Required viewing on school choice (6:05). Notice the focus on "studies". (HT: Tertium Quids) Oh Gosh, this is priceless…
-Max Borders
August 18th, 2008 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Education
Required viewing on school choice (6:05). Notice the focus on "studies". (HT: Tertium Quids) Oh Gosh, this is priceless…
-Max Borders
August 15th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
Want thought-provoking thinking on American education? Charles Murray’s essay, The Age of Educational Romanticism fits the bill. Murray, a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, helps to answer why educators and policymakers are forever analyzing academic underachievement and offering countless remedies to address every academic deficiency. Our quest for perfection, according to the author, is rooted in the mistaken belief that all children who are not doing well, have the potential to do much better. Simply put, society says everyone can – and should be – above average. Since science — and most parents — know intelligence and ability are not equally distributed among children, the current focus on ensuring educational success for all students is a quest grounded in hope, not reality.
Murray calls No Child Left Behind (NCLB), the pinnacle of educational romanticism. Murray notes that even before NCLB we had operational, standard definitions of what it meant to be proficient in math and reading. Only about thirty percent of American students were proficient in either math or reading. Now, under NCLB all students are required to reach the seventieth percentile. NCLB, in essence, codifies the Lake Wobegone effect – where all the children truly are above average.
How did we get here? Murray points to two factors. First, Americans hold onto a strong belief in the malleability of intellectual ability. However, this is a scientifically disputed notion. Second, we also cling to the romantic — and mistaken — notion that our public schools, bad as many of them are, should still be able to raise student performance — even within the constraints of limited intellectual ability.
Despite the gloom, Murray is not a pessimist. Public education’s current problems underscore the death of educational romanticism, a precondition to a much-needed and realistic public discussion about educational limits and abilities — a discussion we’ve needed to have for about four decades. You may not always agree with Murray. But he has a way of asking the questions that need to be asked, marshalling strong evidence to support his arguments, and framing important issues in new ways. All reasons why The Age of Educational Romanticism is worth reading.
August 13th, 2008 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Education, Immigration
Sue Myrick announced today that she will be introducing legislation that would cut off federal funding for colleges and universities that admit illegal aliens. Myrick plans to introduce the bill in September when Congress reconvenes. Myrick’s bill comes in response to a statement by DHS that claims public colleges and universities are free to decide for themselves whether to admit illegal aliens.
Already, Catawba Valley CC has announced plans to enroll illegal aliens — in spite of the fact that current community college policy prohibits illegal alien admissions.
The State Board of Community Colleges will be meeting this Thursday and Friday to decide whether to admit illegal aliens. Currently, the 12:00 pm luncheon session on Thursday is devoted to “immigration issues.” The meeting, which will be held in the Caswell Building at 200 W. Jones St., is open to the public.
August 6th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
On Thursday the State Board of Education will learn how many teachers will be eligible for ABC bonuses. ABC bonuses are cash awards provided to teachers and staff from schools that meet academic progress targets. The awards, started in 1996, are popular with educators. And, many educators have come to expect that extra check.
This year it seems teachers are noticeably more anxious about the bonuses. The final state budget included $90 million for ABC bonuses, $17 million less than requested by the Department of Public Instruction (DPI). In addition, the final state budget included a provision that limited what DPI could spend to $94.3 million, the average expenditure of the program over the last eleven years. It seems in years past, DPI supplemented ABC bonus money with monies from other budgets. That may help to explain why no teacher has ever been awarded less than $1,500, the maximum award amount allowed by law. This year’s tighter state budget may change that. There was growing pressure within the Legislature to “fully fund” the ABC bonuses, but a majority never developed.
I’m all for rewarding a job well done. However these bonuses raise too many questions. Do ABC bonuses really reward good teaching? If your school meets target goals, bonuses are paid. However, good teachers and bad teachers in the same school receive the same reward. How does that policy reward good teaching? Over the past few years, high percentages of the state’s public schools have received the bonuses. Last year seventy-two percent of the state’s public schools met academic targets on state exams. Still, why isn’t this progress reflected on student test scores or in more favorable comparisons with other states?
Since 2004, North Carolina has spent $454 million on ABC bonuses. Considering our test scores and poor performance on many national tests, we should ask: was it money well spent? While no system is perfect, a system that rewards individual performance is far superior to one that negates good teaching and rewards group membership over excellence.
August 4th, 2008 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Education
A record number of parents are exercising a form of school choice in North Carolina. The Associated Press reported last week that more than 38,000 North Carolina families decided to home school their children. While educrats in this state turn a blind eye to high school drop outs and continue to use tests that don’t compare our students to the national results, 71,000 children are being educated outside of the public education system.
