and guardians to involve them in student learning at home and school.”
All fine and good, but aren’t these recommendations suppose to be targeted on reducing the dropout rate? In another paragraph the Commission recommends in draft legislation that the Assembly appropriate funds for a dropout prevention coordinator in each high school that failed to attain a 65 percent 4-year cohort graduation rate.
This is a bad idea. Last I counted, there are 147 public high schools in North Carolina that failed to achieve a 65 percent cohort graduation rate — about 37 percent of the High Schools in North Carolina. A call to the NC Department of Public Instruction confirms that although in some districts the dropout coordinator may have additional responsibilities, nearly all school districts already have a dropout coordinator.
Before spending additional funds, wouldn’t it be better to evaluate the effectiveness of these positions? Why bring in more staff if we don’t even know if dropout programs are working? Aside from the cost, adding dropout coordinators to troubled schools also seems to ignore the iron rule of the bureaucracy: bureaucracies work to expand their power and influence. Will a dropout coordinator really work to put themselves out of job? Seems to me a better option is to use incentives. Appropriate financial incentives for dropout coordinators and principals and added flexibility regarding the use of existing resources and staffing would do far more to reduce the dropout rate. Now if only the Joint Legislative Commission believed the same we’d be making real progress.
No More Board of Education

The Health Commission met to review its legislative agenda on Tuesday, April 22nd and at the top of the list was the latest effort to outlaw corporal punishment (CP). The last time the Commission met, I detailed the plans by leftist Utopians to ban the practice of CP. Little did I realize then that the days of the "board of education" were numbered.
Drafted legislation approved by the Commission states "Corporal Punishment shall be administered by hand spanking on the buttocks…" No more paddles or rulers. (What will creative high school shop teachers do with all of their new free time?)
The other change to law requested by the social engineers is to report the age, gender, race and special education status of each student disciplined. Seems that the Utopians are worried about the number of minority kids on the receiving end of the rod. I suppose quotas will be next. The Commission also worried that special education children are being punished despite laws against it.
I wonder why the NC Health Commission is pursuing this instead of a legislative committee on … maybe, education? This is just what local school boards need. More intervention from Raleigh that removes a tool that helps maintain discipline while adding yet another report to be collected, compiled and sent to Das Capital.
Thank goodness that the legislature has already solved the drop out problem and children are capable of reading at grade level. Oh, wait a minute. They are still "working" on it. "Little Johnny, I know you can’t read and you dropped out of school, but at least you didn’t have to face the paddle."
Look for this bill to be introduced when the "Honorables" (sic) return to Raleigh for the "short" session in May.
NCDPI and Charter Schools: The War Continues
Last week’s State Board of Education (SBE) decision to penalize charter schools whose staffs lack the sufficient number of certified teachers is more evidence of the education establishment’s war on charter schools. New penalties for schools that fail to meet requirements could include withholding state dollars from charter school directors as well as the highest and second highest non-certified teachers (Does this seem heavy-handed only to me?). If noncompliance persists, schools may be recommended for closure. SBE seems committed to making sure any charter school that strays too far from the officially prescribed beliefs about who should be able to teach in our schools will certainly pay.
SBE has successfully managed to ignore an ever-growing body of research that only confirms what we’ve suspected for a long time: There is NO LINK between teacher certification and student achievement. Undeterred by the facts, the education establishment presses on. I only wish SBE’s zealous quest for “accountability” and desire to close low performing charter schools applied to the other 96 percent of public schools in North Carolina.
$72 million High School: April Fool’s Joke?
According to a reader: "The Local Government Commission will be meeting on April 1, to decide the debt application from Watauga County for $72 million for a new high school. This debt is being sought without a referendum."
-Max Borders
Legislative Lowdown: Health Commission
The Public Health Study Commission met on Tuesday with a large agenda although,the most sensational moment by far was the display of a diseased lung to the committee by anti-smoking advocates just before lunch (Yum!). 
Tom Vitaglione, a Senior Fellow at the nonprofit organization Action for Children, presented his group’s wish list for the legislative short session that includes adding five additional vaccinations(including the much questioned HPV vaccine) ($31.3 million, Recurring), more school nurses ($10.8 million, also Recurring) and regulating corporal punishment (Priceless) in schools.
Last year’s legislative long session saw a ban on corporal punishment go down in defeat in the House by a vote of 66 to 50 in the House. Legislative rules do not allow a bill that has been defeated to be reintroduced until a new legislature is elected (in this case the 2009 long session.) Not to be deterred by that loss, Vitaglione is still after the paddle.
This new proposal calls for training in the ancient art of corporal punishment, defining what constitutes it and tracking the incidences of it. Of all of these recommendations, the data collection is probably the most potent. Vitaglione noted that until we measure the use of corporal punishment in schools, we will never know just how many minorities and special needs students are being paddled. It always comes down to the same thing with the Left. Race is like the nine iron in the Left’s golf bag of ideas. You know its always going to come out at some point. (Ironically, many African Americans support corporal punishment. At least I know my 4th grade ruler ace, Mrs. Barrett did.)
It is instructive to note the tactics of Action for the Chil’run:
Run a bill to outlaw an activity you disagree with.
Lose vote but don’t give up.
Restrict and regulate the activity.
Require statistical data to be collected on the activity to use as ammo in the next round.
Vitaglione stated in the meeting that corporal punishment will be banned in North Carolina eventually and it is clear that he hopes to speed up the process through these proposals. He would do well to realize that not all North Carolinians are as "evolved" as he and his group are. There are some parts of the state that still believe in corporal punishment and would rather not have another educational edict handed down from the enlightened intelligentsia high atop Mt. Raleigh.
Come be our Governor, Bobby Jindal
…because of what you’re doing in Louisiana on education, taxation, and ethics reform. The guy hasn’t been in office that long yet and already he’s been able to work with the Louisiana General Assembly to accomplish a lot of good things.
Meanwhile, in N.C. we’ve got scandals aplenty (not to mention this garbage), a state legislator to be removed from office, record levels of government spending, plans for more rolling boondoggles while urbanites sit in traffic and rural yokals ride new roads, the highest taxes in the southeast, and crap legislation from last session coming online. The worst part is, the liberal mobocracy that’s long been bought and sold by less-than-scrupulous power-brokers from eastern North Carolina shows no signs of letting up. Help, Bobby Jindal, help!
-Max Borders