This trend is growing. According to the NC Division of Non-Public Education, the state has gone from 33,000 estimated homeschool students in 2000 to 71,000 for the 2007-2008 school year. That’s growth of more than 115%. Keeping in mind the rate of population growth as well as the increasing popularity of homeschooling as a viable option, there are still more kids being educated outside of the state system than ever before.
When the customer is not happy with the product he or she is paying for, the customer will look for a better product even if they have to spend more money beyond what they pay in taxes. What is North Carolina’s education bureacracy doing to compell 38,000 families to walk away from something they have already bought and paid for?
July 30th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
In a speech earlier this month before the North Carolina Association of School Administrators, Bev Perdue charged that – if elected — Pat McCory would blow a $1.2 billion hole in North Carolina’s education budget.
Bev should go back to school and re-take math. Her numbers don’t add up. First, Perdue charges McCory’s opposition to the Education Lottery would mean a loss of $350 million in revenue for the schools. Let’s be realistic, even with a Republican governor, what are the chances of reversing the lottery legislation?
Perdue, also charges that school vouchers would use up to $900 million in public funding to pay for private schooling. The calculation is curious: 166,363 (private school students in North Carolina) x $5274 in state aid to each child = $877,398,462. Does $877 million = $900 million? I guess Perdue thinks so. What the heck, it’s the government and it’s only $23 million. Close enough I guess.
The Office of Non-Public Schools lists private school enrollment in NC at around 97,000. My guess is the 166,363 figure includes about 69,000 home school students. For the record The Office of Non-Public Schools does not include home school students in estimates of private school enrollment.
The $900 million cost estimate includes ONLY students already enrolled in private or home schools. Most certainly, vouchers would allow public school students to pursue better educational opportunities elsewhere. There isn’t the time to estimate the number and the exact impact here, but there are many reasons to believe that vouchers — rather than hurting the public schools — would actually benefit public education. If overcrowding is as pervasive as we are led to believe, a decline in students should be welcome. The migration should also lead to a reduction in staffing (the greatest percentage of budget expenditures). In many cases, these changes can actually help to improve student teacher ratios and revenue per student. Equally important, since many private schools actually spend considerably less than the state to educate students, vouchers may also work to save taxpayers money.
The claim that vouchers will take $900 million from the public schools is pure fiction. Since when do the public schools have greater claim on tax dollars than tax payers? If vouchers are going to students already enrolled in private schools, how is money being removed from the public schools? Perdue fails to recognize that by providing education to thousands of students, private and home schools actually save the public schools at least $900 million. It is important to point out “publicly-funded” education should not simply be defined as government schools. Publicly-funded schools should be as different in organization and outlook as the public it serves.
No doubt Perdue’s remarks are motivated by the belief that support for the “v” word is still political suicide in North Carolina. But is this true? A July 2008 Civitas DecisionMaker Poll, found 51 percent of NC voters said they would be more likely to support a candidate who supports school vouchers. Similarly, the same poll in June found that 64 percent of voters support a system of education tax credits that can be used at any private or public school. Those numbers reflect a big shift in thinking. McCory would do well to emphasize those numbers and the need to bring our education policies in line with changing public sentiment.
July 18th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
One of the big stories of the FY08-09 State budget is the General Assembly’s authorization of a staggering $523 million in Certificates of Participation (COPs) to finance UNC construction projects. The numbers push the boundaries of the debt affordability model. The economic realities have also spawned some creative future financing provisions. Included in this year’s budget is language (Section 27.7B(a)) that amends existing statutes (Chapter 116-29 (5) and appropriates from the General Fund to UNC, $172 million in 2009-10 and $45 million in 2010-2011 for completion of the of Biomedical Imaging Research Center (BRIC) at UNC-Chapel Hill. The provision expires if the Legislature provides by June 30, 2009, “sufficient debt financing” to complete the BRIC project. No doubt the provision is intended to show strong support for the project. However, as one General Assembly cannot bind another, the provision has little practical value. Someone in the know about UNC capital financing tells me you’d have to go all the way back to the early part of the twentieth century to see a similar provision.
The Biomedical Imaging Center is a huge project ($255 million). And, my guess is the remainder of the project will ultimately be financed through COPs. The growing use of this non-voter approved borrowing should outrage voters, as should the view — common among many lawmakers — that UNC capital projects are jobs programs. We’ll be paying for this building binge until the capital planning process is overhauled and limits are placed on COPs financing. We can’t start soon enough.
July 10th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
Kudos to David Bass of the John Locke Foundation. In a recent article in Carolina Journal, Bass unearthed a distrurbing truth: many families around North Carolina lie about their income when applying for free and reduced lunch programs. His findings are alarming. He writes:
CJ [Carolina Journal] reviewed verification summaries from four school districts, Buncombe County Schools, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools, New Hanover County Schools and Wake County Schools.
Thirty two percent of applicants in the four districts had their benefits reduced or revoked after giving income evidence that differed from the amount reported on the applications, and 37 percent did not respond to the income verification request. That means nearly seven in ten applicants could not or would not verify their income to school officials.
While the fraud is bad, what’s worse is the refusal of many school administrators to pursue those accused of fraud. Why? Follow the money. The percentage of free and reduced-lunch students in schools serves as proxy measure for poverty. It is used to determine a school’s eligibility for Title I funds and to determine if a group of students is making “Adequate Yearly Progress” under No Child Left Behind. As much as schools will deny it, there is a strong financial incentive for schools to keep high enrollment in school lunch programs. Regrettably there are plenty of stories about teachers and administrators encouraging students to sign up for programs, even when both know a family is not likely to qualify.
Bass does an excellent job of highlighting where reform is needed and why free and reduced lunch is a wholly unreliable indicator for poverty. It should be required reading for school administrators and school board members.
July 2nd, 2008 by Civitas Staff | Topics: Education, Legislative Activity
The House voted 60 to 56 not to concur with the Senate bullying bill. What this means is that the House bill, which includes language that provides special protection to homosexuals, will go to conference committee. By the reaction of the homosexual/ACLU lobby, it is very likely that the conference committee will preserve language that (for the first time in North Carolina law) recognizes sexual orientation as a protected class.
Supporters of the legislation, led by Rick Glazier (why is no one running against this guy?), framed the argument in favor of the House bill as providing protection for “all God’s children.” Among Republicans, Rep. Cary Allred was a vocal supporter of the House bill.
Opponents of the bill, led by Rep. Skip Stam, instead called upon the House to pass the Senate bill, which would have provided protection to all children, irrespective of their membership in a protected class. As Rep. Nelson Dollar argued, the House bill is divisive because it divides kids up into different groups. Dollar also noted that one of the country’s leading experts on bullying, Brenda High, opposes bullying legislation that specifies protected classes.
June 27th, 2008 by Bob Luebke | Topics: Education
There’s been much publicity (News & Observer) about a recent National Research Council study that says students taught by teachers with National Board of Professional Teaching Standards Certification (NBPTS) do better in school than those whose teachers are not nationally certified. Educators and teacher groups around the state are touting the study as proof that not only are North Carolina’s 12,770 nationally certified teachers making a difference, but also that the state’s 12 percent salary differential it awards to certified teachers is a good investment.
The study — which included a large sample of NC students and teachers — was intended to put to rest some of the questions that have hovered around the certification program. A closer look at the study and news reports suggests that results in North Carolina aren’t quite what we’ve been led to believe. Instead of answering these questions, the study may have only raised more. Education Week (6.18.08) reported that students with nationally certified teachers seemed to score higher than students with teachers without the credential. However when researchers analyzed studies, most of them struggled to assess the exact impacts of NBPTS.
‘Most of the studies asked: When students have nationally certified teachers are test scores higher, and the answer is unambiguously yes,’ said panel member Mark Dynarski, a senior fellow at Mathematica Policy Research Inc, in Princeton New Jersey and director of the federal What Works Clearinghouse.
The committee struggled though over how to characterize the size of the programs impact on students’ test scores. In North Carolina, for instance, the effect sizes ranged from .04 to .08 – the latter translating to about 1 point on a test with a mean score of 150 (emphasis mine), according to the report.
On the question of what happens to teachers once they acquire NBPTS certification, Education Week continued…
While one study showed that board certified teachers were more likely to stay in teaching, data from North Carolina suggest, that once they achieve certification, they change jobs at a higher rate than do unsuccessful applicants for the credential. And when they move, the statistics show, they end up in teaching jobs where student achievement levels are higher and student poverty levels are lower.
The disappointing findings regarding student achievement scores and teacher migration raise obvious questions about the cost effectiveness of NBPTS. While the NRC study was unable to draw any firm conclusions about cost effectiveness, a few quick calculations might contribute to this discussion.
North Carolina has 12,770 nationally certified teachers. Staff at the Fiscal Research Office tells me NBPTS teachers received an average $527 more per month. On an average 10 month schedule, that’s $5,270 in additional NBPTS pay per year. A conservative estimate of annual state salary costs for 12,770 certified teachers is $67.3 million ($5,270 x 12,770). Sixty-seven million for a 1 point increase in student test scores? Does NBPTS really make a difference in NC? I’m not against teachers. However, I don’t think the NRC study can be used to tout the benefits of certification in North Carolina. If someone wants to forward evidence that this program is cost effective, I’m waiting.